Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the debate forum on the state and future of our democracy on February 29 in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

29 February 2024 · Debate forum on the state and future of our democracy · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a debate forum on democracy's state and future at Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, on February 29, 2024, ahead of four major German elections.
Main themes
Democratic resilience, threats to democracy, right-wing extremism, populism, defensive democracy, civic mobilization, German Basic Law anniversary, Weimar Republic lessons, political culture, extremist networks, Western liberal democracies, reunification legacy
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,702
49th percentile
Sentences
93
59th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
32nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 60%60%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

93 sentences in 26 paragraphs

"How Democracies Die," was the title of a warning and dark analysis of the political present, especially in the United States, by the American political scientist Daniel Ziblatt. Many people in our country have read his astute observations, but most have seen them as particularities of an American situation, whose checks and balances seemed to be out of balance during the Trump years. "This has nothing or little to do with us," many here in Germany may have thought or hoped. After all, we look back on 75 years of stable political conditions, along with social peace and growing prosperity; in addition, we have had more than three decades of reunification.

Yes, the USA is different. Nevertheless, I have always found the perspective from our country on others, including our European neighbors, to be somewhat arrogant. We are not an island in the sea of the West, and there are palpable undercurrents in almost all Western liberal democracies: exhaustion from prolonged crises, insecurity due to geopolitical shifts, fears of change, and above all, a resurgent populism that cynically exploits all of this with attempts to divide and sharp criticism of elites.

Our response cannot be twofold: a calm waiting with the attitude of "It will somehow work out." But also not pessimism that paralyzes where action is necessary. For crisis is not fate. And Ziblatt's finding was not a prophecy, but a wake-up call. And at the latest since the investigation into a meeting of right-wing extremists in a villa in Potsdam, the wake-up call has also reached us.

The democratic center of our society is showing itself, is visible, and in my impression, it has already achieved something. It no longer allows right-wing extremists to solely set the tone in public debate and likewise the media agenda. Hundreds of thousands—conservatives, liberals, social democrats—have been and are on the streets; entrepreneurs and trade unions—just like on Monday evening in Stuttgart—are jointly drawing the line between democrats and those who despise or attack democracy.

How important this is is shown by recent incidents where events were blocked, politicians were attacked, and political discourse was prevented. We need the broad alliance of democrats so that what defines us does not erode: a political culture of openness and diversity, in which compromise is not compromised but respected as a necessary balance between societal groups.

Hundreds of thousands, old and young, entire families on the streets, democracy alliances between workers and employers: Is the most important thing now accomplished? Yes, I believe what is happening is of utmost importance. But equally important is: There is still no reason for calm relaxation. On the contrary: Now we must seize the momentum to strengthen our democracy again, to make it more resilient—in the headwinds of crisis, war, and the loss of old certainties—against threats and dangers from extremists who value it little.

"Successful, but not guaranteed"—this is how we have titled today's conference, and this is how many experience democracy these days and in the run-up to four important elections this year. What can we do together?

I am pleased that we are trying today to find answers in this debate forum. I welcome you all here at Schloss Bellevue. You are warmly welcome! And I am particularly pleased, dear Pinar Atalay, that we have been able to win you as the moderator for our three panels today.

We celebrate the 75th anniversary of our constitution this year and also the 35th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. We are pleased about what has been achieved in our country. And we remember: The guiding star of the mothers and fathers of the Basic Law was the experience and conviction that a democracy must also be defensible. They had experienced that we had once relinquished the hard-won democracy during the Weimar period. There were too few who had defended it, too many who had extended their hands to the enemies of freedom. The oath of "Never again" is deeply inscribed in our constitution. And it is, and we should not forget this, the conviction of the vast majority in our country.

In a time when the democratic order is no longer taken for granted by all, when the doubters are becoming louder, when the declared opponents of this order are gaining support, the formula of a defensive democracy must be more than just lip service. I believe it contains concrete political mandates for action. And I would like to formulate a few—just very brief—impulses for the debate.

We must,

first,

better and more sustainably protect our democracy from extremists. The Basic Law and criminal law contain instruments to fend off such attacks. Incitement to hatred, calls for violence, and violent attempts to destroy the free order: Where they occur, we must not accept them. Organizations that are hostile to the constitution can be banned. Above all, however, we must find means and ways to combat networks that feed, finance, and disseminate anti-constitutional ideas.

And we must also prevent an extremist minority from rendering our institutions dysfunctional. Therefore, we should also make our Federal Constitutional Court weatherproof, protecting it from possible attacks on its independence. The experiences in the neighborhood, in Poland, Hungary, but also in other countries, should serve as a warning to us. Everywhere there, the independence of the highest courts was primarily at the center of attacks on liberal democracy. Therefore, I believe the idea is correct to enshrine regulations for the structure of the court, the election procedure, and the terms of office of the judges in the Basic Law. Regulations that can then only be changed with a two-thirds majority. I do not underestimate the significance and complexity of such a regulation at all. Nevertheless: Now, in my opinion, is the time to think about the content and scope of such a constitutional amendment. And it would be good if a serious debate were initiated on this.

We must,

second,

make the digital debate suitable for democracy. A large part of our exchange, our opinion formation, and our discussion has long since shifted to the digital space. Social media increasingly dominate political debate as well, by painting in black and white, defaming differentiation as a lack of clarity, ignoring what is relevant, and fueling radical positions. The question remains: If we conduct our debates, on which a free society lives, more and more on platforms that profit from aggression and lies—how do we actually defend the respect, reason, and truth that are the foundation of every democracy? Without which a democracy is not viable in the long term.

We must not allow a minority of loud extremists to dominate the topics and the political climate in the country; that lies are deliberately spread, hatred is incited, and outright brainwashing is conducted, and this by enemies of democracy from all over the world. How do we prevent young people from being exposed to a flood of inhumane, often anti-democratic videos on platforms like TikTok? I am convinced that we need a digital protection of democracy as well as new offerings for shared experiences and encounters in the analog world.

Democracy,

third,

needs institutions and people who take responsibility within them. We should therefore strengthen the institutions of our democracy and protect them from being discredited. It is unacceptable when political gatherings with members of the Bundestag are violently disrupted, when small groups of enemies of democracy infiltrate democratic protests; when ministers are harassed on vacation, local politicians are threatened, or offices of representatives, even private homes, are attacked.

Our parliaments, our governments, our mayors—although they may not get everything right every day—are not something foreign, "those up there," but they are legitimized in a democracy through elections and bear responsibility for a time. But it is not only up to them. We need not only a few who practice politics as a profession, not only a few more who do it voluntarily, but we need the majority of citizens who make this community—hence it is called a community—their own and engage for our and in our community. It is urgently necessary and rewarding at the level of cities and municipalities, where in some regions fewer and fewer people are willing to invest time in political work locally. We especially need the young people! I am convinced that we must bind young people more strongly to parliamentary democracy! That is why we have deliberately put the call for a lowering of the voting age on the agenda for discussion today.

Making our democracy weatherproof, as I said at the beginning, requires all of us. It demands commitment and action. And that is why I am grateful for the many initiatives and projects that are engaged for our democracy everywhere in Germany, even in smaller towns and in rural areas. Today, and I am very pleased about this, there are people here who work in such projects, from the Democracy Station in Anklam to the Action Civil Courage in Pirna. They all deserve our support. The Anklam Democracy Station is now threatened with closure due to fire safety issues. Yes, the necessary renovation of the building undoubtedly requires money; and it seems that the municipality cannot manage this important project alone. I do not want to question that at all. But such a thing must not be the end of all efforts. It cannot be that the democratic engagement of young people ultimately fails due to fire safety!

I wish for a joint effort for our democracy now across the country. Making our democracy weatherproof is not a question of "those down there" or "those up there," not a question of government and opposition, not a question of young and old or city and country. What we need is the solidarity of democrats in this country. It is the solidarity of democrats that is always necessary when it comes to the whole—democracy itself.

Dear guests, I am very pleased that you all feel committed to this joint effort. You bring your expertise, your experiences into an exchange from which hopefully new insights and possibilities for action will emerge.

Thank you very much for being here. Now Pinar Atalay has the floor, and then all of you!