Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on employment policy, in Paris on April 28, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

28 April 2014 · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed senior state representatives in Paris on April 28, 2014, outlining France's employment policy priorities amid an emerging economic recovery.
Main themes
Employment policy, economic recovery, structural reforms, competitiveness and employment tax credit (CICE), youth unemployment, growth and investment, responsibility and solidarity pact, public deficit and debt, labor market reform, business support measures, professional training
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,537
89th percentile
Sentences
238
92nd percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.2
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 65%63%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

238 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen directors,

You are the representatives of the State, at the highest level, that of the centrality of the State and also that of the territories. You are in charge of the essentials, and what is the priority that our fellow citizens consider to be paramount? It is employment. What is the challenge of the period we are going through after five years of crisis? It is to be able to give a future to the country, to provide it with both the answers it expects and the confidence it is slow to regain in the face of difficulties. This has been stated by the Minister of Finance. We are at a decisive moment, as is often said. How many times have you heard experienced men and women here, successive presidents, successive prime ministers, the ministers you have known, tell you, "This is it, this is the decisive moment," and yet we are coming out of five years of stagnation. It is true that production in 2013 was exactly the same as in 2008, which means that beyond cyclical movements, a zero growth has been observed during what we have called the crisis. Unemployment is the consequence, with 1,300,000 more job seekers since 2008. Those who still think that there is no link between growth and employment should look at these figures with great meticulousness.

We are at a decisive moment. Why? Because a recovery is taking shape. In Europe, the trend is clear; in the United States, it is even confirmed. Investment is stirring, activity forecasts are improving, and growth is returning, still too weak, but the whole question is whether France will be there or not. That is why the moment is decisive: either we set off with the wind at our backs, or we remain stranded because we have not made the necessary efforts. The policy pursued over the past two years had no other aim: to prepare France for this cyclical turnaround. It is here. The urgency was to stem the rise in unemployment, which was achieved through exceptional means that have been made available to you, such as future jobs, generation contracts, subsidized contracts, training for job seekers, and so many other measures. The results are still partial, but I want to highlight one because it is essential: the decline in youth unemployment. Over the past year, it has decreased by more than 20,000 registered individuals. And this process is now underway.

Major reforms, known as structural reforms, have been successfully carried out over the past two years to address the weaknesses of our economy that everyone knows. We have had a trade deficit for ten years, reflecting a lack of competitiveness. We have had a public accounts deficit for thirty, forty years. Debt today exceeds 94% of national wealth; it was just over 50% ten years ago. Therefore, it was necessary to undertake structural reforms. These have concerned the labor market through an agreement reached between social partners and its transposition by the legislator. There has been professional training, again modernized; there has been the qualification of the most vulnerable employees, the financing of businesses through the BPI, the 34 industrial plans initiated by the Minister of Productive Recovery, and finally, the competitiveness and employment tax credit (CICE). Well, these reforms will produce all their effects. In two weeks, at the latest, the competitiveness and employment tax credit will be paid out; some companies were able to obtain a pre-financing in the year 2013; by the latest, on May 15 - and I ask you to carry out the necessary verifications - at the latest on May 15, all beneficiary companies, that is to say, all those with one or more employees, will receive a payment of 4% of their payroll in the form of a competitiveness and employment tax credit, the only ceiling being set at two and a half times the minimum wage. This will be an immediate improvement in companies' margins with the question raised by the Prime Minister: what will business leaders do with this support, which is not a one-off aid but a structural aid? Will they increase their investments? That would be good for competitiveness and therefore for employment. Will they raise salaries? That is an option. That would be good for purchasing power. Will they create jobs? That would be good for the fight against unemployment. There may be uses that deserve to be monitored here, but let us not start with a principle of suspicion. Because what matters is movement, investment, exportation, hiring, and the ramp-up of the CICE will continue in 2015. This is the challenge, and I will return to it, of the responsibility and solidarity pact.

So if we are having this meeting today, it is because we have decided, together with the Prime Minister and the members of the government, starting from what we have already achieved, to do even more quickly and even more strongly. The challenge is to create the conditions for sustainable growth in our country, and that is the spirit and the letter of the responsibility and solidarity pact. What is its objective? Employment. Because everything must be done so that companies have this priority, this preference for employment. I said during a press conference, it was on January 14, the responsibility pact - which has become the responsibility and solidarity pact - is 30 billion euros in relief for companies in terms of labor costs. A debate has been initiated, including with trade unions and businesses. How to translate these 30 billion euros in relief? What is the most effective formula? Companies have responded, and the union partners have given their views. Ultimately, the CICE was considered the most effective formula. So the CICE will be 20 billion euros in relief from labor costs in 2015. But we have decided to add 10 billion euros in additional relief both on low wages and across the entire wage hierarchy in the company to avoid putting companies facing international competition in a form of inequity. 30 billion to be more competitive, 30 billion to create more jobs and more wealth. It is a bet; there are always bets to be made. The only bet that should not be made is to do nothing because there, we know what happens; we have the experience, so we can extend. What is the bet? The bet is trust; it is to have trust. Trust in business leaders, trust in social partners because they all want to reduce unemployment. They all want to strengthen the industrial base of our country. They all care about the national interest, which can also be their own interest when it comes to succeeding in reviving the French economy.

Tomorrow, the national reform program, the trajectory of our public finances, the essence of the responsibility and solidarity pact will be presented to Parliament. The course is clear, and beyond the measures, beyond the devices, this course is simple: accelerate the pace of growth by reducing business costs. The second principle: support purchasing power by lowering mandatory levies. And the third: reduce deficits through savings, that is to say, by spending less. Yes, it is a courageous effort. The proof is that it had not been made, even if it had been initiated two years ago, but even with this effort of savings, public spending will continue to progress slightly. But in relation to the wealth created, it will decrease. We will have both better management of the State, Social Security, and local authorities without affecting the quality of public service, and at the same time, we will have companies that will be more competitive and even a purchasing power that we can redistribute to employees thanks to fiscal measures that we will introduce as early as the next finance law.

What is the idea? It is to improve the productive offer, which can indeed be initiated without weakening demand. But why is it necessary to restore the productive offer in France? Precisely because our industrial base is too narrow, because our competitiveness is too weak even if we have sectors of excellence, because our growth is not commensurate with our potential. Taking care of the offer is not about taking care of the results of companies; it is about taking care of companies so that they can be best positioned in competition and best disposed to hire and invest.

We also have structural reforms to carry out, with this question: what is a structural reform? We have been hearing that for so many years! A structural reform is a reform that allows for a change over time, not just a quick fix that is made because there is a budget constraint, no, what will allow us to organize differently in the company first, but also in the State, in local authorities, in the entire productive sphere as well as in the public sphere. A structural reform is to avoid spending what we do not need to do without efficiency. A structural reform is to put an end to rents that for years have allowed certain professions to live off our own conservatisms. A structural reform is to ensure that our country is in a position to take technologies and use them to the best, that is what structural reforms are.

We also have to restore public accounts, but at a pace that we have decided to set ourselves without adverse consequences on growth. I hear those who tell us: but ask for another delay, especially from the European Commission! But we have already obtained it, since last year we had a two-year extension of our obligations. So if we restore public accounts, it is not simply in relation to European commitments; it is simply because even if interest rates are low today, we do not benefit from allowing a debt to accumulate that would eventually exceed the total wealth produced each year.

This is what we have decided to do with the responsibility and solidarity pact. It is a strategy. What has perhaps been lacking in the State in recent years is knowing where it wanted to go for five years, ten years, where it wanted to take the country. In all other major developed countries, there is always this question: what is our future? What is the vision we must propose? Some countries have such growth rates, particularly emerging countries, that this question is almost superfluous. I always recount this meeting I had with the Chinese President. I asked him: but what is your objective? He said to me: to double production in ten years. One had to think of that! It had long been an objective, for example, for France after the war. But today, what is our objective? It is not simply to have a growth rate; it is to know if we can still be best positioned in global competition and even improve our positions, defend our territorial economic base, and allow especially the youth to know in what perspectives they can build their destiny.

So the responsibility and solidarity pact is not just a measure that we would have drawn from circumstances; it is France's strategy until the end of the five-year term, which is three years. And everything will be established precisely in the vote tomorrow so that everyone knows—parliamentarians, state officials, local authorities, economic actors, citizens—what the strategy is and where we want to go.

Until then, we also have an employment policy to maintain, amplify, and pursue; that is the role of the Minister of Labor and Employment; we are not done yet. And even if the economic situation improves, we will always have to promote youth employment, always fight against long-term unemployment, and always ensure that seniors can remain in employment or at least not be excluded without a prospect of return.

So what instruments do we have? Future jobs. It has been recalled: 120,000 young people have already benefited from the scheme; we want there to be 50,000 more in 2014, and we have two priorities: one priority, which I heard particularly in response to a question about what we could do on the side of the private sector, is to direct more future jobs towards the private sector; this also applies to subsidized jobs, not to make gifts to companies, but to encourage them to take their share in the integration of young people and in the return to employment of long-term unemployed individuals.

And then the second priority is to act for young people from what are called disadvantaged neighborhoods, which are actually full of assets. And again, I note that the objective is not being met. We must therefore accelerate efforts so that there are more future jobs, more subsidized jobs, particularly in the private sector for the neighborhoods targeted by urban policy.

Second instrument: the generation contracts. Everyone knows the system: a reduction in social contributions of 2,000 euros for each young person hired as long as there is a senior who remains in the company. But not all companies, especially the smallest ones, necessarily have a senior in their workforce. First problem. Second problem is that there are seniors who are currently unemployed, who request to benefit from the generation contract and sometimes find this possibility denied. So I have asked the government to modify the generation contract system in these two directions: to allow the generation contract to further encourage the hiring of a senior and to ensure that the contract can even be improved when it concerns a long-term unemployed person.

The third instrument is training for companies that are looking for employees and cannot find anyone to fill a number of job positions. We have known the problem for a long time: there are unfilled job offers and there is a number of job seekers who still cannot fill these job offers. So we have set up an exceptional program, the 30,000 plan since September, which has been a success. I set the goal with the Prime Minister: 100,000 qualifying training sessions to fill 100,000 jobs in our country. These jobs exist. They only require having qualified young or older individuals to occupy them. So it is an obligation, it is your obligation, it is our obligation.

The key, we know, is training. It is the countries that have invested the most in training that, even with low growth rates, fare the best in the fight against unemployment. Alternation must become a common pathway to employment. Today, there are still too many apprentices who cannot find a company to host them and too many business leaders who, in good faith, say they would be willing to host them but cannot. Again, I wish for a number of developments. I received from Mr. MESTRALLET a report that seemed relevant enough for me to immediately extract two provisions. The first is that I ask that long-term unemployed individuals, regardless of their age, be able to access alternation, or even benefit from the status of apprentice. Of course, their remuneration would be maintained at the level of the compensation as provided. The idea is that we can open the doors of companies to these long-term unemployed individuals. The second idea: there are today companies that make a significant effort in training their staff and are even willing to host unemployed individuals in their structures. That is to say, opening companies, especially the larger ones, to the unemployed, to long-term unemployed individuals, so that they can be qualified within the company, without it costing anything more to our existing systems since it would be taken from professional training funds. This is what I believe needs to be corrected in our training system.

Ladies and gentlemen, you are the representatives of the State and you therefore have a major role to play in this battle for employment. I first think of the pact of responsibility and solidarity. What strikes me always and for a long time is that governments think it is enough to develop provisions for them to be immediately known to those concerned. Perhaps the Prefects sometimes have the same feeling. We decide and no one is supposed to ignore the law. And yet how many times have I heard business leaders, again in perfect good faith, unaware of the competitiveness employment tax credit system! And perhaps they have also been vaccinated! They wonder if it is true! And if they think it is true one year, they are also aware that it may not be true the following year, given the great instability in administrative life and I am not even talking about fiscal life.

Well, we have the duty to tell them that the three-year responsibility pact, the CICE, the competitiveness employment tax credit, will be at 4% in 2014, at 6% in 2015, and that it will last at least until 2017. In 2017, what will happen? I am only talking about the competitiveness employment tax credit, the question will arise as to whether we transform this competitiveness employment tax credit into a general reduction of social contributions or whether we perpetuate it. But again, it will be a choice. In any case, the 30 billion will be made permanent. Your role is therefore to disseminate this information and to demonstrate that the mechanism will be sustainable.

Second piece of information: it was Minister SAPIN who mentioned what will happen on January 1, 2015. On January 1, 2015, on the payslip that an employer will issue to an employee paid at the minimum wage, thanks to the efforts I hope, combined, of all ministries and notably the Ministry of Social Affairs, on this payslip, the amount of social contributions for an employee paid at the minimum wage, it will be clearly indicated, will be zero. Some will tell me "but it may have already been zero"! Yes, but no one knew it. Neither the employer nor the employee. This meant that employers said "but I would like to, I have activity, but do you realize, if I hire an employee, I will have 50% in social contributions on the salary I will pay"! Whereas, here, we will demonstrate that for an employee paid at the minimum wage, it will be zero social charges, and this, from January 1, 2015.

Finally, the Minister of Finance made a confession, it is so rare, he did not know about the C3S. I will not conduct a survey at the end of this meeting to see who knows about the C3S. But it is true that most companies pay the C3S, that is to say a contribution that was made to finance the solidarity system. It has been decided, because it is a production cost, to eliminate this tax over three years, so that companies can have additional means to invest and therefore to know what the rule will be. In the same way, the corporate tax rate will be in the trajectory, as it will be presented tomorrow before Parliament. This trajectory will show that the corporate tax will continuously decrease until 2020, so that companies have this visibility, which commits us. This is what you have to provide as information.

You also have, as was said in the debate with the ministers, to evaluate what the negotiations, the discussions in the branches, in the companies, will be to set the countermeasures to the pact. Because trust must be reciprocal. The State has made its choices, companies will receive a number of reductions in commitments that many are ready for. I ask you to particularly follow the negotiations that will take place in the coming weeks and which will be evaluated at the next social conference at the beginning of July.

Ladies and gentlemen, the French want an efficient State, they want a State. Those who imagine that it would be the market that could determine the choices, that it would be private actors alone who could, through conventions or contracts, determine the general interest, are mistaken. Regardless of sensitivities, there is a very strong attachment of the French to the State. It still needs to be that the State is efficient. For it to be efficient, it is necessary to focus on its essential missions. The dynamic of simplification pushes us in this direction, the clarification of the responsibilities of local authorities obliges us to do so, and the budgetary effort leads us there.

I know that civil servants are ready, as long as they understand what is expected of them. I have therefore asked the Prime Minister, but he presented it to you a few minutes ago, to engage in this review of the missions of the State by drawing all the consequences of the decentralization laws that we have voted or that we will vote. A new decentralization will give Prefects and service directors more freedom to manage budgets, mobilize personnel, and adapt public action to territories. This work must be completed before the end of the year, so that we are ready to go in 2015. We must go all the way with the shock of simplification. I thank Thierry MANDON and Guillaume POITRINAL for working on this with determination and with results that will be produced throughout 2014.

It is true that we need, in any organized society and with a State that intends to be respected, rules and therefore control. But we need, in an open society, in a dynamic economy, we need initiatives, projects, innovations. Our responsibility, your responsibility, is to promote, whenever possible, these initiatives, these innovations, and these creations. Even if it means adjusting, in compliance with the laws, even if it means adjusting a number of systems to promote investment and employment.

Earlier, there was a question about the research tax credit, I confirmed, from the moment I took office, that not only would the research tax credit be safeguarded, but that it would even be expanded to innovation. The research tax credit is a considerable advantage for the French territory. Many globalized companies see France as particularly attractive, thanks to the research tax credit, for establishing laboratories. Because in no other country is there such a system. This allows us to have companies in France that continue to conduct research, that work more and more with universities, because it is very important, who also understand that we also need public research, because there is no exclusion regarding private research or public research, it is a combination. We must ensure that this research tax credit is fully utilized, including by SMEs.

But it turns out, that was the point of this question, that every time there is a request for a research tax credit, every time there is the payment of the research tax credit, there is a control. I recently met with companies from Aquitaine, and a business leader said to me: "I have submitted a request for a research tax credit ten times, each time it has been granted, and each time I have been audited. They found nothing. Can I hope that the 11th time, I will receive the payment without the audit?" I think it is very important, we must end the principle of suspicion that exists everywhere and which must be transformed into a principle of trust. This does not mean that there should not be control. This does not mean that there should not be verification at a certain moment regarding the objective that had been set. But it must be done with discernment, with intelligence, so that no constraint is imposed.

Sometimes, I have met companies, business leaders who said to me: "Will there be audits on the competitiveness employment tax credit? Not fiscal audits, but administrative audits?" No. Those who will conduct the audits, it is the whole interest of the system, are the social partners who will look, company by company, whether there has been a good use of these public supports.

This is the spirit that must be ours. Employment is the only priority that matters. Employment is the only obligation that counts. Employment is the only commitment we can make, eye to eye, before the French people. Because that is what they expect from those who have received the mandate of universal suffrage. That is what they expect from you, who are here, gathered, representatives of the State.

The defense of employment is also the State's approach in managing major industrial files. I think in this circumstance of ALSTOM, the State must necessarily have a say. Why? Because it is the one that orders, not the company, but that orders the company a number of purchases in completely strategic sectors, notably energy. The State must necessarily have its say. It is the one that also controls what France's energy independence should be. That is why the State uses this position, everyone understands it, all those who have an offer to present go to the State, so that it can ensure that the offers are improved, in the direction of localizing activities in France and employment in France. Regarding this file, I have only this single criterion: What will be most favorable for creating activity in France and for employment in France? With also an obligation, because I am the head of State: What also ensures France's energy independence? This is the mission that is ours: employment, growth, the recovery of France.

This battle calls for boldness, mobilization, and perseverance. It is based on a principle that is so simple, which is that of trust. The pact is an act of trust. The pact is a source of trust through the provisions it contains. I am often asked, "But what will be the exact number of jobs created by the pact of responsibility and solidarity?" There is always a temptation in France to want to quantify everything. How many jobs will the pact of responsibility and solidarity create? I wanted to say, as many jobs as possible! What will be the factor, what will be the lever? Surely, some mechanism, the psychology. Will, at some point, business leaders, will, at some point, those who decide, take action or remain on standby? What will be decisive with the pact is to create the trigger. It is in the moment we are going through that this moment, this trigger, must occur.

So, ladies and gentlemen, this is how the policy we are pursuing can give France confidence in itself. What I could also tell you, regarding the relationship you have with the partners you meet in your territories, is to speak well of France, always well of France, of those who animate it, the economic and social actors, of those who make it live, the elected officials, the companies that create activity there, the farmers who ensure that we can have the landscapes we know. Speak well of France. Because what is undoubtedly the problem of France today is that it doubts itself, it questions its future. It must first, in order to be conquering, be confident. It is because I have confidence in the State, I have confidence in the agents who serve it, that I also have confidence in France and that France will trust us. Thank you.