Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the Ludwig Erhard Center on May 18, 2018, in Fürth:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

23 May 2018 · Opening of the Ludwig Erhard Center · Ludwig Erhard Center, Fürth, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at the opening of the Ludwig Erhard Center in Fürth on May 18, 2018, honoring Ludwig Erhard's legacy and the Social Market Economy.
Main themes
Social market economy, Ludwig Erhard's legacy, economic miracle and prosperity, freedom and social equity, Deutsche Mark and currency reform, Karl Marx as counterpoint, post-war German recovery, democracy and political pluralism, Ludwig Erhard Center opening, balancing state intervention and free markets
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,919
55th percentile
Sentences
111
68th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.90
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.34
81st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 51%50%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Technological 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

111 sentences in 33 paragraphs

We all know the photo. A man, with a slight belly of prosperity and rosy cheeks, sits in a dark suit on an armchair. A satisfied look into the camera. In one hand, he holds his glasses, in the other, a thick cigar and his bestseller "Prosperity for All" – Ludwig Erhard, just as he has imprinted himself into the collective memory.

With many chancellors of our history, we associate an outstanding political achievement: Konrad Adenauer and the Western alignment, Willy Brandt and the Ostpolitik, Helmut Kohl and the reunification, with Gerhard Schröder perhaps the reform of labor market policy. With Ludwig Erhard, it is undoubtedly the Deutsche Mark, the economic miracle, and the associated promise that everyone can share in it.

The Social Market Economy, his synthesis of free competition and a regulating state, has fulfilled this promise.

What sounds so convincing and coherent from today’s perspective was quite unconventional at the time and certainly not undisputed. Erhard's methods, for example, the abolition of price controls, rarely met with unanimous approval. From a press conference of the Economic Council of the Bizone, which took place in the late 1940s, Marion Gräfin Dönhoff wrote to her editorial colleagues at DIE ZEIT: "If Germany were not already ruined, this man […] would certainly bring it about. God protect us from him becoming Minister of Economics in Germany." Gräfin Dönhoff was often right with her diagnoses of the times, but here the great liberal publicist was mistaken. With the distance of 70 years, we can say: It is good that it turned out differently.

On the anniversary of Erhard's death on May 5, the newspapers were full on the occasion of the 200th birthday of another economist – you can guess who I am talking about: Karl Marx. I was surprised to hear from the curator of your exhibition that Erhard has been discovered as an exciting counterpoint to Marx, especially in China. The Ludwig Erhard Center is therefore preparing for the buses with tourists from China, who will now also make a stop in Fürth.

It is worth pausing for a moment at this pair of contrasts. In contrast to Karl Marx's categorical, antagonistic thinking, aimed at class struggle and "permanent revolution," the Social Market Economy is not a rigid and closed ideology. And that is what distinguishes it! It is designed for balancing. Social partnership, the ongoing competition of ideas about how this balance can work best, how economic reason and social equity can be calibrated under constantly changing conditions – this has become a hallmark of our society, a trademark of our country, indeed even a model for many in the world.

Where are free market forces restricted by cartel formation or privileges? Where must the state intervene in the market process in a balancing or preventive manner? Or also: How much inequality can a society reliant on performance equity and solidarity tolerate? Naturally, the political camps in Germany do not answer such questions identically. That is good, because the offering of different – and above all distinguishable – answers is vital for our democracy. What counts, however, is the fundamental commitment to the principles of our free and social economic order, to which all democratic parties have committed over the years.

This achievement, which is also a lasting task, is documented by the Ludwig Erhard Center. I believe Erhard would be proud of his museum and his Fürth – that you have dedicated not a golden statue to him, but a place for enlightenment and dialogue. Thank you very much to everyone who made this possible. For your commitment, you have my utmost respect!

I was born in 1956, a child of the post-war generation, raised in a time when we did not have everything. My mother, having fled from Breslau with her mother and sister and their two little daughters, herself without a school diploma, had experienced loss and poverty firsthand. But despite all the deprivations, there was a decisive promise for my family that drove us – like millions of other families – and gave us hope: Things were looking up!

With the currency reform, people regained trust in their future. Thus, the Deutsche Mark became a symbol of stability and prosperity, coupled with the discipline and diligence of the Germans, the beginning of what we later classified as the era of the economic miracle. Ludwig Erhard himself summarized it on the occasion of the 10th anniversary of the Deutsche Mark: "From rubble and ruins, from need and misery, from hopelessness and despair, a new world has emerged."

We owe Erhard an economic order built on freedom and legal certainty. This was for him a central lesson from the disruptions of the currency and economic crises, the mass unemployment and mass misery of the Weimar period, and it was a lesson from the arbitrariness of Nazi rule. But it was also his counter-proposal to communism, which, under the guise of the collective, shackled individual freedom.

The promise of political and economic freedom remained a hope for the citizens of the GDR during the years of division. This freedom and this prosperity were like a magnet that no barbed wire, no wall could weaken. On the contrary: The longer the GDR lasted, the longer freedom was suppressed, the longer prosperity was absent, the more it drove the people of the GDR onto the streets every Monday. There, on the streets, in the peaceful protest of citizens, the end of the GDR was sealed and unity in freedom was born.

Erhard himself was a utopian of freedom and competition. The convinced Atlanticist understood his liberalism as the "pursuit of happiness" – the right of every person to take their fate into their own hands. For Erhard, this did not include an unleashed and unregulated market. He wanted a market framed by a value-based social order, including institutionalized social partnership, in which everyone has the chance to earn their own prosperity.

Globalization and ever faster waves of technological innovation have initiated an economic dynamism that we could hardly imagine a few years ago. Disruption is the word of the hour. What do these upheavals mean for the Social Market Economy? Does Industry 4.0 require an update of our economic order towards Social Market Economy 4.0?

First: Globalization has opened new markets. Germany benefits from this as an export-oriented country in particular. At the same time, the pressure to adapt to our economy is also increasing in order to compete in the global market.

Digitalization is an accelerator of this development. Fiber optic cables connect the world and transport their cargo in seconds over thousands of kilometers. They enable new forms of global division of labor.

These are initially huge challenges for companies in Germany. We can already see how the world of work is changing massively as a result. The demands on employees are becoming more challenging. This is initially good news, as good education and high qualifications are the hallmark of our economic location.

However, we should also take seriously the forecasts that predict less the end of work, but rather a polarization of the labor market.

First:

While the wages and fees of the well-educated, mobile, and flexible are likely to rise in the future, there is a danger that less will remain in the paycheck for the less qualified and mobile.

Second:

Digital platforms are developing as a counter-model to the traditional business. Dis-entrepreneurialism is the keyword. What will happen to social partnership when the employer disappears and the platform only mediates work?

Third:

What does it mean for social security if the normal employment relationship is no longer the rule? Who pays in case of illness and vacation? How does the pension system remain sustainably financed?

Questions of tomorrow that we must answer today! The promise of the Social Market Economy of upward mobility and social security has been a guarantee of political stability for decades. Without this promise, something slips in our society. Ludwig Erhard himself was convinced that a free society rests on conditions that the market and competition alone cannot guarantee.

We should therefore not dismiss these questions as pessimism. In the polarization of our society between urban and rural areas or between high earners and those who fear job loss and social decline, there is explosive potential. Not only since the federal election do we know: Wherever structural change hits particularly hard, those who promise a return to an allegedly intact world with simple answers gain the strongest following. This has been more evident and stronger in other countries, but apparently these developments do not stop before us either.

The answers to this vary. Active shaping of the consequences of globalization and digitalization or retreating into a fortified position and invoking the past. I fear: The answers to the truly big questions of the future will hardly be found in the past. And barriers against international cartel and monopoly formation will hardly be established within a national framework. On the contrary: Those who withdraw, instead of advocating for standards and regulations together with others, lose control and influence. Because then others determine the rules of world trade, the standards for electromobility, or the boundaries of privacy.

We must defend our interests, especially in the digital space. As the father of the Cartel Office, Erhard fought against market-dominating conglomerates. This struggle was lengthy and controversial, in parts of the industry, but also within Erhard's own party. It took nine years from the first proposal for an "independent monopoly office" until the Cartel Office began its work 60 years ago.

Today we see how new giants are establishing themselves in the digital data market, referred to as the "Big Five," which would likely have caused Erhard similar concerns. Because the new digital giants are making huge profits and paying relatively little tax, especially not in Europe.

Moreover: The offerings of digital networks seem free, but we pay with the disclosure of our personal data a price that we can hardly calculate. Data is the currency in this market. We already knew this before the latest scandal surrounding Facebook. The monopolistic concentration of data and power is something that must concern us, and indeed everywhere in the world, not just where power and data are concentrated within a state framework! Classic national competition regulations do not provide a remedy here. But I am sure: Ludwig Erhard would have seen the necessity of an international regulatory policy for the data market. And he would likely have nodded in agreement when I spoke last Sunday at the DGB Federal Congress about the necessity of an ethics of digitalization to keep the digitalization of society and our Western liberal democratic model compatible.

Erhard could not foresee the technological upheavals of our time, but he was not old-fashioned. I am therefore pleased that you have not turned this museum into an antiquities cabinet, but rather a lively place of discussion.

The future space of the museum, which we have just visited, translates Erhard's thinking into today's time. Imagine Erhard would publish his bestseller today. What would that look like? Perhaps he would again sit with a smile on a sofa. Despite the smoking ban, with a cigar in one hand. And probably with a tablet instead of a book in the other. But the title of his work and the claim of his actions would remain the same: Prosperity for All.

Now Ludwig Erhard is no longer here – but this claim remains. Thank you very much!