Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a memorial event on the anniversary of the attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, on October 7, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

8 October 2024 · Memorial event on the anniversary of the attack on Israel of October 7, 2023 · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a Berlin memorial event on October 7, 2024, marking one year since the Hamas terror attack on Israel.
Main themes
Hamas attack anniversary, Jewish trauma and security, German responsibility and remembrance, hostage crisis, Israel-Gaza war, antisemitism, Holocaust memory, Hezbollah conflict, ceasefire advocacy, human dignity, displaced persons, solidarity with Israel
Duration
~15 min
51st percentile
Words
1,771
51st percentile
Sentences
104
65th percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
9.2
12th percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%46%
  • Geopolitical 34%33%
  • Ceremonial 16%15%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

104 sentences in 20 paragraphs

October 7 will forever belong to those days when we remember where and when we received the news of horror – the day when the dream of Israel, the dream of a safe homeland for all Jews worldwide, was so brutally shaken. "They robbed us of the place that should have been our safest. Those who survived are emotionally scarred. I believe some things will never heal." This is what Racheli Nachmias said, a young Israeli who attended the Supernova music festival in southern Israel a year ago. She survived the Hamas terror attack.

When I think back to October 7 a year ago, I remember: Only gradually did the news reach us, the names of attacked kibbutzim – Kfar Aza, Nir Oz, Be’eri – and other places of barbarity. Only gradually did the picture come together, the unimaginable cruelty with which people were brutally murdered – indiscriminately: men, women, children. How even the dead bodies were desecrated. Women and girls were raped. People of all ages were abducted, in the hands of terrorists. The survivors were left with uncertainty and fear about whether their loved ones were still alive, what might be done to them in captivity. In the end, almost 1,200 people were brutally killed, 250 taken hostage.

Never since the Holocaust have so many Jews been murdered in a single day. Today, exactly one year later, we come together to commemorate the victims of the Hamas attack. We mourn with those who have lost their loved ones. We suffer with those who are still anxious about their relatives. We stand by their side.

When I remember October 7, I am today as horrified and incredulous as I was back then. And I remember the conversation with President Herzog on the same day. We have known each other for more than 20 years. I have never seen my friend and colleague so shaken. I also remember well how we visited the attacked region in southern Israel shortly after the Hamas attack, including the site of a terrible massacre: the kibbutz Be’eri. The bloodstained walls in the houses will never leave my mind – even less so the despair and the fear of death that kibbutzniks told me about, the despair and the fear of death as the terrorists were already murdering in the neighboring house and then approached their own front door, the hiding place, the safe room in the house. That very place became a death trap for many.

For a year now, the hostages have been in the hands of Hamas. Among them are Germans. Germany is doing everything in its power to secure the release of all hostages. And we support the American president's plan for that and for a ceasefire in Gaza. I say very clearly: The release of the hostages must remain the highest priority. They must finally come home!

Returning home must also be possible for those who were displaced shortly after October 7 by the daily rocket fire from Hezbollah. Tens of thousands have found refuge somewhere in Israel, fleeing from deadly threats. They have not been able to see their homes for a year because the attacks from Hezbollah make life, even survival, there impossible – attacks that Israel must defend itself against!

This October 7 was a turning point, a deep trauma for Jews not only in Israel but around the world. Israel was their safe haven. They knew, they felt: No matter what happens, we can always go to Israel. And now? Nele Pollatschek has put this uncertainty into words: "We are still sitting on packed suitcases," she writes, "but for the first time we do not know where the journey will go."

I must honestly tell you: As the German Federal President, I could not have imagined that Jews would say this, almost 80 years after the end of World War II, after the crime against humanity of the Holocaust. It pains me deeply!

We come together today to mourn, here in the Memorial Church. This church is a memorial. It reminds us of our German responsibility, of where German racial hatred and unleashed nationalism have led, what suffering and destruction we Germans have brought over Europe in the last century. The more than 60 million dead of World War II and the crime against humanity of the Holocaust obligate us to this day.

Never again means: Never again allowing inhuman racial hatred, anti-Semitism, and extreme nationalism to spread in Germany. This responsibility also includes standing by Israel when the homeland of Jews is attacked and the security and existence of Israel are threatened. And: Never again means advocating for human rights and the dignity of every single person. This is the triple obligation. It is deeply inscribed in the self-understanding of our country. It is part of the foundation of our democracy.

Nevertheless, we feel that in the war in the Middle East, these principles that guide us encounter a painful, also contradictory reality – the longer the war lasts, the more it expands, the more victims it claims, the more so. This war has already claimed too many lives, brought too much suffering – for Israelis and for Palestinians and now also for the people in Lebanon. The people in Gaza have also been experiencing immeasurable suffering for a year, every single day. So many have lost their lives in this war, so many must flee, again and again. Diseases are spreading. And people are starving, especially the children.

The questions are becoming louder, more urgent, and so is the public debate – less about whether Israel has a right to self-defense, but about where the limits of every right to self-defense lie.

For us Germans, this painful, contradictory reality cannot mean that we free ourselves from the triple obligation of "Never again." When principles and reality clash, it is a mandate that reality must become different, a better one – a reality in which Israelis and Palestinians can live peacefully alongside and with each other. This will not succeed solely with military means. It requires a political perspective for the region. And we will contribute to that and must contribute to that.

I wish for an end to the dying in the Middle East, yes, but I want to advocate that in a desperate situation in the region, we do not rely solely on simple, oversimplified advice. The dead in Gaza, the hunger, the destruction would not have occurred without the attack and the massacres of October 7 last year. That Israel would defend itself against a fundamental threat to its security was not only known to Hamas; it was the cynical calculation of the terrorists to draw Israel into a war in Gaza – a war in which civilians have been used as shields for military positions and tens of thousands of innocents have lost their lives.

Yes, I wish for an end to the dying in the Middle East, but I warn us Germans against a careless condemnation of Israel. The German-Israeli historian Dan Diner – one who has been advocating for reconciliation between Israelis and Palestinians for decades – recently pointed out once again the special situation of Israel, that fate has treated Germans and Israelis differently after 1945. "The latter live in constant existential uncertainty, while the former can be certain of their existence – the existence of their state and their people. Such certainty of existence is not granted to Israeli Jews." I do not understand this as a defense of Israel against all criticism. I do not understand this as a plea against efforts to end the war. I understand it rather as a warning against European arrogance towards a country that – unlike us – lives in a neighborhood where the annihilation of the state of Israel is not a phrase but determines politics.

In these days, our gaze is not only directed at the war region. We are also looking at our own country. Since October 7, we have also been experiencing in German schools and universities, in cultural institutions, on the streets, and in the media how this war in the Middle East threatens to tear us apart. Grief, anger, powerlessness, fear for relatives and friends on both sides – such feelings also drive many people in our country. I understand the pain of many. But as agitated as we may be, we must not lose our compass. In the midst of all the division, we must not accept what is unacceptable: When apartments of Jews are marked and defaced; when incendiary devices are thrown at synagogues; when Jewish students are threatened at their universities; when demonstrations call for a Middle East without Israel – then that is anti-Semitism, then that is hatred of Jews. We must and will never tolerate that!

Since October 7, Jews also live in our country in a state of emergency – in a permanent feeling of threat, as stated in the situation report published today by the Central Council of Jews in Germany. Here we are all called upon: police and security authorities, the judiciary, but also society as a whole. We must do everything to protect Jewish life! This is our everlasting responsibility. This is the responsibility that remains! Only when Jews in Germany can live safely and freely, only then is this country truly at peace with itself.

Freedom and security for the people – that must also be the path in the Middle East. That must be the perspective – a perspective for which we work and hope. "When we stop hoping, what we fear will surely come," said Ernst Bloch. I have a hope: the hope for Israel's future. Am Israel Chai! I hope that Israel will one day leave behind the trauma of October 7. I hope that Israel will be strong and resilient so that something like October 7 can never happen again. I hope that Israel will find itself again internally and that people will come together again. And I hope that Israel can and will live in peace with its neighbors.

We will never forget what happened on October 7. We will not forget the people who lost their lives that day. We think of those who have suffered and continue to suffer. We owe it to them not to give up hope – just as they themselves do not give up hope.

"The fear runs so deep," says Michal Ohana, who also survived the Supernova festival. "It is such a deep, such an essential fear. I believe it will take time. But someday I will find my way back to myself."