Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on health insurance reforms, in Nantes on June 12, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

12 June 2015 · Congress of the French Mutuality · Nantes, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Congress of the French Mutuality in Nantes on June 12, 2015, to assess health insurance reforms and reaffirm solidarity values.
Main themes
Complementary health insurance generalization, social protection reform, mutual insurance organizations, solidarity and social cohesion, healthcare system adaptation, health coverage access, Social Security principles, reform vs. status quo, savings and resource mobilization, justice between generations and territories
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,150
92nd percentile
Sentences
238
92nd percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.05
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 52%52%
  • Institutional 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Economic 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

238 sentences in 66 paragraphs

Mr. President of the French Mutuality, I thank you for inviting me to speak here in Nantes, before your Congress. I am pleased to see Jean-Marc AYRAULT again, Prime Minister for two years, who has greatly supported the developments I presented to you at your previous congress.

I greet the minister who has already addressed the congress participants, the mayor of Nantes, who welcomes us to her metropolis, and the parliamentarians and elected officials who go well beyond the department, as several of them follow health and social protection issues, both in the National Assembly and in the Senate.

It is true that this is the second time I am addressing you on the occasion of the congress of the French Mutuality. The first time was in Nice, three years ago in 2012, when I announced the generalization of complementary health insurance. I return before you to evaluate its implementation, regarding the commitments I made; but I am also here before you, on the occasion of your congress, to remind you of the strength of the values that mutuality embodies, which are all the more imperative in the context our country is experiencing.

In the face of withdrawal into oneself, the individualization of behaviors, distrust, and fear, we must more than ever affirm the principles of cohesion, justice, and solidarity, those very principles that you have long inscribed in your organizations.

Solidarity means giving everyone the means to be protected against the uncertainties of life, particularly illness. It also means guaranteeing access for all to the best care, regardless of income, age, or place in the territory. This was the ideal of the first mutuals when they were established at the end of the 19th century. It is still yours.

It was also the ideal held by the founders of Social Security, and you were right, Mr. President, not to dissociate mutuals from Social Security. "It was the grand design to continue in peacetime the solidarity built in wartime," to quote Pierre LAROQUE. This ideal is still yours, and this commitment is still ours.

Some would like to cast doubt on the relevance of this project by claiming that we can no longer afford it, that social protection has become a burden in economic competition, and that insurance mechanisms should ultimately take precedence. Others urge us not to change anything, standing firm against any evolution at the risk of calling into question the model they intend, surely in good faith, to protect. I remind you here: reform is the condition for progress, and the status quo is the certainty of regression.

This applies to our labor law, and I spoke yesterday at the International Labour Conference in Geneva to affirm that there are, in our country, foundations that must be preserved - foundations of rights, foundations of guarantees - but at the same time, we must also make the necessary adaptations in response to new challenges. This applies to our economic organization, to social dialogue, and it is the meaning of the bills currently being debated in Parliament.

But it also applies to the health system, which must adapt to innovations, scientific progress, new modes of care, the needs of patients, and the new aspirations of health professionals. We must each time show that we are faithful to principles and that we are capable of translating them according to realities.

Our duty, and mine, is to do everything possible to ensure that social protection in France remains one of the best in the world; indeed, that is what we proclaim! We should also verify this, given the infringements that may have occurred in recent years. We must ensure that our health system, which is undeniably among the best in the world, can always be there as a safety net for the French. And we must therefore allow it to integrate all innovations and progress, while ensuring that no one is excluded for financial reasons.

The condition, if we want to achieve this, is to make the necessary savings to mobilize resources so that our healthcare system is the most effective where it is most needed. And to do so with justice, between generations, between social categories, between individuals, between territories. This is the direction of the policy that the government has been pursuing for three years.

I have noted your words, Mr. President, regarding this policy. They are not very different from those expressed by many of our fellow citizens: hope is needed, and there is hope; concerns are often legitimate; impatience - that is the one I will focus on in my response.

It is true that reforms take time, too much time. Not because there is a form of resistance - that can happen! - or bad faith, but because, as I often say, our procedures are no longer adapted to the demand for speed and the urgencies of a society, especially when it comes to emerging from a crisis, providing responses to painful social situations, or offering support to the economy.

Waiting six months, eight months, sometimes longer, for a law to be passed, having this patience, and here, I say this before the parliamentarians, to hear amendments or proposals, sometimes to integrate them, to discuss them, one reading, two readings, three readings, a rewrite, and then to have a vote, sometimes a challenge before the Constitutional Council - this has become the rule, and in the meantime, yes, I measure the impatience, because when a reform is proclaimed, the generalization of complementary health insurance, I will return to this, but I could take other subjects, and the time it takes for it to actually apply, too much time passes.

And it is true that if we had a practice in France - you mentioned it, it exists in many of our neighbors - where social partners engage, sign, and ultimately declare what the general interest is, without necessarily having to go through the law, or then later, as a form of ratification, yes, that would go faster! Yes, that would put pressure on the actors who are meant to intervene - actors like Social Security, mutuals, complementary health insurance when it comes to health, but also businesses and employees. It is also true in the field of labor!

In France, it even took a law on social dialogue! Normally, this should have been the responsibility of the social partners. Who better than them can decide what negotiation and dialogue should be in a society like ours, and in companies? Yet it was necessary to resort to the law again. Sometimes, at the moment of signing, there is a kind of retention, a reserve. This is not the one you indicated. You yourself said that the Mutuality was ready to go further and take its responsibilities. So I understand this impatience. And at the same time, these are the rules of our democratic life, and I respect them; because what characterizes the action we have been taking for three years is respect for social partners. That is what we have done, particularly when it came to the interprofessional agreement that modified the rules of complementary coverage.

This is how we have also acted to implement the Competitiveness and Employment Tax Credit, and then the Responsibility Pact - to ensure that it is the partners who can accompany. In the area that interests you more, health, we have always wanted to negotiate and listen to the different stakeholders.

Today we must act in the name of solidarity. That is what we have done for three years.

With the minister, we have always refused to make patients pay for the recovery of our social accounts.

Because for too long, governments had competed in imagination, and there are always some when it comes to making significant cuts in patients' rights - governments had competed in imagination to make patients contribute: flat-rate contributions, ever-expanding deductibles, lowering reimbursement rates for medications, co-payments for heavy procedures in hospitals.

But since 2012, another path has been favored: that of better spending. Better spending to continue to reimburse well; better spending to avoid increasing levies; better spending to better respond to patients' needs; better spending to integrate medical progress. In this regard, while I have pointed out the delays, I want to highlight the speed with which the new medication capable of curing hepatitis C was introduced, despite its cost. Because it was a duty; because it was an obligation; and we preferred, yes, it was an additional burden, to integrate it into the accounts rather than deprive many patients of these innovations.

And I want to return to what the trend of health insurance expenditures was. Until the end of the 2000s, it was an increase of about 4% per year. Today, it is nearly 2%, and I want to commend the efforts of all, particularly yours, and those of health professionals, because without them we would not have achieved this controlled progression. This result deserves to be acknowledged.

Similarly, I want to point out that from 2006 to 2012, the share of healthcare spending covered by mandatory health insurance fell below 75%. This means that the burden had been shifted to complementary insurance, and failing that, to patients. Sometimes, by the way, on both. For the past three years, the share of mandatory health insurance has risen again, which has allowed for a reduction in out-of-pocket expenses and improved the purchasing power of the French.

Does this mean that the patient should have no responsibility in controlling expenditure? I do not think so. The patient must also be respected as a citizen, and he must be involved in prevention actions, in the treatment of his illness, in adhering to prescriptions. And all the information that can be provided to him - this is also the logic of the care pathway - the entire organization of the health system must lead to this responsibility. But I also say it clearly: the financial obstacle cannot be the answer to the patient's responsibility. That is why third-party payment is not irresponsibility! Third-party payment is one more step towards the simplification we all demand; but also towards an additional guarantee of equal access to health for all.

I know that, like any reform, and the third-party payment reform is no exception, it is approved in principle, but contested in its modalities. Sometimes, by contesting the modalities, one can also try to undermine the principle. But I believe that once again, pragmatism is the condition for success. We will proceed in stages, starting with the most modest, that is to say, the beneficiaries of complementary health assistance; this will be done as early as next month, on July 1, 2015; then from July 1, 2016, third-party payment will be extended to patients who are covered 100% by mandatory health insurance. Finally, it will be generalized at the end of 2017, and I have no doubt - I know that you will contribute - that technical solutions will be found by then. Because if there is no technical solution, there can be no solution at all.

It is always in the name of solidarity that I also wanted to generalize complementary health insurance. Nearly a quarter of medical expenses remains the responsibility of patients. But this average figure poorly indicates reality. It is true that this proportion rises to more than half for dental care, optics, prosthetics, and it is the complementary organizations, including mutuals, that cover the largest part of this. This means, Mr. President, you were right that the reimbursement rates displayed by mandatory health insurance have no significance for this type of care, since it is the complementary insurance that makes the bulk of the effort.

The generalization of complementary insurance or mutual insurance is necessarily part of the desire for access to care for all. But it is not enough to proclaim the generalization of complementary health insurance; it must also provide good guarantees at the lowest cost. This is the ambition I outlined in Nice three years ago.

We have not lost time. In 2013, the government of Jean-Marc AYRAULT, as part of the plan to combat poverty, raised the income ceilings for the complementary CMU and for complementary health assistance, affecting 550,000 people. This extension was made possible by the taxation of the employer's contribution to collective contracts. At the same time, the basket of care covered by the complementary CMU and by complementary health assistance was expanded, and for these patients, deductibles were eliminated, excess fees were prohibited, and fixed rates were established for glasses, hearing aids, and dental care.

The complementary health aid, which you pointed out was poorly known and underutilized, has seen its implementation conditions simplified and reformed. At the end of last year, a national call for tenders was launched, which allowed for the selection of eligible contracts and put them in competition; this was not easy, including for the mutual sector, I know, which enabled more than 1.2 million social insured individuals to see their rates decrease by 15 to 40% and to obtain, for some, better coverage. One example: for an elderly person living alone, the tariff relief can reach 300 euros, and it is in addition to the 10% increase in the amount of aid for complementary health decided in 2014 for those over 60.

Again, it is not enough to have complementary coverage; the guarantees must be serious. This is the purpose of the solidarity and responsible contract. You have kindly acknowledged the commitments that have been made and kept: the content has been enriched, ceilings have been set to prevent harmful price inflation for all, and the tax treatment has been differentiated, not sufficiently compared to other contracts.

Then, in 2013, an agreement was reached between the social partners. This agreement led to legislative translation. What was the intention of the social partners? It was to generalize complementary health in companies, that is to say, to ensure that a certain number of employees in small or medium-sized enterprises, who were not covered by anything, could be covered, about 500,000, and that others, the most numerous, who were covered by an individual contract, could have a collective contract offering them better guarantees. From this point of view, the social partners played their role. And they allowed for progress, progress for these employees. Moreover, companies contribute 50% of the costs. This means that a number of employees who had individual contracts will now enter the collective contract and will have better rights. This can disrupt the system. And that is what you told us, Mr. President. Because whenever there can be progress, there is also a downside.

I want to acknowledge the ongoing evolution, because the negotiation movement continues with 23 branch agreements concluded between the social partners, and a recently signed agreement in the temporary work sector that will allow 700,000 employees to benefit from collective coverage starting January 1, with seven months of free maintenance of rights in case of unemployment. In most cases, the negotiated guarantees go beyond the minimum care basket.

At one point, mutuals, and this moment is probably not over, were concerned about this transformation; but they wanted to be well represented in the process; and I think you have made every effort—I want to acknowledge them—so that the share of collective contracts in your activity could increase. You have become one of the main players in collective contracts.

But I return to the problem you raised, Mr. President. The improvement of employee coverage cannot come at the expense of the situation of young people, the unemployed, precarious workers, disabled individuals, and especially retirees.

I hear your concern, and it is surely shared regarding the increased segmentation of contracts and the risk of rising costs for the elderly; because when an employee retires, not only does he suffer a loss of income compared to what his salary was during his working life, but he must also pay a contribution, that of his former employer, and face an additional increase in his overall premium. We can fear that increased competition in corporate contracts will lead to a heavier pricing burden based on age, and it is this vicious circle that you want, that we want, to prevent.

You provided figures; they are accurate. If nothing is done, retirees, at least some of them, may see their guarantees and the cost of those guarantees multiplied by three. I therefore want the generalization of complementary health to be effective for retirees by 2017 and that they can retain their guarantees with the same premium level at the time of their retirement. Subsequently, the evolution of these rates must adhere to objective criteria based on age. What needs to be addressed is the time of exit from the active system in relation to the retirement age and the retirement period.

How to achieve this? There are two possible paths. The first is to adapt the 1989 ÉVIN law, which has nothing to do with the one currently being discussed regarding the exit from group contracts, since this concern had already been raised. This law establishes a general principle, as is often the case, but its application modalities have remained vague.

If we take this path, that is to say, to adapt the law so that the exit from group contracts is improved, the costs will necessarily be distributed among all insured individuals and companies.

The other path is to rely on responsible contracts by targeting fiscal and social aids more effectively to strengthen intergenerational solidarity. The solution could be the differentiation of the tax on contracts in favor of the more responsible ones. This is the solution you have in mind. As soon as the coverage of retirees is planned, there would be a fiscal differentiation in favor of these contracts.

Both paths must be explored, one as much as the other, so that generalization is effective for all French people in a logic of continuity of protection for retirees.

The consequence is that we will need to evaluate state aid. You recalled the figures: nearly 4 billion. This evaluation was provided for by the 2013 law. It must be carried out as soon as possible, that is to say, by the end of the year. When this evaluation is done, all conclusions will be drawn to achieve the result I have set.

Because the generalization of complementary health is not the generalization of the law of the market; it is the generalization of solidarity towards all French people so that the market is left aside, in certain aspects, especially for the elderly. Mutuals are indeed setting an example since the price differentiation between 60 and 75 years is two times less strong than in the insurance sector. This is also the reason why three-quarters of retirees subscribe to mutuals. You yourselves have made the effort, and it would be legitimate for it to be supported by the redistribution of aids.

Complementary health is not a product like any other, and this applies to all French people. Competition is there, it exists, and it can lead—I mentioned it—to advantages, benefits for the insured. But competition should not be used to select good risks, to multiply increasingly discriminatory and costly commercial practices. I therefore ask the minister to closely monitor practices and to prevent all abuses.

That is what I wanted to clarify here, before your congress, about complementary health. But I also wanted to emphasize the role that is yours in modernizing the health system.

The challenge is indeed to work, not simply to reimburse what you do in addition to health insurance. The challenge is to be able to take your full part in the reform, in the evolution of the health system with mandatory health insurance.

Mutuals are not just payers, a role to which some would like to reduce them. The general interest therefore calls for you to be entrusted with a place in the regulation of the care system, not separately, not as separate actors, but with mandatory health insurance. There are not two reimbursement systems in our country; there is one social security system with different organizations: mandatory protection and complementary protection.

Thus, in the agreements with health professions, the role of mutuals is particularly useful, especially to limit excessive pricing practices. We have demonstrated this, you have demonstrated this, notably with the access to care contract. We have achieved a reduction in the average level of excess fees. Of course, you will say that this is not enough, but at least it is already less than before; because we all have this tendency to never judge what has been done but what remains to be done, to never compliment the past—I do not ask you to do so today—but to ensure that there can be new advances. And that is the essence of democracy; it is the very principle of collective action. What has been obtained is no longer to be claimed, but what has not been obtained is unbearable.

I still want to share this reflection. It is addressed, moreover, beyond you, to many political or social actors. If we never say what we have managed to wrest, to conquer, to obtain, to advance, why would the French trust trade unions, professional representatives, mutualists, political actors? If nothing has ultimately been obtained through negotiation, through good pressure, or through a good congress—what you are doing—then why come? Why gather? Why contribute? Why meet in organizations, dedicating time—sometimes precious time for family life—to collective action, sometimes to the great surprise of our own families or those who know us? It is because we have, deep down, faith, an ideal in what we can achieve as progress for our country or for the categories we represent. In this case, all the French people.

So we must acknowledge what has been done. Moreover, this is what we continually produce through all celebrations and commemorations. What is their utility? Not simply to look back with melancholy, nostalgia, at our history, but to tell ourselves that it has been a battle, it has been a struggle, it has been a resistance at a certain moment, it has been a conquest, and that what was possible yesterday is still possible today. We are told: "It is much more difficult because there is globalization, there is competition, there is Europe, we no longer have the means to act." But do we think it was easier 100 years ago, before there were two wars? Or was it easier at Liberation when the country had to be rebuilt? It is true that there was a period with particularly impressive growth rates and progress. But there have not been many more than in periods when the economic situation was less flamboyant. Because not all progress costs; there are also progress that changes life, simplifies it, and allows us to have more strength in common.

This is also what I wanted to talk to you about so that we can move forward in the regulation of the health system, together.

We have a first illustration, as I said, regarding relations with health professions. But you have also, you mutuals, introduced innovations in certain contracting practices, and you wanted these practices to be authorized for you because there was still a paradox: insurances could have more freedom than mutuals to evolve a number of behaviors. I committed in Nice to ensure that these practices could be opened to you regarding the care for which you reimburse a majority share. It was not without difficulty. It is done, and I encourage all mutuals to use these instruments.

Another means of being able to influence collective decisions is the development of third-party payment. The objective, I said, is to achieve a simple and effective organization that is not an administrative burden for professionals but a lever for modernization in the relationship between care providers and funders. It is indeed together, complementary and mandatory health insurance, that you will define this mechanism.

In the same way, it is essential that you can, always together, act for prevention—especially regarding medication consumption, where we have, there, records that are not to our credit. Evolutions are essential to rationalize care, to promote adherence to prescriptions, to lift distrust towards generics. It is only in France that one thinks that with a generic one is less well treated than with a more expensive medication, with an old tendency to say that if it costs more, it must be more effective. Nothing should ever be free, but there is no reason for it to cost more than its cost. We must also act together.

From this point of view, the opening of health data provided for in the bill presented by Marisol Touraine will further broaden the prospects for cooperation and collaboration. We will be able to better analyze health expenditures, measure the impact of innovations while ensuring respect for medical confidentiality. Our health system, as you have rightly said, Mr. President, does not focus enough on prevention and therapeutic education for patients, which exacerbates social inequalities.

We must change the system: what you have called predictive medicine, the care pathway, the individualization this time in the best sense of therapeutic choices, you must also be fully involved. I know that Health Insurance already allocates significant budgets to remuneration linked to public health objectives, so that professionals are involved in prevention. You, mutuals, have expertise in many areas, particularly in all your centers and establishments and in the services you already provide.

The challenge now is to bring together the forces of health insurance, mutuals, associations, and local authorities so that we can define prevention policies and implement care pathways. The health bill also aims to ensure, beyond the requirement for excellence and quality, proximity, by rationalizing the supply of care through territorial professional health communities and hospital groupings. The mutuality has anticipated, as often, what the State would propose because it has long been successful in reconciling excellence and proximity. It is you who have been able, in your establishments, to bring together the health and medico-social sectors. It is you who have been able to imagine new places where several health professions can come together to ensure the efficiency of the care system. It is you who have been able to support vulnerable, elderly, and disabled individuals, by removing the barriers between health and medico-social care or between city and hospital. It is you who have been able, particularly in psychiatry, to think about new forms of care. So, yes, you must be fully involved, associated with the reform of our health system, its evolution through personalized medicine, through new techniques, through everything we can do to treat the most serious illnesses.

There you have it, Ladies and Gentlemen, this is what I wanted to tell you so that you can be convinced that what you represent, mutuality, will be fully considered by public authorities.

But you asked me a question, you said to me: "We are evolving in a changing context. We are facing new challenges both in organization, in the services we must offer, in the funding we must gather. The challenges are not only medical but also economic, and we want an adaptation of our rules so that we can always be mutualists, with the means to maintain our place and strengthen it."

Yes, mutuality must preserve its specificity while continuing its modernization; it must be capable of managing services adapted to the needs of its members, mutualizing health costs in solidarity, and having democratic and transparent governance. You want a reform of the mutuality code. I confirm, after what the minister told you, that this code will be modernized, particularly regarding your governance and the status of leaders. A larger place will thus be made for representatives of employees and businesses at a time when collective contracts will become predominant. The status of the mutualist elected official will be integrated under good conditions so that the guarantees of competence of leaders are compatible with European prudential standards. This project is open and will result in a bill that will be submitted at the beginning of 2016.

The mutuality code of the 21st century will therefore be aligned with these issues and with the reform of the social and solidarity economy, which the government of Jean-Marc Ayrault successfully carried out. You are part of it. You have, even in this social and solidarity economy, a specificity; it will be recognized through the reform of the mutuality code.

Ladies and Gentlemen, Mr. President,

We will indeed celebrate the 70th anniversary of Social Security. In a way, it is also yours. It was the ideal of justice pursued by the resistors. It was also a hope that the workers of our country held deep in their hearts. It was a will that might have seemed almost utopian: to be able to emancipate individuals from the fatality of circumstances, from the determinisms of birth or fortune, by granting them the most precious of rights, the right to health.

Mutuality has responded to this obligation and has been respectful of this ideal. Mutuality has become indispensable. It is a constitutive element of our social protection system alongside mandatory insurance. The easy way would be to shift the burdens that Social Security can no longer bear onto mutuals. The illusion, which may exist in some minds, would be to imagine that Social Security could alone cover all risks. And well, no. It is the originality of our system that ultimately makes its radiance and effectiveness.

So mutuality must have the necessary resources; these are those of the French, through their premiums and contributions, specific rules I just mentioned, and appropriate tax treatment; this is what I mentioned for complementary insurance. You must be assured that your rules will also be considered by the European authorities as compatible with the activity that is yours, and I stand as a guarantor of that.

Mutuality is not just reimbursements, benefits, services, or establishments. Mutuality is a state of mind, a commitment, a militancy, a passion—a passion in the service of social utility. That is why mutuality is indissolubly linked to the Republic. It gives it its social dimension and its citizen participation.

We need the spirit of mutuality more than ever. For what is at stake for our country? Remaining united, being able to live together, excluding no one, subjecting all to common rules, thinking that we belong to the same country with the same hopes, fostering in our compatriots a spirit of responsibility and citizenship, telling them that not everything can come simply from the State, that much depends on their own intervention, on collective action, that they must have confidence in the future and that, if they come together, they will be stronger. So I tell you, mutuality is an example today, in the Republic. Thank you.