Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the celebration "100 Years of Rudolf Augstein" on November 3, 2023, in Hamburg:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

7 November 2023 · Celebration "100 Years of Rudolf Augstein" · Hamburg, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a celebration in Hamburg marking the 100th birthday of Der Spiegel founder Rudolf Augstein on November 3, 2023.
Main themes
Rudolf Augstein centenary, press freedom and democracy, Der Spiegel founding, role of media in democracy, Weimar Republic and hyperinflation, Nazi propaganda and press synchronization, postwar German reconstruction, journalism and the fourth estate, disinformation and scandalization, freedom of opinion
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,711
71st percentile
Sentences
141
78th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%27%
  • Social 28%20%
  • Ceremonial 12%9%
  • Technological 10%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%4%
  • Economic 5%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 29%

141 sentences in 31 paragraphs

"The bread should cost at most 50 billion," wrote the Vossische Zeitung on November 5, 100 years ago. On the day Rudolf Augstein was born, hyperinflation in Germany reached record levels. Daily, newspapers reported on preparations for an attempted coup. Antidemocratic efforts with political promises of salvation of all kinds were in vogue. The times were heated, and the newspapers were quick and sharp: Already in the evening editions, one could read whom the Reich President had met at noon.

In Hanover, Augstein's birthplace, the local "Kurier" criticized on the same day that some papers "are known to serve only the purpose of street sales and therefore seek to achieve their effect through as thick and sensational headlines as possible." It could be clearly seen, it continued, that some reports were "very much exaggerated."

So we see, even back then, in the first German democracy, scandalization, disinformation, and destabilization were topics. Freedom of opinion and the press was also considered a high good, enshrined in the Weimar Constitution. The press landscape was indeed strongly shaped by party politics, but there was still a common understanding that the media play a central role in democracy. That they are to be the suppliers of information that enable citizens to have political orientation. And that politics and media exist in a tension field of criticism and control, which may be uncomfortable, but in this form of government – in democracy – is not only desirable but necessary, indeed indispensable.

When Rudolf Augstein first showed interest in journalism nearly 17 years after these headlines, the world had changed. Nazi Germany had declared war on this world. The forces that had already attacked democracy in Augstein's birth year had won. The press was synchronized, and mass media had become a propaganda instrument. The truth could not be learned from the newspapers. It had become life-threatening. The language of the newspapers dripped with pathos, aggression, and ethnic madness.

Augstein, a student interested in culture and politics, a boy who grew up in National Socialism and was very much a child of his time, took pleasure in writing. He wrote letters to the editor and theater reviews and began an internship at a newspaper. What has been preserved from his time as a soldier in terms of thoughts and texts has been thoroughly researched and published by all of you in recent years, and it shows Rudolf Augstein as a young man with a initially quite ambivalent attitude towards the dictatorship – as was often the case in post-war Germany.

He returned to a country that lay in ruins and had no media landscape left. For the Allies – they were the ones who liberated us – the press and broadcasting were the most important means for a new beginning, for the "reeducation" of the Germans. They began granting licenses for media as early as the fall of 1945.

A little over a year later, "Der Spiegel" was born. That sounds so self-evident. As if it were completely clear that news magazines belong to a liberal democracy. One would like to imagine how, back then, shortly after the end of World War II, a group of young journalists sat together and dared to embark on a new beginning. How they passionately debated a completely new journalism after the dark years of the Nazi dictatorship. About enlightenment and processing, about press freedom and the fourth estate, about hard-hitting research and crystal-clear commentaries.

But you all know: It was different. There were no such gatherings, as we imagine them today, back then. Der Spiegel was, as Klaus Harpprecht once described it, the child of the good mood of a British press officer. It was he who developed a news magazine in the newly founded state of Lower Saxony, modeled after the Anglo-Saxon example. And for that, he sought allies. And he knew the young war returnee Augstein, who in those weeks was directing his journalistic gaze at Nazi Germany by writing about the war crimes trial concerning the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp.

In November 1946, the first issue of "Woche" was published. Six weeks and some complications later, it became "Der Spiegel." Publisher: Rudolf Augstein. He himself once described this turbulent time with the wonderfully laconic sentence: "Thus we were started." In those days, Rudolf Augstein began to provide his answer to the question of how the fourth estate defines itself in the young Federal Republic.

This republic lay, so to speak, at that time like a blank sheet of paper – Bonn was small, the wires were short, the competition manageable, privacy was privacy. The Basic Law guaranteed freedom of the press, but what power the media would have was still up for negotiation. The one who poked against the thorn, who not only measured the power relations but changed them, was Rudolf Augstein. He never indulged in the luxury of not having an opinion.

In doing so, he not only became a midwife for a free press but also an actor in the power structure of the republic. The Spiegel affair revealed what he understood by the fourth estate. To this day, many, including the well-known Peter Merseburger, see in it Augstein's decisive political achievement: that press freedom triumphed and Franz-Josef Strauß had to resign as Minister of Defense, which permanently changed the Federal Republic. "Without Augstein and Der Spiegel, democracy in Germany after the war would have had a harder time," said former Zeit editor Michael Naumann upon the death of the Spiegel publisher 21 years ago.

I think Rudolf Augstein, with his particular sense of irony, would have also appreciated the reversal of this sentence: With him and his news magazine, democracy also did not always have it easy. But that was a good thing.

I would like to draw attention to an achievement of your publisher, which cannot be valued highly enough if one takes democracy seriously. Augstein always ensured that you, the journalists, the documentarians had the best possible conditions for your work. Because he understood one thing very, very well: For any medium that wants to be permanently successful, credibility is the life insurance. Only those who are credible are also relevant, their voice is heard and taken seriously. Only those who are relevant can work successfully in investigative journalism, they have the security and the means to confront the powerful.

And for that, good journalists are needed, who do their work every day. It is not AI and no algorithm – it is journalists who research, write, broadcast, and prepare day and night. They are the ones who often wade through complicated issues with little glamour and search for the flaws in the system. They are the ones who trace and analyze political debates and explain connections. They are the ones who are now sitting in Zaporizhzhia and Sderot.

What Rudolf Augstein did and what you also do is more than a profession – journalism is also a democratic task. This democratic task consists of gathering, verifying, weighing, contextualizing, and evaluating information, facts, events, and statements – and doing so as accurately as possible in this order.

You all face enormous challenges today and are under tremendous pressure, I am very aware of that. Electronic media and especially social networks have not only led to an acceleration of the news business that Rudolf Augstein and his generation of journalists would have likely placed in the realm of science fiction. They have also changed the foundations, the business model of journalism. Today, technology allows for any amount of news to be disseminated easily and in real-time. We are almost live when natural disasters occur in distant parts of the world or when terrorists commit brutal attacks. But the technological change goes much further. Today, everyone is able to receive news – and to become a sender themselves.

Which news is disseminated today is often not a question of content, but is determined by the reach of the sender and, not least, by algorithms. On the one hand, the internet opens up more and more possibilities for us to utilize the enormous potential in the democratization of knowledge. On the other hand, the level of attention for an event today is more than ever directly dependent on the monetization of a news item. To put it bluntly: It is no longer the question of what significance a news item has for the world that is decisive for its dissemination, but whether the world clicks on it.

And with that, the orientation function of media in democracy is also increasingly called into question. The technological change has far-reaching – and in my opinion still underestimated – consequences for our democracies. We are experiencing nothing less than a new structural change in the public sphere, as Jürgen Habermas has noted in resuming his earlier diagnosis.

The consequences of this structural change are as great as Habermas' disillusionment. For this change does not lead to the realization of the dream of a deliberative democracy, as was hoped at the beginning of the internet age. Traditional media are increasingly under pressure because their business foundation is shaking; because the boundary between journalistic and so-called social media is increasingly blurring; because the line between facts and assumptions is also fading; because at the same time our public sphere is fracturing into more and more sub-publics; because even within the sub-publics, volume increasingly decides over reach; because the boundary of what can be said is gradually shifting towards the unspeakable.

Moreover, we live in times when events are accelerating and crises are following one another ever more rapidly. The pandemic, the war in Ukraine, and now the one in the Middle East – many viewers, readers, and listeners find it increasingly difficult to keep track and, even more so, to keep their nerves. The processing capacity of people for "bad news" seems to have reached its limit for many. There is something like "news fatigue." In a kind of self-protection, some then decide to completely switch off, preferring not to take any news into account at all. I meet many of those. Others retreat into a parallel world where madness, conspiracy, and invented truth reign.

But precisely because this is the case, we need journalists who are committed to the ethics of the profession, as shaped by the Enlightenment. Those who are passionate about staying on the trail of truth, who are not willing to bend it for a spectacular headline, who inform the general public about what is and what is relevant. Only in this way can democracy remain possible: If you, the media, create public spaces in which a society can understand itself; if you provide the information and explain the connections so that citizens can orient themselves, form a judgment, engage in informed debates, and, very importantly, make reasoned democratic decisions. Journalism – good, serious, thorough journalism is and remains indispensable for democracy!

How much journalism has fallen into disrepute in recent years, what distrust, indeed what hostility, even to the point of physical attacks you are often exposed to today, I see with the greatest concern. And I am also concerned that it is becoming more dangerous for many of you to report – I think of the protests and demonstrations during the Corona period; that the number of attacks on journalists has also risen sharply in our country.

I want to be very clear: Attacks on journalists, on camera operators and photographers are not expressions of opinion, but criminal acts. They are directed against people, but they are also directed against liberal democracy. It is the task of our rule of law to protect media professionals and ensure that they can carry out their work unhindered. Attacks on journalists endanger press freedom in our country. Even more: They undermine our democracy. We must not allow that!

For good reason, our Basic Law guarantees freedom of the press and freedom of opinion. For good reason, our legal system protects journalists in particular. Rudolf Augstein experienced as a young person the devastating consequences of publishers serving a brutal dictatorship. Yes, freedom of the press and freedom of opinion are high goods, and they must be protected and, if necessary, defended – that is also a responsibility of politics.

But in a time when our liberal democracies are under greater challenge; when forces are also gaining strength in our country that question or even despise the fundamental rules of democracy, in such a time, the media also has a particularly important role – I mean: responsibility. This may seem self-evident to many here – but I believe there is reason to remind ourselves of it.

This responsibility also applies, and especially so, in reporting on war conflicts. Yes, none of us can prevent others, one-sided sources, from publishing false news on social networks and thereby actively engaging in disinformation. But it is therefore all the more a central responsibility of journalists – and also of politicians – not to spread any news as long as the sources are not absolutely clear, and the truth content is not absolutely certain. And we learn anew every day in times of war that a video circulating on the internet does not necessarily strengthen the evidence. "Don’t run with the story until there’s hard evidence," Ian Bremmer wrote just two weeks ago. "Don’t follow sources that are only promoting one side of a conflict." I agree with him.

As I said, I am aware of the pressure you are under and working with. But the fight for attention around the clock often leads to ruthless sharpness, to quick judgments about those in responsibility. Added to this are the excesses in social media – hate, incitement, threats, even calls for violence against members of parliament, even against volunteer mayors. More and more people therefore no longer want to take the step into local councils, no longer see the point in taking responsibility for the community. I view this with serious concern. Because then democracy dries up from the bottom. And that is a danger for democracy as a whole!

It is all the more so as the tone in political communication in the republic has changed in a concerning way. The space for reasoned debate, supported by mutual respect, has become scarce. Where differentiation is necessary, black-and-white thinking often prevails. The more dominant social media become in political communication, the more excess reigns in the discourse. The unimportant becomes seemingly important, every misstep becomes a scandal. In social media, the political actor stands for the whole; there is no left and right, and certainly no center, the attack is aimed at politics. Trump has shown how it works, but also what the consequences are.

Those who only seek the loudest formulation, the shrillest title, and the highest click count, who cater to populist clichés about our democracy and its representatives, contribute to driving our country further apart and strengthening the political forces whose program is exactly that. "I really believe that the situation is serious." This analysis does not come from me, but from one of your editorial members, and I quote further: "The balance of criticism, even in sharp form, and the equally necessary respect that should be shown to all those who bear political responsibility, must therefore express itself in new ways," wrote Susanne Beyer recently.

I read this as a call to your own profession: Let us not become complicit with the agents of outrage management, with the tempo-setters of the outrage rhythm. I want to emphasize this and say: Maintain distance! Remain distinguishable from social media! Remain distinguishable also in language and tone. Do not succumb to the temptation to adopt the culture of perpetual outrage. View the task of differentiating not as a disadvantage, but as the foundation of journalism that is committed to democracy. Do not allow the loud to triumph over the thoughtful in our democracy! I am convinced that this is not only crucial for our democracy – but also for the survival of the very journalism we so urgently need.

In short, and with that we return to Rudolf Augstein: Say what is. Exercise your guardian function in our democracy critically and impartially, but be aware of your responsibility for democracy. Thank you very much!