Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the dinner for the members of the Order Pour le mérite for Sciences and Arts on June 3, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

4 June 2018 · Dinner for the members of the Order Pour le mérite for Sciences and Arts · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed members of the Order Pour le mérite at a dinner in Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, on June 3, 2018, reflecting on technology and human identity.
Main themes
Artificial intelligence and technological progress, human identity in the digital age, ethics of digitalization, science and enlightenment, Order Pour le mérite, future of human excellence, Homo sapiens vs. machine, reason in societal discourse, nanotechnology and genetic research, open future and human agency
Duration
~9 min
31st percentile
Words
1,064
31st percentile
Sentences
44
28th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.26
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
70th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 60%59%
  • Ceremonial 21%20%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

44 sentences in 15 paragraphs

A warm welcome to all of you – and in good tradition, I may add: this year again at Schloss Bellevue!

The constitutional lawyers among you know that my office comes with a number of recurring tasks: issuing laws, accrediting ambassadors, and – when the time comes – appointing the federal government. And last but not least – even though they are not mentioned in the Basic Law – the public session of the Order Pour le mérite and the joint dinner.

The exchange with you is one of the real privileges of my office. For me, today’s day and evening are not only an opportunity for many stimulating conversations but also – if you will – something like a professional development course.

In your lectures, I am allowed to dive into the depths of current science and research, away from the political everyday life – I thank you for this annual pleasure. And as you have seen today, this is not only the case for me but also for the 800 guests at the Konzerthaus Berlin, which had transformed into a lecture hall for an afternoon. In doing so, you all, the members of this proud order, show that you are not only leading figures within your disciplines but that you carry the light of knowledge, the spirit of enlightenment into society and want to inspire us to think further and deeper. We need this, especially today: people who uphold the value, the claim, the constant challenge of reason as the currency of societal discourse – that is exactly what you do, and for that, I want to sincerely thank you all!

In his festive lecture this afternoon, Svante Pääbo asked how much Neanderthal is in us and how he continues to live on in us. In terms of "thinking further," I would like to add a question this evening that you may not consider compelling, Mr. Pääbo: In light of the rapid technological progress, for example, in artificial intelligence or the interconnection of digitalization, nanotechnology, and genetic research, one might be tempted to ask: How much Homo sapiens will actually still be in the humans of the future?

My seemingly simple and, upon closer inspection, not entirely self-evident answer is: It depends entirely on us! I am neither enthusiastic about dystopias nor naive utopias regarding technological progress. In view of the upheavals of our time, the dwindling certainties, the erosion of international orders, I would first and foremost like to emphasize: The future is uncertain. It is more open than ever. And therefore, I advocate that we engage with the technological possibilities of the future as Johannes Rau once wisely put it: Without fear and without daydreaming, but with courage and in the certainty that it is in our hands how we shape this open future.

What is certain is this: The waves of technological development are reaching us in ever shorter intervals and with ever more far-reaching consequences. The same computing power of the computer that defeated world chess champion Garry Kasparov 20 years ago is now quite naturally found in the smartphone in our back pocket.

Machines created by humans now far exceed us in certain abilities that have distinguished us for thousands of years and were our unique selling points: the computing power of our brains, the analysis of data and relationships.

So what is the value of human cognitive performance? What still distinguishes humans from the ever more perfect machine? Or, to relate it directly to the essence of this order: What will its "merits" be in the future? How will we define human excellence in 30, 40, or 50 years that qualifies for admission to the illustrious ranks of the "Order Pour le mérite"?

In this sense, I believe that the discussion about technology and its consequences is no longer merely about the possibilities and limits of technology itself, but it directs our gaze back to ourselves: to what defines us, to what should remain unshakable, to the intellectual, social, and ethical cornerstones, to the fundamental rights of the individual. For this reason, I repeatedly say: We need the debate about an "ethics of digitalization." Because this debate is not only about the future of digitalization – it is about our own.

There are those who believe that the race between man and machine has already been lost. They believe that we, the sorcerer's apprentices, have long lost control of our broom. For decades, since pioneers like Alan Turing and others, there has been speculation about the arrival of "Artificial General Intelligence" – an artificial intelligence that completely surpasses our own. Meanwhile, I have read that some particularly forward-thinking engineers in Silicon Valley have founded a church, not to worship God, but to worship the coming superintelligence, as a kind of advance insurance. With this twist – so the idea goes – humanity at least makes a good impression on its future ruler. Even if this is not entirely serious, it already reflects the harbingers of likely enormous societal and cultural changes that may lie ahead of us.

Exactly one month ago, Karl Marx would have celebrated his 200th birthday. Much has been written about him and his thinking in recent days: about the economist, sociologist, historian, the failed revolutionary, the biting critic of capitalism. What impressed me most upon rereading Marx was the striking relevance of his thoughts on technological development and its societal consequences. I think, for example, of the famous, because so provocative sentence from the German Ideology: "The products of their brains have grown over their heads. Before their creations, they, the creators, have bowed down."

I do not share this pessimism about the future! The future is not fate! We can, in both large and small ways, overcome powerlessness and – to stay with Marx – alienation, if we not only look for the responsibility of others but also recognize our own. We have our fate in our hands – it is up to us what we make of it.

I believe that the age of robots, algorithms, and artificial intelligences should be a welcome opportunity for all of us, and especially for you – for scientists and artists, for both natural and social scientists – to prove Marx wrong! Not for Marx's sake, but for our own.

I thank you – and wish us all a good appetite and stimulating conversations!