Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the 19th Karlsruhe Constitutional Dialogue "70 Years of the Basic Law – Is Germany in Good Shape?" on May 22, 2019, in Karlsruhe:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

24 May 2019 · 19th Karlsruhe Constitutional Dialogue · Karlsruhe, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at the 19th Karlsruhe Constitutional Dialogue on May 22, 2019, marking the 70th anniversary of Germany's Basic Law.
Main themes
70th anniversary of the Basic Law, liberal democracy under pressure, constitutional values and fundamental rights, German constitutional history, Parliamentary Council and Basic Law origins, Federal Constitutional Court, Weimar Constitution centenary, democratic institutions, rule of law, reunification and democratic awakening, civic pride in constitution, threats to democracy in Europe
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,766
72nd percentile
Sentences
98
62nd percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
15.1
76th percentile
Syntax
3.37
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
36th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 72%71%
  • Ceremonial 19%18%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

98 sentences in 44 paragraphs

"The favorite book of the Germans," a weekly newspaper titled at the beginning of May on the occasion of the 70th birthday of the Basic Law – and showed the simple white paperback edition from the Federal Agency for Civic Education, with a gray federal eagle and a black-red-gold stripe, which has found a home in many bookshelves and desk drawers across the country, sometimes more worn and sometimes less so.

The favorite book of the Germans – this is not only a good headline, but also something like the underlying tone of this anniversary. The Basic Law, it seems, exists only in superlatives these weeks. And it is hardly possible to escape it; it confronts you almost everywhere – at the newsstand and in the bookstore, on the internet and social media, in the morning on the radio and in the evening on television.

Here in Karlsruhe, something is also happening these days – here in this city, whose name has long since become synonymous with the Federal Constitutional Court, or, if I may say so: with the "favorite guardian of the constitution of the Germans."

The Basic Law brings citizens into conversation, but also the constitutional bodies, and not only when it has a birthday. And that is why I am pleased to be here today as Federal President at this court – dear Mr. Voßkuhle, thank you very much for the invitation!

The approval of the Germans for their constitution has been high for many years. Even on the 50th and 60th birthdays, the Basic Law was already celebrated as a "stroke of luck." But I have the impression that what we are experiencing these weeks has a different quality. The interest has not been as broad in recent years, and the fundamental rights have rarely been cited so often, and the tone may not have been as combative in the past as I experience it today.

I believe that the new attention to the Basic Law – but also to the Weimar Constitution, whose 100th birthday we are also celebrating this year – this attention is also related to the new concern about the state of liberal democracy.

In a time when democratic institutions are being called into question again in Europe, when elected governments restrict freedom of opinion and judicial independence, in such a time, many people in our country feel the need to stand up for the Basic Law and to fight for our constitutional order again.

The challenges to liberal democracy also fill me with concern, but this concern should not overshadow the significance of our constitution. On the contrary! Precisely because democracy is coming under pressure again, precisely because institutions in other countries are under stress, we should celebrate the Basic Law confidently today.

May 23, our Constitution Day, which we will celebrate tomorrow, here in Karlsruhe, in Berlin, and in many places in our country, this day is first and foremost a reason for joy. We can rejoice in a country "in good condition," and we can rejoice in citizens who stand up and raise their voices for freedom, the rule of law, and democracy. My heartfelt thanks go to all those who live our Basic Law today!

Seventy years ago, when Konrad Adenauer proclaimed the Basic Law in the gymnasium of the Pedagogical Academy in Bonn, there was not much to suggest that it would become a success story.

In occupied and divided Germany, the constitutional work created by the Parliamentary Council under the supervision of the Allies after months of work did not elicit jubilation; hardly anyone was interested in its promises. In the rubble of the post-war period, people had other concerns, and after the catastrophe of National Socialism, most wanted to know nothing more about politics.

The Basic Law did not come into the world in 1949 as a proud bearer of hope for democracy, but rather as an inconspicuous emergency birth, of which hardly anyone would have predicted a long life.

That it could lay the groundwork for an astonishing democratic awakening in West Germany; that it had the strength to become the constitution of all Germans after the Peaceful Revolution and reunification; that it is still appreciated and referenced worldwide today – all of this, I believe, our Basic Law owes to the special spirit that its fathers and mothers imparted to it.

The members of the Parliamentary Council – their great majority, at least – were marked by the years of National Socialist tyranny; many of them had been persecuted themselves, had lost their jobs or freedom, or survived in exile, some were engaged in the resistance. But they were also already aware of the developments in the Soviet occupation zone at that time, and the Berlin Blockade overshadowed and influenced their deliberations.

The new state for which they wrote the Basic Law was meant to be something like the antithesis to totalitarian dictatorship, its justification based on a supreme commandment: Never again should it be possible in Germany to humiliate, torture, or murder people in the name of the state. The Parliamentary Council condensed this into the beautiful sentence: "Human dignity is inviolable." And it placed the fundamental and freedom rights at the beginning of the constitution, as binding and enforceable rights for individuals.

That was undoubtedly a Copernican turn after the plunge into barbarism. The Parliamentary Council reintegrated West Germany into the liberal constitutional tradition of the Enlightenment. And it could, we are far too rarely aware of this today, also connect to German traditions, to the constitution of the Frankfurt Paulskirche and the Weimar Constitution.

I believe that the spirit of freedom that the Basic Law breathes is particularly inspiring and invigorating today, especially in a time when liberal democracy is once again being challenged. In 1949, after liberation from National Socialism, the Parliamentary Council gave West Germans a constitution of freedom; in 1989, East Germans fought for their freedom in the Peaceful Revolution – and together we should defend this treasure more strongly today!

We know that the framework, the body that the Parliamentary Council gave to the new democracy, was meant to be primarily stable and defensible. The representatives, shaped by the failure of the Weimar Republic, created a representative parliamentary democracy, and they anchored instruments, mechanisms like the constructive vote of no confidence, to make the dissolution of parliament more difficult and to ensure the functionality of governments.

Especially today, as we experience an increase in the number of parties in parliament at the federal and state levels and the formation of governments becomes more difficult, these mechanisms remind us of the responsibility of democratic parties to be willing to cooperate and to form stable majorities. The Basic Law cannot – and does not want to – take on this task for the parties; indeed, it obliges them to this task!

In light of the developments we are witnessing in Europe, in Poland and Hungary, for example, there is also discussion in constitutional law about how possible cracks in the "armor of the Basic Law" could be closed. The metaphor of "armor" here is not entirely coincidental. I believe that the resilience of democracy is an important debate, but I also want to take this opportunity to say that a constitution cannot armor itself against society, that in the fight for our democracy we must not only rely on paragraphs and articles.

Because in the end, it comes down to us, to the citizens. We must succeed in convincing as many of those who have turned away as possible to return to our constitutional order!

That is also why I have invited people from all parts of our country to a birthday coffee table at Schloss Bellevue tomorrow. With a large debate, we want to honor the Basic Law there, but above all, we want to have an open, hopefully multi-voiced conversation about the state of democracy in our country.

That our constitution could become a success story was of course also due to the favorable circumstances in the young Federal Republic, to the economic miracle, the Western alignment, the success in preventing the Cold War from becoming a hot war again. Bonn was not Weimar; this applied not only to the constitution but also to the reality that the constitution encountered.

The Basic Law benefited from the circumstances, but it also shaped them. The democratic institutions it designed functioned quite smoothly from the beginning, and the fundamental rights gradually contributed to social change. Or rather: It was primarily the Federal Constitutional Court here in Karlsruhe that gave voice to the spirit of freedom, expanded the scope of fundamental rights, and helped citizens enforce them, sometimes even against a reluctant policy.

The decisions of the Federal Constitutional Court read like a history of liberal awakening in the Federal Republic. They helped dismantle authoritarian structures, as they were still reflected in marriage and family law for many years. And they helped fundamental rights break through in our society, where rulings like "Lüth," "Spiegel," or "Brokdorf" are still well-known symbols for freedom of opinion, press, and assembly in Germany.

A constitution is meant to be something like a stabilizing force in society, but it must not become rigid. It must remain open to social and political change. The Federal Constitutional Court has repeatedly responded to new developments that the Parliamentary Council could not have foreseen, to the needs of modern data protection as well as to a changed European and international order.

Some rulings were hotly contested, some even within the chambers of the Federal Constitutional Court itself. But the mere fact that thousands of citizens in our country turn to the Federal Constitutional Court every year with constitutional complaints is a very strong indication that this court enjoys the highest esteem and much trust.

We know that not only citizens but also parliament and government turn to the Federal Constitutional Court. The journey to Karlsruhe is also a means of politics, and I believe that politics should use this means responsibly – meaning: with restraint in its own interest. When in public discourse, in weighing arguments, contentious questions are quickly narrowed down to the aspect of constitutionality, then, I fear, in the eyes of citizens, this is not necessarily a sign of strength of democracy!

The Basic Law has been amended more often than other constitutions. Some amendments are still controversial today, and there is ongoing discussion about whether it makes sense to enshrine certain state goals. However one may stand on this in detail: The Basic Law, the constitution of our democracy, does not want to be a substitute for politics. It sets the rules for the political process, it wants to keep this process open and therefore does not want to preempt its results.

How great the integrative power of this open constitution is became particularly evident, perhaps even unexpectedly, after reunification. We know that the majority saw no need in 1990 to replace or completely redesign the work of the Parliamentary Council. Whether it would have been better to do so remains a hypothetical question. Today, with the distance of almost three decades, we can certainly state: The Basic Law has long since become the constitution of all Germans – and that is exactly how people in both West and East Germany apparently feel, as recent surveys have just shown again.

In this year, in which we celebrate the 30th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall, I would like to add one more thing that is not in the constitution: The many women and men who fought for freedom in the GDR at that time brought this experience into our shared democracy. I believe that we should remember not only Herrenchiemsee and Bonn but also places of democracy like Leipzig, Plauen, or Prenzlauer Berg, the Monday demonstrations, round tables, and first free elections more often – and not just in the east of the republic!

Approval of the Basic Law is high, but we are also observing today how discontent with practical politics is growing in parts of our society. One in three is dissatisfied with the way democracy functions in our country, and many look anxiously to the future.

Now, it need not be a contradiction if approval of the constitution is higher than that of practical politics. A constitution is a promise, a norm against which reality can be measured. If reality falls short of the promise, democrats should feel encouraged to take responsibility and help to turn things around for the better, within the framework and in the paths that the Basic Law provides. Discontent with what is always also means: It should get better!

The problem today, however, is that many citizens have less trust in democratic institutions, that they no longer readily believe that parties and parliaments can tackle the great challenges of our time.

If today not even half of the people in our country believe that the pressing problems can be solved by the established political parties; if these parties are increasingly struggling to find candidates for local elections in some regions; if a large majority of the young generation even believes that new political movements and entirely different channels are needed, then this is not just a problem for individual parties. Rather, the political order, as our constitution itself has provided for it, is increasingly called into question, or I should say: thrown out of balance.

The Basic Law explicitly mentions political parties and does so in a very prominent place. The Parliamentary Council wanted to send a clear signal against the tradition of party disdain that characterized the Empire and the Weimar Republic, and it recognized the role of parties in political will formation.

I believe that the central insight of the fathers and mothers of the Basic Law has lost none of its significance or validity to this day: parties are not the sole actors in political will formation, but they are indispensable in our federal representative democracy.

That is why I wish that the democratic parties would once again engage in conversation with those who have turned away and are missing from parliamentary democracy – but also with those who are politically interested or engaged in new and different ways. This will only succeed if some prejudices, on both sides, are cast aside.

In any case, I hope that the parties will open their doors and windows even wider, that they will not perceive every unusual idea as an attack, and that they will pave new ways into politics for young people. And conversely: I want to encourage the many committed citizens who are currently working outside of parties for a better country and a better world, who are informed, critical, and curious, to dare to step into the workshops of democracy, which parties still are, and at least to check whether every prejudice is justified.

Our constitution remains alive only if more people in Germany rediscover not only the spirit of freedom of the Basic Law but also its framework, its democratic institutions for themselves.

This Basic Law has brought us remarkably far – its spirit and its institutions. When we remember today where we Germans came from 70 years ago and what we have made of ourselves, step by step, then that is certainly cause for joy – and even more, I believe, a source of confidence and a source of democratic patriotism.

This democratic patriotism cannot be prescribed, but unlike in the first German democracy, it is, at least today, anchored in larger parts of society. And it is rooted in the norms that the Basic Law placed at its beginning: in human dignity, freedom, and democracy. The "Never again," which united the fathers and mothers of our constitution, the memory of the abysses of our history, all of this is deeply inscribed in this Basic Law.

And not in spite of this, but precisely because of it, we can be glad about this Basic Law today! Not in spite of this, but because of it, we can be proud of the brave women and men who, at very different times in our country, fought for freedom and democracy – and of all those who give life to this constitution today.

"The favorite book of the Germans," this book is more than a text that lies dormant somewhere in shelves and drawers, more than a norm that is interpreted here in Karlsruhe. This favorite book of the Germans is a promise of a good future that no one can fulfill but ourselves. Thank you very much.