Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the challenges and priorities of European construction, in Paris on October 15, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

15 October 2016 · EuropaNova initiative on European construction · School of Mines, Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed a EuropaNova forum in Paris on October 15, 2016, presenting conclusions on priorities for European renewal amid Brexit, terrorism, and global crises.
Main themes
European construction challenges, Brexit and European identity crisis, terrorism and the July 14 Nice attack, Aleppo humanitarian crisis, populism and democratic threats, globalization, European renaissance roadmap, geopolitical realignment, Normandy format and Minsk agreements, cultural emancipation in Europe
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,058
86th percentile
Sentences
167
84th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 57%55%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Economic 13%13%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

167 sentences in 49 paragraphs

I would first like to thank the director of the School of Mines for welcoming us here, without competition! I would also like to greet the presidents of EuropaNova and all the parliamentarians who have joined this initiative, and I ask you first to forgive me for not being able to open your work this morning, but I was in Nice for a particularly moving ceremony in memory of the 86 victims of the July 14 attacks.

Among these victims, those who died or those who are still injured, there were 19 nationalities "represented." Many came from Europe, and I met some of the victims there who told me that it was France that had been targeted, struck, overwhelmed, attacked, but that all of Europe felt concerned because it was also July 14. July 14 is the national holiday, but it is also the celebration of freedom everywhere, everywhere in the world.

I come to the conclusions of your work. I have received here, I dare not say the synthesis, but in any case the conclusions. I am called upon as a European citizen, but also - if I understood correctly - as President of the French Republic, even if in the citizen movement, we do not distinguish according to levels, responsibilities, or orders: there are only citizens!

I would like to thank you for this commitment, for the call you launched, Guillaume KLOSSA, Denis SIMONNEAU, Cynthia FLEURY, and many others, because it was important - even before Brexit - that there could be a number of personalities and movements that could mobilize on the European issue.

This is what you wanted to define through this roadmap for European renaissance. Renaissance understood in the double sense of the term: renaissance because we see that we must start again, move forward; but renaissance also because there will be no Europe if there is no cultural creation, no emancipation, if there is not a moment when, far more than those who think they are interested in politics but who want to participate in a common culture, mobilize.

France - and I have ensured this - has taken up several of your proposals; and the President of the European Commission has as well. It was very important that he could, in his speech before the European Parliament, define this roadmap - I do not say it resembles yours in every way, but it was inspired by it. This, by the way, suggests that the democratic debate is not frozen, is not closed, and that there are always spaces that can be used to advance minds and ideas.

The issue - I tell you plainly - is not simply to set new directions for the European Union, but to determine the very future of the project, for it is true that Europe is facing a globalization that has changed considerably, that shakes peoples. It is also confronted with populist challenges that shake party structures; we see it everywhere, in all European countries.

And then, there are new threats, terrorism, conflicts that are at our doors. I was still in discussion this afternoon with the Chancellor to prepare a possible Normandy format, to seek to apply the Minsk agreements, to put an end to a conflict that is, once again, very close to us.

I also think of the wars taking place in the Levant, that is, in Syria and Iraq, with the humanitarian tragedy that is Aleppo and which should shake all European consciences. Today, it is from Europe that this call should arise, this cry so that we can send aid to a city that is today being bombed, besieged, and which is also affected because it is a city of culture. I ask myself this question: why was there, just a few years ago, and it was a considerable force, an opinion that rose for Sarajevo, Srebrenica, and even Grozny; and now, for Aleppo, we must raise our voices even more? But who should do it if not Europe?

It is true that the world is reconstituting itself. We did not realize, when the Berlin Wall fell, that Europe had reunified. We were still in the patterns we had known, that my generation had known, those of the Cold War, of the post-war period, which led us to believe that we were inevitably heading towards a form of convergence of societies, ideas, democracies, and that it was still the borders of the post-war period that would dominate. This is no longer true. We had seen, moreover, through the conflict in the Balkans, we see it now emerging in many regions of the world, and this is what is happening in Iraq and Syria. From there, we see new powers emerging; economic powers, we know them, but also new empires that are reconstituting themselves, often the same ones that existed before World War I.

Europe, faced with this new scheme, this new global context, seems outdated, both because its organization no longer seems adapted and because its project is diluted, simply reduced to economic questions or questions of politics related to cohesion among the 28.

Then comes Brexit, which once again creates not just another crisis, but a crisis of existence; that is to say, that a crisis of meaning, which has been established for several years, is now succeeded by a crisis of existence.

Europe has faced, since its creation, many crises that made Europe always in crisis, which gave a lot of importance to the heads of state and government who were there to resolve the crises with those breathless nights: will they succeed? How long will it take? Then the victory statements at the end, but without thinking that each country had managed to assert its interest and especially its thesis.

Yes, we have known crises, even since 2012. I experienced the financial crisis, I also had to - with the 28 but especially with the eurozone countries - ensure that we maintained the unity, the Economic and Monetary Union, and the eurozone. We saved Greece, even if today not everything is yet delivered for Greece to be, in a certain way, freed!

But here, we do not have just another crisis; we have the crisis, the one that touches on our purposes, and we all felt it through the question of refugees! The fractures were no longer between large countries and small countries, the South or the North, surplus countries or deficit countries. There, the divisions were much more fundamental, in the sense that some countries were ready to welcome, others refused, when it came to talking about distribution. There, it was no longer a matter of distributing subsidies from European funds or compensatory amounts during the Common Agricultural Policy; it was a matter of distributing people, human beings, and we were doing it with criteria from yesterday!

At that moment, we were facing a crisis far more serious than all those we had faced and known in recent decades. It is no longer - and I think Guillaume was right - about inventing a new institutional architecture; that time will come, to know what financial mechanisms we will implement to avoid this or that difficulty or bankruptcy, they are there, we must use them. No, the question is to know what we have in common and what will unite us. The British decision forces us to confront ourselves!

The United Kingdom wanted to leave. I am not sure that it was the intention of its leaders, but today, they have decided to leave! I believe that the worst attitude would be to contest their choice or to want to call into question the very foundations of the European Union. We must therefore go to the end of this negotiation, while preserving the principles of the European Union, notably the principles of free movement. Because if it were to appear that a country can leave and that it has no consequences, that it can continue to trade, to invest as before, without having the common rules of the European Union, it is dislocation that will occur, it is separation!

We must ask ourselves this terrible question: either we renounce the European ambition, we consider that it was a time in our history and that we must now reduce ourselves to our borders, return to our sovereignties as we knew them, then it will be the prospect of dislocation, of erasure. The exit of the United Kingdom will only be a beginning. Or we give ourselves a new ambition, we launch a new initiative, we carry a new impetus in line with the aspirations of citizens, and then we have to give a perspective.

It is true that the Bratislava roadmap has given a horizon, an agenda, priorities. The horizon is to meet again in March 2017, because it is the 60th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome. Yes, also an agenda to take step by step, so that we can have results to present for this anniversary, and to set priorities. I think that, before we get there, we need to be clear on a number of points.

The first is the question of sovereignty. I am deeply convinced that the solutions to the trials I have just mentioned, the challenges we are aware we will have to face, will not be found in retreat, in closure, in national borders, and in renouncing collective solutions. I also think it would be dangerous to imagine that the European idea could ignore the legitimacy and reality of nations. It is probably by playing on this fear of erasure that populists have awakened and rushed in, leading people to believe that it was Europe that was making identities disappear.

Jacques DELORS had a formula, which had been reproached to him several times, to make a federation of nation-states; we had pointed out the contradiction, but he was profoundly right. What falls under the Federation? What falls under nation-states? Europe does not aim to replace nations, but nations cannot, alone, define a European ambition. On a number of projects, there must be sharing and transfer of sovereignty, and on others, nations must be able to intervene fully. It is therefore a matter of uniting Europeans, but not brusquely pushing societies, respecting peoples, and making them converge towards a common ideal, without them having to lose their uniqueness.

The second question is subsidiarity. What should Europe do, what can states do?

The priorities of the European Union, in this phase of its destiny, are first and foremost protection. This is what our citizens demand, protection. Not just the protection of borders, even if it is necessary - I will come to that - the protection of what is essential for us: values, freedom, democracy, our culture, our social model.

So let us start protecting the borders if we want to avoid the re-establishment of internal borders. We have seen that it was in the face of the refugee question that we had to get seriously to work. Protected external borders mean European border guards and coast guards, European means to ensure this security; we cannot transfer this to the countries that have, by geography, the responsibility of welcoming refugees and migrants, and who can no longer bear it. It is therefore absolutely necessary that there be this commitment, that Europe puts all the necessary means in place to ensure: border guards, coast guards, and also the places where refugees and migrants are registered, where we can know who falls under the right of asylum and who must be welcomed - which will mean distributed - and those who, on the other hand, do not have a vocation to come into our European space and who, at that moment, must be returned home with dignity, once their situation has been clarified. But again, European means are needed. If there are no rules, if there is no respect for these rules, there will be no more cohesion and there will be no more Europe.

Security is also the European common good. France has long taken pride—this can happen to anyone—in having a defense that allowed it to project forces abroad, to ensure its independence through nuclear deterrence, and to have strategic autonomy, which enabled it to carry out a number of operations abroad, particularly in Africa, in the name of the European Union. But today, I am aware that the most pressing service France can provide to Europe is to help build common elements of defense and security. Germany itself has evolved on this issue. Until recently, it was inconceivable for the Bundestag to engage in external operations; this remains difficult because these are principled questions that I can understand, but I sense that there is an evolution there. From this perspective, I do not complain that Germany can look at Africa with responsibility, both for its development and for its security. The British, just because they are, or are going to be, leaving Europe, should not be detached from European defense. All European countries must coordinate and participate in the defense effort, and know what each country, again depending on its sovereignty, can ensure.

Protection also means forces to fight against terrorism. I have said it, France has been struck, but many European countries have also been affected. We are aware that terrorism will remain a threat and must lead us to, once again, make our police cooperate, coordinate our intelligence services, act against propaganda and radicalization. Who can do this better than Europe? It is not a risk, as some thought it might be based on the fears they try to instill in public opinion. No, Europe is a shield. It is also very important that we can explain this very simple reality: there are elections that will take place in the United States; a president will be elected. But beyond what she may represent, her convictions, know well that we can no longer expect the United States to protect and defend European territory—not that the United States will distance itself from us, will not be our ally, but because the United States will ask Europeans to defend themselves and that is our duty, it is our responsibility.

The second priority for Europe, also contained in your roadmap, is growth and employment.

Again, economic policies fall under the states. We know that we need common governance. We need the eurozone to have a budget. We need there to be an investment capacity, and we also need to stimulate the countries that are in surplus, while the countries that are in deficit must continue to make efforts for competitiveness and to reduce their debt.

We must also think that the impetus cannot come simply from the European Central Bank. By the way, a curious paradox: for years, there were not strong enough words to denounce the policy of the European Central Bank, and now we have relied on its goodwill; it does what it can, it does what it must, it floods the market with liquidity, but if the states and if Europe do not also take their responsibilities, growth will not be able to resume as much as is necessary.

I truly believe that doubling the JUNCKER plan, that investments in renewable energies, ecological transition, digital technology, and infrastructure are necessary investments, not just to relaunch, but necessary to build Europe as we want it: a cutting-edge Europe in many areas.

It is true that the climate agreement owes much to Europe, not just because this agreement was signed in Paris, but because there was this movement, a citizen movement, that came from Europe; we would not have succeeded without others. It would be ironic that Europe, which has done so much to ensure this climate agreement, would be late—it almost was for ratification—that Europe would be late in relation to all the investments we need to make, and we must even go further than the commitments made at the time of the Paris Agreement.

We must ensure that our companies can have a global size, and here, minds have also evolved. A few years ago, competition prevailed over any other consideration; it was enough for there to be even mergers of companies in Europe for the Commission to come and prevent them, in the name of competition within the single market, even as large companies from elsewhere, often from the United States, came to compete with us on our own ground. That must end.

The same goes for taxation; it is unacceptable that large companies outside the European Union come to do business, develop wealth, but do not pay taxes here to pay them elsewhere. Sometimes, this can happen in a certain European territory—I have even seen that the country in question did not want this money, for fear that it could harm the location of investments—but we must have rules for tax harmonization. There will be no Europe if there is no tax harmonization!

The third priority—but you mentioned it—is culture, education, universities, research, youth, and again, we must show that there is a European uniqueness. European culture is not the sum of all the cultures of our respective countries. It is a form of creation that comes from a conception of civilization that is not closed, that is open and engages with the world. Europe must be open; otherwise, it is no longer Europe. We must ensure that mobility can be a principle, hence the importance we must attach to the free movement of people.

In this regard, I support all the proposals you make on Erasmus for middle school and high school students; every young person should be able to experience a mobility program in Europe. Even in France, there are young French people who have never left their city, never left their village, not because they lack transportation, but because knowledge and discovery do not necessarily come naturally; you will often find that among populists, it is often the voters who are the farthest from the world who are the most afraid of it. Discovering the world, meeting the world, with Europe, but also with one’s own country, is essential for democracy and for freedom. Mobility is not simply a right that we would grant to young people because we think that young people love to travel; it is because it is what will make Europe exist, know itself, and share itself.

I am, of course, aware that we must not call into question the funds allocated to the Youth Guarantee, to apprenticeships, to everything that can enable young people to access qualifications, but I think we need to provide more mobility, including through the European Voluntary Service. We have created a civic service, but the civic service should be European because the needs are everywhere in Europe.

You spoke of belonging; that is undoubtedly the right word: European belonging. The question is whether Europe sees itself as a power—the word may be frightening—no, a power of peace, a power of harmony, a power of development, a power in service of conflict resolution and crisis management. Europe is the first economic power, but it is not a political power. It is lacking in the world. It is not just lacking for itself. The world needs Europe. For that, we must transform our economic power into a political power. That is the message you are sending us.

I have always been European. I have always thought that this idea would be a majority; it is no longer so. I tell you plainly, it is no longer so, except in a few countries, often those that joined the European Union more recently, without fully understanding all the consequences and sharing all the obligations. We must fight this battle of conviction.

Europe is no longer self-evident. The proof is that what had been a long process of enlargement is now at a standstill, and a country is going to leave. Europe is no longer self-evident since populists, sovereignists, and sometimes even in governing parties, suggest that the less Europe there is, the more power and freedom there will be. Europe is no longer self-evident because even the values it carries are being challenged: welcome, solidarity, the social model, a common conception of rights. In the face of terrorism, we have seen that there were a number of challenges that could be articulated. Even the European Court of Human Rights, which is attached to the Council of Europe, one of the oldest institutions of European construction, even this Court, its decisions are no longer respected, and even its authority, its legitimacy is being questioned.

Since Europe is no longer self-evident, we must create this movement. How can it emerge? You say the citizens—I am happy to be able to meet them, but we will have to address this citizen movement.

Do not think that Europe came only from institutions. Before the institutions, there was no Europe, but there was a European spirit. François MITTERRAND always said that the first meeting he attended was the Congress of The Hague in 1948, which deeply marked him; it was the post-war period. There was a spirit that had been created for Europe, but it took ten years to build the common market, the very one whose anniversary we will celebrate next year. There must be this spirit, not just to defend, to defend a reality that is not necessarily satisfactory—and you have articulated that. No, to defend and promote a European spirit.

Heads of state and government have a responsibility, but you know that the European Council decides by unanimity, and that is what makes it cumbersome and slow to make decisions. The European Commission can provide impetus, but it does not have the capacity to decide in place of the European Parliament and the European Council. The European Parliament, as you said, suffers not from a lack of legitimacy—all parliamentarians are elected by universal suffrage—but public opinion has not been formed in relation to a European issue, even if there has been progress since President JUNCKER comes from an electoral process that took place at the time of the election of the European Parliament. Heads of state and government were not necessarily on this thesis.

We must therefore create a movement that does not go through institutional change, but through a very strong conviction that must be carried. Populists use fear; fear is always what, at a moment, can cause public opinion to retract, to fold in on itself.

You must use, we must use hope. What can Europe bring so that we are freer, so that we are prouder, so that we are greater together?

It is more on the great political questions that Europe will be able to convince, because what makes the pride of a nation, a continent, or any community, is when it is capable of weighing in on the fate of the world, when it is capable of changing what seems to be an established order forever.

It is this hope that we must raise, and I know that youth, because it is often what is attributed to this generation, which gives it a lot of responsibilities, sometimes weighs on it because it often inherits the problems we have left it, but it is true that it is up to the youth to seize this European question.

However, once again, nothing is decided. Among many young people—and not just in popular categories as is often said, but among many young people—there is the idea that Europe would be an old idea, that today it is the world that must prevail and that the future does not necessarily pass through that history. Yes! This would imply that everywhere we are in the world, we could defend the European flag and not just our own country.

That is why I call on you, I too, without shirking my responsibility. Until May 2017—I cannot commit for later, but until May 2017—I tell you, I will continue to ensure that the initiatives you have launched, that the hope you carry, can be translated into decisions of the European Council.

Above all, do not let go, do not give your trust until you are certain that it will be well used, well carried, and well translated. Make sure to mobilize all consciences. More than ever, we need it. Thank you.