Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on citizen councils and urban policy, in Paris on October 27, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

27 October 2016 · Statement on citizen councils and urban policy · Paris

Context
Hollande addressed a gathering on citizen councils and urban policy in Paris on October 27, 2016, celebrating participatory democracy initiatives in priority neighborhoods.
Main themes
Citizen councils, urban policy, participatory democracy, city contracts, priority neighborhoods, social inclusion, civic engagement, housing renovation, public services in underserved areas, democratic representation
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,414
66th percentile
Sentences
129
75th percentile
Readability
63
92nd percentile
Grade
9.2
12th percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 48%48%
  • Social 36%36%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

129 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen,

I also greet the elected officials who are here and who contribute to what we are implementing for the city.

But first, I do not complain about this freedom. This freedom that you have taken, this freedom that citizen councils can represent. Because if there is no expression from citizens, what does democracy mean? It is not simply about voting every six years in a city. It is not simply about voting every five years for a President of the Republic. Democracy is also about being able to determine one's destiny every day, to choose one's life, and to have the conviction that one's intervention can be useful to others. This is what you have, at one time or another, testified to.

I have heard the reports, I have also heard a number of questions, and I will stay afterwards to hear you. But the citizen council is an instrument that was created by the Lamy law, and I salute here the one who carried it. It is a tool, an instrument, not a structure, but men and women who can take it up.

When we open, including through drawing lots, the possibility for citizens from neighborhoods, from cities, to sit in a body, there is always a question: Why these people and not others? Why were they chosen and not the others? But that was precisely the aim, to be able to say that certain citizens, through drawing lots, will be able to express themselves, not on behalf of others, but to say what their life is like and what they expect from a policy.

When we create an instrument, we must give it the means to fulfill itself, to manifest itself, to not simply be in confrontation with elected officials; that is not the citizen council. It is not to be a new municipal council; it is to be able to dialogue, to take responsibility with elected officials, to not be a municipal opposition, nor a transmission belt for the municipality, no! To take its place, all its place.

I heard what some said; it was very true: Do we still need to provide the user manual? Do we need time to go to the citizen council? Do we need to know exactly what these acronyms we pronounce in the context of urban policy mean? Do we need to know what a city contract is? Do we need to understand what funding is, what an agency like ANRU can do, I salute its president, what these billions are for to change life in the neighborhoods?

So, what I expect from you is what you have done: to take your place, to speak up, and to participate in decisions. Because the citizen council is not simply a body of participation, a body where we simply ask for an opinion. In the context of the city contract, the citizen council must participate in its development, its translation, its evaluation, and ultimately its proper application.

Urban policy has long been about the billions that have been allocated to renovate buildings, to demolish a number of others, to reconstruct neighborhoods, to improve housing. What did we realize? Not that this policy had failed; it was very important to have a living environment that is dignified, that is human, that is beautiful. Because why should it be beautiful in the old city centers and not in the neighborhoods or in the new towns?

Thus, the principle that we can improve, give a positive and rewarding vision to the inhabitants of the neighborhoods, was urban policy. But that was not enough, because there was the forgetting of the essential, the forgetting of those who lived there, simply you. This is what we wanted to engage through the new urban policy.

First, to establish a map of priority neighborhoods, which are not always those we think of and with a single criterion: income. Where there are the most difficulties, fragilities, sometimes poverty, that is where we must do more. This is the meaning of this map that has been redrawn for the neighborhoods. We then had to find an instrument, the city contract, and ensure that this instrument could bring together all policies, educational policies, because it is in the neighborhoods that we must do more for academic success, security policies, because that is where we must do prevention, presence, and sometimes intervene, but in a different relationship, where everyone understands the role of the police and where everyone also expects to be safe.

And then, the city contract is where we can also do more for the support of social policies, because it is often in these neighborhoods that we need the most medical presence, the presence of psychologists, the presence of all those who can support children. Because you want your children to live better than you, because that is the very purpose of a society.

Through these city contracts, we needed to give a voice. It is always a risk to give a voice; we saw it well this evening! We say we want to give a voice; everyone wants a voice! But this risk is worth it; it deserves to be attempted, this bet of giving a voice. It can be confusing, it can be contradictory. But what is essential is the voice. Nothing is worse than silence, indifference, forgetfulness, abandonment, relegation.

Throughout this day, if I understood correctly, there have been many expressions. With frustration, because when we give a voice, we also want there to be actions that follow. It is not simply about participatory democracy where everyone comes to give their word, their phrase. What we must build, co-construct together, is a policy regarding the cities that are most affected by difficulties, by fragilities, by inequalities, by discrimination, by insecurity, by unemployment!

We wanted to establish an urban policy that is focused on the neighborhoods that need solidarity the most. We wanted to gather funding; we allocated 5 billion for the Urban Renewal Agency. Today, we will add another billion. Why do this? Not simply to improve the buildings, but so that there is more for schools, more for cultural facilities, more for sports venues, more for mediation spaces, more for everything that makes life in the neighborhoods.

In the same way, we will allocate more resources so that digital technology, new technologies are available to everyone in the neighborhoods. We will ensure that business creation, economic development are also made possible in the neighborhoods.

What you said and that I could not hear and of which I was given the report is that you spoke of problems that exist, and we know them. But you also spoke of your successes, of the pride you have, as that woman said, of her children who have jobs and who have succeeded in their studies. Because in the neighborhoods, there are many talents, and if France deprives itself of these talents, if France cannot capture what is best, what is better for our future, how will this France grow?

France depends on you. You are nearly 6 million living in what we call "the neighborhoods of urban policy," 6 million. You are, for the most part, younger than the rest of the French population. You have more zeal, even more desire to succeed. I know that some drop out, and it is those we need to reach. Those who get lost, those who are losing their bearings and who, at one moment, can tip over, we know it. It is those we need to take, while it is still possible. That is also the role we must all have for the neighborhoods.

What I expect from you through these citizen councils is what you have done. First, to invest in these places, to make these decisions with local actors, with the State, with social landlords. Because that is where we can implement urban policy.

What I expect from you is that you can fully seize this instrument, fully take your place, fully integrate these places of debate and democracy. What I also expect from you is that you can speak on behalf of the neighborhoods, show France that it can trust its places, trust its populations, trust its youth. You are France!

At one point, it was said that there are no specific rules for a number of places. Secularism applies in all places of the Republic. The same principles apply, the same rules, the same freedom to believe or not to believe, and the same consequences must be found everywhere in our territories. There should be no discrimination, no discrimination between origins, between paths, between colors, and between religions. We must carry the same idea of the Republic here.

I know that this is yours because, by coming to these citizen councils, they will soon be nearly 1,000, and we will support them, as has been said, with civic services, financial means, and essential training; you are making the Republic! The Republic needs you, and you need the Republic.

Ladies and gentlemen, I could have told you much more about what we want to do together through the policies we have put in place. What I also wanted was to hear you, and what I especially wanted to convince you of is to make urban policy succeed. Urban policy is defined by a government; we did it through the legislator with the law, through administrations to implement our orientations, through local elected officials; nothing can be done without local elected officials. I believe we have a co-construction to establish.

But a policy can only succeed if citizens take it up. There are not citizens on one side and representatives on the other. This is, by the way, what undermines our democracy today. You pointed it out, this climate of distrust, thinking that there are those in power and those who suffer, thinking that decisions are made without listening, thinking that funding is dispersed without consequence, thinking also, and especially in many cities in France, that you are forgotten, neglected, abandoned. This is what we hear; this is what can, at one moment, fuel, we know it, extremism, populism, and sometimes radicalism.

We have this duty, this duty to weave the threads again, to restore dialogue, to carry the same hope together, to make the Republic. You are the Republic; you are gathered here, more than 1,000 advisors, 1,000 who can be in your place. I also know what you may feel; you have been, for some, representatives of associations, others drawn by lot. We wanted associations to have the means to act: 200 million euros have been allocated for associations because if there are no associations in a number of our cities, in our neighborhoods, who will act with the elected officials? Who will be able to support the weakest, the most fragile? Who will be able to give a voice? Who will be able to allow young people to express themselves? Who will be able to support them? So thank you to the associations, thank you to the community adults, because there too, 4,000 people who, every day and even at night, ensure that we can avoid a number of difficulties in our neighborhoods.

Thank you to all those who contribute to giving a different image from the caricature we have of a number of cities and neighborhoods. You all said it; you are both proud and, at one moment, overwhelmed because every time we talk about neighborhoods, we always talk about the same images, the same violence, the same degradation, the same failures. While what I want is that when we talk about neighborhoods, we can talk about success, people, job creation, capacity to create, talent, culture, sports, and the will to succeed!

We have created an Economic Development Agency so that there can be support for young or less young people who want to create their own job, their business, or an association— in short, who can be useful to others and to themselves. Similarly, civic service is available to all local authorities, to all associations to ensure that there is a link between generations or a link between territories.

Then, we need citizens, even those drawn by lot, especially those drawn by lot. You are here; some said to themselves: "But how did we get here?" It is an old idea, drawing lots, even when the revolutionaries, in 1789, sought how to represent the people, there were two principles: election and drawing lots.

It is universal suffrage that establishes democracy! What I urge you to do is to vote. You can have whatever choice you want; it is your freedom. It is your freedom! But freedom is not about voting or not voting. No! Freedom is about using your ballot to express what you want. There are enough options so that we do not neglect what is the main instrument of Democracy.

The revolutionaries of 1789 also asked themselves whether there should be assemblies drawn by lot. This is what we have also thought for these Citizen Councils, where the citizen members would be drawn by lot, chosen randomly, and these advisors are there to seize this right. Seize this right!

My dear friends, there is only one France, just one, even though I have spoken a lot about urban policy. There is only one France inhabited by citizens who are all equal in rights and duties. There is only one France with the same conditions that must be provided to succeed in life, because that is the top priority for you and for the country: to succeed, to succeed in your life, to succeed in the lives of your children, to make your cities and neighborhoods succeed, to make France succeed, regardless of your background, your age, everyone must be able to succeed. The duty of the President of the Republic is to create, with the government, with Parliament, the conditions for you to succeed.

My last word after, I will remain in the forms that will be determined, with you to hear you, perhaps in small groups - the Republic belongs to you - it is you, the Republic. Be fully aware: the Republic is not an entity outside of you. The Republic is you! It also counts on you, just as you can count on it. Never doubt the Republic, never doubt democracy, never doubt France - it is your country and it is a great country. Thank you.