Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the tenth forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on November 24, 2020, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

24 November 2020 · Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy · Bellevue Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the tenth Forum Bellevue in Berlin on November 24, 2020, discussing democratic transformation, COVID-19, and climate challenges with invited experts.
Main themes
Future of democracy, COVID-19 pandemic response, societal transformation, climate change, democratic cohesion, vaccine development, restrictions and public patience, crisis and recovery, social solidarity, political discourse
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,824
73rd percentile
Sentences
116
70th percentile
Readability
45
47th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 34%34%
  • Environmental 32%32%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

116 sentences in 32 paragraphs

"From Crisis to the Future –

how can transformation succeed together?"

I would like to extend a warm welcome to all of you, a warm welcome to the tenth "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy." You can see, even from the arrangement here, that Corona still has a firm grip on us; the infections these days, in these weeks, are even many times higher than during the peak in spring, the second wave is hitting us harder than the first.

Covering our mouths and noses, maintaining distance – whether shopping, on buses and trains, or at the workplace – has almost become second nature for many of us. But the fact that we still have to forgo meetings with friends and family celebrations, visits to restaurants and bars, theaters, concerts, swimming pools, and gyms, all of this takes strength and patience.

Of course, there is much debate and struggle over the measures I have just briefly mentioned. When we gathered at the last Forum Bellevue in June and asked how our democracy is faring in times of the pandemic, Herta Müller took a hard stance against the critics of state measures in Germany, saying: "We obey no state arbitrariness, we obey life. That is the freedom of responsibility for oneself and for others." It remains a fact that one can argue about everything, but not about the existence of a life-threatening virus that we must confront.

Today, we know more about the virus than we did in spring, but we also know: It is still not under control, the infection numbers are too high. Corona is and remains a great, a deadly danger this autumn and winter. We all must continue to take this danger seriously, we must take it very seriously. For now, reason and patience, consideration and caution are our most important resources to protect health, and also to protect lives.

Let us not allow the virus to divide our society! I wish for young and old, vulnerable and less vulnerable people to stand together, in the crisis, but also in the time afterwards. And we have seen in recent months that while we may argue about the right course, we have always been able to find a common path on which we have so far navigated the crisis relatively well – that is, in comparison to others. We have even experienced that the fight against Corona can strengthen democracy and cohesion.

And that is an experience that can give us courage and hope for the coming weeks. And there is still a glimmer of hope, a ray of light in this rather dark season: The development of vaccines is making great progress, and one or even two German companies are making significant contributions to overcoming the pandemic. We can be pleased about that. We know this is not yet the end of the pandemic, but it allows us to hope for the first steps towards normalization. It may be the long-awaited light at the end of the tunnel.

I remain optimistic. The restrictions of these days to contain the infection dynamics are certainly not easy to bear. But we will overcome the Corona crisis together. The virus will not steal our future. On the contrary, we may even learn from the crisis for the future. It is therefore important that we look ahead now and, above all, focus on the time after the plague. Right now, in the midst of the pandemic, we must not lose sight of the other great tasks of humanity. We should ask ourselves what we need to change today to embark on a better future.

And that is exactly what I want to do today with my guests here at the tenth Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy. "From Crisis to the Future – how can transformation succeed together?" is the question we will discuss shortly, at a distance and, as you can see, unfortunately entirely without an audience here in the hall – you know why. I am pleased to welcome four guests who will view processes of change, as you will soon see, from very different perspectives: Here with me in the castle are the economist Maja Göpel, the author Thea Dorn, and the constitutional lawyer Udo di Fabio; and joining us from Vienna is the political scientist Wolfgang Merkel. A warm welcome to all of you. And I am, of course, pleased that many others are joining us on screens, wherever you are watching us. You are also warmly welcome to Forum Bellevue!

The fight against global warming is one of the greatest challenges of our time. If we consider not only the immediate ecological dangers of climate change but also its social and economic consequences for the livelihoods of hundreds of millions of people, and if we take into account the international conflicts it provokes, we must conclude: It is the greatest challenge of all. What is at stake is nothing less than the future of our children and grandchildren, the survival of humanity on this planet.

The dramatic scenarios that scientists have been warning about for decades have already become reality in some parts of the world, while in others they are beginning to manifest: The ice at the poles is melting, sea levels are rising; countries in Africa and Asia are being ravaged by droughts, storms, and floods; millions of people are fleeing because their homes have become uninhabitable. This year, we have followed reports of devastating wildfires in Australia and California. And here in Germany, we have experienced the third drought summer in a row and see in many places how nature and agriculture are suffering.

Activists tirelessly remind us that we have no time to lose if we want to stop this development. And it is thanks in no small part to their commitment that much has begun to move in the broad field of climate policy. The countries of the European Union and other major industrial nations have set the goal of being climate-neutral by 2050; China aims to produce no net greenhouse gases by 2060. The goal of a climate-neutral world has been established, but is it really firmly anchored in our future? We know: In the present, different perceptions and, of course, interests collide. The big question is therefore how we can achieve the goal without jeopardizing prosperity and cohesion, freedom and democracy, and above all without losing the people we need on the way to the goal.

I believe that many people in our country have long since grown aware that we need to rethink, redirect, and even radically change course to flatten the curve of climate warming. "Flatten the curve," we learned during the pandemic, and that is an experience we must also apply in dealing with climate warming, and not later, but as early as possible, now. In politics, business, and society, the realization is growing that we need a fundamental change that affects all areas of our lives: the way we generate energy and dispose of our waste, how we do business and produce, how we work and live, how we move and eat.

In recent years, a lot has happened – I think of the energy transition, the introduction of certificate trading, or the shift in mobility towards electric mobility, the many creative pioneers of change who show us how to operate ecologically and successfully at the same time. But I also think of the many people in our country who take responsibility in their everyday lives by shopping, eating, or traveling in a climate-conscious manner. Some things are on a good path, but much more needs to be deepened, accelerated, or even initiated. We live, in the famous words of Reinhart Koselleck, in a saddle period, in a time of transition.

It is a transition that, due to its magnitude, is repeatedly compared to other great transformations in human history. Some even want to compare it to the Neolithic Revolution, when people became sedentary, others to the Industrial Revolution, the transition to industrial society, which destroyed traditional crafts, devalued established professional qualifications, and at the same time set in motion a migration to the cities. From history, we know that such processes of change put societies under pressure, that they can open deep rifts.

The great transformations of the present – globalization, digitalization, and the transition to a post-fossil age – these upheavals also put social and political orders to the test. Here at Forum Bellevue, we have repeatedly discussed since 2017 the rifts and resentments in Western societies, the loss of trust in the institutions of liberal democracy, a new longing for authoritarian solutions. Many of these phenomena can be traced back to the tremendous upheavals of our time – one could say that today, with the tenth event in this series, we are directly delving into the heart of our topic.

For it is these upheavals that set people in motion on the one hand, but also unsettle them, triggering fears of the future and defensive reactions. Those who fear losing their place in society, their jobs, their prosperity, who feel their way of life is threatened and feel overlooked or controlled by others, may turn away from democracy in disappointment. It is populist forces that then try to capitalize on this by promising either to halt the change or, in any case, to regain control – through isolation in the nation-state, through exclusion of others, through the implementation of a supposedly unified "will of the people," which, it is often said, has long been betrayed by the elites in politics, science, and the media.

Of course, there are also others, there are also those for whom the upheaval cannot happen quickly enough. Especially many young people want the transition to a world without coal, natural gas, and oil not later, but now and immediately. They demand that scientific recommendations be implemented immediately, without negotiations and compromises. Some of them often have little trust in the institutions and processes of representative democracy, which they see as too slow, too indecisive, and too dominated by short-term interests to achieve the climate turnaround.

Their protest follows, as Udo di Fabio has said, the "imperatives of undeniable knowledge and conscience." The great passion with which this protest emerges is indeed reminiscent of other protest movements in history, of the workers' protest against exploitation in inhumane conditions, of the peace protest against nuclear armament. Time and again, such movements have contributed to progress, and we should not deny the climate movement this democratic potential for ecological progress. However, the answer to how the social and cultural concerns of others can be integrated into democratic decision-making, how joint solutions can look, is not yet given.

I am convinced: The transition to a climate-neutral Germany can only succeed if we as a society move forward together. On what path we want to achieve the climate goals, how we want to restructure industry, agriculture, energy supply, and transport, how we want to live together in the future, we must debate and negotiate in a democratic process. Climate protection must not be a technocratic project and also not a policy in "emergency mode," as Wolfgang Merkel rightly pointed out.

For only if we consider different perspectives today, balance interests, negotiate solutions, find compromises, and convince skeptics with arguments, can we hold our society together in the midst of change and preserve democracy and freedom for tomorrow.

What we need now is therefore a democratic climate policy in which citizens are involved; a just climate policy that distributes burdens fairly and offers opportunities for all; and a global climate policy that keeps the future of our planet in view on all continents. We want to discuss how such a departure into a common policy of change can succeed. Let me mention a few points that are close to my heart.

I believe that after several months of the Corona pandemic and crisis, it has become clear that our democracy, perhaps contrary to some skepticism, is indeed capable of acting quickly and decisively. However, we also see that there is a great need for public debate, as well as a desire for greater involvement of parliaments in political decisions. And especially in the fight against climate change, which is much more complicated than the fight against the virus, we must achieve both: We need quick and effective decisions, and we need societal debate and negotiation of the next steps. The pressure to act in the climate crisis does not make democratic understanding and participation less important, but rather more important.

A climate policy that aims to shape change and preserve cohesion needs representative processes, a vibrant public sphere, and the rule of law. Discussions and negotiations are not a weakness but a strength of democracy, especially in times of change. In recent years, we have seen that important climate policy decisions, from the phase-out of nuclear energy to the transition to renewable energies to the coal compromise, have been highly controversial in society. And in the end, it was only through arduous negotiations that solutions were found that were supported by a large majority of people.

We know today that we and the generations before us could have acted earlier or even had to act. But this should not be used as an argument against democracy, especially not against representative democracy! The exchange of knowledge, ideas, and arguments, the always possible correction of decisions when necessary in light of new insights, all of this makes progress and problem-solving possible. How else, if not through public discussion and oversight, should we achieve trust in politics, acceptance of decisions, and willingness to change? And how else, if not through the representative inclusion of others and the balancing of interests, should we be able to preserve the cohesion of society in the future?

In the Corona crisis, problems are intensifying, but we also see how much solidarity actually exists in this society. And we recognize that democracy needs a capable state to manage the social and economic consequences of the pandemic. As we embark on the path to a climate-neutral society, politics must not lose sight of those who cannot easily keep pace with the change. Those who fear losing their job or profession need a perspective for the transition. And those who have only a tiny pension or are now struggling for their existence during the Corona crisis need help and support, as well as empathy, if we do not want to leave the field to populists of all stripes.

Politics must not ignore the burdens that come with major changes. It must also show opportunities. It must show opportunities by stating that prosperity and competitiveness through ecological innovation, more quality of life through clean air and less noise, are also part of the opportunities for a different future. In other words: We need a common idea of the future of this society and thus also a positive vision of the future to actually shape the change and take the majority of people along on this path. Simply warning that it is about survival, that everything is already much too late, does not alone inspire the courage that is necessary. But we need courage if we want to rethink our world and embark on a climate-neutral society!

The fight against the virus has once again shown us that we can only overcome major crises if we work together across borders. The foundations for global action against global warming have been laid; the Paris Agreement was a turning point. Nevertheless, it is concerning that implementation is still fraught with difficulties. It also worries me that more and more states are abandoning the idea of international cooperation. But there are not only these signals; there are also others, positive signals: The European Union wants to reduce its emissions faster than previously planned, and in the USA, after the presidential election, there is a climate policy restart in the air, along with opportunities for cooperation and a willingness to cooperate with us Europeans and Germans.

In this year of the pandemic, we see how much we can achieve when we act responsibly, rationally, and above all, together. This is a very valuable experience from which we can draw strength. And I believe we have every reason to be optimistic, even as we – still in the midst of the crisis – look at the enormous mountain of challenges that lies ahead of us, not only in climate policy.

So let us now, especially now, discuss common paths of change with greater seriousness than sometimes happens in public. And we want to make a small contribution here at Forum Bellevue to ensure that this conversation continues not only here but as widely as possible in many other places in society.

Thank you very much to the guests for being here, to Wolfgang Merkel in Vienna. I look forward to our conversation.