Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the 21st Donaueschingen Regional Discussion on September 15, 2023, in Donaueschingen:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

17 September 2023 · 21st Donaueschingen Regional Discussion · Donaueschingen, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the 21st Donaueschingen Regional Discussion on September 15, 2023, warning civic and business leaders about threats to German democracy from within.
Main themes
Democracy under threat, right-wing extremism, populism, political violence against public servants, social cohesion, civic responsibility, dissatisfaction and anger, division in society, withdrawal from civic engagement, fear and uncertainty, local and regional politics, German society
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,745
84th percentile
Sentences
204
89th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%35%
  • Social 31%29%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

204 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Indeed, I should have been here two years, three years ago. And I just realized when I came here: The pandemic is no longer here, but those who deny it are. You can hear election campaign speeches at the moment in Bavaria and Hesse. In Saxony, Thuringia, and Brandenburg, the campaigners are ready to go. Today, I have brought you a rather contemplative speech that hopefully provides us with material for subsequent discussion. Observations, I say this upfront, that not everyone must share, but that we need to exchange views on.

To begin with, I want to say: I am very pleased to be here with you this evening. I do not say this as a cliché, but from the bottom of my heart, as I look around the room. Because I see many people who take responsibility, who work hard, and who keep this country running. Many of you are involved in local and state politics or volunteer in associations, you run medium-sized businesses and craft enterprises. In short: The middle of society has come here today. I am very happy about that. It’s great to have you here!

Here in the southwest, I know this, economic success and community spirit are at home, here pragmatism meets innovation, here world market leaders live and work with love for their homeland. And when you look around, you might think: In this country, everything is in perfect order.

But, if you will excuse the harsh contrast, this is also reality: Last year, more than four hundred weapons were seized from the hands of extremists right here in Baden-Württemberg. In this state alone, more than a thousand public employees fell victim to violence last year – this includes staff in hospitals and job centers, teachers, police officers, firefighters, and paramedics. A mayor has a gallows placed in her garden because someone disagrees with a development plan. Municipal council members receive feces in their mailboxes because they allegedly voted incorrectly. And of course, we see all of this in other federal states as well. Only, you will agree, that does not make it any better. Just recently, right-wing extremists attempted to intimidate a presiding judge in a trial against alleged members of a right-wing extremist martial arts group via video. And not long ago, a teacher and a male teacher at a school in the Spreewald in Brandenburg were driven out not only from the school but also from their place of residence after continued threats from right-wing extremists.

This is also our country. Unfortunately! And this sounds like isolated cases. Bad enough. But it is about much more! These are small and large attacks on our coexistence, on our democracy. And we must take this more seriously than we occasionally do!

For even though our society is strong, and you are all proof of that: I believe the danger has rarely been greater that our democracy is challenged and attacked from within.

The question is: What is actually changing? Why are we experiencing things that have long been foreign to the political culture in this country, thank goodness? Why are the previously recognized boundaries between what can be said and what cannot be said shifting – and not just in social media? We need to take a closer look at what is driving us apart – and what, out of dissatisfaction, is apparently turning into anger for many and, in extreme cases, leading to hatred. I want to talk about three things first: populism, division, and withdrawal.

And I will start with ourselves. Who does not know it: that impulse when nothing is moving forward and no one knows why. Almost everyone must have felt the desire at some point to eliminate the complex problems, the entrenched issues, the contradictory regulations, the whole thicket, the grown confusion, once and for all. A completely understandable impulse.

And I can imagine, Mr. Pauly, what not only you, but also the mayors are hearing on their marketplaces. The entrepreneurs in their businesses too. The employees from their colleagues. And indeed, it is true: In recent years, one crisis has followed another, many people have very concrete worries. And they are asking themselves: Will I still be able to pay my bills soon, how expensive will heating be next winter? Is something fundamentally out of balance if rents continue to rise, if no one wants to become a teacher anymore, or at least too few do, if the healthcare system is groaning under overload, or – it is obvious – if we are lacking skilled workers everywhere? These are legitimate questions, I want to tell you. But beyond that, something is building up that is more than just a grumbling against Berlin. A mixture of fear and quiet anger is growing, and you can sometimes experience this mixture in the marketplaces. Is the state going to prohibit me tomorrow from watering my garden, going on vacation, or having a steak from the grill with my friends? Populists stir up these fears, exploit them, oversimplify connections, or spread false statements – always with the aim of gaining political capital from it. This culminates in wild assumptions – I believe they are also being exchanged out there in front of the hall – that perhaps politics is pursuing a grand, secret plan to the detriment of its own population. The thesis of a grand conspiracy is quickly at hand. And you know, and it is an experience: Populists always triumph when people are worried.

You remember an election campaign seven years ago in the USA that left us dumbfounded, and a Trump presidency that, for a short time, alienated Europe and the USA – and that was my and our concern. Perhaps, I say this not for the first time, we in Germany have believed for too long that we are the better democracies, believed for too long that our history has taught us once and for all not to fall for simple answers, not to look for scapegoats. The reality that I have just sketched out in a few strokes forces us to rethink this. In a society that is under pressure to change, it seems that even today the simplest of all reflexes is the search for simple solutions and supposedly guilty parties. And they are quickly found: sometimes it is federalism – when we talk about education – sometimes the parties, sometimes coalitions, sometimes their representatives, or even the entire “elite” from politics and business that is to blame. There is a great longing for the one lever that we just need to pull to overcome all challenges. Populists cater to this longing. They deceive us into believing that there is this one lever. The elected politicians are just too stupid to use it.

You know as well as I do: The reality in a pluralistic society with a multitude of different, sometimes opposing interests is more complicated. Populists open a valve for anger and fear; they are not interested in concrete solutions. Anyone who looks closely can see that populists are never part of the solution-finding process. That requires patience, persistence, and the willingness to make compromises. Populism never helps us to move forward and come together. Populism regularly seeks answers to the questions of the future in the past. And that is not how we win the future!

Now I must caution, do not misunderstand me: I do not want to advise anyone to swallow their dissatisfaction. On the contrary. Yes, one is entitled to be dissatisfied at any time with what a government decides. Also with what it does not decide. And one can rightly expect those responsible to explain their decisions. That is to say: Not every critical question is already irresponsible populism. But the important thing is: Do not allow anyone to exploit your dissatisfaction to incite general resentment against “those up there.” Not only because you here in the hall – most of you, at least – are always included when “those up there” are talked about at the regulars' table. Once the authority of democratic institutions and the respect for democratic processes have been undermined and discredited, then, I am quite sure, elections with different majorities will hardly be able to change anything. My urgent plea is: Let us speak responsibly about a democracy that has supported us for seventy-five years, with which we have overcome crises, achieved reunification, and shaped Europe.

And this applies on both a large and small scale: There are reasons for dissatisfaction, but we should not dwell in it. Let us formulate demands instead of punitive measures. Let us discuss it. Wherever possible: with each other and less against each other.

Let us not allow a few to destroy democracy for us. We do not have a second one. And let us always remember: Democracy is never final, democracy is always in the making, but above all, it is not guaranteed for eternity. However, it is the only form of government that can correct itself. Autocratic systems cannot do that; autocracies “cannot err” or draw conclusions from mistakes. Democracy, however, does not live from the paragraphs of the Basic Law, but it lives from the will and commitment of its citizens.

The persistence with which you have created prosperity here in the southwest, continually creating a new future – let us use this persistence throughout our country to solve the problems of our time. Democracy needs all of you. And therefore, my plea: Get involved! Let us stand together against the simplifiers, with the answers that simplifiers do not have! I am glad to have you by my side in this.

Our country is strong, also because it is so diverse. Many came here in the 1960s and 1970s from Southern Europe as so-called guest workers, many foreign students study at the universities in the country, and refugees, most recently particularly from Ukraine, have joined. All the strong companies in your country have decades of experience in utilizing the diverse experiences of people in the country to their advantage. And yet, our open society also brings stress: new role models, traditions under pressure, minorities demanding their place, different value systems clashing. This is exhausting for each of us.

Some respond with understanding and compassion, others with isolation, devaluation, and resentment. And without a doubt, we must finally come to an understanding in Europe about how to manage migration to Europe in such a way that the overload of individual countries and thus also of municipalities in Germany is avoided. And it is cynical that some countries still refuse the fair regulation we are seeking. But it is also unacceptable that people with a migration background who are here are being exploited to vent dissatisfaction that may have its source elsewhere. At the very least, it is striking that protests are sometimes very loud where the proportion of people with a migration background is extremely low. On Saturday, I will speak at an Islamic cultural center in Cologne, and I could already write down what unbearable hate speech you will see on my Instagram account over the weekend.

And I know, because I am often on the move: Even in our parliaments, from the municipal council to the Bundestag, some unspeakable things have become sayable. Since the Corona pandemic and the dispute over vaccination, much has changed in our country. There, agitators also vilify our democracy in city council meetings as a “system,” as an “unjust regime,” or – I have heard it! – even “dictatorship.” The culture of remembrance, which has become part of our national self-understanding, is being attacked, and an end to the “cult of guilt” is being newly propagated. But also: Entire groups are being vilified or attempted to be intimidated.

I am concerned about this linguistic and sometimes also intellectual coarsening: When it suddenly becomes common to speak ill of minorities, when children in our schools are referred to as “headscarf girls,” and when aggressive envy and resentment are expressed towards Ukrainian refugee families, it opens the door to hatred and incitement. And a climate in which extremists seek justification for violent acts – see Halle, Hanau, Walter Lübcke.

But many local politicians also know what I am talking about. The right to demonstrate is being abused to put local politicians under massive pressure by stalking them to their private homes and threatening them there – as was the case in Altenburg, where hundreds of demonstrators rang the mayor's doorbell and his children sat upstairs in fear and terror. Here, assembly authorities must exhaust all possibilities to protect people, to protect those in positions of responsibility and their families. And even in the municipal council, when verbal boundaries are crossed, others must stand together across party lines and raise their voices. Each of these examples may not seem dangerously alarming in isolation. But not everyone has thick skin. And not everyone is strong enough to withstand these attacks. And some, whom we need in local politics, have withdrawn. What I want to say is: When extremists get a foot in the door of democracy in this way, they can and will spread in our midst.

Those who speak with hatred do not help democracy, but rather hatred. Those who portray the political opponent as an enemy have no other intention than to silence others. Those who spread fake news do so to advance their own interests; they want to prevent society from finding compromises that as many people as possible can live with. Those who divide want to destroy the cohesion that has always made our country strong – not just in Donaueschingen.

These are not new insights. We have all known this together. But perhaps we need to remember again what has made us strong: commitment and engagement, self-confidence, initiative, optimism, and the ability to look beyond our own plate.

As different as we may be: The idea that there is something common beyond different individual interests, a common interest – that is actually always the key to coexistence in democracy. And you here in Donaueschingen know this from your everyday life: This coexistence is, especially in times of skilled labor shortages and the race for innovation, also a prerequisite for our economic prosperity. So, my conclusion from this: Let us strengthen everything that connects us!

What we need is a strong center that speaks up. Right here in this hall, there is so much life experience, so much expertise, so much wisdom and skill gathered with all of you. Let us lift this treasure, and raise your voice – we need you urgently.

I can understand that this request does not only evoke enthusiasm. Most have enough to do with the worries of their own lives, their families, their children, their jobs. Many lack the time and energy to participate in discussions that feel like they last forever and usually lead to too little. Some prefer to remain silent now because they worry about whether they will find the right words or whether they will end up on the digital pillory for a linguistic misstep. And who wants to engage in a political discussion when conflict and chaos dominate, when we allow a few loud voices to drown out the many quiet ones?

I talk a lot about democracy at the local level because we all sense: Democracy grows from the bottom up. We need young people, we also need women who are willing to take on responsibility in the municipalities and invest time and effort for it. And the older generation could say: It is worth it! Not only for democracy but also for broadening one's own horizons. Having to look at things from multiple perspectives, balancing legitimate interests, forging compromises – that also prepares one for life. It takes you further, I believe.

And if it is not a mandate in the municipal council, it can also be a volunteer position. Many organizations, clubs, and initiatives are already complaining about a lack of new recruits. The millions of engaged individuals are the true backbone of our democracy; we need this stable backbone of volunteers more urgently than ever for the future. And because this is the case, I have brought the idea of a social obligation period into the discussion. I am pleased that the debate is ongoing. Those who always respond to all this, to the call for engagement and participation, with "What does it matter to me?" must unfortunately be answered: "What does it matter to me?" – this sentence is actually not a democratic sentence. Democracy can only function if it is the concern of all! And indifference, as we know, is the greatest enemy of democracy. That is why I am traveling a lot across the country. That is why I go with my format "Local Time" for three days to smaller and medium-sized cities; I have already been to Rottweil with Ralf Broß, immersing myself deeply in the local conversation during this "Local Time," talking to people, discussing, and advocating for respect for democracy with all its shortcomings. And I advocate for engagement so that we can improve what is not yet good. What I say during the "Local Times," I also say here: Let us support those who stand up for our society! Let us drown out the loudmouths with the many different voices of a strong, successful society that stands together. This is our shared responsibility in these times; it is also the responsibility of a strong center that does not allow our democracy to be talked down!

With this, I also say: Not only the governing bodies at the state and federal levels, but also citizens bear their share of responsibility for our democracy. But a glance into this hall is enough, and I know: We have reason to be optimistic!

Yes, we live in a time of many consecutive crises: the global financial crisis of 2008/2009, the euro crisis from 2011 onwards, the arrival of one million refugees in 2015/2016, then the pandemic; and the pandemic was not yet over when the Russian war of aggression began, followed by price increases and all the economic impacts that have already been mentioned. And on top of that, all the future tasks, the climate-friendly transformation of our economy and society, the digital renewal, the demographic change. Great tasks lie ahead, indeed, to get our country back on the path of growth. Great tasks that particularly challenge many important sectors of our country, which also cost money and are above all laborious.

Regaining sufficient growth is not a given. But shouldn't we approach these tasks with a bit more self-confidence? Just a reminder: We started the millennium with almost six million unemployed. The burden of financing unemployment completely took away the room for maneuver for future tasks; we had almost lost our international competitiveness. We freed ourselves from this essential crisis as well. And it was followed by a decade and a half of tailwind that made much possible, including creating reserves for later crises, through which we fared better than many of our European neighbors. The tailwind is gone, yes. Now we face years of headwinds. This is harder. And the economic situation is certainly not easy. But those of you who sail know: Sometimes you cannot change the wind, but you have to set the sails correctly.

And the good thing is: We have a vision of what our society can and must look like in the future. Our country in the heart of Europe should be climate-neutral by the middle of the century – and at the same time, we want to remain a strong industrial nation, technologically leading and globally connected, but also more resilient and less vulnerable. And that is why many are already working to reduce one-sided dependencies on other countries and suppliers. We are utilizing digital progress and ensuring that we keep pace with artificial intelligence. I am sure: Many of the companies here in Donaueschingen have already set out on this path.

How we can achieve this transformation must be the focus of our political debate. About concrete solutions, about technical innovations, about how we can and want to change our lives. "Workshop of Change" is the name of a series with which I visit examples of successful transformation – throughout Germany. Whether it is green steel in the west at Thyssen in Duisburg or electromobility in the east at VW in Zwickau, the entire spectrum from mechanical engineering to AI here in Baden-Württemberg – our technological basis for change is there. We must not, and the companies know this, lose sight of the people on this path, including those who are uncertain or still have doubts. Because it is also clear: We will only succeed in this enormous change – in modern terms: transformation – if everyone truly has something to gain.

These challenges demand a completely new kind of agility from each and every one of us. On this path to new horizons, we must be capable of multiple changes. Here in the southwest, I see that we can do this. Because in the many small, medium, and not-so-small companies that exist here, this has long been lived. Here, where many world market leaders have been leading the ranking of patent applications in our country for years. Here, it is also known: Those who want to succeed with their product must constantly strive to improve and modernize it, not only the product but also the processes. Seen this way, you actually carry the idea of permanent renewal in your DNA. Therefore, may I ask you: Help carry this willingness to change, which is lived here, and also the confidence in our society!

We need not fear that our country would be unable to master the transformation. We have so much technical know-how, engineers, and skilled workers – we should know which steps we need to take in the right direction.

And I am firmly convinced: Only democracy is flexible enough for us to master this change and this transformation. Because especially in times of great upheaval, when we need new answers to new challenges, we need debate, competition, also criticism, and the possibility of self-correction. And: Only if you also participate will good solutions for all emerge in the end. My message remains, and I say this in conclusion: The future is not fate. Let us make something of it! And if possible: Together!