Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the role of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council, in Paris on October 28, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

28 October 2016 · 70th anniversary of the 3rd Assembly of the Republic, Economic, Social and Environmental Council · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Economic, Social and Environmental Council in Paris on October 28, 2016, marking the institution's 70th anniversary as the Third Assembly of the Republic.
Main themes
Economic, Social and Environmental Council, representative democracy, intermediary bodies, French constitutional history, social democracy, civic participation, anniversary celebration, role of civil society, history of labor representation, Fifth Republic institutions
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,818
84th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
37
30th percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
50th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 52%51%
  • Social 29%29%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

148 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council,

Ladies and gentlemen councilors,

I stand before the Council today, and this is not the first time; since the beginning of my term, I have had to come here 12 times. But this time is the most symbolic as it marks the 70th anniversary of the 3rd Assembly of the Republic.

I salute President BERNASCONI for the momentum he wishes to give to the CESE, and I also think of his predecessors, each of whom, with their own personality, embodied the Council.

Seventy years ago, the Constitution of 1946 created the Economic and Social Council and enshrined it in the fundamental text. Celebrating this event means reflecting on the history of your institution, thinking about its future, and finally considering the place of democracy in our country.

The CESE is a response to a question as old as the Republic: how to represent society in all its diverse components? Universal suffrage is the foundation of political democracy; it is what gives legitimacy to decide and to act. It is what determines the beginning and the end of a mandate, of all mandates. It is what identifies those who will serve at various levels, the general interest.

Such is the meaning of political democracy, but it does not exhaust the civic question, just as political parties do not replace the living forces of the nation. Thus, the citizens of our country have always known how to organize themselves in their various activities to defend their interests and convictions. This is the role of intermediary bodies, so often criticized by those who see them as a hindrance to decision-making and who imagine these structures as already outdated. Intermediary bodies are so necessary in a country like ours, for how can we formalize demands or proposals without their presence? How can we negotiate without their mediation? How can we seek compromises without their meeting?

Intermediary bodies are useful to democracy, not simply in relation to the interests they represent, but also in relation to the search for the general interest. What place, what role for these actors? This question has led to initiatives that have gradually paved the way for the creation of an Economic and Social Council.

I do not know if this idea originated with Henri IV, as the president suggested, but what I do know is that as early as 1848, that is, with the proclamation of the Second Republic, the Luxembourg Commission was created; it was the first attempt to bring together representatives of employers and employees to reflect on working conditions.

Later, the laws of 1884 and 1901, by recognizing unions and associations, constituted an essential milestone in the construction of a social democracy. Then we had to wait for the government of Édouard HERRIOT for the creation of a National Economic Council by law. 47 initial members who ultimately foreshadowed those who are here today. Already, it brought together in one place unions, employer organizations, the agricultural world, and associations. The political upheavals that followed, particularly the Popular Front, gave a new ambition to this desire to act to evolve the elements of French social law. It was also in this body that the law on the 40-hour workweek was developed.

The Vichy regime simply abolished the institution because it was incompatible with the authoritarian conception of corporatism. That is why, during the Resistance and then at Liberation, there was this movement to create an Economic and Social Council and to make it the 3rd Assembly of the Republic.

Thus, your institution was recognized in the Constitution of 1946, with the same approach as yours today, to produce opinions, to intervene on all crucial questions, and at that time, it was about the reconstruction of the country.

The advent of the Fifth Republic could have marked the disappearance of the Economic and Social Council. But the Constitution of 1958 took up that of 1946 and even expanded the composition of the Council to include qualified personalities.

General De GAULLE in 1969, as part of this major reform submitted to referendum, wanted to merge the Economic and Social Council with the Senate. The rejection of the text paradoxically strengthened your institution.

The last step, as you recalled, Mr. President, is the constitutional law of July 23, 2008, and the organic law that followed, with expanded representation for young students and a strengthening of its openness to environmental associations, which makes the CESE an institution particularly in tune with the challenges of the 21st century.

You embody through your existence, through your functioning, a certain conception of democracy that I want to summarize in two key ideas.

The first idea is that France can be united beyond its differences and even starting from them because the CESE is the place where all the Frances that make up France meet. The France of employees and employers, of businesses and work of all categories, of all sizes, the France of farmers, the France of environmental defenders, the France of independents, artisans, mutualists, the France of commitment, of the associative and cooperative movement, families, professionals, volunteers, in short, all generations and even all territories with the regional economic and social councils.

The second key idea embodied by the CESE is dialogue; it is one of the places in the Republic where opposing interests can learn to know and recognize each other, in a framework that respects each one's specificities. Here, you do not seek consensus at all costs, but you forge compromises that allow progress. If there are convergences, you respect the divergences because you consider that they enrich the debate.

I know the objections that are regularly raised against the CESE. What is the point of another body based on the principle of designation rather than election, some tell us. What is the role of an assembly that only gives opinions, others say. And then there are the more radical voices, which always exist, who, in the name of simplifying our institutions, want to simply abolish the CESE, or, within the framework of a legitimate inspiration, return to the idea of a merger with the Senate.

I respond to you, in the context we know and which is serious, of a distrust towards institutions, of a distancing even from voting and democracy in its most essential form, your Council can be one of the solutions to this civic malaise that the extremes can seize upon. You are not, it is true, elected representatives of the people, but you are representatives of all of society. You are not an addition of categories; you are an aggregation of living forces in service of the progress of our country. You are not just another assembly whose majority could vary with the alternations; you are an institution whose composition is stable even if it is regularly renewed; it was renewed in 2015 and is composed equally, the only assembly of the Republic to achieve this result today.

Your role, as you recalled, Mr. President, is to prepare decisions and evaluate choices, to think long-term, to program the future. The Planning Commission, which long accompanied the reconstruction and modernization of our country, was abolished several years ago. But the strategic function of the State, of the nation, remains essential. The CESE can contribute to carrying it, going beyond political mandates, going as far as what public decision can do and which will concern generations to come.

Engaging in policies that will even surpass those who have carried them is, by the way, provided for in the Constitution; I reread it before coming before you. It is stated that all programming laws must come before the Economic and Social Council, to then be presented to the National Assembly and the Senate. Because that was the original idea, and it remains the most modern idea, to ensure that we can, through you and what you represent, be capable of outlining what France will be tomorrow and the day after, what it must discard and what it must carry, what it must concentrate its efforts on to be more itself, so that it can meet the challenges.

You must prepare for new developments, not just in the economic and social domain, but on major issues: the digital society and what it can produce, both as advantages and as risks; territorial fractures; public service and the civil service - that is why you will soon reflect on this subject; the place of young people in an aging society; universal income; the capacity to invest in the economy that will be that of tomorrow, that is, the energy transition.

I know that since the renewal of 2015, your activity has been particularly intense, as in less than a year the government has seized you 10 times, which is already a third of the activity of the previous mandate. Several of your opinions have already resonated; I am thinking particularly of the one regarding the posting of workers, which helped us prepare the labor law and to conduct negotiations at the European level, to challenge the directive and the abuses it generated. I also think of social dialogue; your recent opinion, even in a tumultuous period, was salutary to clearly show that we needed to organize social dialogue, even if the laws contributed to it. Social dialogue also belongs to and primarily to the social partners.

In the same way, what you said about climate justice allows the Economic and Social Council to be in tune with what will now be the translation of the Paris Agreement. You also produced an annual report on the state of France, which allows, beyond the statistics that can be published month after month or quarter after quarter, to know exactly the situation of our country.

Your recommendations, I say, are most often followed by action, and I also want to emphasize why I wanted the social and environmental conferences to be organized at the CESE. Because it was important for me to broaden consultation as much as possible and to make this place the venue for public debate, where there can be an exchange and also the preparation of decisions.

The social conferences have thus created the conditions for interprofessional negotiations that have been transposed by law; I am thinking of the generation contract, job security, professional training, and quality of life at work. Negotiations that have been transposed by law, and that was my conception of social democracy and political democracy. Allowing negotiation to take its rightful place, and when it has led to a sufficiently broad, majority agreement, then the legislator, while not losing any of its rights, must ensure its transcription.

But we have also used the social conferences to have exchanges on what fell under the social partners, particularly within the framework of parity. The complementary retirement schemes or UNEDIC, and I wish to say here that negotiations can resume, so that there can be a sustainability of what we have already initiated as reforms and also the necessary evolutions. It is up to the social partners to take their responsibilities.

I also want to say that it is here that the government's orientations have been discussed together, which have translated into matters of retirement, family policy, and the competitiveness of businesses; I am thinking of the Responsibility Pact, but also of professional equality, both in the private sector and in the civil service.

Among all these advances linked to these social conferences, I want to mention two.

The first is related to urgency; it is the Youth Guarantee. This device concerns young people who are neither in employment, nor in training, nor seeking to integrate into life and the world of work. It is an idea that also emerged from these exchanges and which was first translated into an experiment. For several months, local missions were able to support young people in preparing for their integration into the company, facilitating access to autonomy and particularly to housing. We were able to propose 100,000 Youth Guarantees for the year 2016, with, by the way, financial assistance for each of these young people, which can go up to 460. But we decided, based on this experience, to generalize the Youth Guarantee within the framework of the labor law.

I also want to tell you that this idea of the Youth Guarantee, so essential for these audiences, who are without reference, without solution, and who can drift, who can feel abandoned, is an idea that we have shared at the European level. I want the Youth Guarantee to be one of the measures that, at the European level, is promoted and amplified.

The second advancement I want to highlight, because it is not linked to urgency, is long-term in nature; it is the Personal Activity Account, the CPA. France often reduces major reforms to acronyms, losing the very meaning of what we want to achieve. What is the Personal Activity Account? It is the asset of employees, I would say their capital; it is a new model of individualized social rights. The objective is to adapt employees to the changes in the economy and the world of work while providing them with a capital that is time. The Personal Activity Account integrates the Personal Training Account, the Personal Prevention Account for Hardship, and a new Citizen Engagement Account.

In practical terms, it is open to every person at the beginning of their professional life, and they will be able to keep this account, add additional time to it until their retirement, regardless of their status: employee, civil servant, self-employed worker, job seeker, through their transitions in various jobs throughout their career. This is a major reform; I dare not say a revolution, and these reforms are long-term and take on their full meaning as we discover what they can enable: professional transitions, personal promotions, individual rights within a collective framework, a lifelong journey.

Innovative in terms of social model, this reform also proves that it is through training that we can provide more opportunities, not only to those waiting for a job but also to those already employed. This fundamental right to qualification, promotion, elevation, and success—this is what the Personal Activity Account allows, with a right that is personal, belonging only to the one who has established it, but made possible by a collective framework. A great reform that will endure.

There have been environmental conferences; they were also held here and mobilized even more actors. It was important that the active forces could again be present in this reflection.

Thanks to the work initiated here, two major laws have been adopted; your opinions have once again been useful. The first is the law on energy transition; it happens that the multiannual energy programming was published this very morning, thus reducing the share of nuclear power in electricity production and increasing renewable energies. I remind you that these renewable energies will double: their share in electricity production, currently 20%, will rise to 40% by 2030. This law also contains very concrete, very precise measures to not only stimulate renewable energies but also energy efficiency through housing renovations, the development of clean transport, and the circular economy, not to mention participatory financing.

The second law, which was also developed during these environmental conferences, is the creation of the Agency for Biodiversity. This agency, created by the law of August 8, 2016, which brings together a number of establishments, practically all those that existed until now, will work with local authorities, businesses, non-governmental organizations, and associations to improve and protect our environment and manage biodiversity in a clear and responsible manner.

This is what these environmental conferences have served: debate, of course, reflection surely, and decision certainly. You are accustomed, Mr. President, and you have just done it again, to describe the Economic, Social and Environmental Council as France in miniature. It is true that there are not many places conducive to the development of shared observations. I see in this reflection the first path forward for your council.

You have also wanted to engage in the evaluation of public policies, to assess not the decision itself but what it has produced, to note the positive outcomes when they exist, but also the delays or shortcomings that may have been contained in the laws or regulatory texts at some point.

Your project of collaboration with the Court of Auditors is very welcome because we need this evaluation—not simply a judgment on the accounts, which falls under financial jurisdiction, but a judgment on public management, what it has produced as results, and therefore, on the choices because you are an assembly of the Republic.

You have also wished to fully exercise the role that the Constitution recognizes for you since its revision on citizen participation. The CESE can—and indeed must—take up any petition, as long as it gathers more than 500,000 signatures. Nothing prevents it from also taking the initiative, anticipating the concerns of the country, which your composition certainly allows you to grasp well. This intervention in the process of citizen petitions seems particularly timely and coherent today and complementary to the proposal I made to see a parliamentary debate necessarily organized when 500,000 signatories have indeed signed the same text, which your Council will have examined, formulated an opinion on, and transmitted to the competent assemblies for consideration.

I even propose to go further with the creation of a right to citizen participation, of which you would ultimately be the guarantors—ensuring that, as you yourself said, petitions or a number of movements can exist, having the will to engage the public authorities in reflections for a national debate. You could ensure this approach, which would itself enrich the legislative process.

It so happens that I was yesterday with several ministers who are here, in front of the citizen councils, 1,000 citizen councils that have been created in all the neighborhoods of the city policy, with an original composition since part of them are representatives of associations, and for another part, citizens drawn by lot.

It is an old debate, indeed, to draw a number of citizens by lot so that they can voice their opinions and give their input on a number of subjects. What struck me was the enthusiasm that had seized these citizens, who even wanted to be fully active, to be trained to do so, to be able not just to give an opinion but to co-develop policies. What they wanted was not to appear as a new municipal opposition or worse, an instrument of the elected council. They truly wanted to be co-actors, co-developers of these public policies. More and more, we will have this demand that we must master. It is not about calling into question political democracy, nor social democracy through representatives, nor even the associative world that has the vocation to transmit, to express, but to be able not to frame— in the sense that it should be limited—this voice, but to carry it—and to make responsible citizens who know how far to go, what their role can be.

The worst thing in a democracy is silence; it is indifference that can lead if we do not heed this silence and if we do not make a number of warnings regarding indifference to violence and brutality. This is the responsibility that is ours.

I also know that everyday democracy must allow for large citizen consultations on eminent subjects. Again, at your initiative, you can launch debates and then bring the conclusions of these debates before the entire Nation.

I will not forget the European dimension of your activities. You can contribute to the definition or redefinition of the European project at a time when the Union is experiencing a profound crisis, an existential crisis with a country leaving the Union and others unable to ensure effective solidarity or to take sufficiently effective measures for our security or defense.

There is therefore a European Economic and Social Committee; it is an institution. Is it heard enough, especially at this moment when Europe, if it wants to be listened to again by the peoples, must give hope? First to the youth, by promoting training, mobility, culture, but also to all those who want Europe to be ahead, to be capable of preparing for the future with infrastructure, with digital technology, with energy transition, with higher education, with research, and also with the very idea of public service.

Finally, the Council fully plays its international role; from this point of view, it is also a part of French diplomacy that you ensure. How many times have I seen representatives of African or Asian countries look at the CESE as a reference, as an example to also ensure the representation of civil society? You must therefore also participate in this movement because it is also a way to share this French uniqueness with the whole world.

I want to conclude with this reflection. The major issue for French society is trust in its future. Its problem is doubt about the collective capacity to guarantee progress for future generations. The risk is fragmentation, division, ruptures, and retreats. The major challenge is therefore the cohesion of the country and the definition of a model that allows for shared success—which requires seeking all the factors of dynamism in our economy and ensuring their diffusion, the diffusion of the benefits derived from these opportunities to all. This also requires personalizing our social policies more to reduce inequalities upstream—finally, to make political institutions more open, offering citizens perspectives for participation in collective life and better representation.

What we have to manage is no longer an economic crisis; it is a much greater challenge. We have, in this regard, taken measures that have allowed us to restore the country's accounts and find a path to growth, even if it is still too weak. But it is not simply with growth that we can regain cohesion. It is necessary. Cohesion is about being able to bring the entire country together, in all its diversity, around a common project, not just living together, which is ultimately the minimum, but doing together over time. This is the vocation of the CESE for the years to come—to remain this place, indeed, of consultation and dialogue, this link—as you said, Mr. President—between forces that make their contradiction a lever, and to become a forum for citizen debates and civic engagement. Because it is at the moment when democracy is put to the test that it must find within itself, including in its oldest institutions, the forces of its renewal to unify French society.

This is the entire place that the CESE must take in this democratic renovation. This is the entire essential mission that is ours: to unite the country, give it cohesion, project it into the future, and instill confidence in its destiny.

Thank you.