Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the discussion "Enduring Differences. Daring Disputes. Living Democracy." of the Saxon State Center for Political Education on the 14th ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

17 November 2017 · Discussion 'Enduring Differences. Daring Disputes. Living Democracy.' of the Saxon State Center for Political Education · Dreikönigskirche

Context
Steinmeier addressed a political education forum at the Dreikönigskirche in Dresden on November 17, 2017, during his inaugural visit to Saxony as Federal President.
Main themes
Democracy and pluralism, political discourse and debate, Saxon identity and regional grievances, German reunification and transformation, right-wing extremism and Pegida, elite disconnect from East Germany, civic engagement and dialogue, democratic normality and compromise, citizen trust in institutions
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,045
58th percentile
Sentences
96
61st percentile
Readability
41
37th percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
3.00
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 38%38%
  • Institutional 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 24%24%
  • Geopolitical 11%10%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

96 sentences in 26 paragraphs

"Enduring differences. Daring to argue. Living democracy." A more fitting headline for the kind of debate I wish for our country – not just in Saxony – could hardly be formulated. Therefore, my first thanks go to the team of the Saxon State Center for Political Education, which has prepared this forum for us and thus enriched my inaugural visit to the Free State with one of my most important concerns: a broad debate in a place that is as authentic as possible for democracy.

As for the place, many have confirmed to me that the Dreikönigskirche was a particularly good choice. It was right here that the Saxon State Parliament gathered in the early 1990s, and it was right here that the state constitution was enacted. And that is why I want to thank not only the State Center but also express my joy that so many are here this morning and are ready to engage in this discussion with us. A warm welcome to all of you!

"Enduring differences." There is a subtle dot behind it on the invitation card. I believe we could also use an exclamation mark in these weeks. Democracy thrives on diversity, on pluralism, on accepting differences, seeking compromises, and finding majorities, even when it is sometimes arduous. Just how arduous that is, we are currently feeling when we look to Berlin: exploratory talks can take longer than some viewers would like. Party conventions do not always proceed harmoniously. Young people do not always share the views of the older generation. And the media could occasionally report amidst all the back and forth: This is democratic normality.

In any case, we are – this is my conviction – not doing ourselves any favors by scandalizing every dissent and seeing failure in every delay. When I speak with citizens during my travels across the country, I often have the impression: Most support democracy as an idea, but many find the arduous struggle for compromises and majorities to be quite dreadful. When reading texts from you, dear Professor Patzelt, or surveys like the Sachsen-Monitor, this impression is confirmed. On the one hand, the memory of the Peaceful Revolution of 1989 is very present here in Saxony; one can feel the pride in a great democratic achievement. The courage of the Saxons has rightly entered history and should, as I believe and recently stated elsewhere in Mainz, occupy a much larger space in German memory.

On the other hand, it is also noticeable: Many people have somehow grown weary in the face of some confusion, many changes, and adjustments that have been demanded of the people here since German reunification. Reunification, or perhaps I should say more precisely, the transformation has cost strength. And the elites who are driving this transformation – in the economy and administration, also in education, science, and culture – these elites, as recent surveys and studies have shown once again, still largely do not come from Saxony, not from the East, but from the old federal states. This is noticeable, it is being talked about, and – I know – it occasionally generates resentment.

The Saxons themselves, in any case, seem to often not adequately participate in the successes of their homeland, in their own, also public perception. This is certainly not the whole explanation for some of what has happened politically in recent weeks – keyword election results. But perhaps it is one element of it. Perhaps an element is the anger that occasionally finds expression, the anger towards the establishment in politics and the media. Perhaps this anger has simply grown larger than we wanted to acknowledge. I am firmly convinced: Some Saxon bashing does its part when it is pretended that all of Saxony has already fallen into the hands of Pegida.

I do not want to be among those who contribute to the stigmatization of the Free State and label an entire country as right-wing or racist. But I also do not want to conceal the findings of science, which has compiled many causes, many factors for the recent developments and says: Each individual factor can also be found in other regions of Germany, but the sum here in Dresden, in Freital, Meißen, Clausnitz, and Bautzen, the sum is the problem.

And this problem must be clearly named: Hard right-wing extremism, as we encounter it when, for example, Nazi ideology is revived or a "New Right" is conjured up, must call all democrats to action. One cannot simply stand by with a shrug and watch. That is why I was happy to listen to the reports about the citizen dialogues. I want to add: I personally have great respect for many people, many initiatives right here in Saxony, who are standing up against such developments and thereby defending the fundamental rights of our constitution.

However, let me say this openly: There is another challenge that we must not forget about: the regaining of the ability to converse in our society, where distrust, dissatisfaction, and some resentment over smaller and larger injustices turn into rejection of the whole, into absolute confrontation. Pegida and Nopegida regularly chant against each other, but – as I have also been informed in the state parliament – there are no conversations between them. The democratic dispute, the controversy, all that which is urgently needed in terms of content does not take place in such situations. On the one hand, because some actors have long since abandoned the rules of democratic engagement, instead spreading the language of hate and wanting to intimidate others. On the other hand, because many perceive the polarization as so extreme that they give up the discourse even before it has begun. I am not only talking about Saxony; I am also thinking towards the West, all the way to the Netherlands, to France; you know the developments.

"Daring to argue." This is therefore very rightly stated on the invitation card, and I would like to add: An exclamation mark would also be appropriate here, and indeed for all of Germany. To the younger people here in the hall, let me say as someone born in 1956: There have been very tense phases in our country before. There was the suppressed protest in the GDR, and there were sharp disputes in the West German Federal Republic, found in history books under keywords like Ostpolitik, environmental movement, or NATO double decision – decisions that caused deep polarizations even in West German society. In retrospect, such conflicts – as annoying and emotional as they were at the time – did not harm us, because in democratic disputes, what was politically feasible and what was not was worked out.

After German reunification, in my impression, fundamental debates were considered rather unpopular or even unsuitable for a time. Our biggest problems – so the misconception – had been overcome with the Cold War. And critical minds say – probably not entirely without reason – that this is precisely why the necessary debates on future issues did not take place in the necessary depth and breadth. There were regional conflicts. You all remember them as newspaper readers or television viewers, such as Stuttgart 21 or flight routes in Berlin. But questions that truly affected the whole country and that would have required a much more intense debate were too little present.

And I do not only mean the reception and handling of refugees, but also the question of internal and external security or a topic that will hit us with great force: the consequences of digitalization, all the changes for the working society, for the future of social security systems, and much more.

In the population – also in political circles – a diffuse unease has developed in the meantime regarding the challenges of the new era, a time of new global crises, also new wars, and hard-to-calculate risks.

"The world out of joint" – I once said about this. This has become something like a feeling of life that has gradually set in. And for many, it was not just a catchphrase, but a description of the situation in which we live. With growing discomfort, people turned on the television in the past years, because they already sensed: Here come more terrible images from Syria or from Libya or from Ukraine. And the question that arose for many was: "Does anyone actually have this under control?" I believe the refugee situation since September 2015 was not the trigger of the great unease in our society; it was not only then that the deficit of debate was felt. There was already a pent-up discomfort about the developments I just described. With the refugee situation in 2015, a new dynamic then emerged, which we will surely discuss on the podium shortly. The handling of asylum, flight, immigration, and integration issues shows, in my view, particularly clearly: Our society needs open debate about challenges and problems, needs argument as a catalyst in decision-making processes.

However, and this is very serious to me now: The gesture of constant outrage, the unrestrained anger or threats, whether directed against refugees or against mayors, does not help us in any way.

Democratic dispute does not function as a moralizing ping-pong of sharpened extreme positions. Democratic dispute does not have to forgo emotion and passion, but it needs the willingness to reason, the focus on problem-solving. And it must above all assume that both sides are ultimately willing to rely on facts and seek solutions based on those facts. It is not easy to defend this principle while the mainstream prefers to rely on emotions and camera-friendly escalation rather than on rational arguments and majorities. But it is precisely this principle that must succeed for the good of democracy, for the good of our society.

Sometimes distance helps to find objectivity in difficult situations. Distance from oneself when personal injuries or disappointments play a role. But I also mean distance in a geographical sense. If one has had the opportunity to look at this country from the outside for a while, to compare a bit how people are doing elsewhere, then one gets the impression: Some outrage is not entirely understandable. And one looks with more sobriety, with less resentment and more appreciation at what we have achieved in Germany – rightly so, in my opinion.

"Living democracy." Dr. Löffler, you did well to attach the mandate for your new office to this third point: "And what political education should be…"

In a hall with so many experts from school and extracurricular political education, I will not presume to give wise advice. But I would like to bring a small list of questions into this discussion.

I start with an obvious one: Is there actually enough space on the curricula of our primary, secondary, and upper secondary students for political education? The Minister of Education will surely have an opinion on this, but I am quite sure others will too.

That would probably already be a long debate in the context of educational federalism – 16 states, 16 concepts. Therefore, we should carefully narrow down the question: How could Saxony's youth achieve top rankings in societal issues alongside the natural sciences?

And what role – a difficult question – do the parents actually play? Those who speak with initiatives like the "Third Generation East" hear that there is still a persistent silence, in some families even taboos regarding the processing of the East German past.

This concerns not only the much-cited "GDR times," but also the years after the "turn": the years perhaps in which hope and expectation quickly turned into disillusionment and disappointment. Just think of keywords like Treuhand or pension equalization.

I am also interested in political education in public institutions. What does it look like in administrations, in social services, at the police?

I have come to listen to as many of you as possible and look forward to your contributions to the debate. They may be open, rest assured. The Minister-President and I spent a whole day yesterday in rural areas and spoke with many volunteers. We are, I can say, experienced in clear communication.

So let us now do what the invitation encourages: give debate a public space and make democracy come alive.