Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the Armenian genocide, in Paris on January 28, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

28 January 2015 · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the CCAF in Paris to mark the centenary of the Armenian genocide, announcing his planned attendance in Yerevan on April 24, 2015.
Main themes
Armenian genocide recognition, centenary commemoration, memory and transmission of trauma, France-Armenia historical ties, genocide as crime against humanity, Holocaust remembrance, Raphael Lemkin and the word genocide, Armenian diaspora in France, resistance through memory, MANOUCHIAN and Armenian contributions to France
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,408
66th percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
55
75th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
72nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 45%45%
  • Geopolitical 30%30%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

125 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. Defender of Rights,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Madam Mayor of Paris,

Ladies and gentlemen.

I am here at the invitation of the presidents of the CCAF, exceptionally, as 2015 is an exceptional year. It marks the centenary of April 24, 1915, the centenary of the genocide.

On April 24, 2015, I will be in Yerevan. I will not be there in my personal capacity - I have already been to Yerevan, I will be there on behalf of France. I will be there with representatives from around the world, not enough in number, but already present for the centenary.

On April 24, 1915, a tragedy was committed. The brightest personalities of the Armenian community were first arrested. Among them was KOMITAS, and it is around the KOMITAS monument in Paris that you all gather every April 24.

The destruction of a people always begins in the same way. By the destruction of its spirit, of its culture, by the denial of its knowledge and of the men and women who embody it. But then the process is unfortunately established. Women, men are murdered, murdered because they are Armenians, murdered because they are Jews, murdered because they are, not in an organized society, in a profession or in a culture, no, because they are what they are.

The Armenians were thus murdered, the men first, then those who remained were chased, taken away, deported, deported to Syria. A curious and terrible fate that a hundred years later, in the very places where barbarity was committed, another barbarity is still at work.

And then there are the women, the men, the children who never reached where they were taken, because they died of exhaustion, of hunger, of cold. The survivors, for there were some, were placed in camps foreshadowing other camps, those camps where most of them died, when they did not escape. Thus, it was the first genocide of the 20th century, and it was not the last.

I was yesterday, and many of you were with me, at Auschwitz. A terrible massacre since in the single camp of Auschwitz, 1,100,000 Jews were killed, murdered. But the word genocide was not yet known. It was necessary that in 1941, with the first rumors of mass extermination in Eastern Europe, a Polish Jew exiled in the United States, the jurist Raphael LEMKIN, invented the word genocide. And he thought of the Armenians, and he imagined what awaited the Jewish people.

He had named the crime. It still needed to be known. So the Armenians, scattered around the world, have always been keen to transmit, to provide evidence and to be able to say what was, because memory is the ultimate resistance to prevent the erasure of the martyrs. It is this tragic memory that, from generation to generation, Armenians around the world have transmitted for centuries, not simply to their children, no, to their loved ones and, wherever they live, to all those who, at some point, may ask a simple question: but why did you Armenians come here? And you answer: "We came here because we are survivors or children of survivors."

That is why there has been a struggle, yours, but not just yours, the struggle for recognition. And it was on January 29, 2001, that France recognized the Armenian genocide. It is a very simple law, very simple to write, which was not at all simple to pass, but which contains a single article: "France recognizes the Armenian genocide."

This law was necessary because the history of Armenia and France has been intertwined for a long time, as you reminded us, gentlemen presidents. Even before 1915, CLEMENCEAU and JAURÈS defended the cause of persecuted Armenians. CLEMENCEAU and JAURÈS, the same who defended DREYFUS.

In 1909, the French navy, the navy of the French Republic, came to the aid of the Armenians of Cilicia, and French ships were still there in 1915 to save the fighters of Mount Moses. This is what created an indestructible relationship. And it is in the name of this friendship, of this memory, that tens of thousands of Armenians chose France as a refuge. Most often arriving through Marseille, they settled where they could be welcomed. They brought to France their bravery, their trust, and their hope. They adopted France as their homeland. They shed their blood during the First World War when they were called to fight, and during the Second, notably in the Resistance with the emblematic figure of MANOUCHIAN.

But they did more than that, more than providing evidence that they were full-fledged French citizens, who loved their country while forgetting nothing of their history. They convinced France of the indelible pain they felt, of the impossible forgetfulness. And so they fought, with others, for the truth to be told about the misfortune that had befallen them and their families.

This law was also necessary for the absent, for those 1,500,000 men, women, and children who died and whom you sang about, Charles AZNAVOUR, the martyr "so that they do not end up as your words covered by a wind of sand and then of forgetfulness."

The law of January 29, 2001, did not aim simply to state what had happened. The law did not aim to compel historians either because no law can change history. No, what was at work was to draw all the conclusions from historians who had patiently, meticulously confirmed the organization of the crime and described its magnitude.

And even today, researchers are at work around the world to provide details on this horror. And this will be the purpose of the international conference that will be held at the Sorbonne next March on a hundred years of research on the Armenian genocide. And I wished to place this conference under my high patronage.

The French law is not an accusation against the living; it is a duty towards the dead and a soothing gesture towards the descendants. And that is why denial is unbearable because it is an insult. The law must protect society from manipulations, from all manipulations. And this is France's position regarding denialism; this is the position of its Parliament, even if we know that there has been a decision from the Constitutional Council that must be respected.

And this is France's position, in the sense that it defends this right before the European Court of Human Rights. The debate is indeed now brought to this level, and I wanted our country to intervene to say and explain what our conception of freedom is. Freedom of expression, freedom of the press, we have stood up again in recent days to defend it after the massacres, those in Paris. Freedom of expression is sacred, but the freedom of expression that we want to preserve at all costs is not and will never be a falsification. It will never allow for an apology, and this is what we must always pass on to our children. There is a difference between insolence, impertinence, contestation of opinions, and falsification, manipulation, denial of a crime against humanity.

France does not give lessons to anyone; it knows what the wounds in the history of a nation can be. Every people has its pride, every people has periods of glory, every people also has its torments. Every country has experienced darker times in its long journey, ours too. And recalling them hurts. But silencing them would perpetuate the evil.

France's role is therefore to contribute to appeasement, to dialogue, to peace. There must always be pioneers, vanguards at some point. France has the pretension to be one of them.

I also know that there is always hope, everywhere. In Armenia as in Turkey, there are many free spirits working towards this reconciliation. Initiatives have been taken in Turkey, statements have been made, I am thinking in particular of those intellectuals who asked for forgiveness in December 2008 from their Armenian sisters and brothers. I do not forget the courage of Hrant DINK, who paid with his life for his commitment to the truth. I myself paid tribute to Hrant DINK when I went to Turkey, and I greeted his widow.

Turkish authorities recalled last year the significance of April 24, in their words, and wanted to associate themselves with the commemoration and the suffering experienced by Armenians. This is a first movement; it cannot stop there. And I had the opportunity last year, when I went to Yerevan, to acknowledge this sign, but also to emphasize that it could not be sufficient. The effort for truth must continue, and I am convinced that this centenary year will see new gestures, new steps on the path to recognition. And it is time to break the taboos and for the two nations, Armenia and Turkey, to invent a new beginning.

In France, the celebration of the centenary will be an opportunity, as you will emphasize, Mr. President, for great excitement. The 2015 committee that you lead will invite all French people to gather, to reflect, and to contemplate what the Armenian genocide was in the history of humanity. There will be dozens of events, even hundreds, and there will be exhibitions, concerts, plays. The vitality of culture, French culture, culture inspired by the greatest Armenian authors.

Memory must not be used to divide but rather to unite, to denounce prejudices and to reconcile once again, and it is possible. The centenary of the Armenian genocide should not be simply dedicated to commemoration but should also be devoted to peace and progress for Armenia.

For in this region, the situation is also concerning. Today, our attention is drawn by so many conflicts that we might end up forgetting another of these conflicts that causes deaths, always deaths.

Today, the border between Turkey and Armenia is closed. It has been closed since 1993. It must be reopened. This is the spirit, moreover, of the protocols that were signed in 2009 in Zurich, in the presence of France, and this must be an important step in the rapprochement between the two countries. Are the minds ready for it? In any case, not on all sides. A statement was nevertheless signed by Armenian and Turkish intellectuals last autumn. They express their common dreams that between Armenians and Turks a new stage opens in respect of each people's history with strong gestures.

And it is also in relation to this issue of peace that I want to address the question of Karabakh. On May 12, 2014, the day of the 20th anniversary of the ceasefire in Karabakh, I was present in Baku and in the afternoon in Yerevan. I wanted to symbolically mark the importance of this date and the necessity of finding a solution to this conflict that has caused many victims, tens of thousands of victims twenty years ago and continues to cause deaths, not later than just a few days ago.

I personally proposed to the President of Armenia to host him in Paris with the President of Azerbaijan so that we could find a resolution to the conflict.

I held a summit on October 27. I must say that it did not lead to great results. I could grow weary and consider that it is a file, there are so many others, that it is not useful to open since it is so difficult to arrive at a draft of solutions. Well, no. I believe that France has this duty, has this responsibility to work for a sustainable and peaceful solution to the dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

For a hundred years, the Caucasus region has experienced too many wars, too many dramas, too much misfortune for us to resign ourselves. And when I see what this region could be, its richness, its possibilities for development, the link it can offer between Europe and Asia, between the past and the future, I tell myself that we must not resign ourselves.

France has also decided to invest in Armenia. France is the largest Western investor in Armenia, but there is too little investment in Armenia, and we must be aware, you know, of the difficulties for Armenia to export, to import when there are not only accommodating neighbors.

So I invite French entrepreneurs, I am not talking about Armenian entrepreneurs, French entrepreneurs, not all of whom are of Armenian origin, to do more for the economy of Armenia and thus strengthen the friendship between our two countries. You represent here 500,000 French people of Armenian origin, 500,000 French people who have inherited a part of Armenia's history. But also, a part of the responsibility for its future. You have this strength that has allowed you to be what you are here, in your country, France; it is the strength of Armenia's history, the culture of Armenia, and with the Diaspora, this Diaspora on a global scale that has defied time and adversity, you have one more strength.

I have confidence in the future of Armenia, and I also have confidence in you because you have learned the virtue of patience. The path of the Armenian people has been long and difficult. This is what Achod MALAKIAN used to say when he remembered his own journey. A little boy who arrived at the age of four in Marseille, at the Quai de la Joliette on a day in 1924, he made his way and became a great filmmaker, one of the greatest French filmmakers, Henri VERNEUIL.

This journey has also been that of many of you, of your parents, of your grandparents. The path has been long and difficult for the Armenian people to have the crime, the genocide of which they were victims, recognized. The path has been long and difficult for the outcasts, the stateless who took France as a refuge in the interwar period.

Well, you have succeeded; you are men and women of loyalty, loyal to your origins, loyal to your history, loyal to your families, loyal to Armenia, but above all loyal to your country, France, which you defend and of which you know that its values can serve as examples of emancipation and dignity for the world.

And at a time when our country has been struck by barbarism, by intolerance, by hatred, by terrorism, you give us, Armenians of France, French of Armenian origin, an example of dignity that makes you proud and therefore makes us proud as well.

Thank you.