Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the reform of decentralization, democratic modernization, access to public services and health, education, and agricultural policy, in Sombernon (Côte d'Or) on March 12, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

12 March 2013 · Reform of decentralization, democratic modernization, access to public services and health, education, and agricultural policy · Sombernon, France

Context
Hollande addressed elected officials in Sombernon, Côte d'Or on March 12, 2013, outlining reforms on decentralization, rural policy, public services, and agriculture.
Main themes
Decentralization reform, rurality and rural development, territorial organization, local authority competencies, public services access, agricultural policy, digital divide, metropolitan governance, regional development, demographic policy, land use policy, intercommunality
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,112
92nd percentile
Sentences
270
94th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 42%40%
  • Economic 29%28%
  • Social 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

270 sentences in 77 paragraphs

Mr. Mayor,

First of all, I want to thank you for your welcome, the welcome of a Republican, the welcome of a farmer, the welcome of a rural elected official attached to his territory and who wants to make it thrive.

I am here in Burgundy, the region presided over by François PATRIAT, who demonstrates his ability to develop urban areas, such as Dijon, while also making the entirety of his territory thrive.

I find myself here with the elected officials of the Auxois-Morvan region, a land that François MITTERRAND considered to be the heart of Burgundy. I dare not say the capital! I have just learned that I am succeeding here, in Sombernon, President GISCARD d'ESTAING. This land is therefore part of a France that has mattered in our history and will continue to matter in its future.

Because rurality, of which I am one of those who, as an elected official, has had to defend, is both our history and our future. It is our history because it is in rurality that France was founded with its agriculture, its production, its landscapes, its traditions. But rurality is also a factor of confidence in the future because it is in rural territories that we will find the levers for our own development, provided we value all our assets, and there are many in these territories.

France has this particularity in Europe, I would almost say this exception, of having a particularly dynamic birth rate; we have the highest fertility rate in Europe and at the same time have the most harmonious population density on the territory in Europe. We have, at the same time, the capacity to continue to grow in terms of our population: by 2030, there will be 70 million French people, and we also have the possibility to sustain this population in a balanced manner across the territory, provided that we have a real land use policy and that rurality can be fully utilized.

I believe in rurality because it allows us to preserve the diversity of our regions, our productions, our cultures, and our agriculture. Rurality, even for urban French people, is also a reference. The French from our cities either want to know their roots and find them in our rural territories, or having no roots, want to plant them somewhere, including in rural territories.

Despite all these challenges, I am not unaware of the questions that are yours. These questions, these concerns are numerous. There is first the very future of our local authorities: the municipality, the department. But there is also the presence of public services: education, health. The digital divide that risks occurring if we do not adequately equip our territories. And finally, the questions raised about the very future of agriculture, particularly livestock farming.

To all these questions, I want to respond in my initial remarks as well as through the interventions that will be yours.

The first question I want to address is: "Why a new decentralization law?" Is it about transferring new competencies? Certainly. Is it about transferring responsibilities to local authorities? Not necessarily, if they are not to be financially compensated. Is it about complicating the territorial map even further? Certainly not, as long as there are enough levels.

So, what is the objective? It is to clarify, simplify, and organize.

First, it is about stating who will do what in the territories of tomorrow.

The region must expand its competencies to encompass all economic development, innovation, employment, vocational training, and transportation. The department must retain its function of solidarity: territorial solidarity between municipalities and between intercommunalities, social solidarity through a number of services, generational solidarity because it is on the departments that a good part of the funding for dependency currently rests.

Intercommunalities are project areas and must be strengthened. After a somewhat tumultuous procedure, the prefects have established the maps of intercommunalities, and they must now be applied. Intercommunalities must have the capacity to set local urban planning plans and to master space well, even if mayors must retain the authority to issue building permits.

Thus, in this new decentralization law, we have a framework that will be simplified and that will allow each level of local authority to know exactly what it has to do, and for each of our fellow citizens to clearly understand who is responsible for what.

We will also have to recognize the metropolitan fact, that is to say, the fact that there are urban areas in our country that must play their full role. I have told you, I was the mayor of a modest-sized municipality, even if it has great ambition; I was the president of a general council, Corrèze, considered rural. But I have never wanted to oppose urban areas to rural territories. I have never allowed myself to fall into this simplification to pit one against the other.

Because if there are no urban areas, there are no spaces that can be adequately irrigated economically and in terms of major infrastructure. But if urban areas absorb rural space, then our hope for a balanced territory is over.

We must therefore recognize the metropolitan fact and, at the same time, allow rurality to have the same access to services as in large cities. This is the whole challenge of our land use planning. This is what the decentralization law must also do by allowing spaces for dialogue between local authorities, between the executives of regions, departments, intercommunalities, and between the representations of elected officials, to clearly understand how we structure the territory.

Dialogue is also, at the national level, the creation of a High Council of Territories. It will be composed of the main elected officials of our country designated by their peers, representatives of the State to enable good cooperation and to organize ourselves well so that France itself can be united.

There will be no change in France if the State does not cooperate with local authorities. There will be no local success if there is not also this national conception of development.

The reform must also be guided by essential financial aspects. Three principles must underpin the relationship between the State and local authorities in this matter:

- The first principle is trust. I have asked the government to present a pact between the State and local authorities so that allocations are set without having to be revised or reduced over the next three years. Similarly, I wanted local authority funding to be made sustainable and guaranteed through two mechanisms:

- The first is the raising of the ceiling of the Livret A: the Caisse des dépôts can lend to local authorities for more than 20 years at rates that must be below those currently practiced, so that any local authority with a long-term project can find financing.

- And then, there will be a second instrument, the Local Authorities Bank, which succeeds Dexia, which sank before us and cost taxpayers dearly. This Local Authorities Bank must serve all elected officials.

- Finally, I am ready to welcome a proposal made to me by the mayors of France so that they can organize themselves to raise a certain amount of capital in the markets. Why not? As long as we have very low interest rates in the markets, anything that can be mobilized as savings to be allocated to local investment will be welcome, provided it is at the best price.

- The second principle is responsibility. In these times of budgetary rigor, everyone must make an effort, everyone must do their part. That is why the State has indicated to local authorities that allocations would decrease by 1.5 billion, not in 2013 since they have been preserved, but in 2014 and 2015, on a total of State contributions that currently amount to nearly 52 billion euros. It is true that this is a sacrifice, and I know what it can represent. But at the same time, we must all make savings; we must all seek to use public funds in the spirit of the best quality and the best efficiency.

- The last principle to govern the financial relations between the State and local authorities is solidarity. Because the effort I just mentioned must be fairly distributed. This is what we call equalization, a complicated term to simply mean redistribution. The State must grant more allocations to rural territories and fragile neighborhoods. These are urban solidarity allocations and rural solidarity allocations. They will not only be preserved but increased. And then, there is redistribution between local authorities, between wealthy departments and poorer departments, given the tax structure, between regions, between intercommunalities. Because we cannot accept that in departments where there is a significant financial mass due to a population and especially businesses, there cannot be a reallocation of these surpluses to the most affected territories, either by the aging population or by the extent of the territory.

These are the principles that will allow us to have, in the next three years, a clear relationship between the State and local authorities.

But one of the ways to make savings, without costing taxpayers anything and without compromising the quality of public services, is to lighten procedures and standards. Every time we impose an additional constraint on local authorities, it is an additional burden and therefore an additional tax that we are forced to raise from our fellow citizens.

Today, there are 400,000 standards that are applicable. 400,000! This makes no sense! Many, moreover, are obsolete. But they are nonetheless applied with administrative complexities that are unbearable, high costs, legal risks even when they are not applied and lead to litigation. I want to put a stop to this normative inflation. There will be a systematic reduction in the number of standards, rules, and constraints. I want to act quickly. I have heard many speeches on these subjects as an elected official. I do not want mine to be just one more.

There will be a law, following excellent parliamentary reports, that will come to simplify, reduce, clarify, and lighten procedures and constraints. This law can be applied with the speed that our Constitution provides for in exceptional cases.

This is what the first question is about: "What future for our local authorities in the context of a new stage of decentralization?"

The second question is: "What democratic representation of our territories?" Even if democracy has deepened with local freedoms, we must consider that, here too, new structures call for citizen involvement, different from the past.

I think, in particular, of intercommunalities. I have been an intercommunal elected official. Often, in intercommunalities, we spent much more than in our own municipalities. However, we were elected, of course, but not chosen to exercise this responsibility by our fellow citizens. From now on, community elected officials will be designated by voters, through a system of designation at the time of municipal elections. Everyone will know who will sit in the intercommunal structure.

Then there is representation at the departmental level. I have told you, I was president of a general council with a cantonal structure that, in the department for which I was responsible, had disparities that could go from 1 to 20 or from 1 to 30. Here, I believe it even goes to 33. We also had, and you also have, a representation that is not particularly balanced in general councils. I think that at the national level, we must be at 15% women in general councils. Can we accept, in the very interest of the department, this form of representation? No.

From there, we could establish an electoral system based on proportional representation, majority, as exists for the region, ensuring ipso facto parity, or take into account rather the territorial reality and the representation of a number of local authorities through a ballot that could be, in a certain way, the representation of the cantons, but broader than in the past and with a man/woman or woman/man duo that allows for respect for parity.

Those who criticize this reform have often forgotten that they proposed the territorial council that would have led to the same redistricting. There will be a reduction in the number of cantons and a parity representation in each canton through this binomial ballot.

I am aware, however, that there are territories that must be represented and that have a large area but few populations. We will ensure that for these specific territories that we know well, here in Côte-d'Or, but everywhere in rural territories, there is flexibility, an exemption that allows for population disparities between urban cantons and rural cantons, but in a reasonable manner.

Here is the idea behind this reform. I believe it is designed to preserve the department and to guarantee parity and fair representation of the territories.

I also want to mention democratic modernization through the limitation of the accumulation of mandates. This is a topic that has been debated for years, a passionate and therefore exciting subject! You know that this reform will take place during the five-year term. It can only be established if there is at the same time a status for elected officials. This is a demand that has long been advocated by associations. I want us to have the same approach, as it is far from my intention to accuse elected officials. It is too easy, too convenient, especially in times of difficulty.

I know what elected officials can do in a territory, I know what they represent, I know what their daily tasks are, I know the range of requests they receive, even as their resources are scarce. From there, we need respected elected officials who can fully perform their work, which is not just a job but a mandate they receive from the people, yet which nonetheless takes up their time and sometimes compromises their careers. Hence the need for a status for elected officials.

The last element regarding democratic representation: we must also take into account the citizen demand, which is sometimes impatient, sometimes even disturbing, but which is a sign that our fellow citizens want to know everything about our activities. This is the demand for transparency.

I am in favor of the exercise of the right to petition, of the ability to have projects for deliberation and consultation placed on the agenda of our local authorities. Not to slow things down, but ultimately to anticipate, to prepare the right decisions.

Another major concern is that expressed by the mayor, on behalf of all the elected officials here: it is access to public services. The Republic is indivisible. There are not two categories of citizens: those who can easily, due to their geographical situation, access all facilities and services; and then the others who, due to distance, impossibility, or bureaucracy, cannot do so.

I know the consequences, in rural areas, of weakened or even erased public services. This feeling of being forgotten, abandoned, especially of being relegated, by those who, at the outset, experienced life in the city and came to settle, as they say, in the countryside, thinking they would have all the services they had received until then and who are now searching for them, due to the lack of guaranteed presence of these administrations and public services. There is a democratic and civic issue here. I want to address it.

I intend to act in four directions.

First, to ensure that public services can be better organized, that there can be, under the authority of the prefect and the president of the General Council, a departmental scheme for public services. We need to be able to group around the same spaces public service houses or any other formula of administrations and even private services, so that, in the same place, all means, all services, all information, all advice can be provided in each living area.

I have asked Jean-Marc Ayrault's Government to mobilize the nine major public service operators: La Poste, Pôle emploi, the Health Insurance, the CAF, pension schemes, the MSA, EDF, GDF, and the SNCF, so that they pool their resources, train their staff to deliver, sometimes, services from another company, and so that we can have, in the territory, every time, all possibilities of intervention.

We will not succeed everywhere, but if there is this federation, if there is this meeting, this mobility, then we can best respond to the needs of our fellow citizens. The State itself will set an example. It will create a National Fund to contribute to the expenses related to this new organization.

The question remains of the presence of the State. There are two concerns often expressed. First, what will be the future of the gendarmerie or police in a number of territories? This reform is not easy to implement, but again, let us try to respond, not as defenders of an administration, gendarmerie or police, but by knowing what best ensures the safety of our fellow citizens in a territory. Who should fall under a police zone, a gendarmerie zone? What matters is having security forces that intervene. This is the framework that the Minister of the Interior is preparing.

The second question is the future of sub-prefectures. Again, let us try to respond to needs. I believe in the usefulness of sub-prefectures to support elected officials in their projects, to participate in employment policies, to assist businesses. But does there always need to be a unique location to provide these services? It is not about removing resources; it is about using them differently. I think there is nothing better than an administration that sometimes comes directly into contact with elected officials.

Then, there are sub-prefectures that must still have this building because it is a service rendered to the public, beyond what can be done for elected officials. For example, I do not take my reference by chance; the sub-prefecture of Montbard corresponds to this logic. But there is necessarily always the same question to ask in the territory: what is the most useful, the most effective, what allows us to best meet the needs of users?

That is the situation regarding access to public services. But there is also access to health, which has also become one of the major concerns for our fellow citizens and for you, who represent them, with what we call "medical deserts," with an aging population and a medical demography that is not favorable. Many doctors are going to retire, and few young doctors want to settle in a number of territories. Because, here too, lifestyles have changed: a number of young practitioners no longer want to have the same constraints regarding on-call duties or the organization of their days or vacations.

We must therefore act. How? The first decision I made is to ensure that in the Social Security financing law, 200 jobs for territorial general practitioners will be created, who will have the guarantee of a monthly income of 4,600 euros, where they will settle, that is to say, in the territories we consider priority. So that this is not just a necessary incentive, but a guarantee of income for these young doctors to be sure of succeeding in their professional lives.

Secondly, there needs to be a more direct link between city doctors and public hospitals, both for organization and so that some can continue their careers, including in hospitals.

Finally, there are what we call "health houses." Here, in the department, there are two projects currently being developed. They aim to bring together health professionals in the same place with a quality of service, with a pooling of resources, with even greater efficiency for patients and social security beneficiaries. Therefore, we must, with the region, the department, and the State, have a public policy to support these structures. We have started to do this, we will continue, and we will even amplify the resources allocated to these health houses.

I also want to emphasize the school, the school of the Republic to which rural territories are very attached. It is what structures a municipality. Nothing is more painful for a mayor than to see it closed. Everyone here knows that when a school closes, it does not reopen. There is also the interest of the students that justifies not leaving classes with too few students. Even if we know that there are still, I have known in my own department, unique schools where you find students from CP to CM2 and where the teacher does remarkable work. But it must still be in the interest of the students.

To preserve the school of the Republic, for the past 10 months, we have reversed the trend. We are creating positions when they were being cut. We will illustrate this as early as the next school year, which will mean that school maps will benefit from more openings than closures.

But there is also the question of school rhythms. I know the subject. We wonder how it existed before, at 4 and a half days, to have so much trouble finding it again. But why switch to 4 and a half days? Simply because the demonstration has been made. We are the country in Europe—I do not dare say in the world, I do not want to check everywhere!—where we have the shortest school year: an average of 144 days for our students when others have 188. It is the only area where we have reduced working time to such an extent! And not to the advantage of the students since it results in some of the longest working days in Europe. Because in addition to the school day, we must add the time for school transport, which means that students can leave at 7 a.m. and return at 6 p.m. and sometimes later in the evening. I have experienced these situations.

There is therefore a need to return to 4 and a half days and to have the necessary flexibility to achieve this. I will ensure that. But the necessary support has an additional cost! For all the municipalities that will implement the reform in the 2013/2014 school year, there will be this fund that will allow them to have a subsidy between 50 euros and 90 euros per child. I will frankly tell you my position: if I were a mayor, I would not hesitate, but those who want to take their time can of course wait until the 2014 school year to have the school rhythm reform that seems best to them.

One last topic I wanted to address before you is very high-speed internet. Here too, for rural territories, this can be a progress or a calamity. The calamity is ultimately to live with one more inequality, that is to say, a disconnection from the rest of the territory, as was the case with mobile phones at one time. Today, no individual, and certainly no business, will settle in a territory if they are not sure of having at least high-speed internet and for a business, very high-speed internet.

I have therefore decided that over the next 10 years, the entire French territory, I mean the entire French territory, 100%, must be equipped with very high-speed internet; within 5 years, at least half of the French territory. We will mobilize very significant sums with private operators and local authorities. A portion of the State subsidy will go to rural territories because that is where subsidies are necessary. If it is to equip cities and urban areas with very high-speed internet, there is no need for a subsidy! Private operators benefit from it and do not need any public support. For semi-urban areas, incentives will be necessary. But for rural areas, this must be done with local authorities, with operators, and with the State. I guarantee you that.

That is what I wanted to say in introduction for the debate we are going to have. But being here in Côte-d'Or, a large agricultural region, I want to talk about agriculture and livestock. Agriculture is facing, in general, a new and positive challenge for our country. There is an increasing global demand for all products: animal production, as well as plant production, is an opportunity!

The second asset: the price of agricultural products is increasing, especially for plant productions. But for animal productions, there is an additional constraint, which is that the cost of raw materials has risen considerably, without the production prices so far allowing for a pass-through.

The risk, as we can see, is therefore strangulation for farmers, with margins becoming nonexistent and a strong incentive to change land use. Why continue livestock farming if, on a number of lands, it is possible to grow cereals or plant productions with a guaranteed price and very high profitability, which speculative movements can also amplify?

We therefore have a duty to regulate prices and ensure that farmers can pass on their own difficulties to distribution. But we also need to ensure that quality products, such as livestock here, can also be valued through labels, through recognitions, through prices, and also through consumer information. It took, once again, for us to discover that a number of frozen products, labeled "pure beef," were "pure horse," for us to reconsider the issue of certification and traceability.

I have therefore decided that in France, we would have this obligation: to make products known. The major distributors, by the way, have so far committed to this. At the European level, it is more difficult, but I believe that what has just happened will allow for strengthened traceability. This will ensure that consumers can have even more assurance that everything consumed is French beef. Again, this traceability will have a double advantage: 1 - consumer trust and 2 - support for French production.

I also know, and I was alerted during this trip to Côte-d'Or, about the problem you are facing in eradicating bovine tuberculosis once and for all. You have made a lot of efforts. This is a very important issue because if we were to lose our tuberculosis-free status, we would no longer be able to export our calves to consuming countries. This issue applies to Burgundy and to other regions of France. We therefore have the obligation, not only to comply with the standards but to eradicate this disease. And this is where I also come to the questions of hunting, on sensitive issues. It is absolutely essential that we have an order issued by the Minister of Agriculture that allows us to act to combat bovine tuberculosis.

A final word on agriculture. Many were concerned, again, because there were doubts about the future of the Common Agricultural Policy. I went to negotiate at the European Council for the future of the European Union budget. I was not able to obtain as much as I wanted, in terms of overall spending. Because there are countries that believe it is appropriate for Europe to have less credit while the European budget is 1% of European output, of production, of growth. 1%...

But we have stabilized this expenditure. Within this expenditure, I had a commitment towards farmers. I wanted the Common Agricultural Policy, for the share that belongs to France, to be guaranteed, stabilized at the same level as today and even with a possibility to take inflation into account. This has been achieved.

We therefore have exactly the same direct aids as before with coupling to production, which was a very strong demand from the profession £ with limited warning, which was also a demand from the profession £ and with a redistribution of aids, which is not always the case for the profession, but that we will have to ensure in the coming months.

I know that the agricultural profession engages in solidarity between sectors. We have therefore succeeded, and all farmers must know this, in preserving the level of direct aids to agriculture and production. In addition, we have increased the funds dedicated to rural development. This is everything that will allow us to support the specificities of our agriculture and our territories. It is the regions that will have the responsibility to distribute these aids with, of course, national rules, particularly for installation and for livestock buildings and for compensation for territories deemed to be disadvantaged.

We have therefore guaranteed this funding, we have greater flexibility to use it, we have allowed for a redistribution of these aids. So we must use these means to develop our agriculture, because it is an asset for our country. Today, France's foreign trade has a deficit of more than 60 billion euros in 2012. But the agri-food industry and agriculture are in surplus. We must therefore use this sector, which is a sector of employment, which is a sector of activity, which is a sector of foreign trade, to improve our growth and to make good use of our territories.

To tell you the truth, I believe in the future of our rural territories. I do not consider that it is a burden for the Nation, as is often said, nor even a risk for the country, for those who live there. No, these rural territories are an asset. These rural territories allow us to preserve a heritage, to settle a population, to ensure a culture, and to provide more means for the success of our economy.

Competitiveness, as they say, is not simply competitiveness between companies; it is also competitiveness between territories. To have competitive territories, we need to have very large cities of European dimension: Paris, Lyon, Marseille, Strasbourg £ we need to have metropolises that have major university, scientific, cultural, and sports facilities £ we need to have regions that ensure economic development, departments that can ensure solidarity, and a rural territory that can be animated.

Countries that better manage their territories will be countries that have succeeded in making them a factor of growth. Growth is in the territories. It is the territories that generate this growth. When we free the territories, we free growth. Territorial harmony is therefore an asset for France. The growth of tomorrow will depend on our territorial capital, which is not to be confused with the future of the sole capital. There is the capital. And there is the capital of the territories: that is you.

This is the message I wanted to convey to you here, in one of our most dynamic rural territories. I remind you that there are 20 million of our fellow citizens living in rural territories. It is therefore to them that I address myself, telling them that the Republic will be with them, because they contribute to making the Republic of tomorrow. Thank you.