Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the Fritz Stern Lecture 2019 on March 5, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

5 March 2019 · Fritz Stern Lecture 2019 · American Academy, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier delivered the Fritz Stern Lecture 2019 at the American Academy in Berlin, reflecting on democracy, reason, and Fritz Stern's intellectual legacy.
Main themes
Democracy and reason, cultural pessimism, Fritz Stern's legacy, transatlantic relations, rise of irrationality in politics, populism and political discourse, globalization and social upheaval, complexity and information overload, historical lessons of Weimar Germany, threats to democratic institutions
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,435
81st percentile
Sentences
181
87th percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
12.6
53rd percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
60th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 44%41%
  • Geopolitical 17%15%
  • Institutional 17%15%
  • Technological 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 7%

181 sentences in 45 paragraphs

"Is Democracy Losing Its Reason?"

I am pleased to be a guest at the American Academy once again. Moreover, it is in honor of a man to whom we Germans and the transatlantic relations owe so much: Fritz Stern. Thank you very much for the invitation!

At the same time, I am sure that Fritz Stern would have found it particularly challenging to speak about reason at the height of the carnival season. But I gladly accepted the invitation nonetheless, for in the USA, there is no carnival season – or so they say!

But seriously: Tomorrow is Ash Wednesday, which is precisely the right time to strive for the right balance of passion and sober reason. A balance that Fritz Stern struggled for throughout his life. Few passages in his great work are more touching than the scene on the tenth anniversary of the assassination attempt on Hitler, in which he describes how his aversion, indeed his hatred for the Germans transformed in the encounter with the descendants of the executed conspirators of July 20. He, who left Germany in October 1938, had to leave, and found a new home in New York, became not only one of the greatest historians of our time. He, the American Jew born in Germany, literally became a "companion" to that Germany which had once driven him out, like few others. I mention this also because, despite the sharpness of his intellect and judgment, Fritz Stern was not someone who underestimated emotions. He also knew that one must never underestimate them.

Yet the loss of reason was the central theme of his first major work "The Politics of Cultural Despair" – published in German under the title "Kulturpessimismus als politische Gefahr." How was it possible that the Germany of his ancestors, that the democratic Germany that followed the Empire, sank into irrationality and barbarism and dragged Europe and large parts of the world into an abyss of violence and crime? That was the great, the enormous question he tackled as a young doctoral student at Columbia University.

He concludes this book, which marks his rise as a historian, as a keen thinker, and as a brilliant stylist, with a rhetorical question: "But, we must ask ourselves, could there have been any other 'Third Reich'? Could one find any secure hold or resting point in this wild leap out of political reality? Can one renounce reason, glorify violence, prophesy the age of the absolute ruler, condemn all existing institutions – without thereby preparing the triumph of irresponsibility? All this was done by the völkisch critics, thereby proving what terrible dangers a politics born of cultural pessimism harbors."

For Fritz Stern, this outcome of his research was never merely an insight into the causes and origins of a past catastrophe. His arguments, his advocacy, his passionate struggle for a politics of reason were fueled by the deep conviction that with the loss of reason, democracy and freedom themselves are at stake.

And today? One may say: Reason is not exactly in vogue. And democracy is under pressure. When I had the honor last June to inaugurate the Thomas Mann House in Los Angeles as a new place for transatlantic debate, I came across a remark by Thomas Mann about the darkening of reality in the mystical and irrational of the late 1920s; a remark that Fritz Stern also picks up: This kind of darkening, this obscurantism, writes Thomas Mann, is sentimental coarseness, in that it seeks to hide its brutal and unreasonable physiognomy under the imposing mask of sentiment, of German loyalty, for example.

"Sentimental coarseness" – that seems to me an apt description of a more than current phenomenon that we can observe in the political discourse in our own country, but also on the other side of the Atlantic and in many societies worldwide today.

We observe it, and we lament it. But that is not enough. We must try to understand: What fuels the rampant loss of reason? What drives the furious longing for scapegoats? Why does the appeal to our lowest, not our best instincts find so much resonance? Fritz Stern's keen mind is missed today to provide answers to these questions. Thus, we must strive without him, always with his admonition in mind, that we must not make it too easy for ourselves in searching for the causes.

I see

four

great, intertwined challenges that we face. Challenges of our time, in which old dangers resonate.

First

the sheer overload of human reason and emotion in the face of the objectively growing complexity of our interconnected world.

Second

the challenge of new answers to the economic and social upheavals that globalization has caused in many of our societies over the past decades.

Third

the communicative challenge of convincingly conveying the political actions of a democratically constituted politics in this confusion. An action that must cope with contradictions and ambiguity while others simultaneously offer radically simple answers.

Fourth

finally, the challenge of a dramatically changing appropriation of information and knowledge in our digitized world, through which evidence and reason become just one option among many.

Let us begin with the first challenge. The growing complexity and interconnectedness have been described in many ways. Interconnectedness does not only mean more exchange, more choices, and more prosperity. It also means that political crises are hardly ever regionally and temporally confined anymore, but increasingly interact with one another, merge into one another, and even mutually reinforce each other. Navigating these crises – from Brexit to Kashmir to Venezuela – is already a tremendous challenge in itself. But how much more difficult is it to maintain a clear view of what is not only pressing at the moment but also important in the long term? By this, I do not only mean investing in the lasting good relations between states, as has recently been achieved with the Aachen Treaty between Germany and France, but also promoting innovations for the day after tomorrow, seizing the opportunities of digitization while simultaneously regulating its risks wisely.

This complexity is not only a challenge for reason but also for our capacity for empathy. People's expectations have risen enormously with the direct view into other worlds – both here and in faraway countries. Our ability to empathize with other realities and perceptions can hardly keep pace. We are often emotionally overwhelmed. This overwhelm produces counter-reactions: fear of identity loss, retreat into supposedly familiar reference spaces, a return to nation, ethnicity, religion, or region. A sense of home and belonging is vital for human beings. This is not a "secondary need." In the unboundedness of the globalized world, it gains noticeable importance. But when it retreats into exclusion, into rejection of the other, especially into fear of the future, and narrows down to the image of a merely imagined, supposedly great past, then it becomes dangerous. With the loss of openness, a society also loses sight of reality and possibly the ability for peaceful compromise. It loses that confidence in the future from which the ability and will to shape can first arise.

Second

cause: Without a doubt, our country, Germany, is among the winners of globalization. That is beyond question. We owe our prosperity and security to our global interconnectedness and our partners and allies. But this must not remain an abstract argument in the face of increasingly growing inequality and widespread concerns about the loss of cultural home and identity. What may hold true in the aggregate has left many, too many losers in individual cases. This is also one of the causes of the societal polarization that we observe in our own country, but also in many other societies. We must better steer the societal, economic, and technological upheavals into humane channels, cushioning their disruptions. It remains the political challenge of our time to shape globalization in a way that is worthy of humanity. And this challenge is no less on this side of the Atlantic than on the other side.

In addition to the cognitive and political challenges of our increasingly complex world, there is also, third, a communicative challenge, the transformation of which I have personally observed and experienced over the decades of my political work. If we can only process the complexity of future developments we face with great intellectual and political effort, then it has become all the more difficult to communicate this complexity convincingly in our societies.

How does the picture drawn by sober numbers, that we live today in the historically best of all worlds, reconcile with the subjective feeling of a world gone awry, in which one crisis chases another? How should I weigh the daily horror images from the Middle East or parts of Africa against the undeniable progress in education, health, and poverty alleviation in many countries around the world? What is the Paris Climate Agreement worth for the future of our children in light of the often unsustainable consumption of resources and the devastation caused by an ocean of plastic waste in our world’s oceans?

How, finally, can I reconcile the different traditions, interests, and perceptions of many societies – and their governments – with the standards of our open society, which we want to see realized universally as quickly as possible?

Particularly foreign policy is fundamentally dependent in our open society on there being an understanding in the public for the necessity, for the opportunities, but also for the limits of diplomacy. For the fact that it is not about all-or-nothing, but about balancing conflicting interests. For the fact that differentiating views and compromises do not necessarily mean the abandonment of one’s own standards, but rather the insight into the impossibility of enforcing them now, everywhere, and immediately. For the fact that not every crisis is synonymous with the failure of one’s own policy. The challenge of not only penetrating and politically shaping the complexity of our world but also successfully conveying its contradictions and ambivalences is perhaps greater today than ever. The world is not merely will and imagination, nor is it only black or white. A realistic picture of reality must also acknowledge that there can be conflicts within one’s own politics; between the political emphases and goals we pursue: peace, human rights, security, economic success, alliance solidarity, or disarmament. If we want to negotiate reasonable solutions and also rely on broad societal support, we must succeed in communicating these conflicting goals and the resulting considerations convincingly.

This brings me to the fourth challenge: the rapid change in our communication and our information behavior. The internet gives us access to an unprecedented wealth of information from the most diverse sources. But more than that, it enables hundreds of millions of people to access information that was previously unreachable for them. This represents a significant advancement. At the same time, Henry Kissinger has precisely distinguished in his work "World Order" that this flood of information must not be simply confused with knowledge, and certainly not with wisdom. Knowledge requires verifiable facts and established connections. Wisdom requires experience and judgment. Particularly in the manifestation of many social media, the information machine of the internet, however, provides us with precisely the opposite. A constant rain of information washes away crucial standards of objectivity. At least, that seems to be the case at present.

The crucial aspect of a debate is not always the personal connection to a topic. The personal experience of an individual is an argument, but not the whole truth. If one confuses this, one also believes that a newspaper is lying when it reports something that does not align with personal experiences. This is often the cause of daily outbursts in social media. The mockery, hatred, and harshness of many online comments do not leave our society unscathed, even if they only make up a small part of internet communication and are spread by a minority. They contribute to a radicalization, initially only in speech, but through constant habituation also in thought, leading to a radicalization in our democracies.

In addition, there is the phenomenon of a debate manipulated by technical means or from outside. So-called "trolls," who spread disinformation on behalf of foreign governments, or automated social bots that influence public opinion, achieve the exact opposite of the openness that the pioneers of the World Wide Web hoped for and which was supposed to make the medium enlightening. They deliberately disrupt the open democratic discourse that seeks the best solutions through the use of one's own intellect and the sharp instrument of reason. We must never allow ourselves to be deprived of this democratic discourse, this honest struggle for solutions!

The digital revolution creates endless new possibilities and opportunities. It will bring forth new forms of work and economic activity. To preserve the enormous gain in information openness, we must restore the quality and integrity of public debate. For the mere representation and amplification of moods—whether from individual inclination or from manipulative political interests—is a real danger of our digital age. The price for this is high, too high. The erosion of reason is the beginning of the erosion of democracy. The history of the 20th century, particularly our own, provides ample evidence of this. We have learned from it. But what we have learned must not be destroyed—neither by trolls nor by Twitter messages at a minute's pace.

The digital revolution still promises a historic advance for global civilization, in the unfolding of human creativity and the resolution of social and ecological problems. The power of reason, the conviction that one must strive to redefine the realm of political possibilities for a fairer, more peaceful, better world, and not just stage the moment, is precisely what has connected us across the Atlantic for so long and hopefully will continue to do so. That is why a place like the American Academy in Berlin is so important—not only today but also, and especially, with an eye toward our shared future. Germany needs the transatlantic partnership! Germany wants this partnership! A partnership with close exchange and certainly also passionate debate, but above all founded on mutual trust.

The dimensions of these four challenges—on a global scale, in our own societies, and for each individual—intensify the feeling that our present has become "fragile," to use a word from Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht. The optimism for the future and the expectation of convergence from the time of the fall of the Berlin Wall have faded. The primacy of one's own national interest is coming to the forefront again. A new fascination with authoritarianism is spreading in many places. We must resolutely oppose this temptation—aware of the insights and the great legacy of Fritz Stern.

Reflecting on this leads us, with Fritz Stern, to the question of the future of reason in the digital age. In the answer to this question, I am convinced, lies also the answer to the question of the future of democracy—and the democracy of the future. Let us beware of viewing our form of government as too static. It is not enough to merely describe the status quo defensively. Everything around us is changing. Political systems too. If we want to preserve them, we must also think of democracy in the future.

Conversely, if nationalism is being touted to us today as a model for the future, then our reason can know what that means. We can understand the dynamics that are unleashed when each country considers only itself important, when national interests are pursued without regard for others and at their expense, in a short-sighted and narrow manner.

It is true: politics is not determined solely by reason, but also by emotions, by passions, by struggles over ideas, and by the fight for majorities. Fritz Stern was aware of the fragility of peace and that reason is by no means the only driving force of humanity. However, the legitimate, indeed necessary, political and emotional debate must not abandon reason as a standard. It requires the willingness to doubt, to verify, and to question. There is no shortage of topics for this debate. How should a united Europe be structured? What visions for our continent will be on offer in the European elections at the end of May? Can we renew the promise of Europe for peace, security, and prosperity for the younger generation? What vision can we offer for a digital future that we can look forward to—so that people do not turn back to a merely imagined past? How can participation and representation be shaped in the democracy of the digital age?

I remember the admonition of the wise, old George Shultz during a discussion with me and American scholars at Stanford last year, who, after all the future visions enthusiastically presented by young researchers, simply reminded us at the end of the discussion that all new technologies must also be examined in terms of how they enable political coexistence and democracy in society. A statement, softly spoken—with the authority of age and political experience—that was completely at odds with the rest of the discussion. Many there found deliberative democracy, as we know it, too slow and cumbersome, a kind of Galapagos tortoise. Nevertheless, it remains true: we must not lose patience with democracy. It is a slow, deliberate, but also a sustainable form of government, perhaps the only one that enables and protects freedom.

In the face of growing complexity, we must consciously invest in our judgment and discernment—each of us individually and society as a whole! The overwhelming importance of education for the flourishing of democracy was perhaps the most important insight of Alexis de Tocqueville in his studies on democracy in America nearly 200 years ago. Education needs offerings, needs opportunities, but it also requires the willingness of the individual to make an effort. It is precisely one of the temptations of the modern world to replace a lack of expertise with radical judgments. But political judgment and intellectual effort necessarily belong together in our complicated world. Otherwise, we risk going astray. A sharpened mind is the best insurance against manipulation and susceptibility to manipulation.

Among the institutions that play a crucial role in the fertility of our societal debates and the quality of our judgment are the media. The media landscape is undergoing a dramatic upheaval. But independent professional journalism has a great responsibility for the power of reason in our society. By this, I do not mean those media that fabricate and stage news themselves, but journalism that strengthens the political judgment of our societies through objectivity, contextualization, and foresight.

The contempt for reason, which Fritz Stern feared and which we observe today in many parts of the world and also at home, is a warning signal. That nationalist thinking, which our historical memory still recalls, boasted of the "end of talk," in my language: the termination of dialogue. Critics were only perceived as representatives of a hostile system. Then there is only one's own truth and the lies of others. Fritz Stern insightfully elucidated the disastrous connection between the contempt for reason, indeed a conscious, almost celebrated irrationality by many, and the collapse of German democracy in the 1930s. One is occasionally reminded of this today when listening to the prophets of the shortsighted but enthusiastically celebrated struggle against the so-called "establishment." Only those who know nothing of the catastrophic failure of the authoritarian paths of the past may still consider them a model for the future.

The belief in a better world can move mountains, but only reason can protect us from dangerous detours and missteps. We do not need cultural pessimism, but curiosity and creativity! We need confidence and courage and a precise, scrutinizing gaze that is aware of the power of reason, in order to continually reshape the path to a democratic future in the abundance of our world. From many conversations and encounters, I am confident that we—and the coming generation—will find good answers to the questions. That is why we can also approach this open future with confidence.

To conclude once again with the words of Fritz Stern: "The faith in reason and in the possibilities of human progress seems to have become invalid today, and yet the deepening of our historical experience need not lead to the abandonment of this faith. Rather, it can result in a stronger awareness of the vulnerability of human freedom and an even greater dedication to it." So he wrote over 60 years ago in his introduction to the book "Varieties of History" in remembrance of the catastrophes of the 20th century. So why should we despair today?

Thank you.