Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the future of Social Security, in Paris on October 6, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

6 October 2015 · Commemoration of the 70th anniversary of Social Security · La Mutualité, Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed a ceremony at La Mutualité in Paris on October 6, 2015, marking the 70th anniversary of France's Social Security system.
Main themes
Social Security anniversary, history of social protection in France, universality of rights, solidarity and social welfare, post-war reform legacy, health coverage, financing and reform, labor movement, Atlantic Charter influence, Beveridge and welfare state origins
Duration
~49 min
94th percentile
Words
5,820
94th percentile
Sentences
202
89th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 57%57%
  • Economic 22%22%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

202 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, Ministers, both those of today, those of yesterday - and I do not forget those of tomorrow - who have made, are making, and will make Social Security.

I want to include in this greeting the ministers who come to us from Europe, sometimes from further away, who have also established social protection in their time or aspire to create one.

I also wanted to greet the parliamentarians, the representatives of the trade unions and employer organizations who together manage the Social Security funds, as well as the managers and staff who make Social Security for the French people.

We are gathered here today, in a symbolic place of the social movement, the Mutualité, to commemorate the birth of a great institution, Social Security.

Seventy years ago, a year after the liberation of Paris, General de GAULLE promulgated the ordinances establishing Social Security. They had been prepared by Pierre LAROQUE, who is now known to all the children of France, and rightly so, with the assistance of Alexandre PARODI; these ordinances were presented by Ambroise CROIZAT, the Minister of Labor. Few French people remember this date that created Social Security, and not many know the names of the men who were the originators of this great idea. And yet they changed France because for the first time in the history of our country, work accidents, illness, old age, and family burdens could be covered by social insurance that encompassed all these risks at once.

Today, and it was good that the young people were present, Social Security is a pillar of the Republic; it is there, permanent, vigilant, discreet, relieving the French of the anxieties that were the lot of previous generations. We hardly talk about it anymore, except during commemorations, to lament its financial imbalance, which we are actually reducing, or to regularly criticize its functioning, which we are improving nonetheless. But what would each of our lives be like if this coverage were to be lacking? What would our lives be without Social Security? Perhaps we need to ask this question to understand the meaning of what was done in 1945 and what has gradually been built over the past 70 years. The meaning of this day is surely to look at what history has been able to accomplish, but it is also to show the vitality, the relevance, and the future of Social Security.

Social Security is an idea that comes from afar. Its history is one of women and men who united to help each other; it is the history of cooperatives, mutuals, and the labor movement. It is also a story within the Republic since from the middle of the 19th century, this aspiration found its place through progressive laws but also through social struggles, conquests, strikes, and major negotiations.

But it is in the depths of the abyss, while democracies were fighting for their survival, that this great ambition of social protection emerged. On August 14, 1941, Winston CHURCHILL and Franklin ROOSEVELT jointly drafted the Atlantic Charter; we were in the midst of war. These two statesmen were already beginning to reflect on what the principles of the post-war period would be. Freedom, surely, international cooperation, necessarily, but they added to these principles a social protection that must allow every man and every woman to live free from fear. The National Council of Resistance and General de GAULLE made the same reasoning for the dawn they hoped for. It is, according to the beautiful formula of LAROQUE, to "continue in peacetime the solidarity acquired in wartime," but not a solidarity from within, not the solidarity of a group or a profession, a company, no, a generalized protection against the main risks on a national scale and throughout life, "from cradle to grave," as William BEVERIDGE, who invented Social Security on the other side of the Channel, said.

Social Security carried a triple ambition: universality of rights, uniformity of benefits, unity of management. Very quickly, this will encountered the interests of those, and they were many, who preferred to maintain the old organizations and limited solidarities. For a long time, benefits were minimal and affiliations strictly linked to employment status, which created many exclusions. 1945 is not a golden age, I say this at a time when some think it was better before. 1945 was a promise, which also reminds us that great reforms always require time, perseverance, a firm course, and pragmatism to achieve. And Social Security is no exception to this rule of social life; it is a conquest, it is a construction that justifies the time that was necessary to reach what we know today.

Universality eventually imposed itself, for the family branch in 1978, with the disconnection of the right to benefits from activity: one can therefore receive these family benefits without being in work. In 1999, it was universality for health insurance, with the establishment of Universal Health Coverage. For financing, it was 25 years ago that universality was achieved with the creation of the CSG, which contributes from all incomes, from work, capital, replacement benefits; it is the withholding tax that remains today a model for the evolution of our taxation. Social Security has also constantly adapted to economic upheavals, changes in family structures, the lengthening of life expectancy, and the constant advances in medicine. And that is why the results are impressive; thanks to family policy, France has become the leading European nation in terms of birth rate, fertility, and the place of women in the labor market.

Thanks to health insurance, our hospitals have modernized, our clinical research is globally recognized, and health technologies are widely disseminated; in this sense, Social Security is an important lever for growth, innovation, and attractiveness for our country. And then the result, the one that mattered most, is a better life; a 60-year-old man can today expect to live more than 23 years - I paused for a moment because I am at that age level, 23 years. A woman, nearly 28 years, which is 10 years more than in 1945. I do not say that Social Security has given us 10 years, and yet it is thanks to all these means, these advances, this monitoring, this support of health policies that have been pursued for years that we have been able to reach this level of life expectancy, and the journey is not yet over.

We also have, over the same period, an infant mortality rate that has been reduced by 20; it is one of the lowest recorded in the world thanks to Social Security. Old age was once synonymous with precariousness since in 1945, one-third of people over 65 received a pension, one-third! Old age today is synonymous with freedom; the average standard of living of retirees is roughly equivalent to that of the working population. The result of Social Security is also the reduction of inequalities: for the 40% of the poorest French people, social protection increases their standard of living by half through benefits and redistribution.

Yet, despite these results, Social Security is regularly questioned about its sustainability and equity. Undoubtedly, the regular chronicle of deficits undermines confidence in the very solidity of the system, and criticisms abound; oh, they are often contradictory! I hear here and there calls for less spending, always, but without specifying the necessary savings. Is it about reducing reimbursements, closing hospitals, rationing care, not hiring nurses, reducing pensions, but to what extent? When we get into this level of detail, no one knows.

I know others who demand to improve the remuneration of health professionals, and that is quite legitimate, not to touch the pharmaceutical industry while proposing to lower the level of social contributions without, of course, resorting to other levies. The equation seems difficult to solve unless the intention is to dismantle the social model: then clarity emerges. For nearly 30 years, Social Security has been debating its future; for the older ones who experienced the general states, it was in the 1980s, then the successive plans to restore the balance of accounts. I will not name all the ministers; they are not all here, and I risk forgetting some. Yes, through all these plans, all these announcements, all these restructurings, the idea has taken hold that the system itself was at the end of its rope, and it is tempting to question deficits to better contest the foundations of the system itself. The harm has probably been exacerbated when governments short of money and especially capable of great imagination have allowed Social Security to borrow, that is to say, to repay tomorrow what we were not able to honor. And that is how social debt was born, with a contribution that was supposed to extinguish it; the debt has not been extinguished, nor has the contribution.

To this financial forward flight, for that is what it is, when one begins to borrow on the markets to finance current expenses, operating expenses, benefit expenses, has been added a doubt about the legitimacy of the system: some insured individuals, we know them around us, feel they contribute without receiving, while others would receive without contributing. But it must be recalled that 90% of Social Security expenditures are related to retirement, family benefits, and healthcare, that is to say, to universal benefits that everyone can access regardless of their income level and at any moment in their life.

Fraud exists as in any organization; its amount is necessarily difficult to specify; we talk about one billion, at least detected, a little less. And then there is what is not detected; it is not the cause of the deficit, but it is an insidious evil, fraud, because it casts doubt on the equity of Social Security and weakens the consent to finance it. And that is why the strictest rigor is required against those who abuse it because they steal much more than public money; they undermine the very idea of solidarity. And it is not because there are abuses that the system itself should be called into question and that we should return to the principles of universality.

What threatens Social Security most strongly is conservatism, which leads to accepting regression rather than daring to reform, that is to say, trying to maintain the status quo at the risk of losing what has been built, while it is reform that allows progress and enables new advancements while better controlling spending. There is another threat, which is individualism with the supposed freedom of insurance and the privatization of coverage: would I not have more interest in insuring myself because I know I am healthy, because I am not too old yet, and because I do not have too many children, rather than entering a general, collective system?

This trend exists, but it is an illusion because there cannot be a Social Security worthy of the name if it does not rest on a very broad solidarity; it is the mass that allows us to ensure the distribution between generations, it is the mass that allows us to cover risks that insurances could not cover, and it is because we have been able to establish solidarity between incomes, between generations, between those who are sick and those who are healthy that we have been able to create what Social Security is today. If I want to summarize my thought, Social Security is much more than mechanisms for benefits, reimbursements, pensions; it is belonging to a common whole, and that is why Social Security is very much linked to the Republic. National cohesion is ensured by school; social cohesion is Social Security; these are the two main pillars of our Republic. Social Security remains a strength and will remain a strength on one condition: to renew it without ever ceasing to remain faithful to its principles.

Being faithful to its spirit means first and foremost managing social accounts well; that is our primary responsibility. We owe this requirement to future generations; we also owe it to today's citizens to ensure this responsibility for financing, and that is what we have done for the past three years. The deficit, which reached 30 billion in 2010, has been reduced to 12 billion in 2015; it is still too much, but half the way has been accomplished. The social debt, which exceeds 150 billion euros, the deficits that have accumulated and could not be repaid by the contribution that had been created, 150 billion euros that we have passed on to future generations. This social debt, for the first time this year, is decreasing.

Health insurance expenditures, which were increasing by nearly 6% at the beginning of the 2000s, have been reduced to 2% this year, not by cutting coverage but by eliminating unnecessary procedures, encouraging cooperation between healthcare facilities, developing outpatient care, reducing hospitalization time, and strengthening prevention. That is why the target set for the evolution of health insurance expenditures will still be met in 2015 for the third consecutive year. I want to commend the professionals who contributed to this result, which the minister has presented for the third time. We are achieving this without degrading the levels of care, as over three years the share of healthcare consumption covered by Social Security has increased, erasing the setbacks caused by co-payments and reductions in reimbursements. I take pride in leading a country where the amount remaining to be paid by patients is now one of the lowest among developed countries.

As for the old-age insurance system, it will regain balance in 2016 for the first time in 12 years; this is the result of successive reforms, and it is also due to the good management that has been implemented. Nevertheless, the young people, those who were on this stage and who may have just discovered Social Security, have a concern, and they express it. They say: will we also have the pensions that your generation was able to obtain? We must reassure them by demonstrating the capacity of our pay-as-you-go system to pay them the pensions to which they will be entitled through their contributions. That is why we carried out the pension reform in 2013, led by Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault and Minister of Social Affairs Marisol Touraine, which consisted of linking the contribution period to life expectancy.

This principle cannot be rejected because it is the most basic of precautions, and it is even a matter of respecting the promise of Social Security, because what matters is of course the contribution period, but it is also the duration of time spent in retirement. That is why we made this reform, which allows us to achieve the balance of Social Security, at least for the pension system, by 2020. But we know well that there are demographic factors that will require us to do so, hence the link that has been established between contribution periods and life expectancy until 2030. It is very important to have this long-term vision because it allows us to tell our children that if they have contributed, they will be entitled to a pension of an amount they can already foresee.

What has been done for the general scheme must also be initiated for the complementary AGIRC-ARRCO schemes. Courageous measures must always be taken when it comes to restoring the balances that have been lost, but these measures cannot rest solely on employees; companies must do their part, as it is in their interest and is even a condition for preserving parity. I therefore ask the social partners who have the responsibility, the sole responsibility, to negotiate on the complementary schemes and ensure their future, to seek all solutions, which have been proposed, to ensure the sustainable balance of these schemes.

Ensuring the sustainability of our social protection system also means ensuring that it is financed by stable resources that do not penalize either the economy or employment. And once again, I want to state this simple reality: Social Security is not the enemy of competitiveness; it contributes to economic performance when it supports research, as I have demonstrated, innovation, when it supports demographic dynamics, when it frees individuals, that is to say, workers, from the worry of tomorrow to allow them to fully devote themselves to their activities. But Social Security must not be a hindrance to employment, and if we pit Social Security against employment, then the risks are very serious of undermining the principles we know.

So, to avoid this opposition, we must have a financing model for our schemes that cannot rely exclusively on wages; we must be attentive to the cost of labor, which is the purpose of the responsibility pact that alleviates the burden of social contributions for employers and has introduced the Competitiveness and Employment Tax Credit, which itself is based on the payroll. This amounts to 40 billion euros that have been released until 2017, and already the social security contributions, I am indeed talking about social security contributions, are zero at the minimum wage—contrary to many preconceived ideas—through all the exemptions that are provided.

But beyond the pact, it is up to us to go further with the social partners in clarifying resources. All questions must be examined, the financial autonomy of Social Security in relation to the State, the distinction between taxes that fall under national solidarity and social contributions, the integration of new forms of employment related to digital and collaborative economies (how to collect from these new activities to ensure rights for those who contribute to them?), and it is through these reforms that we will strengthen Social Security.

Our second commitment, beyond managing accounts and preparing for the future, is to fight against inequalities. Family policy has been made more equitable; it has not been easy to make it understood that there would be a modulation of family allowances while ensuring the universality of benefits, that is to say, the fact that regardless of income, family allowances are granted. The annual revaluation of the RSA (Active Income Support) will lead, by the end of the five-year term, to a 10% increase in purchasing power compared to inflation. At the same time, access to complementary health coverage has been facilitated for 700,000 beneficiaries. And we can already see, I could continue the list of measures, the effects of this policy: inequalities have decreased in 2013, and the 10% of the most modest people have seen their standard of living increase for the first time in five years.

But the fight against inequalities is not simply measured through the income scale, and Social Security contributes to this in several ways, first by facilitating access to care through a better distribution of healthcare professionals across the territory, which the minister is working on. The third-party payment system, which is the subject of, and rightly so, many questions, even though it is a payment method that is widespread in almost all European countries, has been in place since this year for low-income individuals: I did not understand why they were complaining about it. The third-party payment will also be offered from July 2016 for maternity and chronic illnesses, and I believe that doctors can understand this necessity. Then, there will be deployment for all insured individuals and healthcare procedures by the end of 2017, and I have myself reminded several times that this can only be done if the technical solutions are simple and allow doctors to have the guarantee that they will be paid for their services as quickly as possible. This is the condition for this system to be viable and accepted.

But the reduction of inequalities found its limit in our pension systems. Depending on the professions exercised, life expectancy could differ between a worker and an executive, since those who worked and still work in difficult jobs contribute like others without being able to access their pensions like others. It is to remedy this situation that the account for occupational hardship was established, which gives individuals in the most demanding jobs an additional compensation.

Starting this year, rights are opened, and points are accumulated during professional life based on the degree of exposure to easily identifiable hardship factors such as night work and assembly line work. Then, it will be up to employees to determine how to use their points, their rights as they see fit, with their employer if they are still employed or to retire earlier. It was necessary to ensure that companies could implement this within the right timeline and deadlines, and here too, the generalization will depend on the conditions of application.

Our third responsibility for the future of Social Security, but also for improving daily life, is to facilitate access to rights. It is good to have rights, but they must also be usable as intended. However, it is primarily the most vulnerable who are victims of complexity, and I know, I will not name names or even functions, that when a measure is taken, they have a very great capacity to prevent its application. This ultimately leads to the result that the sums that had been planned are not spent: this is probably the goal of those who have the genius to set criteria, conditions, and introduce controls, to ultimately render the provision that may have been voted by Parliament inapplicable. But the leaders and managers, on the other hand, are not in this mindset, and they are often sensitive to what may indeed seem to them a terrible injustice, that rights are recognized but cannot be truly exercised. We have the case, in particular, for the RSA activity, since many of those who are entitled do not claim it, hence the reform that will come for the activity bonus. I also know how unbearable the difficulties faced in the RSI social regime are for self-employed workers, both in establishing contributions and in calculating benefits. So the government, here too, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Social Affairs, wanted to work with these professionals to make improvements that were expected after a poorly conducted reform, that of 2008, which had very damaging consequences.

The issue of simplification also arises for health insurance, even for Universal Health Coverage, where a number of insured individuals see their rights interrupted because they have changed addresses, jobs, or because they have difficulties renewing their Vitale card. The Social Security financing law for 2016, which will be presented by Ms. Touraine tomorrow at the Council of Ministers, will establish Universal Health Protection for every individual aged 18 and over residing in France in a stable and regular manner: this is a major reform.

The goal is to have a Vitale card for life as long as one resides in France, to obtain it very early, to renew it without difficulty if lost, and to have this affiliation recognized regardless of job changes or professional interruptions. Progress will be the continuity of coverage and a very profound simplification of procedures with the funds. And more broadly, there will no longer be what are called dependents; there will be individuals, and that changes everything because individuals must be considered, they must be recognized, not simply because they have rights but because they belong to the same community, the national community, and they must be respected. That is the meaning of this reform.

It is more than simplification because it finally guarantees, for the first time, what was undoubtedly in the minds of the founders of Social Security, the universality of health insurance. And this reform is not based on the creation of a new right as in 1999 with Universal Health Coverage, but on the continuity of social coverage and thus personalization. This reform shows that 70 years after its creation, Social Security remains a living construct and that it is always possible to improve it, not just rights, not just benefits, but simply life, the life of our fellow citizens, without it costing more to the State or to contributors.

In the same way, a unique retirement account will be created for every French citizen by 2017. Each person will have a complete view of their career at any time, gathering all the information on the rights accrued during their professional life, and a single retirement liquidation procedure will also be introduced. This means that when one has worked in several fields, belonging to several schemes, and several funds, one will request the liquidation of their retirement in one go, and this will simplify the process.

This is also a way to respect the citizen. Those who have worked their whole lives and who are obliged, because it is the rule, to seek out their employers who have long since disappeared or in archives that have been lost due to family situations that may have also evolved, will no longer need to provide proof since it will be established throughout their professional life. From this point of view, digital technology provides us with solutions and must change the relationship of users with the funds with information portals on social rights. I have even understood that there would be a common visual identity for all Social Security organizations, "la Sécu," because that is ultimately how the French know it.

But simplification is not just for users; it is also for businesses. The nominative social declaration will be introduced starting in 2017; it will allow for real progress since it will be possible to declare contributions directly from payroll software, eliminating many procedures.

I have set myself a goal, not the only one, for this five-year term: to achieve simplification of the payslip. It is a struggle; I have ministers before me, I take advantage of it - but it is not just the ministers, because even those who could benefit from it resist because it requires changing the software, because it requires modifying what has been communicated out of habit until now, and the same people who complain that it is complicated do not want to change anything. Many think that when they look at this payslip, what is written is the reality: well, no, it is not the reality, for example, for social contributions because a second document arrives, sometimes later, listing all the exemptions from social contributions, which means that there are well-meaning entrepreneurs who say, "But I pay a lot of social contributions," forgetting, because it is at another moment, another time, the other paper they received that shows the exemptions. How can we understand that we charge or that we believe we are charging and then we reimburse? So it is true that to avoid the absurdity of situations where we exempt while at the same time displaying the nominal amount of the contribution, we might say that the best thing is to lower the contribution; it is so much simpler, it will create a simplified payslip.

The simplified payslip is not just simplification; it allows for much more balanced social relations where the balance of power can also change by knowing who pays and who pays for what. And if Social Security does not provide this clarity, does not provide this transparency, then it is threatened, because Social Security is not an immutable construction; it must move, it must evolve. But it is also not an irreversible acquisition, and I will give you my conviction.

It is not governments that will be able to save Social Security, as was said a few years ago; it is the adherence of the French people to the principles that underpin Social Security that will be decisive. In the not-so-distant past, the French mobilized every time they felt that Social Security could be in danger. But if their trust begins to wane or is lacking, then what has been built over 70 years can be undone much more quickly. And that is why the future of Social Security depends on this strength, on citizen strength, on the strength of those who are all the French people, the beneficiaries of this acquisition, of this republican pillar.

But the future of Social Security also depends on the capacity for adaptation and projection that social actors and the State must have for Social Security. Now, let us look at the facts. In recent years, and this has accelerated, the economy has been considerably disrupted by technology, professional life has changed a lot: careers are discontinuous, diversified, young people enter the labor market later, and mobility is more frequent. And then there is undoubtedly the digital aspect, which is an explanation for the blurring of the boundaries between different forms of work. What is an entrepreneur? What is an employee? What is a craftsman? What is a self-employed person? What is someone who rents their labor for a few hours?

So social protection must take these realities into account to prevent transitional moments from becoming breaks. And this is a new essential reform that will therefore be introduced, with the personal activity account. This major reform aims to gather rights that are accumulated by a person at any time in their professional life. This personal activity account is a person's capital; it is what belongs to them. It belongs to them because they have worked, because there has been a recognition of rights. It has accumulated over time, and it is up to the person who has this account, who therefore has this heritage, this capital, to decide how to use it.

This account will primarily be expressed in terms of time and will merge, for example, the personal training account, time savings accounts, and any hardship accounts. The ambition is to create links between systems that are too compartmentalized and to give more freedom in the use and management of these rights, providing choices to every individual. These orientations will be discussed at the social conference. Myriam EL KHOMRI is in charge of it. It will be on October 19. I call on social partners to engage in this consultation and discussion. Then, a labor bill will be presented at the beginning of 2016, and it will incorporate the personal activity account, a major reform for the coming years.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Social Security, in 1945, aimed to ensure dignity for everyone through the solidarity of all and among all. It was the most beautiful promise that the reborn democracy could make after the dark hours of war. And this promise remains; it is there, and we must continue to fulfill it.

Social Security is not a set of techniques and rules; it is the expression of a will to create a system where everyone is connected to one another without ever infringing on their freedom. This construction is based on a requirement, collective responsibility, which means generating resources, establishing sustainable financing, controlling expenses so that the Nation can bear the cost without prejudice to competitiveness and employment.

And this construction also relies on personal responsibility, so that social insured individuals are as aware of the contributions they pay as of the benefits they receive, not just so they can make this comparison, but so they know that the levy, the contribution, the tax is not a confiscation, is not an injustice, is not an abuse of power by the State or the Social Security funds, that the contribution, the contribution, the tax allows for financing and covering the essential risks of life.

In short, Social Security, if it wants to have a future—and it will have a future—must be just and effective because it is the good of all and the heritage of each. We would like to believe that Social Security, because we always have this pretension, we, the French, is not an invention of our country. Social Security is an aspiration of all countries and all peoples, and our Social Security is undoubtedly a reference. But in the most developed world, there is also this capacity to organize differently from us to ensure coverage of risks. And for all emerging countries, we must propose this model of Social Security to show that it is not linked to a state of development or only to a history, a culture, but simply linked to the recognition of rights everywhere in the world.

In celebrating the 70th anniversary of Social Security, I want to pay tribute to social dialogue, yes, to social dialogue because I consider it essential: if there had not been social dialogue, there would not have been Social Security as we know it today.

My message also is to pay tribute to parity because if there had not been this work between employers and employees, there would not have been this organization either.

Yes, tribute also to social partners. I say this at a time when there have been unspeakable acts at AIR FRANCE that should not discredit trade unionism but discredit the authors, which is very different. And I will never take it out on intermediaries, social bodies, those who are meant to represent employees and employers because we need to have interlocutors, because the State cannot decide everything. And if we discredit them, if we stigmatize them, if we push them aside, then what will be the very foundation of what we can do in the name of the general interest in the French Republic?

So, yes, tribute, on the occasion of the 70th anniversary of Social Security, also to the family movement represented by UNAF because I also know what these associations represent everywhere to ensure the well-being of families. Tribute to the staff of the funds, to all the managers, to all those who dedicate themselves to Social Security.

Finally, Social Security owes much to the women and men who keep it alive, and, as I said, to the citizens who must take ownership of it because we have a duty to evolve this great institution while keeping it true to itself, to its spirit, that of the founders. And what is at stake with Social Security is not the history we must revisit; it is what the very idea of its foundation carried. The most beautiful idea there is, the great idea that makes peoples advance, is progress. And if we doubt progress, then there is little chance that institutions like that can endure.

It is progress that drives us forward. Progress can be slowed down. Progress can sometimes come to a halt. So it is up to all of us to resume the march, to quicken the pace, to believe in what we are doing, and to tell ourselves that today, what we are putting back on the table for progress will be welcomed, I hope, by future generations. But our duty towards future generations is to make the necessary choices for reforms, to correct what needs to be corrected, to better finance, to ensure employment and growth, and above all to give young generations confidence in Social Security. It belongs to them. Thank you.