Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the situation in Ukraine, the fight against terrorism at the European level, the economic and monetary union, the sale of Rafale aircraft to Egypt, Franco-German relations, and Greece in the Eurozone, in Brussels on February 12, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

12 February 2015 · European Council (press conference) · Brussels

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on February 12, 2015, following the Minsk ceasefire agreement on Ukraine and EU counter-terrorism discussions.
Main themes
Minsk agreement on Ukraine, ceasefire negotiations, Franco-German diplomacy, fight against terrorism in Europe, economic and monetary union, European Council decisions, separatist conflict in eastern Ukraine, Greek crisis in the Eurozone, Rafale aircraft sale to Egypt, EU solidarity and sanctions on Russia
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,817
90th percentile
Sentences
252
93rd percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.97
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

252 sentences in 65 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - The European Council focused on Ukraine as there was an assessment of the agreement that was reached yesterday, more precisely this morning, and also the hearing that was scheduled with the Ukrainian President POROSHENKO. Then we moved on to the agenda, which was essentially about the fight against terrorism, with a number of measures taken by the European Council. Finally, there was a presentation of what the perspective for the coming months of the economic and monetary union could be, and the Council then concluded.

Thus, the main focus was on Ukraine and anti-terrorism measures.

This morning, after 17 hours of discussions, an agreement was reached. I outlined the main points and I returned with Mrs. MERKEL to what conclusions we could draw.

The first is that this is an agreement whose conclusion was not a foregone conclusion. Angela MERKEL and I decided to take an initiative more than a week ago, and it was fraught with risks as it involved convincing not so much President POROSHENKO - even though it was necessary to get him to make proposals that would allow for an agreement - but also and above all President PUTIN. It was also necessary for the contact group, with the separatists, to accept everything that we would have clarified during that night in Minsk.

We acted, Mrs. MERKEL and I, with the support of all the Europeans who once again confirmed this to us today. And I want to particularly acknowledge Mrs. MOGHERINI, who was kept informed throughout these last hours and who perfectly understood that the Normandy format was the best way to reach an agreement.

So there was an agreement. And even if there had not been an agreement, I think the initiative would have made sense as it marked the solidarity between France and Germany and also the willingness to do everything for peace. But if there had not been an agreement, the European Council would likely have been led to new measures. And surely the question raised by some American figures regarding the delivery of arms would have found a response. Surely there would also have been a desire on the Russian and separatist side to further escalate the fighting.

This agreement, therefore, is here and it is a hope. But it is a fragile agreement. Fragile because the ceasefire will only take effect on Sunday at midnight, more precisely at 0:00. And so, there can be a number of movements and operations, and there may still be victims until Sunday.

It is a fragile agreement because it is necessary to enforce the ceasefire, to ensure it is respected. And that France and Germany have chosen to engage with Europe, which has notably confirmed this commitment - yes, that Germany and France have decided to be vigilant, that is to say present throughout the implementation of this agreement, is also a guarantee for the Ukrainians and an even stronger involvement for Europe.

It is a comprehensive agreement as it covers not only the ceasefire but all the issues, namely the withdrawal of heavy weapons, the decentralization that must be granted to the eastern regions, the elections that must be organized there, as well as the constitutional reform, and finally the control of the border, not to mention the restoration of economic exchanges, the establishment of a genuine banking presence throughout Ukraine so that there is the same currency, humanitarian aid, the release of prisoners. This shows that none of the aspects of the conflict has been overlooked.

And as it is comprehensive, it assumes that there is cohesion among the actors to implement it. That was the whole challenge of the contact group this morning. It assumes that there is no desire to buy time for some to launch military offensives, and then to rebuild forces. It also assumes that there is respect for the order that has been established to ultimately achieve Ukrainian sovereignty, thus territorial integrity and thus control of the border. This means that we are only at the beginning of the process. We already have the experience of a protocol that was signed in September, which was never truly engaged and implemented.

So what happened in Minsk during these 17 hours is very important. First of all, because it is the first time that we deliberated for so long with four parties in the framework of the "Normandy" format where we discussed all the subjects. We came up with a text. This is very important because there were so many hesitations at one point, so many questions at others. It was not certain that the contact group, with the separatists, would ultimately ratify what we had negotiated. We believe that a step has been taken.

But there are still, as I said, uncertainties. The European Council expressed all the support it could give to this agreement, while remaining vigilant. It welcomed the initiative we took with Mrs. MERKEL. With President POROSHENKO, it was recalled that aid must be provided to Ukraine. Both humanitarian aid and energy aid. It was also desired that the Commission engage in a discussion with Ukraine, and indeed also with Russia, on the implementation and application of the association agreement that was concluded with Ukraine.

That is what was said, that is what was done.

These moments were also very important for Franco-German relations. I had already expressed myself on this. Europe is strong when Germany and France are in a robust relationship and take initiatives. And when France and Germany agree to take their responsibilities, whether in the international field or in the economic field, it is visible and it matters. And with Mrs. MERKEL, we have been in total solidarity in these last weeks on the initiative we wanted to take for Ukraine. And far from weakening European unity, we have strengthened it. It was manifested this evening. All the voices that were expressed in this Council - it is indeed all the voices, almost all participants spoke - all these voices welcomed the initiative, viewed the agreement as I have just described, and wished that the opportunity be seized while being extremely vigilant about the conditions for the application of the agreement, while still being questioning about the coming days, as I myself said upon entering the Council this afternoon.

That is the first subject.

The second subject, the fight against terrorism.

I thanked all the participants in the Council this evening. Why? Because they were all there on January 11. In any case, all the heads of government wanted to be there on January 11 alongside France. Because it was France, because it was freedom that had been attacked. Because it was values that had been called into question. And because Europe wanted to show that it is not simply a market, not simply a currency for the countries that make up the eurozone, that Europe is not simply an institution, that Europe is first and foremost a community of destinies, of values, of principles. And that at a moment, there are symbols that end up summarizing what the European project itself is: to build a community and ensure that we can both defend our freedoms and at the same time defend ourselves against terrorism. That is the whole challenge: to be able to strengthen a number of mechanisms, to improve our rules, to protect ourselves and at the same time to be concerned about what we are, that is to say a space of freedom.

Several decisions were made. First, the urgent adoption, but which depends on the European Parliament, of the so-called PNR directive. You know that this is for air travel, with nevertheless guarantees that will be given for data protection. And in the dialogue that has been initiated with the European Parliament, which was represented this afternoon by Martin Schulz, I believe we can reach a conclusion.

There were two decisions concerning Schengen. Schengen, what is it? We talk about it so often, so poorly. Schengen is an external border, which allows for the removal of internal borders. If there are those who want to restore internal borders - that exists - then it requires that all the mechanisms that existed before Schengen be reinstated without being sure of greater effectiveness. But if we want to keep Schengen, that is to say an external border, it must be controlled. It must have a means of verifying who comes and who goes, and that Europeans can feel safe. Hence the strengthening of controls, systematic and coordinated checks based on current rules.

But also the second decision concerning Schengen is also the revision of the rules known as the border code, to ensure these systematic controls permanently. It will take time to change the rules, but nothing prevents these checks from being carried out under the current rules.

A decision was also made regarding the financing of terrorism, because terrorism benefits from all the ills of the international financial system. That is to say tax havens, money laundering, hidden assets, fraud, trafficking. So if we want to fight, not just for tax equality or against tax evasion, we must also fight against everything that can promote the financing of terrorism, that is to say having traceability of transactions, also having knowledge of hidden assets, and thus holding banks accountable.

Measures will also be taken to strengthen the fight against firearms trafficking, of which we see the use that can be made. We did not stop there, and there is cooperation that was already engaged on intelligence that was recalled. But there was also a common will regarding the internet for European legislation, based on what exists to combat child pornography, so that we can have the same effectiveness in hunting down illegal content, or those that glorify terrorism, and have as clear a dialogue as possible, as frank as necessary, with the major operators.

In the same way, it was decided to use a portion of European funds for education, training, social integration, reintegration, and a common action in prisons. Everyone knows what prisons, not just in France but in Europe, can be as a mode of recruitment, enrollment, and indoctrination.

I also insisted on the fight against terrorism with Europeans who must take their responsibilities in Africa. We see it right now with Boko Haram, in Nigeria, Cameroon, Chad, Niger but also in the Middle East. Europe cannot simply be in the observation of what it must do within its borders. It must also know that it is expected outside for its own security.

Then there was the economic and monetary union that was discussed through reports, notably from the President of the European Central Bank, the President of the European Commission at length. It is an approach that has been proposed and which shows that when reforms are engaged over time, when they allow for greater mobility, greater efficiency, greater competitiveness, they produce results. It was also established - but we already knew it - that the countries that had most reduced their budget deficit were also those that had experienced the strongest growth. The question is where to start.

We once again insisted on stimulating growth, notably with the Juncker plan, with the European Central Bank - its president was there - and I believe we have indicators that are rather pointing towards a stronger recovery in Europe than expected.

Regarding Greece, I know this subject has interested, but it was not at the European Council that it should have been addressed, as it had been at the Eurogroup yesterday and it will be during the Eurogroup meeting on Monday.

Prime Minister TSIPRAS participated in his first European Council. He actually spoke there to explain what Greece's position was regarding these meetings. The dialogue will continue - in the coming days so that there can indeed be an assessment of the situation and the best responses that must be given based on the rules, their respect, but also based on what the message from the Greeks was during the last elections.

There you go, I am now ready to answer your questions.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you spoke of your commitment and that of Germany, which is a guarantee for the Ukrainians. Have you already planned to meet again, in this Normandy format, to see a little bit, step by step, perhaps just after the ceasefire, that it is well applied? Secondly, on the sidelines of this Council, the news of a contract with Egypt for 24 Rafales came out. I wanted to know if this makes you optimistic for the future of the Rafale in exports to countries like Qatar or India, with whom there have been very long negotiations regarding these Rafales?

THE PRESIDENT - So the first question you are asking is about the meetings we have been able to imagine for the implementation of the Minsk agreement. We indeed thought that if the ceasefire were to be established as planned, that is to say Sunday at midnight, it would probably be desirable in the following week to have a conference by phone, and only by phone, with the four, as we have actually multiplied these in recent weeks, to see clearly if what was intended is indeed being put in place. And if necessary, in the coming weeks, we could have a physical meeting, with the four, within the Normandy format.

The European institutions will also play their role, and in particular Ms. MOGHERINI, the High Representative for EU foreign policy, will necessarily have to take the initiative, as she has done, and the President of the European Commission as well.

The second question you are asking, which has nothing to do with the subject, that is why I did not address it - is the confirmation of Egypt's purchase of 24 Rafales and a frigate. Several companies are involved: Dassault, Safran, MDBA, DCNS, Sagem, and many subcontractors as well. The whole represents a contract of 5 billion euros.

This is indeed the first export contract for the Rafale. Until now, only the French state was buying Rafales. It was happy, so happy that it wanted to share its happiness with others. But it must be said that the French state encountered a number of disappointments. I do not want to say for the past two and a half years, but for a long time. And a number of promises had not necessarily been confirmed. I will not list here all the countries that had at one time been considered as potential buyers of the Rafale - who were wrong not to make this choice but who did not do so.

With Egypt, it happened very quickly. For several reasons. The first is that Egypt wanted a high-quality aircraft, and the Rafale is a high-quality aircraft. Then Egypt wanted this aircraft quickly, given the threats that exist around this country. Finally, because Egypt wanted to renew its aircraft and had long placed its trust in France. And so there was a tradition.

However, there was a problem that was not minor, which was that of price and financing. For the price, it is the manufacturers who negotiate. For financing, the state has made a number of efforts. And why did it do so? Not simply for Rafales to be sold, but because we consider, I consider, that in the current context it is important for Egypt to be able to act for stability and to be secure. Not just stability on its soil, but stability in the region. And security was also necessary given the common border with Libya and the fight against terrorism, and what is also happening in Sinai.

I have therefore seen President Sissi several times. The last time was during my trip to Saudi Arabia for the funeral of King Abdullah. And it was at that moment that we agreed on the essential parameters that were then reworked by the Minister of Defense, Jean Yves LE DRIAN. It is Jean Yves LE DRIAN who will go on Monday to sign.

The manufacturers, of course, have been fully engaged and have also mobilized. I think this is important in terms of our industrial policy. It is important for security in the Middle East and Near East region. And it is also important for what it reveals about the mobilization of the state.

Several times contracts have slipped away from us. I am talking about the last 10 years. Surely because there had not been this willingness to support, to finance, to find at one point the capacity to conclude. This has been done with Egypt.

Will this happen with others? There are indeed several avenues. India, Qatar. I do not want to announce anything until it is concluded, but I think that the fact that there is this first contract could be an additional convincing element.

This will also have effects on employment in France, since several of these companies will have a workload plan. This will also have budgetary consequences, since you know that there was a contract, if I may say, a rule that had been established, that the state would buy Rafales, and if the Rafales were not sold for export, the state would buy the Rafales that had not been sold. So there was still an interest in exporting them. This will also allow us to respect, as we had already anticipated, the military programming law.

I truly congratulate all those who contributed to this success. First of all, those who negotiated, the companies, and also the know-how of French workers, technicians, and engineers. The Rafale, it is true, is an aircraft that has exceptional performance, and we can indeed observe this through a number of operations that are taking place at the moment.

QUESTION - Regarding Greece, I would like to know what you are willing to accept in the demands of the government of Alexis TSIPRAS, particularly the desire not to make additional budget cuts, so does the reduction of the requirement for a primary budget surplus seem acceptable to you, while the IMF is demanding such cuts, particularly in the pension system?

THE PRESIDENT - It is the finance ministers who are directly concerned. They are the ones who, at the Eurogroup, will evaluate and see how to finance a framework for support to Greece.

Greece has a primary surplus. That is to say that Greece is doing better than many countries in Europe, with an austerity that has been particularly painful. So the question is pertinent. It is not simply about the budget that we need to act, it is about more significant structural reforms. You know that the Greeks are making proposals, particularly in terms of tax reform, tax control, and administrative reform, and it is these reforms that will probably be the criteria for Greece's commitment, along with, of course, the negotiation of the debt, which we know is based on clear parameters. Moreover, Greece does not say otherwise: what has been borrowed must be repaid.

So it is true, this was indeed one of Mr. TSIPRAS's arguments today, to clarify what he intended to do in the coming months, is to highlight - and he is not responsible for it since it is ultimately the record of his predecessors with the cost that this entailed for the Greek population - the fact that there was a primary budget surplus in Greece.

QUESTION - On Ukraine, if the agreement were not respected, would that mean you would be in favor of additional sanctions, and would you still oppose, for example, the delivery of arms? And regarding the Franco-German relationship, it is indeed felt with Ms. MERKEL that things have been improving for the past few weeks, as you yourself said. Is this a willingness on your part, or perhaps on hers, or a combination of circumstances?

THE PRESIDENT - I prefer that the agreement, which has been long discussed and negotiated in recent hours, be implemented and respected. The issue is still to have a ceasefire on Sunday, as operations are continuing, I have said, that can have consequences for the Ukrainian civilian population.

So if the agreement were not respected, we would first need to know who is not respecting it. But if on the separatist side, and therefore supposedly on the Russian side, there were proof that the agreement was being set aside, we would enter into the process that you know well, since it has now been underway for several months, of sanctions that would be added to those that have already been pronounced. We can clearly see the consequences: they are not happy, neither for Russia nor for the countries that impose the sanctions. At the same time, it is the price to pay.

France does not want to deliver arms to Ukraine. I have said this, it is not in the process we wish. We do not want to go to war. We want to make peace. That is what I have been doing over the past few months. Trying to make peace, and to achieve it as much as possible. So we do not place ourselves in that hypothesis.

Relations with Ms. Merkel? We have known each other for two and a half years, through the responsibilities we hold within Europe, but also in the context of our bilateral relations. And these relations have always been those in line with my convictions - hers are known - but they have always been frank, direct, cordial. And we have always worked well together. I have often told you, we have often found compromises on very difficult subjects, on Greece already two and a half years ago, on support for the eurozone, on banking union. The European Stability Mechanism, we have worked with Ms. Merkel.

Now, we have moved to another level in our relations, in our responsibilities. We have been able to take the initiative, and I think we both considered that France and Germany could not simply be a recollection of the past. With Ms. Merkel, we celebrated the anniversary of the Franco-German treaty, the Élysée Treaty, we have held a number of symbolic events, and we have talked very often about the relationship between our two countries. There were also, precisely on June 6, the ceremonies for the D-Day landings. And so we said: we should not just talk about the past, talk about what France and Germany have been able to do for the construction of the European Union. We must commit to the future. And what more beautiful cause than that of peace? That is what we have been able to demonstrate in recent months. And I believe that, beyond our two persons, it is our two countries that have found themselves here, in a useful approach.

And it is true that I was also sensitive to gestures of friendship that Ms. Merkel has made. Again when she came on January 11 to Paris. She was one of the first to express to me that she would be there. That whatever happened she would be there. And on other occasions I told her that France would also be there.

QUESTION - Regarding the "Mistral" contract, the Interfax agency indicates that there are hopes in Russia for a delivery of the ship as early as March. Could you comment on that? And the second question regarding Greece: yesterday there was a long Eurogroup meeting, which explained to Mr. VAROUFAKIS that there needed to be a discussion within the program. Do you think we can do without an extension of the program, or not?

THE PRESIDENT - So, first question, on the Mistral, the conditions are still not met. I hope they will be one day, but you were asking me the question: will the ceasefire be effective? Will it be respected? Will the process we have described be able to be implemented? If that is the case, at that moment the sanctions will be gradually lifted - even if the delivery of the Mistral was not linked to a sanction, France was not obliged to postpone the delivery.

But it is clear that if everything were to be put in place, measures would be taken, at the European level, to ease the sanctions. I also spoke of their tightening if the agreement were not implemented due to a responsibility that would have been identified. So let us put ourselves in the best of hypotheses, at that moment Europe would have to lift a number of sanctions. And France at that moment could fit into the process. We are not there yet.

On Greece, what the Greek Prime Minister wants is to modify the program to take into account a number of commitments he has made to voters, and indeed under a simple principle - that democracy has spoken. It is not a problem for Europe that the new government says it will have a reform program, a framework of reforms, that corresponds to its aspirations. And must this framework allow Europeans to consider that it is reliable, that it is credible? That is what is currently being discussed. This could not indeed be clarified by a statement yesterday. And well, that is what must be sought through dialogue on Monday, even if there is not much time to lose. Since you know that there are rules for certain EU member countries, that if the program were to be modified or extended, it would need to be ensured that Parliament could vote. This is particularly the case for the Finns. So there is a fairly tight schedule. The Greek Prime Minister, the Greek finance minister, are aware of this.

THE PRESIDENT - Regarding financial facilities, you know that one of the most sensitive issues when there are contract negotiations is financing, either through loans or guarantees. And here, it has been ensured, for reasons I have mentioned, both industrial, economic, related also to employment, but also for strategic reasons, that there are a number of facilities granted on the guarantees, allowing for the conclusion of the contract.

Egypt was absolutely determined to acquire the Rafales. It was this aircraft that Egypt, President Sissi, had considered to be the most suitable for the missions of its air force. We made sure, the State, that is why I want to commend the ministers, the Minister of Finance as well, not just the Minister of Defense - but the Minister of Finance ensured that there could be guarantee modalities that would be compatible with Egypt's current means.

Regarding Greece, did he convince? It was not the European Council that needed to be convinced. He was heard. It was his first intervention. The first intervention is always important. When I came to the European Council, it was in May 2012, it was to express the value I placed on growth. And indeed, that is what allowed for a first step towards growth, which was not yet strong enough; we had to return to it with the Juncker plan - but it was already a first start. I expressed how concerned I was about the European budgetary treaty and how we needed to find other ways for stability, for the eurozone.

I believe he outlined the main points of what he wanted to do. Now the Greek Minister of Finance needs to clarify in order for there to be a negotiation at the Eurogroup that can be conclusive. Otherwise, as I said, given the timelines, it should go through other modalities.

And today, the States must, within the framework of the Eurogroup, be mobilized. The ECB, as you noted, has increased its liquidity ceilings for Greek banks, so we cannot ask the ECB for what falls under the States' responsibilities. Therefore, in the coming hours and days, there will still be a lot of discussions.

And what was important, I think, in this Council, was the dialogue that was established, because every time there is a new member of the European Council, whoever it may be, we observe them. We wonder if they will change the rules, the rites. Generally, they do not succeed in changing the rites. They can still try to work on the rules. But it was important for Prime Minister TSIPRAS to settle in, to represent Greece, and to engage in this dialogue.

It is also up to him to understand that rules exist and must be respected. But these rules do not prevent this fundamental discussion on the modalities of reform. If - and this is a question that goes well beyond Greece - if there were no change related to an alternation, why would voters continue to vote? Europe cannot be a constraint and an obligation to pursue a single policy. But there is an obligation; France submits to it, because it is our common life - it is to respect the rules.

Thank you.