Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the dinner for the members of the Science Council on January 30, 2020, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

6 February 2020 · Dinner for the members of the Science Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the Science Council at a dinner in Berlin on January 30, 2020, reflecting on science, democracy, and climate policy.
Main themes
Science-society dialogue, climate change policy, anti-intellectualism and post-factual attitudes, role of science in democracy, interdisciplinary research, ethical dimensions of AI and robotics, democratic legitimacy of climate action, Isaac Asimov's legacy, science communication, social and political challenges
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,396
41st percentile
Sentences
59
39th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
13.3
60th percentile
Syntax
3.25
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 33%27%
  • Ceremonial 33%27%
  • Environmental 23%19%
  • Institutional 10%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 19%

59 sentences in 16 paragraphs

A few weeks ago, at the beginning of this still young decade, Isaac Asimov would have turned 100 years old. Some may know him, know his science fiction stories and novels, which he primarily wrote to entertain. That is true. But he also raised serious questions. His laws of robotics were an early attempt at the ethical design of a, as he put it, robotic future and a, as he would probably say today, dynamically evolving artificial intelligence. And he was not unfamiliar with dystopian visions of planets that have fallen out of ecological balance due to overpopulation.

As a science fiction author, Asimov did not only look imaginatively into the future. He also observed his own time attentively and critically. Already 40 years ago, for example, he warned against distrust of science and a "cult of ignorance."

Reservations about expert knowledge and the conscious ignoring of scientific findings have unfortunately not disappeared in the last 40 years. On the contrary: In Germany, for instance, 43 percent of respondents recently said that facts are merely a matter of opinion. Even though other surveys show that you, scientists, enjoy considerable trust among the population—certainly much more than politicians, journalists, or others—we still face a significant challenge, namely to boldly and actively confront science-blind and post-factual attitudes wherever we encounter them, and instead to advocate for a constructive and productive exchange between science, politics, and society. This will be particularly evident in the discussion of climate change and climate protection policy, where Asimov's visions of the future and criticism of the zeitgeist converge, so to speak.

For although there is great consensus in science—despite all the still open questions in detail—about climate change and its human-made causes, ignorance is not lacking. There are climate skeptics who deny climate change as such or at least its causes. There are those who acknowledge human-caused climate change and the necessity for a change in thinking, but pretend that this has no practical implications for politics, the economy, and society. And there are also those who tend to underestimate the necessary and sometimes profound changes to our energy and economic systems required for effective climate protection policy, focusing instead on costs and social upheavals.

And yes, not least, there are those—I would like to address this here—who show a completely different kind of ignorance or rather simplification: namely, those who, with scientific objectivity and a derived claim to definitive and absolutely valid insight, downplay every small and large step in the right direction or ridicule planned measures, while simultaneously making maximal demands, as if there were no people who must politically support all of this—essential in a democracy—and indeed must help shape it in the best sense. Or those who equate Macron and Merkel in environmental policy with Trump and Bolsonaro—seeing them as the same political establishment that has conspired to lead the world into climate catastrophe.

So far, so disheartening. But all these forms of ignorance—I prefer to say simplification—must concern us. For responsible and effective climate policy is undoubtedly one of the great challenges of our time. A challenge that requires from all who have a serious interest in both preserving our natural foundations of life and in the future of our democratically constituted society the willingness to talk not against each other, but with each other, and to act wherever possible. The willingness to do so must connect us in democracy. The fact that there are other pressing tasks at hand, such as securing our social systems in light of demographic change, defending democratic values, managing migration, or pacifying numerous crisis areas around the world, does not make the task of shaping climate change any easier.

All the more important is the support from science. It is important because we need science to better understand and foresee connections, problem situations, interactions, and possible tipping points of a development, to develop robust scenarios for possible development paths, to research the foundations and possible applications that open up pathways to solutions, and to provide concrete recommendations for action.

Especially because topics like climate change have such a profound impact on people's lives, they require profound and interdisciplinary support—not only with the involvement of the natural and life sciences, computer science, and engineering sciences, but also of the cultural, humanities, and social sciences.

At the same time, however, it holds true: Science can ultimately provide no answer to how we want to shape our lives and our future. Even the best scientific analysis may recognize unavoidable conflicts of goals, but rarely resolve them. And even the most convincing recommendation for action will fall flat without the necessary framework for implementing scientific findings into societal practice, without the necessary resources. And as important as financial resources are, there is one essential resource that cannot be bought, but can only be gained in societal discourse, and can also be squandered: broad support and acceptance from the people.

Striving for this acceptance is an original task of politics and societal debate, and this debate includes the struggle for compromises, but even more importantly, for the prioritization of tasks. An indispensable foundation for all these discussions and decisions, however, remains not to be blind to reality by relying on seemingly simple solutions, but to operate on the basis of scientific findings and sound forecasts.

Rarely has science been so much at the center of political controversies: criticism of science on one side, the appeal to science in climate protests on the other. In any case, science cannot complain about a lack of attention at the moment. We all—science, politics, and society—should rather take on the task and harness the power of enlightenment that resides in the acquisition of knowledge according to our shared understanding. This serves not only science itself but all of us, society as a whole, best. That is precisely why we need an intensified exchange between science, society, and politics. I advocate for this exchange. I am glad to have you by my side in this endeavor.

For my part, I am convinced: Science can and should open itself even more, especially for a fruitful dialogue with civil society and politics. This does not mean that every researcher must constantly seek the public stage. But it does require the willingness to engage in this dialogue outside the core business of science and to have a greater impact on society.

This exchange and mutual openness are, in the Science Council, which uniquely unites science, politics, and society, a long-established and pleasantly productive practice in science. For this, I also sincerely thank you!

This thanks also goes to the chair of the Science Council, dear Professor Brockmeier. Thank you for dedicating your time, energy, and ideas to this body for six years and for shouldering the chairmanship for the last two years. I am very grateful to you for addressing the issue of the relationship between quantity and quality of publications during your time in the Science Council, for urging universities to greater openness and courage in internationalization. And for the fact that the integrity of and trust in science has always been a personal concern for you. But alongside the many topics you have discussed and decided upon in the Science Council, the recommendation of the Science Council for the selection of excellence universities carries the greatest weight, as it is associated with immediate consequences. I can imagine that this does not make you only friends. But the scientific landscape, as well as politics, should be grateful to you for making your recommendation with such clarity and decisiveness.

I believe you leave after six years not only with a tearful eye. For I know you are looking forward to being able to devote yourself fully to your professorship in Hohenheim again. And, as I read in an interview, you are looking forward to not being constantly on a plane or in a car, but to being able to drive yourself again, as that is when you can think best. We wish you good thinking, many new, fresh ideas, and always safe driving.

That should suffice at this point, for gratitude, as Asimov says, is best and most effective when it does not evaporate into empty phrases. And so one might suspect that on an occasion like today, this gratitude may be more readily accepted if the food has not gone cold in the meantime.