Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the situation in Gaza and Ukraine and on European construction, in Brussels on July 16, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

16 July 2014 · European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed press at the European Council in Brussels on July 16, 2014, summarizing decisions on Gaza, Ukraine sanctions, and EU leadership and economic priorities.
Main themes
Gaza ceasefire, Ukraine crisis and sanctions, European Council decisions, Jean-Claude Juncker investment program, EU digital market, energy union, stability pact flexibility, Russia and separatists, European Investment Bank funding suspension, climate commitments, posted workers directive, EU institutional appointments
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,201
78th percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 64%64%
  • Geopolitical 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

136 sentences in 38 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - The European Council started late and finished relatively early, not that there weren't important issues raised; I would say the most urgent ones were addressed. What was the urgency for the European Council? This evening, it was to call for Palestine, particularly the situation in Gaza, for a ceasefire, to ensure that pressures could be increased, especially on countries that can influence Hamas, so that there could be a truce, and that civilian populations would be spared. Thus, the Council revisited this painful issue, namely what has been happening for several days now with a situation that is known, unfortunately too well: rocket fire, assassinations, I think of the three Israelis, and of that young Palestinian who was burned alive, and then, the rocket fire that led to repression and bombings of which the Palestinian civilian population is a victim.

So the European Council, concerned with finding a solution, at the very moment when a six-hour ceasefire was declared, ensured that there could be a multiplication of contacts to restore the situation of 2012, when the ceasefire was declared.

Then, there were decisions regarding Ukraine. First, the process that Mrs. MERKEL and I, along with Presidents PUTIN and POROSHENKO, launched in Normandy, which is now considered a dialogue process. The Bénouville process, since it took place in that castle, was welcomed by the European Council.

At the same time, it was noted that once again, the ceasefire did not hold, and that there was a lack of commitment on the Russian side regarding what our objectives had been in these discussions, namely the release of hostages, border control, and the pressure that should have been applied to the separatists for a political dialogue to take place. Consequently, it was decided to raise the level of sanctions against entities, that is to say, groups, companies, or individuals, who have assisted the separatists or who have committed serious violations of the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Ukraine.

A first list will be established by the end of July. A second decision was also made, which was to suspend funding from the European Investment Bank, as well as from the EBRD, regarding projects that had previously been jointly halted, and which will therefore be interrupted, as long as there has been no progress in Russia's attitude to resolve this situation, this Ukrainian crisis. That is what the European Council had to pronounce in terms of decisions and initiatives on the international level.

The other part of the European Council's working time was devoted to the intervention of Jean-Claude JUNCKER and the search for personalities who could occupy the positions that the European Council has the capacity to appoint. So the first point, the intervention of Jean-Claude JUNCKER. He reiterated what he had said before the European Parliament, which had justified the majority he had found. I must say that his orientations correspond to what not only the European Council had been able to establish as principles at the end of June, but also to what France had wished.

First, a 300 billion euro investment program over the next three years, public and private investments, allowing European institutions to intervene in high-speed broadband, transport infrastructure, education, research, energy efficiency, and renewable development. Jean-Claude JUNCKER specified that he had presented this investment program after having long determined the possibilities with financial institutions such as the EIB. It is a credible program, it is a program that can be quickly implemented. It is a program that calls for a mobilization of all so that the list of projects can be drawn up in a short time.

The second principle that again received my support is the conception of the stability pact, with the use of all margins of flexibility, as they have been specified, indeed, on two occasions, in 2005 and in 2011, taking into account the situation of each country and the efforts in terms of competitiveness.

The third priority, which I had myself highlighted as essential, is true for France, and it is true for many countries that want a large digital market, an organization of digital affairs in Europe, industrial leaders in digital technology.

Finally, there was this fourth priority on energy union or common energy policy, so that we can also meet the dual challenge of competitiveness in terms of price and respect for our commitments regarding climate. Commitments that will need to be strengthened at the climate conference, which will be held in Paris at the end of next year.

Jean-Claude JUNCKER also revisited a number of points that we will need to clarify with him, regarding taxes on financial transactions, regarding the free movement of workers, but with social rules, what is called the directive on posted workers, and also on asylum and immigration policy, so that there is solidarity among member countries and above all better border surveillance.

Finally, I also agreed with a conclusion from Mr. JUNCKER's intervention, according to which there will be no new membership of countries to the European Union during the next five years.

After Mr. JUNCKER's intervention, and the debate that followed, there was an exchange on the responsibilities that must be decided by the European Council. There had been many debates, exchanges, discussions, which Mr. Van ROMPUY had initiated several weeks ago. From there, it was noted that there could not be a designation, for example, for the position of High Representative of the Common Foreign and Security Policy of Europe, if there was not a global package.

And there could not be a designation of a global package if there was not a certain clarity on the composition of the European Commission and the competencies that would be devolved to the countries. At the same time, and this is my position, the President of the European Commission must have a wide initiative to organize his Commission. The European Commission cannot serve as a variable adjustment to the decisions that the European Council would have to make. It was therefore decided on two things: the first is that each country should provide the name of its possible commissioner by the end of the month; there is no ultimate date, there can even be several names that can be proposed by some countries, as it will also be necessary to take into account the requirements regarding the representation of women in the European Commission.

And it was decided to convene a new European Council at the end of August to proceed with the two designations, which are those of the President of the European Council, and of the High Representative for foreign policy. The question of the presidency of the Eurogroup may also arise, but it does not fall under the European Council, even if the European Council must be informed of this appointment. That is what I wanted to tell you, Ladies and Gentlemen.

France, through my voice, has considered that this was the best method, and that as soon as there was this need for clarification, for negotiation on a number of positions, and that, moreover, a political balance had to be found, as soon as the President of the European Commission is from the center-right, and that was indeed the result of the European elections that justified this choice, then there had to be a representation of the socialist, social-democratic component for the positions of responsibility still under discussion. I can answer your questions before I fly to Côte d'Ivoire."

QUESTION - Good evening Mr. President. François BEAUDONNET, FRANCE 2. A question about the candidate from France, other states in Europe have already given names, can you tell us a bit more about the French candidate, especially since we can imagine that for Mr. JUNCKER, it is important to know with whom he will be able to work, so will you give us this name before the end of July? Thank you very much.

THE PRESIDENT - This evening, no. Why? Because this evening, it was only about the positions that fall under the Council, even if the Council was not able to decide today. However, I confirm that I will discuss, I have already done so, with President JUNCKER, but even more specifically about the competence that could be entrusted to the French Commissioner, and about the person who could occupy this position. And the name will be communicated at the end of the month. The competence will probably be presented at the end of August.

QUESTION - Unintelligible

THE PRESIDENT - President JUNCKER wants women, but France has the freedom of choice.

QUESTION - Alain FRANCO. Good evening Mr. President. Alain FRANCO, RTL and Le Point. Earlier, Herman Van ROMPUY said that he had had very many discussions, phone conversations with the various heads of state and government to prepare this Council, this Council spent, I believe, about five hours, four or five hours on the question of the positions, perhaps

THE PRESIDENT - No

QUESTION - Well, perhaps a little less, but at least a few hours. In any case, a lot of energy was spent to resolve the question of the positions, and to appoint two people, no more than two people, since that was the objective. And yet, you did not manage to find the two suitable people. You explain to us that it is a question of meccano, in fact, a kind of institutional meccano, but there also seems to have been a lot of opposition from certain countries regarding certain names. So could you enlighten us, beyond this institutional meccano, what really got stuck?

THE PRESIDENT - In fact, there was little time reserved for discussion, why? Because it was noted as early as the end of the afternoon that there would be no possibility of designation, why? Because some countries wanted to have a global view of the positions, the two that could be decided this evening, that of the presidency of the Eurogroup as well, and the consequences that this could have on the European Commission. So there was not really any discussion about the people, the constant having been established that it was better to give ourselves time and above all, that President JUNCKER should first receive the candidacies from the different countries for the composition of the Commission, and have a discussion on the distribution of responsibilities.

So what may seem surprising is that this Council, which had been convened to decide on the people, did not decide, and that it did not spend a very long time on it, since it had been almost agreed, even before the opening of the Council, that there would be no designation. Were there nevertheless any progress? Yes, why? Because it is clear that the High Representative will be of a political sensitivity of the European Socialist Party, since the President of the European Commission is of a center-right sensitivity, from the EPP. Regarding the European Council, it will be a personality who must gather consensus.

This work could not yet be conclusive today. There are countries that have said nothing, including Italy, since, to speak frankly, there is an Italian candidacy for the High Representative but they did not express a position in the Council, so as not to put any candidacy in difficulty, preferring to have a decision to postpone rather than an explanation, a contestation, or a criticism of one candidacy or another. Respect for individuals, respect for institutions, and concern to find the necessary compromise at the end of August. Time was therefore mainly devoted to what I have told you. The international situation, it was rather long, the intervention of Mr. JUNCKER, and the debate that his proposals could provoke.

QUESTION - Excuse me. You give us certain directions of decisions. Have you decided that the High Representative will be an Italian and that the President of the Council will be from an Eastern country?

THE PRESIDENT - No, no. If we had decided that, we would have decided since we have names that can easily be deduced based on these geographical origins, for Italy in particular and even for an Eastern country. There was no question of a geographical distribution.

QUESTION - Good evening Mr. President. You specified and you just specified that there has been no discussion on the people for the position of High Representative of the European Union. Can you still define a profile? What would be the required qualities? The Lithuanian President spoke of neutrality, experience. We can see that ultimately, Ms. Ashton’s experience has been relatively mixed. So what qualities do you expect from the person who will be chosen in a few weeks and what margin of maneuver will you leave them?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, France is not a candidate for this position. It never has been. France has a foreign policy that it conducts with the intention of being useful and that it conducts in coherence with the European line that the foreign ministers define together under the leadership of the High Representative, today Madame ASHTON. It is this same conception that will prevail. The High Representative does not have the vocation to embody foreign policy by himself or herself. It is a collective deliberation. She must be the spokesperson, sometimes the negotiator. Today, I speak in the feminine because the person who holds this position is Madame ASHTON, and it will necessarily be a woman in this responsibility given also what we must offer as an image of Europe. From there, there is the concern to be present in negotiations. For example, Madame ASHTON has just come out of several days of negotiations on Iran. As far as I am concerned, you know that the Italian candidacy has my support, but what I think is useful is that it is not simply about giving a national position.

It is about seeking a common position, and I have already indicated sufficiently what this High Representative could be. It is true, you are right, there are reservations, hesitations regarding the countries that have joined the European Union more recently or that are on the Eastern or Northern borders of Europe. But the person who holds this position is not a reflection of the foreign policy of their own country; they are the one who must carry a European policy. That is why I think that a number of reservations will be lifted.

QUESTION - Mr. President, indeed, does this not ultimately resemble a veto from the Eastern countries that did not want a pro-Russian personality, as they repeated during this Ukrainian crisis where we have the impression that the European Union is progressing into phase II, with phase II sanctions being added? Perhaps carried away by this somewhat slow logic, the Eastern countries wanted to express their dissatisfaction and impose a veto?

THE PRESIDENT - No, there was no veto. The proof is that the countries did not need to express themselves in the Council. I told you that the debate was particularly short because, in a way, it had been anticipated. What these countries want, and it is quite legitimate, is to have assurances that the composition of the European Commission will make room for them, particularly for the competencies that may be assigned to them.

That is why these countries wanted to be informed about the composition of the European Commission, but they are well aware that a compromise will have to be found. Is there a link with the level of sanctions that was pronounced this evening? No, because we are not at level III of sanctions. There have been decisions, I will not repeat them, concerning Russia where individuals are considered to have a particularly negative role in the process, hence this list which will be specified and expanded. And then, there is also the acceptance to lift the embargo on non-lethal weapons destined for Ukraine. Non-lethal means weapons that are not battlefield weapons, which are not intended to inflict human losses. I think this was the right level, and France wanted it to be at this level. That there be an elevation but that there not yet be a transition to level III.

QUESTION - Good evening, Mr. President. Just a follow-up question. You said the position of the High Representative should go to a socialist. Do the socialists still claim a second position for themselves, or have you realized today that it will be too difficult to push that through with Martin SCHULZ's presidency in Parliament?

THE PRESIDENT - The socialists have expressed themselves. They have met and considered that they have the vocation, given the distribution of positions, to claim or apply for both responsibilities. What was said in the Council is that this position was completely unassailable and, I would say, could not be negotiated for the position of High Representative, but that for the position of the Council, a personality was needed, who in my eyes, can come from the socialist and social-democratic ranks, but who must have the vocation to bring people together. Even if this is not the rule on this, it is rather the principle of unanimity that must prevail in the Council, which makes the task necessarily delicate. Therefore, we need a personality who can have this quality of being able to bring people together, to have a certain authority, a certain experience to do so. There are names that do not necessarily have the vocation to be known today because it may put them in difficulty in their functions, but there are names that can be proposed and that will be.

QUESTION - Jean-Claude JUNCKER wants to form his team before the end of July. When will France announce the candidate it proposes for a portfolio?

THE PRESIDENT - So, Jean-Claude JUNCKER must announce his decisions rather at the end of August, before the European Council scheduled for August 30. What countries must do, for those who have not yet presented their proposals, is to send to Jean-Claude JUNCKER, particularly France, the name of its future Commissioner and see with him, and I will personally take care of this, the competence that can be assigned to this Commissioner. That is what we will do. So there are two steps, one step until the end of July, it was the question of Mr. BEAUDONNET, I should announce the name, and then, have the exact distribution of competencies, which will clarify the decision of the European Council. At the same time, I wanted to clarify, we cannot put the European Commission, the President of the European Commission, under pressure by making its composition a variable adjustment of the decisions we would have made for the High Representative, or for the President of the European Council, or for the President of the Eurogroup. Moreover, on an anecdotal level, but I know that for many it is essential, it was Madame MERKEL's birthday and you heard the cheers. A jersey of the German team was given to her, signed not by all the players, I do not know if a comparison will need to be made, but by the participants of the European Council. There you go, Europe considered that it had won. Thank you!