Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the 54th German Historians' Day on September 19, 2023, in Leipzig:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

19 September 2023 · Opening of the 54th German Historians' Day · Leipzig, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the 54th German Historians' Day on September 19, 2023, at the Nikolaikirche in Leipzig, marking the anniversary of the 1989 peaceful revolution.
Main themes
Historical knowledge and democracy, peaceful revolution of 1989, role of historians in society, disinformation and post-truth politics, Russian aggression and historical revisionism, history education and teachers, liberal democracy under threat, German identity and memory, science and enlightenment, Eastern European freedom movements
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,820
84th percentile
Sentences
203
89th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
36th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 41%35%
  • Institutional 32%28%
  • Geopolitical 17%14%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 14%

203 sentences in 61 paragraphs

On September 4, 1989, 34 years ago, a banner was displayed here in the courtyard of the church. A banner with a demand that was unheard of at the time: "For an open country with free people," it read. How much courage did the civil rights activist Gesine Oltmanns and her friends have to unfurl this banner! And how much courage did the people here in Leipzig and in many other cities in the former GDR have, who took to the streets every Monday. They rose up against injustice and arbitrariness. They fought for this open country with free people, peacefully and without violence.

It was these brave individuals who brought the wall crashing down back then. They stood up against a state power armed to the teeth, which was feared to use massive violence. We owe it to the courageous of 1989, here in eastern Germany, but also everywhere in Eastern Europe, that our country and our continent were reunited. They made history in democracy!

The Nikolaikirche is a place of German freedom history, and I am very pleased to be here today. Thank you very much for the invitation. As you come together for a historian's day in person for the first time since the pandemic, this is a meeting in difficult times. We are experiencing a time of uncertainty, of insecurity. A time in which a violation of international law has been unleashed in Europe, for the first time since World War II. A time in which we all feel the consequences of this war. A time in which liberal democracies are being challenged, both from the outside and from within.

It is also a time in which science, and also the science of history, must assert and defend itself anew. When facts become fragile, when false claims, even conspiracy theories, can spread rapidly and by the millions; when the line between truth and lies becomes increasingly blurred; when truth is no longer based on rational knowledge, but is a feeling; and when such felt truths increasingly shape political debates: When the past is simply invented, then your task, the work of historians, becomes all the more important.

Reinhart Koselleck once described it this way: "The task of historians is [...] to reconstruct historical truth."

And that is exactly what you do. You investigate facts and provide us with interpretive patterns for history. You help us understand the past; to understand why we have become what we are. And for that, I want to thank you all from the bottom of my heart today.

My thanks also go to the history teachers among you. You all work day in and day out to impart historical knowledge and historical judgment to young people. For a country like Germany, whose identity is so strongly shaped by its recent history, this is indispensable. And this is all the more true as teachers today sometimes personally feel the challenges that our democracy is also facing: When students devalue or even attack people of different skin colors or religions, when they glorify violence or call Hitler a great man. This historian's day is also a place to support teachers who teach freedom and democracy in such situations.

I would like to ask you all today: Do not relent in your offer of orientation! Teach young people to understand and evaluate history. To develop historical consciousness and judgment, your commitment and passion are invaluable. Our entire society needs you!

In a democracy, knowledge of history is not only desirable – it is indispensable: Only with knowledge of the past can we contextualize the events of the present; can we form an opinion; can we recognize longer lines, but also breaks. And especially for us Germans, looking back, the lessons from the past are a constitutive part of our identity.

In short: Historical knowledge is at the core of a democracy. And it is the foundation for active, enlightened participation in democracy.

"History is uncertainty," writes Volkhard Knigge. Not only are facts being re-evaluated, but interpretations also change over time. Historical knowledge is indeed dynamic knowledge. And it must be.

The prerequisite for this is an independent, critical, and also uncomfortable science of history. Sapere aude, this guiding principle of the Enlightenment, prompts us to ask about the why and thus also about the truthfulness of statements. It is democracy that makes critical reflection a public matter.

This distinguishes a democracy from authoritarian regimes, where the argument of power bends; where there is no freedom of science; where no criticism is welcome; where history is often misused and reinterpreted for political purposes.

We only need to look at Russia these days: We see how Putin reinterprets history and is already having history books rewritten. When he disguises the Hitler-Stalin Pact as a peace project, when he places the main blame for World War II on Poland. We see that he slanders Ukraine, with its Jewish president, as a fascist state – that is also his justification for the invasion of an independent, peaceful neighboring country. We see how lies are presented as truth and in Russia it is not allowed to say what is a fact: the war against Ukraine. Putin abuses history as a weapon!

However – and who knows this better than you: History has always been in a field of tension. It has always been the basis of politics – a means of politics and a means of political rhetoric. That history is also reinterpreted and distorted is something we experience not only in authoritarian states but unfortunately also in liberal democracies, and it is not only about the war in Ukraine.

History is very present in our time. These are times of historical power.

Because our liberal democracies in Europe and North America are also being increasingly challenged; because in many countries, right-wing populist or nationalist parties are gaining ground and are increasingly sitting in governments; because political forces are also gaining strength in our democracies that want to deepen the division of our societies, for all these reasons, history, or rather, historians are also coming under greater pressure here with us.

Even in Western liberal democracies, populists attack the freedom of science because historical findings contradict their ideological interpretations of history, their longing for national hero narratives. Even in democracies, scientific events are disrupted, textbooks are censored, critical questions are criminalized, and scientists are deprived of their existence. The only response can be: A clear commitment to the freedom of science! Academic freedom is a constitutive element of liberal democracy. Everywhere!

However, the gaze must also turn to our own country. Even here, there are sometimes attempts – not by the state, but by other influential actors – to intimidate scientists. There are also political forces in our country that deliberately reinterpret history – I say this very clearly here, in the Nikolaikirche: Those who claim the legacy of the Peaceful Revolution of 1989 in the fight against democracy or even call for resistance against an alleged dictatorship in today's Germany are engaging in nothing other than a cynical reinterpretation of history.

Those who speak this way abuse the term resistance! Those who speak this way mock the brave individuals who actually stood up against the SED dictatorship and risked a great deal for it. Those who speak this way also mock all the women and men who actually resisted during the time of National Socialism and who usually paid for it with their lives.

Criticism, dissent, protest: All of this is necessary in a democracy. All of this is legitimate in an open country with free people. But let me say here – especially at this historically significant place – very clearly: Nothing, absolutely nothing justifies equating protest in a democracy with resistance against a dictatorship!

I am not speaking here as a historian, but – it will not surprise you – as the Federal President. This role, this office entails becoming, sooner or later, a subject of historical research, like any head of state. My task is also to provide navigational assistance in the thicket of political everyday life and for the future of our democracy. Engaging with our past is essential for this, as it is a part of us.

That is why I am convinced: The continuous engagement with history is part of self-understanding and self-affirmation in a democracy – and thus, in a way, also part of an enlightened understanding of the office of the Federal President. And every Federal President sets their own accents, which are determined and re-determined by the respective time. Of course, a Federal President cannot and must not impose a view of history from above – this also distinguishes our democracy from authoritarian regimes. And of course, in a democracy, different interpretive patterns of history compete with each other.

This is precisely the noblest legitimacy of our democracy, that it guarantees the freedom of controversy. Those who scorn this freedom or even want to abolish it must have the Federal President against them. For he stands above the parties, yes. But as I said in my inaugural speech six years ago: I will not be impartial when it comes to the matter of democracy!

Especially because our democracy is also being challenged, there can be no other topic for me as Federal President than the state and future of this democracy. And for that, it is important that we are aware of its history.

An important contribution to this is made by the Federal President's History Competition – this year we celebrated its 50th anniversary. It was initiated by one of my predecessors, Gustav Heinemann.

Back then, at the beginning of the 1970s, it was primarily the young people who insisted that our country open itself to a critical engagement with its darkest past. For a long time, far too long, most Germans had refused to confront the civilizational break of the Holocaust. The memory of it, the memory of the victims of National Socialism, of the enormous crimes committed by Germans, this memory is now part of our identity.

Those who today loudly demand an end to the so-called culture of guilt are not only fighting against our culture of remembrance. They are denying a central part of our identity. I say very clearly: The relativization, in some places even mockery, of the Holocaust and its processing is anything but a marginal issue. For what lies behind the tasteless jokes and provocations? Nothing other than the will to dispose of history and to shatter what processing of history means.

There can be no final point under this memory! We owe this to the victims and to ourselves!

And that is why it is important to me, as Federal President, to also commemorate the victims of the Nazi regime at places that have so far hardly been anchored in our collective memory. Places in our neighboring countries like Malyj Trostenez, Fivizzano, Babyn Yar, Paneriai, Korjukiwka, and Chaidari. But also in Germany, such as in Gardelegen, where enormous crimes were committed even in the last days of World War II.

And that is why it is important to me to critically examine the role of the Federal Presidents and their office. What continuities existed before and after 1945? How much were the heads of state engines, brakes, or rather mirrors of societal development? A research project conducted by your colleague Norbert Frei is to provide answers to all of this, and we will present its results in four weeks at Schloss Bellevue, because I believe: Historical responsibility must not end at one's own doorstep!

And precisely because the German democracy of the present has followed the abysses of the Holocaust; because we Germans know that democracy is never secured forever, because our democracy is also under greater pressure, I believe it is also important to make the roots of our democracy even more visible.

Not only ex negativo, not only from the "Never again!" can our identity be grounded in history, but also from the traditions of freedom and democracy that have existed in Germany and to which we should remember with a bit more confidence. I am concerned with breaks, but also with fine and sometimes stronger lines that connect individual events on our long path to democracy. From the Mainz Republic through the Vormärz to the year 1848; from the November Revolution of 1918 through the Weimar Republic to the emergence of the Basic Law.

I am pleased that in Weimar there is now a prominent remembrance of the National Assembly and the beginning of democracy; that the city of Leipzig has established a Robert Blum Democracy Prize; that a new federal foundation to promote the many small "places of democracy history" has begun its work. I am pleased that the Paulskirche in Frankfurt has been rediscovered as the site of the first elected parliament and hopefully can become more attractive if the participants do not lose their courage; that the popular uprising of June 17, 1953, in the GDR is receiving significantly more attention. And I would very much wish that the opposition and resistance in the GDR receive a central and prominent place of remembrance, where what was achieved and happened in so many places in the former GDR in the fight against the SED dictatorship is collected.

Courage for change and the conviction that we have it in our hands to shape the future – that is what the pioneers of democracy have passed on to us, and that is why remembering it is so important to me. I am convinced: When we remember this part of our democracy history, we also strengthen our responsibility for democracy. For history reminds us: Democracy and freedom did not fall from the sky. They were fought for at great cost and desperately defended in the 20th century. Bringing this to consciousness is worth all efforts.

Yes, engaging with history is part of self-understanding in a democracy. This also means that we must continually question ourselves critically. We must also ask new questions. Today, we are a society of many with many, very different backgrounds. And correspondingly diverse and multifaceted is our history. And because history always consists of stories, I know that many stories in our country have not yet been told or are not sufficiently told.

By this, I mean the stories of the people from the east of our country. They have mastered upheavals to an extent that my generation in the West did not know.

I also mean the stories of the so-called guest workers and their children and grandchildren from Turkey, Spain, Italy, Greece, former Yugoslavia, and Portugal, to whom we owe a great deal.

I mean the stories of people from all over Europe and the world who live here today: people from Poland, Bulgaria, and Romania, from France and North America; people from Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, and Syria, recently from Ukraine, who have fled to us from persecution and war.

Many of them are not just guests. If they have been here for a long time, they are a part of us. We have long since become an immigration country, a country with a migration background. And all these stories must become a much stronger part of our shared history – that is also what I mean by critical self-questioning.

And one more thing is part of it: We must also ask ourselves on whose shoulders large parts of Western modernity were built and at what cost. Of course, this question is not directed only at us. But during my travels in African countries, as well as in other countries of the Global South, I have repeatedly experienced how important it is there that we Europeans are willing to engage in a self-critical approach to our history and are also open to addressing our responsibility for colonialism. And I am quite sure: In a few weeks, I will fly to Tanzania, and there too, this topic will reach me again. We cannot evade these questions, because – I have experienced this often enough: at Documenta, at the opening of the Humboldt Forum, and earlier in other responsibilities with the many questions of cultural property restitution – all these questions have long since shaped our debates here. If we want to credibly represent and advocate for our values, especially in the Global South, then we cannot afford any white spots in our self-critical engagement with our history.

But all these questions are not only about our history. They are about our future.

Next year, our Basic Law will turn 75 years old; it has been in effect for our entire country for almost 35 years, and I believe there is good reason to celebrate this day. We can be proud of what we have achieved with this second democracy in Germany!

The years after the fall of the Wall and the gift of reunification were a time of tailwind for us Germans. They were – despite all the crises – years in which we succeeded in many things. But it looks like we now have years of headwind ahead of us. We must now ask ourselves: Where do we stand as a country, as a society in a time when we are challenged and called upon like never before? In which such enormous tasks await us? The consequences of the pandemic, the war in Ukraine, the fight against climate change, the transformation of our industry towards climate neutrality, the pressure on our democracies: Mastering all these challenges will demand a lot from us in the coming years. I believe it also raises the question of what kind of country we want to be in the future.

February 24, 2022, has swept away some certainties of the last decades. "The era of totalitarianism has brought misfortune to Europe. In Europe, no civilized country can solve problems with violence anymore," said former Polish Foreign Minister Władysław Bartoszewski in 2005. It was the hope of a great politician who survived Auschwitz. It was the hope of many, including my hope, of all those who worked to ensure that this does not happen again: that Europe does not fall back into a time of hatred and violence. But that is exactly what has happened. Putin has placed himself outside the community of civilized states with this attack on a peaceful, democratic neighboring country.

For us Germans, this February 24 has made it very clear that we must do much more than in the past decades to protect and defend our democracy. And by that, I do not only mean defense against external threats. That too. But I also mean the innermost core of our democracy.

Our Basic Law is based on the experience that the first German democracy was deliberately destroyed by its enemies and ultimately was not strong enough to defend itself against these enemies. Never again should democratic freedoms be misused to abolish freedom and democracy, that has guided the mothers and fathers of the Basic Law. And they have enshrined strong instruments to ensure that our democracy can be resilient.

But are we still so sure that exactly that cannot happen, that freedom and democracy can not only be attacked from within democracy but can even be endangered?

When I speak here today, I must also mention that this danger concerns me. I am worried that the tone in many debates is becoming increasingly sharp and irreconcilable, that hatred and incitement are increasing, and the willingness to engage in conversation is decreasing. That the boundaries of what can be said are shifting further towards the unspeakable.

Is this really the country we want to be?

I wish for a country that – despite all the difficulties and challenges we face – trusts in its strength and power.

I wish for a country in which the people who live here are aware of how precious our democracy and our freedom are – and that democracy and freedom are not self-evident and never guaranteed for eternity.

I wish for a country in which parties, politicians, and political leaders tirelessly, but also passionately advocate for our democracy and our freedom and propose solutions for obvious problems.

I wish for a country in which every individual takes responsibility for our democracy. A country in which every voter is also aware of the responsibility they have on election day when casting their vote. No one can excuse themselves if they strengthen the contemptors of democracy with their vote.

And there are those people who are engaged in and for democracy. I recently had the pleasure of hosting thousands of people at the citizens' festival who do just that: who advocate for their neighborhood, for their village, their city, for our country. And I know there are many, millions, who do this! They are the great, strong backbone of our democracy. And: They are the great majority. We must strengthen them, we must support them. Let us give a voice to the many quiet ones against the few loud ones!

Let us engage in debates, let us also argue when it comes to finding solutions for the enormous challenges we face. This is not only possible in a democracy. It is necessary! But let us do it with fairness, and yes, also with decency! And let us not forget that in a democracy, decisions must be supported by a majority – and that we must not leave the weaker behind. There is no other way, no matter how laborious that may sometimes be.

But let us be vigilant and determined when boundaries are crossed. Let us not look away when elected council members and mayors are intimidated and threatened, withdrawing. Let us not look away when teachers are bullied and intimidated, driven out of their city because they have publicly exposed swastika graffiti or racist slogans at their school. Let us not allow people to become victims of racism, anti-Semitism, and inhumanity!

Vigilant democrats: They are the best protection of our democracy! That is the country I wish for, and I will do everything I can to contribute to it!

One thing is essential for this: That we trust in the power of reason, in the power of facts, in the power of argument. In short: in a reason that is based on the values of human dignity, justice, and truth. On values that are universal. And for that, we need you, ladies and gentlemen, we need a critical, enlightening, independent science. And let us use your results for critical and self-critical thinking!

"Whoever thinks does not want to be persuaded, but to be convinced," said Victor Klemperer.

So let us not give up our efforts to convince. Not politics and not historical science. Historical science is enlightenment. Enlightenment is the lifeblood of democracy. Be enlighteners! Fight for the valuable legacy of enlightenment! Then you will also fight for democracy!