Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a memorial service for the victims of the attack on October 9, 2019, in Halle on October 9, 2024, in Halle:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

13 October 2024 · Memorial service for the victims of the attack on October 9, 2019 · Halle, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a memorial service in Halle on the fifth anniversary of the October 9, 2019 antisemitic terrorist attack, honoring victims and survivors.
Main themes
Antisemitism and racist terrorism, collective remembrance and mourning, victims and survivors of the Halle attack, trauma and its lasting effects, Jewish community safety in Germany, 'Never again' responsibility, state failure to prevent attack, radicalization and extremism, solidarity with minorities, memory as societal obligation
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,695
49th percentile
Sentences
114
69th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
8.5
7th percentile
Syntax
2.71
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
55th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 74%73%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

114 sentences in 19 paragraphs

No one among you – no one among all of us who are here – began today with a light heart. And many of you, dear relatives, dear survivors, dear emergency responders, dear people of Halle, have been carrying a burdensome weight for days. Those among you who have lost loved ones may feel the grief even more acutely today than usual. And those who survived and witnessed the terrible terrorist attack in Halle and Wiedersdorf five years ago may once again feel the long breath of that fear from back then and the pain that has been inscribed in their personal memory since October 9, 2019.

And that is why it is good that we come together today. I am grateful to all of you for making the journey. Even those survivors and relatives who could not be here today are with us in spirit. We are gathered here today on their behalf as well. Because this memorial service is the place and the moment for a collective remembrance. Both remembering and coming together on this day are so necessary.

October 9, 2019, changed your lives forever. Two people did not survive this heinous crime. Jana Lange was shot and had to die simply because she was walking down the street at that moment. And Kevin Schwarze was murdered and had to die simply because he was having his lunch at Kiez-Döner. We remember both of them today with sorrow. They are missed by their loved ones, and they are missed in our midst.

Those who survived the terror in Halle carry the heavy burden of that terrible day. For all of you, there is irrevocably a before and an after. The before ended at 12:01 PM when the first explosive device was detonated in front of the synagogue. Fifty-two people survived on the first floor of the synagogue. They experienced that an attacker wanted to kill them, wanted to murder them, simply because they were Jews. They experienced this in the heart of Germany, which should be grateful every day after National Socialism that Jewish communities can once again celebrate their holidays here.

The people in the synagogue endured for hours, in the greatest fear of death. They pushed furniture against the doors, stared at the surveillance monitor, and prayed. At Kiez-Döner, which the perpetrator subsequently targeted out of hatred for Muslims and immigrants, people survived because they hid. They crouched behind shelves and refrigerators, behind a bathroom door. They lay between cars after jumping out of a window. They wrote a farewell message in the family chat. For a long time, they too did not know if they would all have to die. In Wiedersdorf, people with serious gunshot wounds survived only because the perpetrator's weapons malfunctioned when he aimed directly at their faces.

Surviving that day, that October 9, means having to remember again and again. One's own memory is something that cannot simply be turned off, something one cannot evade. We say so easily today that someone is traumatized. Yet no one else can fathom what the emotional wound feels like, how it affects one, how it accompanies one and also strikes again and again. For many, survival means leading a different, heavier, and in certain ways, more uncertain life.

I am very grateful to all of you who have spoken and continue to speak about yourselves and your experiences. Some of you have already done this in your closing statements during the trial and found very clear words – words that have touched me, words that must touch every person who has heard them. Others have raised their voices in a documentary on the occasion of the fifth anniversary. This is valuable for two reasons. On the one hand, silence about what has been suffered would only preserve the suffering of the individual, as the memory researcher Aleida Assmann once said. On the other hand, remembering is a task that we as a society share together. This is crucial.

We remember because we stand by the side of the victims. And we remember because we as a society connect a task, a responsibility, with this memory that reaches into the future: It is the responsibility that what has happened does not happen again. This self-commitment of "Never again!" is the foundation of the Federal Republic.

In the closing statements of the Halle trial, a survivor said that the idea of "Never again!" includes that no Jews and other minorities in our country should ever have to fear for their lives again. For this survivor, the act irrevocably shattered the idea of "Never again!"

The state was unable to prevent the attack on Jews in their house of worship. It could not prevent that, in the heart of Germany, descendants of victims and survivors of the Holocaust were put in mortal fear for hours because a German anti-Semite and racist attempted mass murder. The perpetrator's hatred targeted Jews, Muslims, women, the defenseless – all those he wanted to erase according to his crude ideology. No one apparently had this perpetrator on their radar. Today we know that his plan had a backstory of radicalization. And the question remains why we did not see this backstory.

I know how painful this question is. And I find it extremely disturbing myself. Even after five years, I still remember my visit to Halle the day after and the voice of a young man who was practically shouting in front of the synagogue: "You cannot protect us." We must understand his anger, his despair as a lasting reminder and take it very seriously.

Our security authorities are doing this. They face the daily task of combating and preventing anti-Semitic and extremist terror. They do this with a lot of personnel and modern tools. I am glad that we, as a state, have responded to the threat of violence with more protection. The truth is, however, that it is becoming increasingly difficult to fight against terror almost daily. Because the threshold for hatred and violence is lowering. And the networks of hatred are becoming harder to track down. And the trail of violence does not end. It stretches from Kassel to Halle to Hanau, from Mannheim to Solingen.

The concrete danger reaches deep into the everyday lives of so many people. It is a bitter reality that synagogues, Jewish kindergartens, and schools in Germany must be protected from attacks – still and especially more so, 80 years after the end of the Holocaust. It is unfortunately a bitter reality that Jews must fear every single day of being attacked, insulted, or spat upon. And since the terrorist attack by Hamas on Israel, which has just been commemorated, it seems that a valve for unrestrained hatred of Jews has opened here and in many other countries.

Anti-Semitism and racism do not just exist. Ideologies are thought up and spread by people. Conspiracy myths are invented and fueled by people. And both serve as motives for perpetrators. The murderers of Kassel, Halle, and Hanau may have committed their murders alone on the day of the act. But they did not think alone.

Too often, the internet is becoming a fueling station for hate, where people – most often young men – recharge. Here, everything is available around the clock: extremism, fundamentalism, conspiracy narratives, hatred of humanity. The dosage occasionally varies. And it is not the case that these fueling stations of hate are far removed from our lives. In fact, almost every one of us passes one by at some point when we – and who does not? – are active on social networks. And through TikTok, X, Telegram – and whatever they are all called – it is increasingly possible to influence the social climate, to poison the space in which we conduct political debates, and to saturate it with hate.

However, one thing is also clear: We are not powerless. We can confront the danger of radicalization together. It is time to speak out where someone is acting against minorities. It is time for reason where someone is inciting anger and hatred. It is time for solidarity where someone is being attacked. At this point, we must never allow ourselves to be divided: When another ignores or tramples on human dignity, then it is time to stand together. That is the lesson from Halle: The risk of becoming a victim of inhuman violence is not evenly distributed across all in society. But precisely from this arises our shared responsibility. Each of these inhuman attacks targets the very heart of our open society. Each of these attacks concerns every one of us. We must confront these attacks together. This is the mandate from the promise of "Never again!" And this is the foundation of our democracy's self-understanding.

We do not have the option to undo what has happened. The terrorist attack in Halle was a terrible act. We mourn those who were murdered. We feel for the relatives and those injured in body and soul. But the fact that we are here together today is an important message: The perpetrator of Halle wanted to divide us as a society. And foremost, he wanted to erase Jewish life. He did not succeed in either. He did not achieve his goal. Just now, I had the opportunity to participate in the synagogue in the handing over of a Torah scroll. It touched me deeply. Jewish life in Halle and elsewhere in Germany is growing and thriving.

I would like to conclude with some words from Rabbi Jeremy Borovitz, who survived in the synagogue on October 9 with his wife and friends. I want to quote these words also because they address all of us. They come from the closing statement of the trial: "Whenever we see something, whenever we hear something, we must speak out, we must act. We can only prevent another Halle […] if the good and decent people of German society do not allow something like this to happen again."

That is the lesson from Halle: Each one of us matters. Let us not remain silent. Never again. Let us counter hatred with our decency!