Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the fourth forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on May 23, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

23 May 2018 · Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy · Bellevue Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the fourth Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy in Berlin on May 23, 2018, marking the 69th anniversary of Germany's Basic Law.
Main themes
Future of liberal democracy, civic engagement and democratic participation, populism and anti-establishment sentiment, trust in democratic institutions, Germany's Basic Law anniversary, political apathy and disengagement, civil society vs. political parties, compromise and democratic culture, direct democracy and digital democracy, common good and civic responsibility
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,049
58th percentile
Sentences
101
63rd percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
12.1
47th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
72nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 51%49%
  • Social 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 21%20%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

101 sentences in 32 paragraphs

"Society Without Politics? Liberal Democracies Under Test"

Today is a special day: exactly 69 years ago, on May 23, 1949, the Basic Law was solemnly signed. It was the birth hour of our representative-parliamentary order, and it is, of course, no coincidence that we are continuing our series of discussions on the future of democracy on this anniversary.

The fathers and mothers of the Basic Law were influenced by the failure of the Weimar Republic. They knew that a democracy is based on conditions that a constitution alone cannot guarantee. Democracy needs democrats who are willing to engage and collaborate. It needs citizens who respect others as equals and do not absolutize their own interests, who have the courage for open but fair debate and the same courage – no less important – for compromise. This presupposes an interest in the common good – certainly more than mere indifference and apathy.

One of the architects of the Basic Law, the later Federal President Theodor Heuss, put it very nicely in a simple formula: "The 'without me,'" he once said, "is the destruction of all democratic sentiment, which fundamentally relies on the 'with me,' 'with you.'"

We know that this democratic sentiment had to develop gradually in the Federal Republic. And in East Germany, people were only able to practice democracy with and after the Peaceful Revolution. This did not happen overnight and certainly not without setbacks and disappointments. But it is hard to deny that – beyond the changes – Germany has become a vibrant democracy with stable institutions. Compared to many other countries, we live today in an open society with well-informed and engaged citizens, with diverse and independent media, and I add: certainly with responsible politicians.

I say this because it has recently become somewhat fashionable to proclaim the apocalypse and to prophesy the end of liberal democracy. I do not want to join this chorus of doomsayers. And I even believe that it is dangerous when democrats talk themselves into depression instead of passionately advocating for their institutions and beliefs.

Precisely because we live in a stable order, we should confidently face the challenges that democracy is currently exposed to and that put it to the test – in Germany, in Europe, and in many parts of the world. And that is what we want to do together today.

The positive finding does not change the fact that changes are taking place. We all feel that something has gone awry in liberal democracies. Even in our society, cracks have emerged, hatred and contempt have entered the political discourse. The democratic attitude of "with me" and "with you," which Theodor Heuss described, has in some parts of society given way to a "without me" or even a "against them," which is sometimes reinforced by a "against those up there."

For example, we are experiencing that many citizens engage with great passion in civil society but have no interest in getting involved in political parties and democratic institutions. It worries me when I see how extremely difficult it was for the parties just a few weeks ago in Thuringia to find candidates for city and municipal councils.

It is quite evident that the trust of especially younger citizens in democratic institutions has declined. At the very least, they no longer see parliaments as places where solutions are found that improve their lives. Their "without me" often stems from an ironic to cynical distance towards the political process, sometimes even from contempt for politicians and institutions. Distance from politics has become fashionable for many; at least it spares them the justification of why they engage there.

However, we are also witnessing the rise of new political forces that are massively stirring up sentiment against the so-called "establishment," against an alleged power cartel of elites in politics, media, and business. They claim to be the sole representatives of the true will of the people, dismiss compromise as weakness, promise simple solutions, and often direct their ire against societal minorities. "Us against them," that is the prevailing attitude here.

Some movements advocate for direct democratic procedures or want to introduce a digital "click democracy" to help the will of the people break through. We must ask ourselves whether there is not also a longing for redemption from politics expressed here, the desire to escape the arduous struggle at the negotiating table, the laborious balancing of different interests. That is why I find it not so surprising when the French publicist Jacques de Saint Victor speaks of the "anti-political" in light of some currents these days. A controversial thesis that will need to be discussed.

But of course, it is not very enlightening if we only deal with coarse labels. The designation of movements and parties as populist rarely helps. For some, it is a justification not to listen closely to fundamental criticism, and others feel quite comfortable with the accusation of being merely the voice of the actual people, the true people. In this role distribution, both sides avoid each other. Engagement is necessary; democracy thrives on it! The question is only: Where are the boundaries for this engagement?

How difficult it is to draw boundaries is shown by one of our panelists today when he writes: "No one needs to fear absurd political proposals and sharp tones. Populism may be as anti-establishment as it wants, as long as it is not anti-parliamentary and anti-democratic."

Well said! But isn't that exactly the problem? Are we not dealing precisely with this anti-parliamentary reflex in many Western democracies? And did we not experience in the first democracy on German soil that radical populism relies precisely on the disparagement of political institutions and their representatives?

Bonn is not Weimar, and Berlin is certainly not. But I am, like many in my generation, shaped by, for example, Kurt Sontheimer's analysis, which posits that excessive and mass-mediated criticism of the system and especially of parliamentarism prepared the failure of democracy in Weimar. Has this finding been historically resolved? Or is it relevant again in times when the failure of the rule of law or the failure of democracy is proclaimed multiple times a year?

Indifference towards the political, a departure from democratic institutions, resentments against the establishment – these are the topics we want to discuss today, here at the fourth Forum Bellevue.

We want to ask about the societal causes of these developments, but also about the shortcomings of our representative procedures. And we want to ask what we can do to keep our democracy alive, to make political engagement attractive for as many citizens as possible. I find new forms of participation particularly important, which can complement established institutions and enrich the debate. For it is precisely a strength of our democratic order that it is not institutionally rigid but remains open to change.

I am pleased that this afternoon I can welcome three combative public intellectuals here who look at the topic from very different perspectives and have also made very different proposals on how democracy could be revitalized.

Christoph Möllers is a professor of public law and legal philosophy at Humboldt University here in Berlin. A few months ago, he described in the magazine "Merkur" a bourgeois middle class that has gotten used to "believing in a world without politics or at least in one where politics can neither take anything from them nor give anything to them."

He is concerned with citizens who do not even see themselves as unpolitical because they go to the polls, engage in clubs and projects, tweet protests, or read or write clever analyses about the decline of political culture. But according to his observation, they do not care about the political institutions in the narrower sense.

"Those who consider the order as it is to be worth protecting," he writes, "will have to trust its political forms." His appeal to get involved, to join political parties, and to dedicate a relevant part of one's time to political engagement is, of course, sympathetic to me; that will not surprise you.

But what is the reason that parts of society have turned away from politics? How can we bridge the gap that has apparently opened up? To what extent must the parties also change? I want to discuss all of this with him shortly. A warm welcome to Christoph Möllers!

I am pleased to welcome a scholar who deals with various forms of politicization, which we have also been observing in Europe in different ways for several years. Donatella della Porta is a professor of political science at the Scuola Normale Superiore in Florence, and she researches social movements and political protest and can tell us – given current events – a lot about a country that is currently deepening the furrows of worry on the foreheads of Europeans. Perhaps she will tell us that we are worrying too much. For in her distinction between regressive and progressive forces, she categorizes the "Cinque Stelle," which is about to enter the government in Italy, as progressive – as positive political forces. I would like to hear from her what she thinks is progressive about this movement and whether she is sure that left populism strengthens democracy and only right populism harms it. Why – she must reveal that to us shortly.

In any case, according to Donatella della Porta, political protest is an indicator of the inadequacies of representative democracy: the parties are no longer able to feed the pressing questions into the political system that concern the citizens. She therefore calls for more opportunities for participation, more "deliberative democracy."

But what exactly should we imagine by that? To what extent do the new movements change existing party systems? Do they strengthen or weaken representative democracy? I want to discuss this with her shortly. It is great to have you with us today – Benvenuta, Signora della Porta!

My third guest is David Van Reybrouck. He comes from Belgium, is a historian and archaeologist, a writer and playwright, and his essays "For Another Populism" and "Against Elections" have also caused quite a stir in Germany.

David van Reybrouck sees representative democracy in a dramatic crisis. The cause of this, he believes, is a growing gap between less educated groups and highly qualified elites. Populism is the cry for help from the less qualified and forgotten voters who can no longer recognize themselves in their representatives.

Instead of looking down on these voters and excluding them, Van Reybrouck wants to involve them in the political process and create places where people from different backgrounds can meet and exchange ideas. Not entirely new, some might say in the hall, but David van Reybrouck, with his citizen platform "G1000," calls not only for more participation in Europe; his further idea sounds truly revolutionary: he also advocates complementing the elected parliament with a second chamber whose members are determined by lot. This is a view that is not per se anti-parliamentary, but David van Reybrouck considers elections to be a "primitive-aristocratic" element, and democracy that relies solely on elections he deems insufficient. Hence his vote for a so-called aleatory democracy, which also relies on elements of chance.

Such proposals sound surprising, even foreign, and I have many questions about this, especially with regard to Germany. For example, I would like to know to what extent populism can be an enrichment for democracy: What new problems does it bring to the agenda, what blind spots does it uncover? He will explain this to us shortly: A warm welcome to you as well, David Van Reybrouck!

Today, on the day of the Basic Law, we are particularly aware of how fragile and, above all, how little self-evident democracy is. And the reflection on the past 69 years also makes it clear to us once again: Democracy is not, democracy is constantly becoming. We cannot, as the political scientist Klaus von Beyme once said, "store it as a dried species of government forms theory in the intellectual botanical drum."

That is why I am pleased that we can now discuss the democracy of the future, here on the podium and then throughout the hall. I am certainly glad that you have come to this event. A warm welcome to all of you at Schloss Bellevue!