Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the ceremonial event marking the 75th anniversary of the beginning of the Nuremberg Trials on November 20, 2020, in Nuremberg:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

24 November 2020 · Ceremonial event marking the 75th anniversary of the beginning of the Nuremberg Trials · Nuremberg, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremonial event in Nuremberg on November 24, 2020, marking the 75th anniversary of the opening of the Nuremberg Trials on November 20, 1945.
Main themes
Nuremberg Trials 75th anniversary, individual criminal responsibility, crimes against humanity, international law development, Nazi war crimes, London Charter, justice and accountability, Benjamin Ferencz, aggressive war prosecution, Holocaust remembrance, post-war legal order
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,228
62nd percentile
Sentences
124
73rd percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.2
34th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.36
85th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 64%63%
  • Geopolitical 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

124 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

and above all, esteemed Benjamin Ferencz,

even though we cannot speak to you in person today and express our gratitude, it is a great joy to have you among us. This country, Europe, and the world owe much to your wisdom and perseverance. I thank you for your words, for your work, and for your lifelong commitment, your ambition to make this imperfect world a better place.

Benjamin Ferencz will still have the images in his mind. Seventy-five years ago, this room was one of the few courtrooms in Germany that had not been destroyed by war. It was once one of the largest courtrooms in Bavaria. And yet it does not seem large enough for what it was meant to encompass 75 years ago.

Nuremberg was a rubble field in November 1945. Many German cities were heaps of debris. Our country was morally and materially destroyed down to its foundations. Beneath this mountain of guilt and destruction, the law was also in ruins.

Yet here, in this hall, an international criminal court was to convene. Here, the law was to be rewritten. While outside the court the rubble was being cleared away, the four victorious powers of the Second World War laid the foundation for the legal order of a new world in this hall.

The world had to be reordered. The loss of the old order could be felt as clearly in this room as outside the Nuremberg Palace of Justice. This also applied to international law. No institution was prepared for the handling of crimes of a Nazi dimension.

Many places where this injustice occurred were not known 75 years ago. Of course: Auschwitz, Buchenwald, Theresienstadt, Sachsenhausen, Dachau, many others, yes. But some I have only seen in recent years: Paneriai in Lithuania, Malyj Trostenez in Belarus, Wieluń in Poland – places of unimaginable horror! They are places that stand for the will to annihilate, for the will to erase, and for a deeply criminal conduct of war.

Even the main perpetrators of the most monstrous crimes invoked in this hall – the reading of their statements still sends chills down our spines 75 years later – the impunity of their actions. Nullum crimen sine lege. Nulla poena sine lege.

Benjamin Ferencz once said that he never accepted this argument, for no one had ever been able to credibly convince him that it was lawful to smash a child's head against a tree to kill it. Impunity could not be an answer to an injustice of this magnitude.

In this hall, 75 years ago, 21 key representatives of the Nazi regime sat in the dock. They were the planners, masterminds, and main actors of Nazi tyranny. They had exercised governmental and command authority. Now they were to bear responsibility for it. Nuremberg was the place of judgment. The London Charter created the legal basis for the trial. For the first time, the leaders of a state stood trial and were to be charged with the gravest crimes that world history had ever witnessed: for unleashing an aggressive war, for war crimes, and for crimes against humanity.

The London Charter established a double renewal for international law with the legal foundations for the Nuremberg Trials. What was new was not the prohibition of war crimes or the mistreatment of prisoners of war, the terrorization of civilian populations, and other serious violations of humanitarian law. All of this had already been established as customary international law since the Geneva Convention of 1864, the Hague Regulations of 1907, and subsequent agreements after the First World War.

The preparation and conduct of an aggressive war had already been condemned under international law in 1928 by the Briand-Kellogg Pact. However, until then, the responsibility for violations of international law rested solely with the state, the state on whose behalf the crimes were committed. What was new in the London Charter was the anchoring of individual criminal responsibility for those who had committed the gravest crimes, and the opening of possibilities for criminal prosecution. And new was the creation of a legal definition of crimes against humanity, which was applied for the first time in the Nuremberg Trials 75 years ago.

"So now war, pogrom, human trafficking, mass murder, and torture sit in the dock," wrote Erich Kästner, who was an observer for the Neue Zeitung and witnessed the opening of the trial here in Nuremberg.

And indeed, it was initially the perpetrators of the atrocities, the commanders and financiers, high-ranking officials, ministers, and military leaders, who were to be held accountable in Nuremberg. Later, in the twelve subsequent Nuremberg trials, the direct participants, soldiers and SS members, as well as doctors and lawyers, were also prosecuted.

The idea of the Nuremberg Trials was groundbreaking: "Violations of international law," the judges aptly noted at the time, "are committed by people, not by abstract entities." Government officials and high-ranking state officials should no longer hide behind legal immunity for their criminal orders, and the executing order recipients should no longer be able to invoke a state of necessity.

This meant nothing less than this: The law stands against power. It was to set limits to its blatant abuse. It was the foundation for a universal system of international criminal law and an international criminal jurisdiction – ultimately for an international order oriented towards law and justice. It was also the foundation for a principle of world law, according to which war crimes and the gravest human rights violations should not go unpunished anywhere in the world.

The main war crimes trial in Nuremberg was a revolution. It not only made legal history, it made world history. World history also because the Allies had agreed on a common procedure for this trial. Soon after the joint victory celebration, disillusionment set in the relationship between Americans, British, French, and Russians. Nevertheless, the Nuremberg trial became a common procedure. It outlined a new, a different history: the emergence of an international criminal jurisdiction. It came late, only after the Cold War – and the path to it was arduous and marked by setbacks. And yet, it was a great breakthrough. Without the main war crimes trial in Nuremberg, there would be no International Criminal Court in The Hague today.

In Germany, the Allies paved the way in Nuremberg for a national legal reckoning of Nazi history. However, the crime against humanity of the Holocaust only found its way to German courts years later, in the Ulm Einsatzgruppen trial in 1958 and finally in the Frankfurt Auschwitz trials starting in 1963. Without the persistence of people like Fritz Bauer and his few allies, this would probably not have happened. But Nuremberg was a prerequisite for this first Auschwitz trial.

For what would we know today about the crimes of National Socialism without the evidence collected in the Nuremberg Trials? What would we know about the perpetrators and their victims – without the files and documents of the Nazi administration, the recordings of mass graves in the concentration camps that the prosecution in Nuremberg had compiled?

Nuremberg, the city of the Reich Party Rallies and the Race Laws, was a mirror for the Germans. Nuremberg confronted them before the eyes of the world public with the fact that National Socialism itself, including its conduct of war, had been a crime. The trial and the verdict of Nuremberg allowed no justification anymore; they demanded purification. But the Germans struggled with this at the time.

The learning process – also outside Germany – was lengthy. What Nuremberg had introduced, that the gravest violations of international law must not go unpunished, only became established as a principle much later. Ideas to maintain the court here as a permanent institution, as a sort of outpost of the United Nations, remained a distant dream. It took decades for the spirit of Nuremberg to materialize and for an international criminal court to become a reality. Only after the atrocities of the Yugoslav War did the will finally grow to establish an international institution to prosecute violations of international law. The time after the fall of the Iron Curtain in Europe was a time of optimistic internationalism.

In the past two decades, we have had to experience again that hopes for a further legal framework of international relations have not been fulfilled. Old and new powers compete with each other. Globally binding norms are perceived as restrictions on one's own power. International criminal jurisdiction is increasingly facing challenges, even here in Europe. The United States and Russia have not joined the International Criminal Court, nor have China, India, and several dozen other states.

The USA, which played a major role in establishing the International Military Tribunal in Nuremberg and whose international lawyers were also the conceptualizers for the International Criminal Court, have been working actively against the Hague court under the current administration.

And yet, I trust that the nation that has accompanied our country for decades as a friend on its path to democracy and the rule of law will now return to a collaboration that also recognizes the value of international criminal jurisdiction. And I hope that the court can strengthen trust in its impartiality and legal incorruptibility through its actions, an impartiality it needs to convince the skeptics.

The US chief prosecutor in Nuremberg, Robert Jackson, excellently articulated the long-term goal 75 years ago: "We must never forget that by the same measure we use to judge the defendants today, we will also be judged by history tomorrow."

I know that indictments from the International Criminal Court against heads of state are not always seen as helpful in fragile peace processes. Criminal trials can narrow the political space for negotiations. The pressure they exert can also complicate the withdrawal of dictators. How do we exclude the possibility that criminal law is used as a weapon against political opponents when we actually want to prepare the ground for political dialogue? This question arises for mediators in many internal conflicts around the world. It played a role, for example, in ending the apartheid policy in South Africa and in the peace talks in Colombia. International criminal jurisdiction inevitably operates in a tension between legal considerations and political interests.

Nevertheless, Nuremberg was a breakthrough on the path to strengthening the law in international relations. But international criminal jurisdiction also repeatedly shows how difficult it is to want to bring more justice to the world with normative principles.

Some lofty hopes have not yet been fulfilled by the International Criminal Court. But in the challenge to the Hague court, a little of its effectiveness is also revealed, the fear of ruthless autocrats of being brought to justice.

Despite all its imperfections and deficiencies, international criminal jurisdiction has established itself. Seeking to respond to unprecedented excesses of power with the means of law was a beginning 75 years ago. Today, the International Criminal Court is an institution. Failing to punish the gravest crimes would be fatal – this message from Nuremberg has indeed not gone unheeded.

Without Nuremberg, warlords from Serbia, Croatia, or Rwanda would not have been punished for mass murder, torture, and rape; genocide would not be prosecuted as a crime today.

Without Nuremberg, there would be no principle of world law, and national courts could not act against violations of international law. They would have little recourse against two former members of the Syrian secret service who fled to Germany and are now being held accountable in a Koblenz court for crimes against humanity in their homeland.

Without Nuremberg, there would be less hope for justice – also for the victims. For Lewiza and Dalal, for example, just two of many Yazidi women who were abducted and raped by ISIS; who later found refuge in Germany and are being helped here to overcome their trauma. They were the protagonists of the documentary "Slaves of ISIS" by British lawyer Philippe Sands and director David Evans. I am pleased that Philippe Sands is here with us today.

Dalal and Lewiza hope that one day the perpetrators will have to answer before the International Criminal Court. They hope that their complaint will be heard, for the aim of such trials is not only the conviction of the perpetrators. It is important that the victims can testify to the injustices they have suffered, that atrocities are documented and recorded. It is important that the truth comes to light. For no one can step back from this truth. It remains a legacy, a task, and a test. This was the goal of Nuremberg.

Criminal jurisdiction can ultimately only be part of the answer. Crimes under international law are a breach of civilization. If they go unpunished, not only does the law suffer, but humanity as a whole is harmed. The goal must be to restore the broken law in the name of humanity itself. In conflict with power, the law must assert itself. It may not always overcome power, but it can set limits to it.

Or in other words: It is not merely the concert of the powerful, but the strengthening of the law in international relations that creates the foundation of a supranational order that the world needs – and urgently needs to continue.

This is the legacy of Nuremberg. We Germans are particularly called upon to carry on and defend this legacy.