Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the German-French Museum Hartmannswillerkopf on November 10, 2017, in Wattweiler:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

17 November 2017 · Opening of the German-French Museum Hartmannswillerkopf · Hartmannswillerkopf, Wattweiler, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at the opening of the German-French Museum at Hartmannswillerkopf on November 10, 2017, commemorating WWI sacrifices alongside French President Macron.
Main themes
Franco-German reconciliation, remembrance of World War I, dangers of nationalism, European unity and sovereignty, Hartmannswillerkopf battle, memory and responsibility, national identity vs. nationalism, youth and Europe's future, Franco-German partnership
Duration
~12 min
43rd percentile
Words
1,455
43rd percentile
Sentences
85
55th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
8.8
10th percentile
Syntax
2.87
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.32
77th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 51%51%
  • Social 30%29%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

85 sentences in 28 paragraphs

This is, as peaceful as it may seem to us today, a place marked by horror. Those who look at the images from the last days of fighting in May 1916 gaze upon a deserted apocalyptic scene, upon bare, charred tree stumps, upon a mountain peak pockmarked by shell craters. Only the summit cross still rises from it, like a reminiscence of a civilization that was shot, suffocated, burned, and destroyed here in machine-gun fire, in the staccato of mortars, in the poison of gas shells, in the blaze of fire.

Taking the mountain from the other side was the goal when the fighting at Hartmannswillerkopf began in December 1914.

Maximilian Ott, a soldier from Württemberg, is the first casualty, Marius Magnin the first on the French side.

In the end, there will be 30,000, French and Germans. For this order of conquest remained in place, even when Hartmannswillerkopf had long lost its strategic significance, as the Great War moved on to Verdun, to the Somme, to Artois. Over the years until the cessation of fighting in 1916, the front line barely shifted, and it did not move again until the end of the war. What did tens of thousands fight and die for here?

"Mangeuse d’hommes" – man-eater is what Hartmannswillerkopf is called. The mass death at this place stands for the madness of war. Yet one thing we know: We know that it was not the mountain that demanded human sacrifices. It was the delusion of the superiority of one's own nation over other nations, for which millions of young men went to war and perished. It was – so it must be said for my country – the unbridled claim to great power, an exaggerated nationalism that hammered into the heads of young people that France was the supposed "hereditary enemy."

Today we remember, French and Germans together, what happened here. We remember because each generation must learn anew to distinguish the idea of the nation from the ideology of nationalism. We remember because we never want to tread the wrong path that nationalism leads to: repression at home and aggression abroad.

We need memory as a memorial, as a place of remembrance, as a museum – but that alone will not suffice. When we commemorate the soldiers who rest here, when we honor their memory, we do so because their death must not allow us to rest. This will not be any easier 100 years after the events – when the last eyewitnesses have passed away and young people ask: "What does this have to do with me?" – but it is therefore no less important. Not this mountain is a man-eater – nationalism is a man-eater!

Europe! This Europe, the peacefully united European Union, is the answer to the devastations of two world wars.

This Europe, united by the signs and symbols of its terrible past, is an extraordinary and by no means self-evident achievement, as the much too early deceased British historian Tony Judt wrote. This new, shared memorial here at Hartmannswillerkopf is such a symbol. And I am grateful to be here with all of you today, gathered for this solemn remembrance.

But, as Tony Judt reminds us: Europe's past obliges us not only to remember but also to commit to the future. Maximilian Ott was 28 years old, Marius Magnin 26, when they lost their lives here. Today there is a whole generation of their age for whom the united and peaceful Europe has become a matter of course. A whole generation of their age that says: "Europe is my second home. I am French. Or I am German – but I am also European."

What a tremendous European achievement that is – but also what a responsibility! These young people are meant when it is said: Europe is committed to its future.

Esteemed President Macron, dear Emmanuel: At the Sorbonne in Paris, you spoke to this young generation. And I have not only read your speech but noted in every line: You are truly committed to the future of Europe. And I want to assure you: D’accord. I stand, like the vast majority of my fellow citizens, by your side. Your momentum from France – we feel it in Berlin. And I am sure: We will take it up with vigor. Only if France and Germany stand together, only if we move forward together, can Europe succeed!

Esteemed President Macron: Just as this place teaches us to free the idea of the nation from the wrong path of nationalism – so you, in your Sorbonne speech, have freed the idea of sovereignty from its bondage to the nation-state. You said: European sovereignty does not contradict national sovereignty – no, it complements it, it even enlarges it.

A sovereign, strong, and capable Europe is the prerequisite for each of our nations – whether Germany or France, Poland or Spain – to be able to act in this world at all. That is already the reality, the world experience in which young people today are growing up. These young people not only move across national and linguistic borders with great ease, but they have long understood that they are fatefully connected to one another across borders. And they sense that this connectedness applies in both good and bad ways.

And that is why they have high expectations of Europe. When they speak of Europe as their "second home," it expresses a high demand – for protection and security; for being embraced and having a place in the world. In this world, which is changing rapidly and radically through new technologies, where wars rage and extremism is preached, where the model of Western liberal democracy is by no means unchallenged, where one power – the USA – is withdrawing and another – China – is propagating a strong but certainly not democratic counter-model. In this world, a sovereign and self-assured Europe is not just a possibility, but – if you ask me – an absolute necessity!

The united Europe has much to assert in this world: democracy and the rule of law, a globally unique balance of individual freedom and social equity. Its roots lie – as stated in the preamble of Lisbon – in our common cultural, religious, and humanistic heritage. If I may refer once again to your Sorbonne speech, Monsieur Le Président: "What holds Europe together most strongly will always be culture and knowledge."

The united Europe, in short, is a child of the Enlightenment, and like the Enlightenment itself, it is not an achievement but an endless process. We have all contributed our part to it. The Enlightenment speaks many languages. It speaks the French of Voltaire, Rousseau, and Diderot. It speaks English like John Locke and David Hume, German like Moses Mendelssohn and Immanuel Kant. It also speaks Dutch like Spinoza and Polish like Jastrzębowski. It speaks in all European languages. It is Europe's project.

That the Enlightenment must be a European affair is also evident in that we have never stopped arguing about it. Without criticism and correction, enlightenment is unthinkable. And without criticism and correction, the European project is also unthinkable. Even today, the European project needs some correction of the European structure, some overcoming of national prejudice, and much new thinking. But that we stand here together today shows that we Europeans have been able to learn even from the most terrible deviations of the past. And therefore – for heaven's sake – unlearning, the forgetting of the lessons from the century of world wars must not be an option for Europe!

Yes, they still exist again and again: Those who pit one homeland against another. Those who place their own nation above another. Those who measure their own sovereignty by the weakness of the other. This ideology led Maximilian Ott, Marius Magnin, and 30,000 young people to this deadly mountain, where their future came to a sudden end.

Their contemporaries today have grown up differently: in peace and in freedom, rooted in Europe. It is their future that matters, here and today. Will the European idea remain alive? Will we succeed in understanding the memory of our bloody past as a commitment to a common future? In all the challenges, in all the trials, in all the decisions that still lie ahead of us:

L’Union Européenne est la meilleure idée que nous ayons jamais eue.

Elle n’est pas du passé.

Elle est l’avenir que nous désirons.

Et cet avenir, nous le tenons entre nos mains.

The European Union is perhaps the best idea we have ever had on this continent.

It is not the past.

It is the future we want.

It is the future that lies in our hands.