Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on efforts for higher education, in Saclay on September 17, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

17 September 2015 · Statement on efforts for higher education · Saclay

Context
Hollande addressed students and officials at the University of Paris-Sud on the Paris-Saclay campus to outline his government's vision for higher education reform in France.
Main themes
Higher education reform, university excellence, student success and democratization, research and innovation, Paris-Saclay campus, globalization and competition, youth as national priority, internationalization of French universities, grandes écoles and university rapprochement, digital transformation, foreign student enrollment
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,767
90th percentile
Sentences
199
89th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 58%57%
  • Economic 19%19%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

199 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Madam, gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians, elected officials,

Gentlemen presidents,

Ladies and gentlemen students.

I am therefore starting my university year.

I needed to find a place of excellence. There were many in France. I needed to be in one of the largest universities in Europe. There weren't necessarily many in France, but there was yours. The University of Paris Sud at the heart of Paris Saclay.

I also wanted this return to have a symbolic character. To be on a campus that will tomorrow be that of many students, tens of thousands, but also that will be part of an urban scientific project, within the framework of sustainable development, that is to say, an exemplary project.

I come before you, you are students following different programs, and that is what makes the originality of Paris Saclay and your university. Being able to bring together, work with, and research students with their teachers, who can together participate in raising the scientific level of our country.

France needs strong universities, a brilliant higher education system. Not simply to continue a tradition; we know what universities have represented in the history of France. No, it is because it is a decisive issue in the context of globalization, of competition, because competition is also there, in knowledge, in know-how, in places of excellence, in research. If France wants to be at its best level, it must invest not only in its youth but in its universities, in its schools, and in its higher education.

Youth is the priority of my term. You will tell me, it should be the priority of all public action, since it is what will allow our country to move forward.

To translate this priority, there is, of course, school, from the youngest age, but there is also what we must provide as a perspective to every young person: the ability to access a program of excellence. It can be general, it can be professional, it can be at a school level, but it must be open through its universities to all successes.

Universities have undergone considerable changes over the past 20 years. First, there has been an increase in the student population; there has also been research that has become increasingly internationalized; there has been the rapprochement of universities and grandes écoles. Digital technology has also arrived, which has disrupted a number of learning conditions. And there has been, and this was not a given, the presence of companies at the very heart of universities.

So our universities must - even in this context that has considerably disrupted their conditions of existence and operation - always meet the same requirements. What is expected of the university is to welcome democratization, to transmit knowledge at the highest level of know-how, which requires highly qualified teaching staff. What is expected of the university and higher education is research. There can be no university without research, no research without higher education.

So we are facing this transformation, and at the same time, for demographic reasons but also for political will, there are more and more students in our country. For the past three years, 150,000 more students, those who are good at calculations, and I believe this is the place, have pointed out that 150,000 students is equivalent to 7 to 8 additional universities. If they make that reasoning, it is also to arrive at a budgetary calculation; but to suggest that this should also be accompanied by as many resources. In a way, it is irrefutable.

So there are more and more students, and there will always be more. What we ask of higher education is not only to welcome these students in various forms, from grandes écoles to universities, but at the same time to help them succeed because what would be the use of a higher education system that is open, that sees its numbers grow, if at the end of each of your journeys, there is no success? Success in all its forms, the diploma, but also professional success, employment, or success in academic terms, access to a research path. So we need to combine quantitative reception, democratization, the demand for a stronger presence of young people in higher education, and quality, and excellence.

But let us remain on a positive note; if there are more and more students, it is also because young people trust the university, the grandes écoles, higher education. Trust in the diploma, which should lead to employment, trust in the knowledge that is provided, trust in the teachers who accompany them here. This trust is that of French students, it is also that of foreign students.

There are 300,000 from all continents who are enrolled in French higher education. This represents 12% of all students; our goal is to reach 20%. At the same time that we have this desire to welcome more French students, we also have the ambition to welcome more foreign students. Not simply because we have a duty of international solidarity, even if we do, but simply because it is an opportunity for France to welcome young people from all continents who will bring us their experience, their knowledge, their desire to learn, and who will also tomorrow be the best defenders of France's interests, including in terms of the ideas we carry around the world. You know the dramas that today strike the Middle East, these young or less young people who leave Syria or Iraq, among them, there are students. We must ensure that those who come to us can also resume their studies.

I went not far from here, it was in Cergy-Pontoise, to meet these refugees, not so many by the way, who had been in our country for several days, many were young, I asked them: "Where were you, what were you doing?" Many were students. So their first request, almost before talking about housing or their own living conditions, was: "Will we be able to enter a new university cycle?" It is our duty. But beyond these situations, we want to welcome more foreign students.

We must not disappoint this trust. We must therefore ensure that this democratization is truly one, that is to say, that young people can be in conditions not only to access higher education but at the same time to be able to stay there. Nothing is worse than selection by failure. Nothing is worse than the disappointment of having followed a first university cycle and not having extended it. To achieve this true democratization, which also helps to combat social fatalism, the reproduction that we know well, even if I believe that now with the number of students in our universities, in our higher education, there is fortunately a reduction in social disparities.

But we must ensure that we can mobilize more scholarships, based on social criteria, and since 2012, the Government has allocated 500 million euros for this university year. For this single university year, there are 135,000 additional scholarship holders out of a total of nearly 700,000 scholarship holders, 660,000 if I want to be precise. What does this mean? It means that one in four students is financially supported by the State. I am not just talking about the tax benefits that may be linked to the presence of a student in the household. Why do we want there to be this support, even if sometimes they are still too modest compared to the situation of many of you? But because it is the condition for you to be able to study and succeed. Because we have also ruled out selection by money. By the way, this year, tuition fees will not increase; this is the first time in years. It is true that there are countries that consider that the proof of the quality of higher education is high tuition fees. We know these countries. Sometimes they succeed; but there are other models, the Germans for example, the Scandinavians have the same system as us, relatively modest tuition fees. Which, by the way, poses a problem for the functioning of universities, I agree. So what we do not ask students through tuition fees, we must ask the national community, in the name of solidarity.

I will also share with you a feeling I have. When I see students who have graduated from our universities, from our grandes écoles, and who rightly want to value their diploma, I tell them: "Think also about what the State and your parents have done for you; think that all this education has been financed. Do not believe that you are simply the product of a selection, the product of a success. You have merit, you have worked, but you also owe it to what the State has done for you; and you can also at some point give back to the State what it has brought you, to the Republic so that it can continue, for your own children tomorrow and for the success of the country, what it has already allowed you to do."

So we do not want selection by money, but we also want students to have a professional experience. This is the whole question, sometimes controversial, of internships. The law of August 10, 2014, not only considered that internships should find their place in higher education but that these internships should be better paid, better controlled sometimes. I also know that there are students who work to continue their studies. We have ensured that there can be an activity bonus to support them, and this will concern 100,000 students.

We also want to facilitate access to housing. This is a major issue that also concerns your university since here you will also build or construct housing. Because we want to have campuses, because we also want students not to spend too much time in transport. So since 2013, we have built 12,000 student housing units. There will be 40,000 by 2017. We have introduced a mechanism, the student rental guarantee, to allow some of you, even if you do not necessarily have your parents' guarantee, to access housing.

The minister, along with Thierry Mandon, is preparing a national student life plan that will allow, here as elsewhere, to strengthen access to rights, enable engagement - this question has come up several times - improve access to health, and ensure that life on campuses can also be as attractive as possible. This plan will be presented in the coming weeks and will include a promise I made that is now fulfilled, which is the gap year in academic paths. To make it possible, during a university cycle, to take a break either because there is a desire to engage, or because there is a personal desire, or because there is - this was posed to me - a desire to create a business and then return to the academic path.

This is what we wanted, democratization that is not massification. Massification gives the impression that we simply want to increase numbers. Democratization is about achieving success. To ensure this success, we asked ourselves the question: how can we make our higher education system - which is based on the history, on the identity of many institutions, sometimes the most prestigious - how can we create a true community of higher education? So the law, which was passed in July 2013, introduced the grouping of higher education institutions and research organizations and also modernized their governance. If you want an example, it is that of the Saclay cluster, because it has allowed the grouping of two universities, grandes écoles, research organizations, and together, to be of the necessary size not simply because it would be large or because it would be big, but because it would be the right size to be able to pool, to converge, and also to give a form of excellence label. This is also what we wanted to achieve through the recognition by the IDEX.

During the discussion of this law, there was a debate, as there sometimes is in France, that is to say, about obvious things, but with extremely sharp positions. The question at the time of the debate - I speak before the parliamentarians - was whether we should allow teaching in the English language in universities? I am very attached to Francophonie, but to think that it would not be possible to provide teaching in English, sometimes to students who themselves are foreign, to not welcome all the researcher-students who would like to join us, to think that there would be some kind of breach of fundamental principles, almost republican, of our Human Rights, by having courses that could be taught, for a time, in English, is to not understand what the university system is. Here you have these courses, and I think it is very important for attractiveness, for influence, and therefore for the French language. Because at some point, foreign students end up speaking French. This is still an asset for our country.

The second issue: grouping, international openness, new technologies. Digital technology is part of the major tools that contribute to the modernization of higher education. Here too, an endless debate, does digital not replace traditional teaching? Does digital not remove the role of the teacher? But digital is also the possibility of having information, knowledge, and know-how that comes from all over the world, provided that we can analyze and decipher it! It is also this extraordinary adventure of MOOCs that allows us to share with many Francophone countries what we have in common, and this is also part of your successes here at Saclay.

So once we have talked about what we have already done, the structures we have put in place, our willingness to welcome, our pride in being among the best today, we must still think about what we want to do with higher education in 10 years?

Why 10 years? Because if it is beyond 10 years, no one thinks it is possible, and if it is less than 10 years, no one thinks it is achievable. So 10 years is a good objective. We asked two great academics, Bertrand MONTHUBERT and Sophie BEJEAN, to think about a national strategy for higher education, to say what we can expect from higher education and what higher education can expect from the State and local authorities, because we are now linked? This is what these authors were able to do and presented to me around the idea of making French society a learning society. I do not know if it is proper French to say learning society, but the neologism has its interest. It means learning throughout one’s life, that is to say, learning well, it means always trying to know and understand, and this learning society allows us to have an ambition in terms of raising qualifications, to fully utilize the digital revolution, to be able to propose this challenge not only to young people but also to older individuals, particularly to employees, and to make this learning society a society of sustainable growth. This strategy is supported by a major objective that I take, as far as I am concerned, as an objective that should be that of the nation.

To bring 60% of an age group to a higher education diploma in 10 years, of which 50% at the bachelor’s level and 25% at the master’s level. So I will be told, “But is this realistic, is it really possible?” A long time ago, a President of the Republic, François MITTERRAND, spoke of 80% of an age group at the baccalaureate level, it took more than 10 years, but it was done, and today we must have the same ambition, to raise the level of knowledge, and having this rate of 60% puts us not much higher than others, because other countries also have this will, so it is to stay in the race and, if possible, to lead it. And I therefore expect the ministers to take up the conclusions of what is called the StraNES report and translate it, not into another language, but into a financial and administrative language. What does this mean, when we have this objective, what does it mean in terms of financial resources, in terms of organization, in terms of mobilization, what does it mean in terms of student support, what does it mean in terms of student orientation?

Orientation is crucial; we must avoid the pitfalls that lead to failure, we must ensure that success in the first university cycles can be complete. This requires improving information, raising awareness among young people from high school, the link between your university and the high schools in Île-de-France that may be concerned, therefore the high school students.

We must also ensure that the choice of a field corresponds not to a destiny; sometimes one enrolls without having fully decided on one’s profession, but at least to a desire, a will, an ambition. Orientation should not simply be an easy option; we should not go towards the same fields, always the same, and reproduce them, even though it is not necessarily either the desire or the need of the economy. We must also avoid what is even more unfortunate, that is to say, random selection; I went into a university field because I was chosen, not based on my qualities, but simply by a random draw. So we must ensure that there can be orientations that are better managed, better understood, better supported, and with capacities that also correspond to the desires and choices, but that also correspond to the needs of the economy. We cannot lead young people towards fields, sometimes long ones, when we know perfectly well that there will not be any opportunities afterwards.

Therefore, we will reform orientation while avoiding selection. I know that there are selective fields; we have excellent, remarkable ones, well-known, the system of grandes écoles, but let us not allow it to be believed that university is a guaranteed diploma. It is work, it is an investment, it is a commitment, and what matters is the level that will be recognized nationally and internationally. What we wanted to do precisely with these groupings is to ensure that students from grandes écoles, like students from universities, can have mobility, that some come to do research in universities, that students can go to grandes écoles so that, in the end, we can be stronger collectively and more assured individually.

As I said, the university is not simply the place for the initial training of young people, of you; it is also the objective of training throughout life, having back-and-forth exchanges between employment and the place of training, which you will inevitably have in your life, something that in my generation was unthinkable. However, today, given the speed of technological changes, changes in jobs, and what will be provoked by both digital technology and the energy and ecological transition, we will have to relearn anyway. So we will ensure that the university can, with higher education, achieve this.

I arrive at your university, Paris Saclay, I therefore greet its president, a broad grouping of institutions, as I said, with the grandes écoles present here that will be increasingly numerous, along with universities, with research centers, and it is an unprecedented gathering of forces that you have been able to accomplish. It happens that in my university life (I had one!), going to the Saclay plateau, or Jouy-en-Josas, was considered an expatriation. There were even student movements to prevent leaving. It is true that there was no means of transport at the time; you have noticed that now there are many, so you see what remains to be done, and the commitments that have been made and the investments that will need to be made. But, I return to what has happened here, with this common will that makes you part of a whole where there are multiple activities. You will undertake a university life project, over a few years, which will also be a project where you will exchange, mingle, and have an incomparable experience and an incomparable identification, labeling. We need to have these exceptional places, known everywhere. They are often cited, they are cited abroad, they were not cited much in France; we cited schools, we cited universities, but we did not cite the ensembles. Today, Paris Saclay will be an ensemble. Not simply a collection of knowledge, a collection of research, because research is the essential element.

So for that, we need to invest. It is the responsibility of the State; I believe it is around 1.5 billion, which is considerable. There is a jury, the Future Investment Program, its president is here, Louis SCHWEITZER, he has significant resources today, you must consider him, because he judges you, since, even if it is not him, an international jury is constituted, we wanted that. Because what we wanted is for it to be recognized. Not simply by presidential or ministerial will, because we would have said, it is here, no, we wanted it to be an international recognition by the best researchers and academics. I believe you will be in the famous Shanghai ranking, but I have no specific information, and this ranking is not, for us, the supreme knowledge, but you will be among the best. I said it, you have here a tremendous potential; it is here that you will have the highest master’s and doctoral training, and you must pursue this objective continuously.

It is an opportunity, I say this before the elected officials, for the territory. The elected officials, who are increasingly solicited, there is the State, and then the region, the departments, and the agglomerations or cities. They must understand, these local authorities, that it is an issue for their own image, for their own territory, that it will have considerable consequences in terms of business creation, housing, communal life, that it is also an exceptional chance to have so many young people present, even recognized internationally. So there must be this synergy; it must not be a battle simply over who will pay and how much, or who will prioritize housing, who will have the research sites, which is why I asked the prefect of the Île-de-France region to fully dedicate himself to this task so that we can make this territory live and connect it to the capital by the most modern means of transport. Therefore, there will be significant infrastructures created on the plateau, there will be the arrival of a metro line, which will complement the road service. There is the Saclay campus itself, with the means of the PIA, Future Investment Program, of which I want to emphasize, once again, the role. Why?

This PIA, Future Investment Program, represents about 36 billion euros of funding that has already been committed or is about to be. We will add another 10 billion euros, so that may not mean much to you, but it represents 24 billion for higher education, training, and research, that is to say, of these resources, 24 billion are dedicated to research, two-thirds. Because that is the message we wanted to convey, confidence in the future, it is called the Future Investment Program. You are the future, the university is the future, research is the future, so the majority of resources are for having cutting-edge equipment, excellence programs, multidisciplinary approaches, the rapprochement of research, training, and business.

And the PIA will experience a new development; I announced it a few months ago, I confirm it here, we will open a new program, a new loan, to finance new operations, because we want there to be more master’s programs, we also want to enhance these trainings, in innovation, in the creation of start-ups, that is a very important point.

The university is a place for business creation, higher education in general, grandes écoles as well. Now in all schools, all universities, there is a dedicated space for creation. I even met, he is here, the vice-president of the university who is already a business creator and who wonders if he will be able to remain a student. He is already the vice-president of the university! If he wants to be president one day, he must stay at the university, or he has another ambition, but he should declare it!

But being able to create one's own business or to have it created at the university, in the school, and having the possibility for others to create jobs is still an ambition that we must carry. This implies that there are dedicated places, facilitators, and bankers who can also provide their financing. Now, this is also the role of the university. There are more and more students who are creating businesses. For this, I wish that the Future Investment Program has as one of its criteria the desire to promote everything that can lead to the creation of jobs, the dissemination of technology, the dissemination of innovation, particularly on the side of small and medium-sized enterprises. Therefore, a PIA of 10 billion will be launched in 2016 and it will support the major orientations that I have just outlined. That is what I wanted to tell you.

Our higher education system is a major issue for our country. Our higher education system is advancing and it is much more mobile, much more determined than it is said, the most flexible. For a long time, universities were viewed as places of threat. This goes back a long way; there was even a fear of concentrations of students. That is why they were perhaps somewhat distanced from the capital. It was thought that academics did not want to change and that they had retreated into their laboratories or their lecture halls. The opposite has happened. When we proposed this great ambition and it again figures as a national priority, there is mobilization. Students - I hope so - teacher-researchers - I am sure of it - professors, all categories of staff here in the university, who even had the capacity to come together, which was not a given, to seek funding, to meet partners, who were sometimes sidelined, large research organizations, and also businesses. For a long time, businesses were on the sidelines; there was a fear that they would professionalize the university, and then businesses wondered if academics would impose research methods that did not correspond to their immediate interests! No, that did not correspond to their immediate interests. It was the interest of the country, and together everyone spoke, elected officials, business leaders, researchers, academics, grandes écoles, and this has led to what is now beginning to take shape.

This is what I wanted to conclude with to say how capable our country is of moving forward. Sometimes it is believed to be frozen, sometimes it is believed to be timid, but as soon as a project is proposed to it, as soon as it is told that it has fundamental guarantees, the fundamental guarantee for higher education is autonomy, the ability to access the university without any other constraint than the desire to succeed, as soon as this perspective is offered to it, as soon as these guarantees are given, the higher education system is like all of France; it wants to move forward. It wants to succeed, but also on the condition that all the necessary conditions are provided to achieve this: funding, the budget will be safeguarded. There will be funding through the Future Investment Program. There will also be funding through vocational training to allow employees to come and train in higher education.

So, as soon as it is given finances, as soon as it is given pride, a pride in saying that you are the future of the nation and that this is where our destiny is also at stake, then we are sure to succeed. Because here I was struck, even though I stayed for a short time, by this multidisciplinarity, by this diversity that you represent, by also these numerous institutions that you have been able to federate here and that correspond to a very simple will that has always advanced the university and higher education, progress. Here you are all advocates of progress, of human progress, of scientific progress, of economic progress, of social progress, of ecological progress that is now necessary; progress is made in universities.

Thank you for being students, teachers who, in a way, are the artisans of progress in our country. Long live the Republic and long live France.