Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the event series "Bellevue Forum on the Future of Democracy" on the topic "What Future Does the West Have?" on the 19th ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

22 September 2017 · Bellevue Forum on the Future of Democracy · Bellevue Palace, Germany

Context
Steinmeier opened the inaugural 'Bellevue Forum on the Future of Democracy' in Berlin on 22 September 2017, addressing the question of the West's future with scholars including Heinrich August Winkler.
Main themes
Future of Western liberal democracy, rise of authoritarianism and populism, open society and its foundations, German unity and post-1989 euphoria, transatlantic world and the West, democratic discourse and free speech, nationalist-populist movements, challenges to rule of law and human rights, historical uncertainty and political change
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,917
74th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 33%32%
  • Geopolitical 28%28%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

148 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Dear Professor Winkler,

It feels like just yesterday, and – I checked again – it was only two and a half years ago that you invited me to present the fourth and final volume of your "History of the West." I remember the discussion and know that we came to the conclusion together: Somehow, this country has arrived in the West, after many delays and detours. It is accepted by the transatlantic world with all its rights and obligations.

Not much time has passed since then, and yet everything seems different today: Neither of us would have expected at that time that soon a new book from your pen would be due with a worrying title that your readers probably least expected from you: "Is the West Breaking Apart?"

You will soon provide the first answer to that, but I would like to warmly welcome all of you first. Especially – alongside Professor Winkler – our guests and discussion partners Susan Neiman and Parag Khanna. Together with you, we want to open the "Forum Bellevue for the Future of Democracy" this evening, and I would like to extend a warm welcome to all of you.

This marks the beginning of a series of discussions that is very dear to me in these times when old certainties are increasingly lost. In this series – over the next two years or so – it will not primarily be about current political issues, although we cannot ignore them, as will become evident in the discussion. Above all, however, it will be about the question that moves all politics: How do we preserve the foundations of an open society? How do we maintain the conditions for the success of liberal democracy?

We all know: The epochal upheavals of 1989 and 1990 did not mean the end of history, even if some wanted to predict that at the time and some hoped for it. I looked again at the wonderful speech by Richard von Weizsäcker at the state ceremony for German unity on October 3, 1990. Anyone who reads this speech today can feel how great the euphoria was back then. The happiness of the Germans, finally united in peace and freedom, was closely linked to the hope that freedom and democracy would now spread radially in all directions around the world.

"Wherever the urge for political freedom, for performance and dignified social welfare breaks through – even to the heart of Beijing –," von Weizsäcker said at the time, "the values and rules of Western democracies form the model against which everyone measures themselves."

I am not so sure how much today’s China actually measures itself against the USA or today’s Europe. In any case, these euphoric words today, just 27 years later, sound like a report from a distant world. Today, we are painfully aware almost daily that freedom, the rule of law, and human rights are not self-evident – obviously not even where they seemed to be established. We realize that historical achievements can be lost again if their foundations become fragile. Not the end of history, but its openness, its uncertainty is the theme that occupies us these days and which we want to explore together this evening.

For some time now, we have been experiencing how the principles of an open society and liberal democracy are being called into question, sometimes ridiculed or challenged, far to the west and east of European borders, but – that is the whole truth – also here in Europe. Some societies appear to be infected by the fever of authoritarianism. Nationalist-populist movements are on the rise, inciting hatred and spreading enemy images. Democratic states are being deformed. Recently, representatives of "authoritarian" or "illiberal" democracies have presented themselves with a strong awareness of power – sharply distinguishing themselves from the liberal democratic model. Even intellectuals who question democracy as such – I only think of the American philosopher Jason Brennan with his book "Against Democracy" – manage to make it onto bestseller lists in Germany.

There is no reason for alarmism in our country. Our democracy is stable. But we also see these days how politicians are loudly booed, insulted, or pelted with objects at campaign events.

I want to make it clear: The free exercise of the right to vote naturally includes the free competition of parties before the federal elections. Sharpness in controversy is allowed and, in the decisions that need to be made, even required. We need competition of opinions and political offerings – in speech and counter-speech and, above all, without intimidation and violence. This is an achievement of our political culture that we can be proud of. Tomatoes and whistles are not a means to higher understanding in democratic discourse, and earaches are not a sign of a successful controversy.

Anyone who only goes to rallies to prevent others from speaking is turning against the open debate that they demand. And anyone who wants to intimidate journalists with threats is clearly not interested in arguments. Especially those who are angry and of a different opinion should take the floor themselves instead of wanting to silence others. In Germany – unlike what some want to make us believe – there are no taboos, no bans on speech in political discourse, at least as long as the line to insult, incitement to hatred, and violence is not crossed.

Everyone has the right to public speech. No one is threatened with imprisonment for critical opinions. But still, I want to insist on one point: It does no harm to listen to people who represent a different position with good – or even less good – arguments. It is a good part of the political culture in Germany that we, despite all differences of opinion and all conflicts of interest, have not questioned the legitimacy of political competition, because so far no party has claimed to embody the people as a whole or to speak in the name of the people.

And yet we must ask ourselves where the anger comes from that is breaking out in some places. We are also experiencing in Germany how populists exploit disappointments and insecurities. Some people feel unrepresented or have doubts that our state can solve the truly burning problems. Some have lost trust in democratic processes and institutions, including the media. Others express open contempt and hostility towards parties and politicians, not just during election campaigns. There are also those who have "simply gotten used to believing in a world without politics" – Christoph Möllers described and diagnosed this wonderfully some time ago in "Merkur." I say: Not everyone who distances themselves is an enemy of democracy. But they all are missing from democracy.

Last but not least, we are witnessing how the democratic discourse is changing, especially through the internet and social media. In times of filter bubbles and echo chambers, fewer and fewer citizens seem to be talking about the same things. Hate messages and comments contribute to the polarization of the public. The spread of fake news has led some to the impression that everything is a lie anyway. Others confuse politics with nonsense and think that it is all about the most original tweet. Or about being as shrill, loud, or disrespectful as possible.

So much for the description. And yet: If some now say with an indifferent shrug, "everything is going down the drain anyway," I can find nothing in that attitude. This does not mean at all that we democrats should rest on our laurels, rely on what has worked in the past, and confidently trust that everything will somehow turn out well. There is no reason for excessive calm. Yes, politics must fill the perceived gaps; it must not dismiss where answers to pressing questions are simply open. But it is also true: We, the citizens, must confidently take care of democracy and also learn again to fight for it.

Those who are disappointed with democracy once expected something from it. And perhaps many people are disappointed because their expectations are high, perhaps too high for some. I see it this way: Democracy is not a promise of salvation and does not provide final answers. It is rule for a time, and it delivers solutions for a time. It stands for continuous questioning, for self-criticism, and – I believe, ultimately as the only political system in the world – also for self-correction. Democracy is a political learning process. And therein lies, especially in times of change, the real reason for its strength. Precisely because democracy is always unfinished and open-ended, it can find answers to new questions that arise from the radical breaks of our time.

Many social, cultural, and technological changes are reaching the roots of our society. Digitalization is leading to the breakthrough of autonomous systems that replace human labor and control larger parts of our daily lives without us having to make conscious decisions. Artificial intelligence and biotechnological design are putting the Enlightenment's image of humanity to the test. Globally available prosperity is increasing, but at the same time, inequality is growing in most societies. Social contrasts have not disappeared. And the wealth gap is a major cause of migration – we have experienced this in the past three years. Migration, in turn, changes our society. Cultural identity in the singular can no longer be preserved. Cultural plurality as a hallmark of global modernity is certainly a gain, but it is also a challenge.

Instead of staying on the surface, we democrats should direct our gaze to these deeper upheavals of our time. This is a risk. Because for many of the questions we encounter, we often do not yet have good answers. But that should not prevent us from asking them. We need the courage to allow irritations, doubts, and uncertainties. We have every reason to be unsettled.

That is why we need places where we can hold the necessary debates – with passion, clearly, but hopefully in the spirit of reason and the will to truthfulness. That is why you are here, because such a place is meant to be the Forum Bellevue.

A forum is the format for uncertain times and conditions. It is not a seminar where finished and fully thought-out ideas are simply lectured. Rather, what we are starting here is an open space where we can discuss the unfinished and questionable, where we can try out unfamiliar arguments and perspectives. In this sense, the Forum Bellevue is meant to be a place of democracy.

In the coming months, we will deal with fundamental questions of this time:

In November, we want to talk with Salman Rushdie and other guests about the enlightening potential of literature and about defending freedom of opinion, art, and science against fanaticism and anti-intellectual resentments.

At the beginning of next year, we want to discuss with journalists from Germany and abroad how the democratic process is changing through the internet and social media.

Of course, we must talk about the strengths and weaknesses, about the acceptance of forms of representative democracy, about the responsibility of religions for curbing intolerance and violence. And last but not least, about a question that I hinted at in my inaugural speech in the Bundestag: How much inequality can democracy tolerate?

At this point, I would like to thank the Bertelsmann Foundation for their support: Without you, especially your personal commitment, dear Ms. Mohn, we would certainly not have been able to establish this series of discussions as comprehensively as I have just outlined.

To kick off the series, we want to take stock today. We have chosen a topic that somewhat overshadows the others: It will be nothing less than the future of the West. And of course, we are immediately faced with the question of what we actually mean when we talk about the "West": A geographical term? A normative project? A military-political alliance system? Or is it a bit of everything?

For us Germans, "the West" has initially become a cipher for our political identity. As a "late nation," our country – as Heinrich August Winkler has described on many pages – has undergone a "long journey to the West." Today, Germany has found a firm place in the community of values of liberal democracies. The Federal Republic could not have existed after 1945 without being anchored in democracy. This still constitutes a good part of our political self-understanding, and it is something that must be preserved.

With growing concern, we observe that in some states that belong to the European Union and NATO, certain firmly held beliefs are apparently beginning to slip. Of course, since February, we have primarily been looking at the United States, but the whole truth is: even in some countries in Europe, principles that have certainly been constitutive for the self-understanding of the West are being challenged today. These include the rule of law, the separation of powers, civil and human rights, but from my perspective, also critical reason, respect for science, and the legacy of the Enlightenment.

In this situation, we are faced with profound questions: Does the West have a future as a political model, as an alliance of liberal democracies? What is the state of its normative project? Can what has historically taken root in Europe and the United States be disentangled from geographical, indeed geopolitical, constriction, and can it claim universal validity? What persuasive power, what impact can this normative concept of the West actually have in today's multipolar world?

What is particularly important to me is that we should distinguish between the history of the West and the validity of its normative principles. We must not close our eyes to the Janus face and the record of sins of the "West." The self-contradiction was already present in the person of the American founding father Thomas Jefferson, who stated: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal" – and at the same time was a slave owner. The record of sins of the West includes war and violence, colonialism, as well as poverty, exploitation, and exclusion. Therefore, it is wise for us to consider the perspective of those who look at the West from the outside, from Latin America, Africa, and Asia. We want to take this perspective into account in tonight's debate.

"The West" has always been a promise for countless people seeking prosperity and free development, but it has also been a political battle term that defines the common "we" and distinguishes this "we" from others. Even after the end of the Cold War, there remains the risk that the term not only brings together but also separates. That it even stands in the way when it comes to forming new alliances or addressing new sources of danger that threaten not only the West – such as terrorism.

Is it therefore sufficient to illuminate our own blind spots, mistakes, and contradictions in order to regain credibility for this normative project of the West? Or should we rather – as some suggest, though it is not my proposal – completely part ways with the term "West"? Others hope: the more the fundamental values of the West assert themselves as universal values, in all directions, the less we need this term, this one direction at all. Our guests should help us tonight with their judgment, with their experience, to answer questions like these.

Dear Mr. Winkler, you describe in your new book how the "normative project of the West" has come under defensive in recent years. And you call on liberal democrats, in this context, to work even more closely together, not only within the framework of the European Union.

Our second guest is someone I am consulting for the first time, who has already forced us to think with a radically different perspective on the world at the Foreign Office. Dear Mr. Khanna, you are Indian and American, live in Singapore, and look at the "West" from a completely different viewpoint. In your latest book, you critically assess the Western, particularly the American, system of government, which you believe is not capable of meeting the challenges of the future. Instead, you advocate for something that sounds unusual to German ears and provokes aversions, namely a "direct technocracy," in which the democratic legitimacy of decisions is less important than the results that emerge from the decision-making processes.

Just a few months ago, I had the pleasure of discussing the question with our third guest at the Protestant Church Day: Is reason still salvageable? Ms. Neimann, surprisingly, this interested 5,000 people at the time. That surprised both of us. In the end, the audience was surprised that we both answered the question of whether reason can be saved with a yes. Dear Ms. Neiman, I can imagine that you would like to say something about this as well, as an American. That alone would be reason enough to invite you. But we are also interested in your position of "moral clarity," derived from the concept of reason, particularly in relation to the universal validity of human rights.

In your latest book, you write: "Growing up means acknowledging the uncertainties that run through our lives." That sounds almost like a motto for our series. We are on the way to finding answers to the questions – answers that we do not currently have.

I look forward to the discussion – and wish us all an inspiring evening. Thank you very much and welcome!