Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the Jewish community in France, anti-Semitism, and Israel, in Paris on March 20, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

20 March 2013 · CRIF dinner · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the 28th annual CRIF dinner in Paris on March 20, 2013, speaking on French Jewish history, anti-Semitism, and France-Israel relations.
Main themes
Jewish community in France, anti-Semitism, French Republic and Jewish history, the Shoah and Vel d'Hiv roundup, CRIF dinner, French Jewish identity, Dreyfus affair, republican universalism, acts of violence against Jews, memory and commemoration, Israel, integration and citizenship
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,044
86th percentile
Sentences
194
88th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.8
29th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 43%42%
  • Geopolitical 32%31%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

194 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Mr. President of CRIF, dear Richard PRASQUIER,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The CRIF dinner - this is the 28th - is a precious appointment for the Republic. Because this dinner brings together the Jewish community, but also the highest institutions, represented by the presidents of the National Assembly, the Senate, the presidents of parliamentary groups, the main parties - even when they have separated in the afternoon - the representatives from all over the country, and notably from the various faiths, all present together this evening.

The CRIF dinner is therefore a rare moment, there are few in our Republic, a moment of exchange, a moment of challenge, but also a moment of trust - mutual trust, trust in France, trust in the Republic.

Mr. President, you recalled the link between France and the Jewish community. It is a link that dates back to the highest Middle Ages and was sealed by the French Revolution. Indeed, it was under the Constituent Assembly, on September 27, 1791, that Jews, for the first time in Europe, became citizens. Persecuted for centuries, they welcomed this declaration with joy, albeit with some disbelief - and I want to quote it: "The National Assembly revokes all arguments, reservations, and exceptions inserted in previous decrees relating to Jewish individuals."

This was the beginning of a long history, that of Judaism in the Republic. A history marked by great figures.

I will mention a few.

Edmond FLEG, the philosopher, who was able to articulate the essential link between Jewish universalism and republican universalism, between the people of Human Rights and the people of the Ten Commandments.

Jules ISAAC, this great teacher, who, through the "MALET-ISAAC" textbooks, taught generations of French schoolchildren the story of their own country. And he did so as a republican, as a citizen.

René CASSIN, Vice-President of the Council of State, author of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Nobel Peace Prize laureate, who was for thirty years the president of the Alliance Israélite Universelle - this institution dedicated to the dissemination of both Jewish culture and the French language.

I could have mentioned others, I think of Jean ZAY. But I want to mention Simone VEIL, whose life testifies to an irreducible attachment to France, but also to the suffering from which our country failed to protect her.

For this history of Jews in France also experienced moments of fracture. There was, at the end of the 19th century, the DREYFUS affair and the anti-Semitic hysteria it provoked. But it is precisely because the Republic had triumphed, because freedom had prevailed, because the law had won, that, in Lithuania, the father of Emmanuel LEVINAS could address his children regarding the DREYFUS affair: "A country where they tear each other apart over the fate of a little Jewish captain is a country where one must go without delay," and many came here, to France.

This trust, however, was betrayed in 1940. It was the status of Jews, then the deportation of 76,000 Jews from France with the active complicity of the French state. I recalled this, and before me, it was President Jacques CHIRAC.

I recalled it on July 22 last on the very site of the Vel d'Hiv roundup. France, 70 years ago, failed in its word and its greatness. But honor was also saved by France, the France of the Resistance, the France of the Righteous, the France of the anonymous who, without even measuring their own heroism, reached out to the innocent. They remember.

But other wounds would follow, made even more unbearable by the memory of the Shoah. Mr. President, you mentioned some of them, and it is always cruel, it is always painful to hear these facts: the attack on Rue Copernic, on October 3, 1980, when a bomb killed four people, on a Friday evening, in front of a synagogue, during the Shabbat service - and also, on August 9, 1982, on Rue des Rosiers, which cost the lives of six people - and then others, and others still. And I think of the torture inflicted on Ilan HALIMI, kidnapped and tortured to death in the Paris region, in February 2006 because he was Jewish. Each time, we hoped that this sinister list was closed, and from CRIF dinner to CRIF dinner, all those who preceded me at this podium must have told you that it was the last time, that it would not happen again, that we would be vigilant. They were sincere and did everything to ensure that this fatality would not recur.

Until that March 19, 2012, in Toulouse, at the Ozar Hatorah school, where MERAH killed Rabbi Jonathan SANDLER, his sons, Gabriel and Arié, Myriam MONSONEGO, the daughter of the school director. That day, President Nicolas SARKOZY immediately went to the scene, on behalf of all of France. That very evening, we gathered, we political leaders - we were in the midst of a presidential campaign - at the Notre-Dame-de-Nazareth synagogue. We were together to make the same commitments, to express the same pain, to share the same compassion.

On November 1 last, I wanted to welcome Benjamin NETANYAHU at the very site where this barbarity occurred. We spoke, each of us, because we were concerned, France and Israel. And on Sunday, I presided, a year later, over a ceremony in memory of the victims, of all the victims. That is why we included our soldiers, Imad IBN-ZIATEN, Mohamed LEGOUAD, Abel CHENNOUF, cowardly murdered by the same terrorist, because they were French soldiers.

For the Jewish community as for the Republic as a whole, there is and there will be a before and after Toulouse. That is why I wanted all the lessons of this tragedy to be drawn. The government has strengthened, wherever necessary, the security of the Jewish community, its places of worship, its study centers, its schools. 500 buildings are subject to measures. It is the responsibility of the state, of the Minister of the Interior. The Republic guarantees freedom of conscience, and therefore the free exercise of religions.

But this phrase came back to my mind, I heard it at the school in Toulouse, spoken by parents and even by children: "How can we accept that at the beginning of the 21st century, the police are led to protect schools, how can we bear the idea that children might fear going to school and parents fear sending them there?" I tell you here, the Republic will be at peace with itself when that fear has definitively disappeared.

For ten months, but it was true before, the police services, under the authority of justice, have dismantled several terrorist groups, such as in Sarcelles, in Torcy, and very recently in Marignane. Not just any terrorist groups: some had already struck, others were preparing to act. Hence our vigilance, hence the role entrusted to the intelligence services. All the more reason for them to be effective, to reorganize. This was done by the Minister of the Interior through coordination between the central directorate and the territorial services, the creation of a genuine internal inspection, the improvement of information sharing, and the relationship between justice and police.

All this seems obvious. We must ensure that nothing is lost, that no information is forgotten, that no lead is dismissed. A law has also been adopted, unanimously, which is the best signal we can send. This law allows for the prosecution and conviction in France of those of our nationals who, abroad, engage in training or even terrorist acts.

In the same way, this law allows intelligence services access to all technical data collected during internet access. But there is another lesson from Toulouse, Mr. President. You mentioned it this evening - we know it, but it has reminded us in a terrible way. This lesson can be summed up in a few words: horror does not discourage hatred. For a year, after Toulouse, anti-Semitic acts have not ceased. The figures are relentless, they have been recalled by the President, and moreover, they underestimate reality. Not all victims file complaints, and some complaints are dismissed without follow-up. Therefore, procedures will be simplified, with the possibility of filing a complaint without civil party status, for insults, defamation, racist and anti-Semitic provocations. Madame the Keeper of the Seals is preparing a circular in this sense, because we will be unyielding.

Anti-Semitism is not only the hatred of Jews, it is already its essential object - anti-Semitism is the hatred of France, of what it represents: France, the homeland of Human Rights, France which has inscribed the word "fraternity" in its motto. That is why our response must be that of France. It is this spirit that must inspire our laws and our actions in the training of civil servants, in the culture of our fellow citizens, in the education of our children.

Education is memory, 70 years after the Shoah, nothing must be forgotten. This unique crime in history cannot be compared to any other. The Shoah must be taught everywhere, in all middle schools, in all high schools in France, in our cities, in our villages, in our neighborhoods, in our suburbs. It is not an optional teaching, which teachers would hesitate to profess in certain circumstances or in front of certain students. It is in the curriculum, not to impose, but to enlighten, to ensure that everyone understands what this crime against humanity means and what this genocide was.

Education is also the transmission of reference points, and that is the meaning of the teaching of secular morality, which the Minister of National Education has proposed and will establish throughout the school journey. Those who smile at the idea of this teaching are very wrong. It is not about moralizing or teaching a morality, but simply about recalling what the principles of the Republic mean, secularism, the reference points, the disciplines, the rules that we must respect in any organized society. By ignoring the reminder of these rules, they are no longer considered as rules, as norms, that impose themselves on all.

But our vigilance must go beyond the surveillance we could have over the actions of certain groups or what may happen in such or such neighborhood. Today, it is on the internet that we must focus all our attention. The internet, this virtual universe, a guarantee of all freedoms, where everything can be written, where all rumors could be true, where all images circulate and where hatred can slip in and spread without constraint, since all opinions are equal, since everything can be written, since everything can be seen. We have seen, alas, the dissemination of tweets - oh! the word may seem gentle - of anti-Semitic tweets, which multiplied last autumn.

It has therefore been requested that social networks remove these racist and anti-Semitic messages as soon as they are reported by an association. But it was necessary to go further, to seize the courts, which have ordered social networks to transmit the data allowing the identification of the authors of these messages. Because it is too simple, because one can disguise oneself, one can mask oneself, one can borrow names of circumstance to utter these insults. The Keeper of the Seals, once again, will ensure that these judgments are executed, because there can be no impunity for racist and anti-Semitic authors. They must know, if my voice can reach them, that they will be prosecuted and convicted for their actions.

To fight, to fight relentlessly against the rejection of others, against all racisms, against all intolerances, you said it, Mr. President, is the duty of every republican. It is also the duty of a country worthy of itself.

But combating all hatreds does not mean confusing them. Anti-Semitism is a very particular hatred, which goes deep into history, which has always fed on myths, which has been animated by obsessions through fables and lies.

Anti-Semitism has taken many forms over the decades. The ones from yesterday have not disappeared, you recalled them. Others have taken on a new dimension, with radical Islamism. Anti-Semitism is not reduced to it, and radical Islamism is not reduced to anti-Semitism. But this threat exists and we must confront it.

This extremism is not Islam, it distorts and perverts Islam. Muslims are its victims, they suffer to see their faith, their sacred texts, their traditions, thus attacked, thus sullied, they also suffer from the confusions, the amalgams, the caricatures that further reinforce discrimination.

I salute the leaders of the Muslim faith who are here this evening. Their presence has meaning, it has a significance that goes far beyond this place. They participate, within the Republic, in the fight against extremism and they must do so without fear.

I thank them for having supported, from the very first day, the decision I made to intervene in Mali on behalf of France.

What was at stake was the integrity of a country that risked being overwhelmed by terrorist groups - a country, I remind you, that is 90% Muslim - where women were subjected to a law that was not their own, where sacred monuments were profaned, and where the population was asking for help against these extremist terrorist groups. But it was not just about Mali; it was about all of West Africa, and, alas, recent events have proven us right. Our intervention has led to significant results in two months: the offensive of the terrorist groups has been halted, and the cities have been recaptured. In the final phase, in which we find ourselves, almost the entire territory will return to the sovereignty of Mali in a few days.

I salute the courage of our soldiers. Like you, Mr. President, I pay tribute to the five soldiers killed in combat, who died for the most just of causes, freedom, who died for France. I also think of our hostages: everything must be done to free them.

But there is a lesson, another one, that we must draw from all that I have just said: it is that free peoples are never weak peoples.

And this lesson must apply to France. It is by being strong that it will be respected; it is by never renouncing its values and principles that it will be able to maintain its influence. It is by upholding the law and ensuring it is respected that it can still be regarded as a power. This lesson that a free country must never be a weak country applies everywhere in the world.

I know your eyes are turned towards Israel. This country bears the name of a people who have been persecuted for too long. It has revived Hebrew, which had been a dormant language for 2,000 years. It was created in the aftermath of genocide to welcome all Jews, wherever they come from, who have suffered for who they are. Your attachment to Israel does not need to be explained or justified. It is legitimate. And it does not date from today or from recent years. I found what Léon Blum said, before he died, in 1950: "French Jew, he said, speaking only the language of my country, primarily nourished by its culture, I nevertheless participate in the admirable effort, miraculously transported from dream to reality, which now ensures a worthy homeland, equally free for all Jews who have not had, like me, the good fortune to find it in their native land." This phrase has not entirely lost its relevance.

Today, for Israel, the great challenge, the only one - the others having been accomplished and realized - the only challenge is peace. It requires the recognition and respect of the sovereignty and security of each. All peoples have the right to self-determination. The Palestinian people have long waited. It is time for a Palestinian state to exist alongside Israel. It is in Israel's own interest; as long as Palestine does not have recognized borders, Israel will not have them either. Therefore - this is the constant position of France expressed through me, as it has been by others - a lasting peace can only come from a fair and negotiated agreement between Israelis and Palestinians, with the support of the international community. Since the only solution is that of two neighboring and sovereign states living securely within their borders, nothing should be done that goes against this objective. This is France's position.

I have had the opportunity in recent months to meet with the President of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, the Prime Minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu, and, two weeks ago, President Shimon Peres. To all of them, I have spoken the same language, that of trust and responsibility. Each must now take their share of courageous decisions. For as long as there is no peace, there will always be these fears, these concerns, these questions. I know it is difficult; there should be no preconditions, neither on one side nor the other. An opportunity, with the formation of the new Israeli government, is being seized by the international community. I hope there can be a translation of this in the coming weeks.

But peace is not limited to the Israeli-Palestinian issue, for the entire Middle East is at stake. I want to tell you here what our positions are beyond our concerns. France is primarily attentive to the situation in Lebanon, where religions and communities coexist - but with the memory of the rifts that are not so far away - and where pressures are exerted from the outside with Syria, and from the inside, with Hezbollah, whose ties with Syria and Iran are established and even claimed.

I have heard you, Mr. President. The Bulgarian authorities have said, and they must confirm, that they had evidence of the involvement of members of Hezbollah in the heinous attack in Burgas, which targeted Israeli tourists last July. I say it here, Europe must be ready to draw all the conclusions from this.

I also understand the questions raised by the changes underway in the Arab countries of the region. The revolutions of 2011 continue; they raised promises - which have not disappeared - but today they evoke fears that may strengthen. I think of the uncertainties in Egypt, the difficulties in Libya with weapons circulating.

But it is in Syria that we must focus much more than our gaze, which is too often averted. We must bring much more than compassion or a circumstantial condemnation. Bashar al-Assad is waging war against his own people - 70,000 victims in two years. This war is terrible for civilian populations but also for neighbors, with a large number of refugees, and for Lebanon, the risk of contagion. Then there are these chemical weapons that are present in Syria. Therefore, the continuation of the war benefits only two camps: Bashar al-Assad to maintain himself and extremist groups to exploit the misfortune, the disarray, the absence of political transition, to use their forces for chaos. It is therefore urgent that there be a political solution in Syria, but there will only be one if there is also military pressure. That is why France wants to strengthen the political alternative, has recognized the coalition, provides it with material, humanitarian, and - if conditions are met - military assistance within the European framework.

But I want to warn here. If there is no solution in the coming months, then there will be an escalation whose consequences all the countries in the region will have to face.

I hear the gravest of threats, but it is not unrelated to the previous one, for it is the same minds and the same forces that are at work. The main threat to Israel's security - not only, by the way, to Israel's security: to the security of the region, to the security of the world - is the Iranian nuclear program. The authorities of this country multiply statements calling for the disappearance, for the destruction of Israel. This openly declared design, associated with the stated desire to pursue a nuclear program, outside of any international control, is therefore a major threat. It cannot be allowed for Iran to acquire nuclear weapons.

France will therefore take its responsibilities to ensure that pressure continues, that sanctions are intensified, so that Iranian leaders comply with their international commitments, with the resolutions of the Security Council. Again, let the Iranians - or rather the Iranian authorities - not count on the supposed weakness of their interlocutors. France will fulfill its duties and will not fail in its word.

That is what I wanted to tell you for this 28th dinner of the CRIF, the first that I have the honor to preside over, if I may say so - for you have a President, and I would not presume to enter into this ongoing process; I am against the accumulation of mandates, and besides, I do not meet all the conditions!

But I wanted, through this first speech before you, to both tell you what I think of the exceptional relationship between the Jews of France and the Republic, and also what France's position is regarding peace between Israel and the Palestinians, regarding the threats - that you should clearly know what our lines of force or the lines that should not be crossed are.

This is the mark of respect I have for the CRIF.

You will celebrate its 70th anniversary in the coming months. I want to highlight the role of this institution in the Republic. You represent the Jewish institutions of France; you are therefore a constructive interlocutor for public authorities. I did not say easy; I said constructive! And since I did not say easy, I salute Richard Prasquier, who will leave his position in May. It is a terrible month, where one can arrive and also depart. I thank him for having been throughout his six years of presidency a demanding voice, a clear voice, a strong voice, certainly of the Jewish community, but also of the Republic. I send him all my best wishes for the continuation of his commitments, for he will have others, in service of the causes that are dear to him, and notably the one that has made the unity of his life: memory.

Memory, that of suffering but also of Jewish hope. The suffering and hope, you have illustrated once again, it is that of humanity, it is that which makes life stronger than anything else, that there is a continuation, that there is a march, that there is progress, and that France is capable of overcoming everything, if it knows how to come together, as we are doing this evening, at least for a dinner.

But we must come together - not simply gather, because there would be peril - no! we must gather on what seems essential to us: what makes France still have a voice to speak, a role to play, an influence to exert, an economy to promote, a language to defend, values to uphold? Yes, that is France! And that is why you feel deeply like citizens of the Republic.

All identities, all singular threads, all personal stories, all wounded memories that make up the national consciousness belong collectively to France.

France is made of all these mixed influences, of successive immigrations, of countless particular contributions, each of which can be considered irreplaceable. Among these contributions, there is that of French Jews, these "children of Abraham and Marianne," heirs of a word and a tradition, who have never ceased to make a loyal gift of their talents to their homeland.

You have, your parents, and you yourselves, defended the homeland each time it was threatened. You have given the best of yourselves and you continue to do so. You have participated in so many works, achieved so many cultural, economic, and medical successes! You have contributed, whatever your place, to the prosperity of our country. You have done so without ever forgetting the deep roots that connect you to Judaism. So I tell you, as I will tell others: our country needs everyone, all its children, all its citizens, all its talents. Without you, France would not be France, but with you, and with all, France will be even greater. Thank you.