Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the Congress on Poverty and Health on March 21, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

28 March 2023 · Congress on Poverty and Health · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the Congress on Poverty and Health on March 21, 2023, in Berlin, speaking on the link between social inequality and health outcomes in Germany.
Main themes
Poverty and health inequality, social determinants of health, welfare state challenges, life expectancy gaps by income, child health in disadvantaged families, preventive healthcare access, homelessness and health, social cohesion and democracy, housing and education as health factors, regional inequality in Germany
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,814
52nd percentile
Sentences
86
56th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 60%60%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

86 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Actually, we Germans are lucky! After years of division, we live reunited in one country again. In every post-war decade, child mortality in our country has decreased. Life expectancy continues to rise in Germany, and with it, of course, the chance for all of us to experience a long and active retirement after our working lives. Unemployment has fallen sharply over the past two decades, social insurance employment has risen significantly, and wages and pensions have also increased for several consecutive years. So I could say: Compared to other regions of the world, we are doing well on average. But when I say on average, it also means: not for everyone.

Yes, we are a wealthy country. Probably no generation in our country has ever had it better. For many, many things are taken for granted: their own four walls, for some their own house, the car, the vacation, perhaps even a second one, even a long-distance trip. And most have earned all of this through their work.

I myself was born in the mid-1950s, raised in conditions that were once called simple circumstances. I have witnessed how prosperity has grown over many decades. I am pleased that many in our country are doing well and that this is also visible.

The problem is not that; the problem is that many do not want to see how many are worse off. This poverty we are talking about is visible, and not just at food banks or in homeless shelters. It is visible in regions that have been left behind, in neglected neighborhoods, and often already in kindergartens and elementary schools. Not only clothing, but also dental health often reveals social background. In socially disadvantaged areas, forty percent of children of kindergarten age have crooked teeth and advanced dental caries. In general, these are the first signs of the overall realization: Those who grow up in poverty have worse health as adults.

That there is a connection between social status and health has long ceased to be a matter of mere speculation. Here, before this audience, this requires no detailed proof. But the larger public in Germany is hardly aware that in population groups particularly affected by poverty, the risk of stroke is two to three times higher, and mortality from cancer and liver diseases is significantly above the average population level. The Robert Koch Institute has shown in a study that individuals with low income, who are at risk of poverty – that is, those who have less than sixty percent of the median income available – have a significantly lower life expectancy: four years less for women, eight years less for men.

The health inequality expressed in these numbers – that is the challenge for our welfare state. It touches not only our sense of justice but also the cohesion of society and thus what is the foundation and prerequisite for any successful democracy.

It is good that public health and social medicine have been paying significantly more attention to the individual status of people in poverty and the societal consequences for some time now and that they are also finding public recognition for it. And we owe this increased interest the indication that the distinction between absolute and relative poverty cannot provide a false sense of security. Income remains a still central category for describing a person's social status. But in truth, when we talk about the connection between poverty and health, we are talking about a multifaceted underprovision that, of course, concerns income, but no less importantly: housing, education, working conditions, technical and social infrastructure, everything that determines life at the place of residence. And the crucial point is: For the poor in our society, much of this comes together at the same time.

In any case, we know that, for example, unemployed people participate in preventive examinations and health promotion measures much less frequently than employed individuals. We know that children from socially disadvantaged families participate significantly less in regular examinations regarding their health and development status. As I have read: Only 29 percent of children from these poor families are still presented for the U9 examination, which is the examination just before starting elementary school. I know the reasons may vary widely. But it is quite obvious that the existing structures, from family counseling to youth services to health departments, have so far not been able to make significant changes. How a better integration of all the agencies in contact with families can succeed – I am sure you will also discuss this at this congress.

Let us take a step further: While poverty generally leads to a higher morbidity and mortality risk, the loss of one's own home almost certainly results in health damage. Those who lose the protection of their own home not only become ill but often also remain without a doctor. Gerhard Trabert will certainly report more on this shortly. He cites scientific studies indicating that ninety percent of homeless people not only have inadequate medical care but are also in urgent need of treatment according to normal standards. And the low density of doctors in poorer neighborhoods cannot be the sole reason; it is certainly not the decisive reason. For many, the threshold, and this is more my assumption, for accessing public and state assistance on the social ladder downwards is becoming increasingly higher. For an unknown but presumably large number of homeless people, health insurance coverage has been lost. For the homeless, who actually sleep on the street and perhaps occasionally in shelters, there is fundamentally a lack of treatment options in many places.

I know and have looked at how infinitely difficult it is to pave the way back into health insurance for people without insurance coverage. And you will certainly also exchange ideas here today about what solutions for this still eminently important problem might look like, how to bring help to those who do not seek medical treatment on their own initiative or who have no means to do so. Where the levers are in the structures, where improvements can be made, I am sure you will make suggestions.

In any case, I want to take this opportunity today, which is also why I am here, to thank all those who are professionally, but many also voluntarily, engaged in health care for the poor in our society everywhere in our country. I have seen various models in different places where general life assistance, debt counseling, medical care, and much more are offered from a single source, from outreach acute care, if I may call it that, to special consultation hours for uninsured individuals to expanded practice models. And for most models, it is true that they generally operate under precarious financing conditions.

I suspect that all of you here in the hall care about the health of poorer people in our society; in offices and institutions, in science and research, in local social projects. You care about children from low-income families, about single parents, about people without permanent housing, about refugees without papers, and many others.

You look where the spotlight rarely shines. Where people do not stand on the sunny side of life. And that is why I am happy to have come to make your demanding, difficult, unfortunately necessary work more visible – above all, to say thank you. Therefore: Thank you very much for your work and your commitment!

What you do must not escape our attention in times when war is also reshaping political priorities; in times when investments to protect our planet are becoming increasingly urgent. We cannot and do not want to question either, but it is also true: Our welfare state must remain strong and capable. In shorter terms: Social policy is democracy policy. Only a societal model that attempts to create cohesion under ever-changing conditions, a state that does not overlook the voice of the poorest and most vulnerable, only such a state and such a policy will find lasting acceptance.

We will have to better protect our country from external dangers, we will have to accelerate the path to climate-neutral economies. But in the midst of this time of great upheaval, we must also remember something I said a year ago in my speech at the Federal Assembly: We will only succeed in the necessary change in society if even the weakest have something to gain. Only as a social country will our democracy remain stable.

Are there actually reasons for optimism? I do not want to sugarcoat anything. But since I have spoken about children from low-income families, I want to return to that at the end. Because the foundations are laid very early in life for a successful life, for later social, economic, and health status, we must not miss any opportunities at the beginning of life. In the coming years until 2035, the labor market may have more than seven million fewer people available. Even now, young people are desperately sought in almost all vocational training professions. Rarely have the conditions for entering a professional career, where one can secure one's own income from work and thus fend off poverty, been as good as they are now.

Against this backdrop, it is disturbing, concerning, but above all unacceptable that so many young people still leave school without a diploma or sometimes even with a diploma do not meet the requirements for learning a profession. So much depends on the starting opportunities for life after school: self-esteem, social status, income, and, which is why we are here, also health.

Those who want better health conditions for low-income individuals must therefore start here. So: seek improvements so that as many children as possible are presented for early detection examinations in pediatric medicine from the very beginning and regularly. We need prevention, intensive counseling, and support for identifiable health disorders and developmental delays. We need investments in an education system that leaves no child behind, does not send anyone into life without a diploma, and prepares them for a life of their own.

I admit: These are not entirely new insights. Rudolf Virchow already stated 170 years ago: "Education, prosperity, and freedom are the only guarantees for the lasting health of a people." Striving for that should actually be a matter of course for the welfare state of the 21st century.

Social policy is democracy policy, I said. And by the way, that is why our social insurances also have a democratic element. In the social elections, which will take place again this year in pension, health, and accident insurance, many hopefully will participate and actually assert their claim to co-determination. My thanks go to all the volunteers who make and organize these elections possible.

I wish your congress lively debates, fruitful exchanges, and above all, public recognition of your discussions! In this sense: Good luck and thank you very much!