Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the European agreement on climate, the fight against the Ebola epidemic, and common economic policy, in Brussels on October 23, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

23 October 2014 · European Council summit · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a Brussels press conference on October 23, 2014, following the European Council's landmark climate and energy agreement setting 2030 targets.
Main themes
European climate agreement, greenhouse gas emission reduction targets, energy savings and renewables, carbon market and ETS stability reserve, solidarity mechanisms for less wealthy EU states, energy security, Paris 2015 climate conference preparation, Lima conference, EU leadership on climate, agricultural sector protection, international climate diplomacy
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,533
82nd percentile
Sentences
200
89th percentile
Readability
55
75th percentile
Grade
10.2
23rd percentile
Syntax
2.84
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

200 sentences in 67 paragraphs

Good evening,

We have therefore reached an agreement that I find very ambitious for the planet because Europe is setting an example. It was indeed a matter for Europeans to determine whether they would impose on themselves the rules they ask others to respect in the fight against climate change, but also in the conversion of our industries and in our ability to better manage our energy, that is to say, to save it for the benefit of households and businesses, both for their purchasing power and for their investments. It is a good agreement. Like any good agreement, it is a compromise. It took time, a lot of time, and I want to thank all the countries that contributed to it, that is to say the 28, as they were not all in the same situation. The Commission, the President of the European Council, Germany, and France played their role precisely to ensure that at the last moment there could be a number of adjustments, particularly for countries that had a significant effort to make in terms of conversion, especially for coal, and also for the interconnections that are dear to a number of countries, Spain, Portugal, but in a certain way also to France, to allow for greater energy independence.

France was determined, and its President even more so, that an agreement could be found today. Why? Because our country will host the Climate Conference in December 2015 and because in a few weeks, in a few days, there will be the Lima conference, which is supposed to be a preparatory step for the conference that should normally lead to a differentiated global agreement, what we call the Paris conference for the fight against climate change.

It was therefore now that Europe had to reach an agreement, not a partial agreement, not an interim agreement, not a provisional agreement, but a conclusive, definitive agreement for the period that will go until 2030.

You know the quantified objectives, at least 40% for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, 27 to 30% that can go up to that for energy savings, and 27% for renewables. These figures were not a given in advance and were preserved in the negotiation. Many thought that we would stop at 40% for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions; it is at least 40%. It is true that France would have preferred to go even further for energy savings, but at some point, we must allow for transitions to take place, so it will be at least 27% to go up to 30%.

On renewables, for us, the figure was 27%, and it remained at 27%.

There was also a desire to convince the United States, China, and other countries that Europe could be a reference. And if Europe had not reached an agreement this evening, how could we engage the United States, China, and other countries, emerging countries, those who have questions, especially if Europeans had shown timidity? It was therefore essential that Europe show the way and could mark, for this European Council, strong commitments.

What was the difficulty? The difficulty was that European countries are not in the same situation. Not in the same situation in terms of wealth. Not in the same situation in terms of renewable energies. Not in the same situation in terms of possible energy savings. Therefore, there had to be a form of solidarity.

Indeed, there will be a system of quota trading for what we call industrial and energy installations, the ETS. These quotas will guarantee the price of carbon. I was particularly attached to the creation of a stability reserve. This is a technical but essential point so that there can be a carbon market that results in a sufficiently reasonable and stable carbon price, so that medium and long-term investments can be made considering this parameter. If there is doubt about the price of carbon, why would there be investments to save it?

This "stability reserve" has been introduced into the agreement and will therefore be in European legislation since the European Parliament will take it up.

Secondly, the solidarity mechanism for the countries we call the least wealthy will be a system of free quotas so that they can adapt and reach the objective without it costing them too much. For other energy consumption, what we call outside the ETS, mainly transport, housing, and agriculture, there too, a number of provisions have been made so that the wealthiest countries make the most efforts and that the least wealthy countries can have more ease and transition.

I have nevertheless ensured that agriculture can have a particular mechanism because I believe that agriculture, and this does not only concern France, must be a protected sector.

On energy security, it was very important that we could, particularly in the context you know regarding gas, ensure Europe’s autonomy in the medium and long term. The proposals that have been retained will allow Europe to be ready in the face of delivery interruptions.

Finally, there was a long discussion with certain countries, and I participated with Mrs. MERKEL, to find a solution for what we call "electric interconnections." And that there be firm objectives so that we can promote these interconnections by 2020, even 2025. This will be a favorable factor both for the cost of energy and for Europe’s autonomy.

If I want to add one more word, it is that France, in a certain way, had anticipated this agreement with the law on energy transitions that was adopted in the National Assembly and that will now be transmitted to the Senate. We had retained the objectives that were included in the European agreement. There is therefore no gap between what we wanted for France and what we accepted for all of Europe.

Finally, regarding what is necessary in terms of investments: the JUNCKER plan, the 300 billion, is inseparable from what we have just decided today. Because if there are no public-private investments, it will not be possible to implement what we have just proposed for all of Europe, with firm commitments. The JUNCKER plan, the 300 billion, will largely be devoted to these investments to save energy, to seek new energies, and also to ensure interconnections.

I finally think that for Europe, a new horizon is emerging. It is not just a matter of being exemplary; that is already a lot. It is not just about enabling the conclusion of the climate agreement in 2015; France was keen on this, and nothing is yet decided. But it was also about sending a message to the new economy, to all these investors, to all these entrepreneurs who are launching into the energy market with innovations, particularly bold technologies.

For Europe, it is also a vision of its future, of its energy future, of its industrial future, and also of its future in terms of lifestyle. Having another conception of energy consumption, modes of transport, modes of consumption, or modes of production. It is also a form of well-being economy that we are preparing.

If I want to add one last argument, it is that of independence. Europe does not have sufficient energy resources; it is forced to buy them from abroad, which can indeed degrade its trade balance or make it vulnerable to certain supply sources. What we have just decided will allow Europe to be more autonomous by producing new energies, being able to diversify its supply sources, and finally consuming less energy. Because the best way to be independent is to consume less energy, especially fossil energy.

There are not always European Councils that end with such an important agreement. I would say that there has been a particularly strong moment since the construction of Europe that has not necessarily gone down in history, which is the banking union. This was a very strong moment since this agreement completely changed the conception that Europe had of its own solidarity. What had lost the states was to come to the support of banks, even though it was the banks that had created the crisis. The banking union is exactly the opposite. That is to say, to have a mechanism that puts banks in solidarity so that states no longer have to intervene. This was a long negotiation that lasted more than a year, a year and a half, and which allowed Europe to emerge from this Eurozone crisis.

The second strong moment, I consider, is today, with an agreement on what tomorrow's common energy policy or Energy Union will be, even if we are still far from the integration process. What remains for us to do is growth, sustainable growth, growth that can reduce unemployment, growth that can also offer young people a perspective of confidence in their own future, but we will talk about that tomorrow, and we will also discuss it at the European Council in December.

When there are such strong news, such engaging decisions, adventures that are emerging on the industrial level, and examples that can be given to the rest of the world, I think we should not hold back. Today, I do not hold back my pleasure in being able to say that France has played its full part, but at the same time, the agreement that has just been concluded in Brussels will place on France another responsibility: to succeed in the Climate Conference, to convince others now. France has also set an example since we announced a contribution. I did this during the United Nations General Assembly in September of one billion dollars for the Green Fund. But we will also need to engage all the countries that are the largest carbon emitters, particularly the United States and China.

I conclude on EBOLA because it was discussed for a good part of the European Council this afternoon and early evening. There are three principles that have been retained:

Aid whose amount will be determined tomorrow, aid in support of the affected countries.

The second principle: to make personnel available, personnel coming from all over Europe and even from other regions of the world so that there can be care for the affected populations and the corresponding evacuations. There will not be sufficient healthcare personnel if there are not particularly rapid evacuation arrangements for personnel who may be affected. What Europe must do is not only provide funding to the countries, not only put healthcare workers in a position to intervene but also provide evacuation means.

Then the third principle was the designation of a coordinator, and the simplest solution was that the next Commissioner for Humanitarian Affairs could be designated as the coordinator for EBOLA.

France, as you know, is mobilized in Guinea. I remind you that there are already three treatment centers; the third will open in just a few days. Three treatment centers of 100 beds: two from Doctors Without Borders and one from the Red Cross. There are two training centers, and there will be a treatment center for Guinean healthcare workers.

France will also participate in the European Fund, but it was essential to show that everyone was taking their part. And those who cannot do so through healthcare personnel will do so through the budgetary means they will dedicate to the fight against the EBOLA epidemic. On this point, I think we should neither fall into catastrophism nor into inaction. Catastrophism produces panic; it is unnecessary. Especially since one can recover from EBOLA; we must recover from EBOLA in Africa and everywhere in the world. We must also not fall into inaction on the pretext that the known cases, even if they are increasing sharply, may ultimately appear alongside other disasters. There are so many, of a magnitude that would not justify mobilization. If, because the epidemic is progressing at a geometric rate. Therefore, it is very important that there can be this mobilization. France must have control systems that are not simply air controls. But also controls on modes of transport, all modes of transport, and even maritime. That is what we are going to put in place.

That is what I wanted to tell you, Ladies and Gentlemen. We will meet again tomorrow for the other part of the Council, which will be devoted to the economic situation in Europe and also to the Eurozone, which will have its own summit to address the same issue.

QUESTION

Spain made a lot of effort on this issue of interconnection. Has France really changed its mind? Is it no longer opposed to electrical interconnection with Spain? Will the objectives be binding, has France slowed down so that Spain will no longer be an energy island?

THE PRESIDENT

For at least two years, France, along with Spain, has had an understanding on this issue. It is not about leaving Spain or Portugal in a situation of isolation. We must also respect environmental regulations for the transport of electricity, that is to say, regarding high-voltage lines. However, as soon as there can be investments that can be imaginative, some may indeed be to bury a number of lines, if possible. We have considered that the targets set, 10%, corresponded to the common interest of Europe. We have had the same reasoning regarding Portugal. We will also hold meetings in France, Spain, and Portugal to best address this issue.

QUESTION

A small question somewhat on the sidelines of this Summit, but we remain at the European level. Italy has published the letter from the European Commission asking for additional information regarding the 2015 budget. Matteo RENZI even published a tweet with the hashtag "open Europ," transparency in Europe. Do you ultimately welcome the Italian approach, and could France, for its part, publish the letter it received from the European Commission?

THE PRESIDENT

It is a very ordinary letter. We can choose not to publish ordinary letters. Letters that simply ask for information and request to continue the dialogue. Several letters have been sent to several countries. This is the procedure, by the way, to provide a number of clarifications.

That is where we stand. We, with the Commission, are dialoguing via telephone, not yet via tweet, I am sorry, and through correspondence. But this letter did not have great significance beyond asking for a number of pieces of information and clarifications. In any case, we will have to give our response by the end of the week. We will do that. But the dialogue continues under very good conditions.

QUESTION

Does this dialogue with the Commission imply new savings for France? That is to say, since the French structural deficit is higher than expected, is the Commission asking you for new savings? Are you ready to make them, if that is the case, or are you waiting for a more global agreement that could take place in December with the famous triptych proposed by Jean-Claude JUNCKER, investment, structural reform, new deadline for France, new trajectory? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT

What is at stake? The stake is growth, I said at the beginning of this Council. Growth must be the priority. We must stimulate growth through national policies.

How? Some through structural reforms, which are reforms that raise the potential for growth, the capacity of an economy to create more wealth and more jobs. This is what some countries have been doing for years, what France, for too long, until 2012 to stay on cuts that everyone can understand, had not done. We say this will take time, because it takes time to see results—Germany took several years to see results—but we have initiated structural reforms and we will continue to do so since regarding competition, work, innovations, and regulated professions, we are ensuring to continue what we have already started. This is the first aspect that some countries must address in terms of reforms to raise their growth potential. Countries that have already made these reforms must support their domestic demand, ensure there are more investments, both private and public investments. And that is what we will debate tomorrow.

The second element to support growth is the European plan. You know there was already a first plan following my election that amounted to 120 billion. We realized it took time before it was consumed, implemented; it was necessary to recapitalize the European Investment Bank. What Jean-Claude JUNCKER proposes is a broader plan, 300 billion euros, which would mobilize more investments, not just public but also private. I told you what its content could be: digital, energy transition. This plan, if it is to be effective, must be implemented quickly. That is why, with Germany, we have begun to define the projects we could present. And we have also sought resources that could be allocated for the financing of this plan. We will surely discuss this tomorrow and especially in this European Council at the end of the year.

And then the third way to promote growth is to have rhythms of deficit reduction that both respect the treaties and commitments; that is why we talk about structural deficits, which means nothing to anyone in this room, as well as beyond, it is a complicated calculation that does not simply reduce to the nominal deficit. When we start talking like this, it means we have already lost the thread of what we wanted to say to the French!

So we will respect European commitments but with maximum flexibility. This means that we will look for what does not add to savings, since we have already presented the savings, 21 billion euros in 2015. We can see how we can better mobilize certain resources, better calculate certain expenses, but there will be no modifications on this point. We need to respect our commitments with maximum flexibility. That is what the dialogue with the Commission allows.

QUESTION

I would like to return to the climate. Does the final text, as Poland and other countries requested, include a clause stating that the various elements of the agreement can be reviewed after the Paris conference?

THE PRESIDENT

No, there is no date set, no deadline mentioned, but the European Council can, at a time it deems appropriate, once a number of commitments have been made, look at the status of compliance with the objectives. It is the European Council that is sovereign and can therefore review, re-examine but simply make decisions that correspond to the objective. What the Poles wanted was to have a mechanism that could have been imperative, that is to say, at a specific date and with the reserve for CO2 that could have been reviewed. No, that will not be reviewed, but the European Council can always take up all the commitments that have been made during this agreement.

QUESTION

The European Commission proposed a target of 15% for electronic interconnection. During the negotiations, France was against this target? And why?

THE PRESIDENT

It was Portugal that requested that it be raised to 15%. We said that we should first achieve 10%. That is still better. When we are not at 10%, we should first reach 10%. And then we see what more we can do. We thought that 10% by 2020 deserved to be the target pursued.

QUESTION

Two small clarifications on what you stated regarding the budget. You said several letters had been sent; does that mean that France received several letters?

THE PRESIDENT

No, no, the Post Office was not overwhelmed by the situation in France! There was no reason. But the Commission sent letters to several countries asking, but this is the procedure—for clarifications on the figures that had been transmitted, explanations that could be given, and additional information that could be provided, but that is all.

QUESTION

Second question, you said there would be no modifications on this point, after mentioning the 21 billion euros.

THE PRESIDENT

21 billion euros in savings, that is what we presented to Parliament, we must leave it at that, we will not go beyond that. It is the document as it was presented. After that, we need to look for other means to achieve the objectives that are those of the structural deficit.

QUESTION

You spoke about the measures that have been taken or are being considered for the Ebola epidemic; a first case has been confirmed in Mali today. Can these measures, you mentioned Guinea, be extended to other countries experiencing this epidemic?

THE PRESIDENT

For this little girl who came from Guinea, who was reported as carrying the virus, we will do everything to ensure that the Malian authorities can support her with medical personnel; we have a presence there. This proves that there is always a risk due to population mobility. Moreover, Guinea was affected because people coming from Liberia arrived in Guinea. The challenge is to prevent population movements that could then contaminate other countries.

It should be noted that the incubation period can last up to 21 days, so a person may appear to be in good health, travel, and then declare the disease much later. That is why, even on planes, we can check for fever, but we cannot necessarily check that there is a person who may be carrying the virus.