Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the discussion round "From the Bonn to the Berlin Republic – Memories and Lessons" on September 5, 2017, in Bonn:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

18 September 2017 · Discussion round "From the Bonn to the Berlin Republic – Memories and Lessons" · Bonn, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a discussion round at Villa Hammerschmidt in Bonn on September 5, 2017, reflecting on Germany's political evolution from the Bonn to the Berlin Republic.
Main themes
German political history, Bonn Republic to Berlin Republic, collective memory and national identity, German reunification, social market economy, Ostpolitik, 1968 protest movement, RAF terrorism, Munich Olympics massacre 1972, Basic Law and postwar democracy, historical lessons and reflection, political transitions
Duration
~17 min
57th percentile
Words
2,016
57th percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
52
67th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
3.26
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
74th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Ceremonial 43%38%
  • Social 39%35%
  • Geopolitical 11%10%
  • Technological 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

89 sentences in 21 paragraphs

What a wonderful start. Allow me to begin not with a formal address, but with a greeting to our young musicians: Thank you!

I love jazz, and the first piece could hardly have been more fitting for our topic today: "Where or when" – where or when have I heard that before, seen that before, felt that before? We experience such déjà vus in many small moments of everyday life, sometimes also in politics. Suddenly, a sentence sounds very familiar, perhaps an entire campaign like in days gone by, even though many years have passed. Of course, we also know the opposite, the famous feeling: Everything was different back then, above all, everything was better. Between these two extremes sways the memory of each individual, and probably also the memory of a nation. What we remember is rarely objective, more a colorful collage of keywords, image icons, and not least the interpretations that parents, teachers, friends, and various correctional instances allow in our minds. In both private and political matters, I believe: We remember what we can and want to remember, preferably events that fit smoothly into the beliefs of our present.

Or to put it another way: Idealization is a natural force, even in an age of seemingly inexhaustible film archives and the supposed certainty that we can research everything and everyone on the Internet at any time. That is why I have invited you today in a very classic way – I could also say very analog – to the Villa Hammerschmidt, to an authentic place and with a deliberately somewhat open title: "From the Bonn to the Berlin Republic – Memories and Lessons." I did not want to dictate from the outset what should be discussed here and, above all, what should not. But I admit, if you look around, the guest list will reveal what I secretly hope for from this evening – as many perspectives and as many different voices as possible on the question of how our country became what it is. What have we grown from, where have we failed as a society? And what have we possibly learned from it?

You are all witnesses to such valleys and triumphs: from former Federal Minister to the current Lord Mayor, from journalist to editor-in-chief, from cultural creators to the wife who has "held her husband’s back" for decades, as it was described in times when women in leadership positions were rather the exception.

All these biographies are part of the great arc that can and should be addressed today. A man like Jürgen Schmude may think back to his years in Helmut Schmidt's cabinet, or Friedel Drautzburg to his fight for the capital Bonn, the bitter defeat in 1991, and how it then became all the more impressive to settle in Berlin and redirect a piece of the Rhine to the Spree. In this sense: Everything flows. By the way, there will also be Kölsch later.

The evening will likely develop like a mosaic, a picture made up of snippets of memory, of which we hope that they will find their place somewhere in the collective memory, whether as inspiration or, where necessary, as a warning. The professors here in the hall may forgive us for giving up the claim to completeness right at the beginning, because the arc from the Bonn to the Berlin Republic is simply too wide, and the topics are too multifaceted. Just think of the birth of the Basic Law and the provisional nature that Bonn was to remain for a long time, of the Adenauer era from the beginnings of the Western alignment to the construction of the Wall, or of the economic miracle, of the social market economy under Ludwig Erhard, of the Auschwitz trials, of the first Grand Coalition, of the dispute over Ostpolitik, of Benno Ohnesorg, Rudi Dutschke, and the issues of the protesting 1968ers – historical amnesia, educational emergency, Vietnam War, outdated conventions – of the many struggles against the establishment that followed, struggles with words and – that also happened – struggles with weapons.

The Bonn Republic experienced bloody cuts, two alone on this very date, on September 5. In 1972, Palestinian attackers stormed the quarters of the Israeli team in the Olympic Village in Munich. They murdered two athletes, took nine hostages, demanded the release of more than two hundred Palestinians held in Israel and the RAF terrorists Andreas Baader and Ulrike Meinhof. In the night of September 6, the rescue operation at the airbase in Fürstenfeldbruck failed. All hostages died, as did a police officer and five of the attackers.

Tomorrow, I will speak at the memorial service in Munich together with President Rivlin and inaugurate the new memorial site in the Olympic Park. I belong to those who are very grateful that such a place now exists. But I will also admit: It was a long way to get there. This gap closes late.

Another September 5 in 1977 became a turning point. For Gerhart Baum, whom I warmly welcome this evening, it was the beginning of a political "state of emergency," as he once said in retrospect. It was the day of the kidnapping of Hanns Martin Schleyer. The day when his driver Heinz Marcisz and the three companions – the police officers Reinhold Brändle, Roland Pieler, Helmut Ulmer – were murdered.

Today, I mourned at the memorial cross in Cologne-Braunsfeld with the relatives of the victims, spoke with them, and heard again that what happened is not history – not for the relatives, who are shaped by the events, by the murders that have left deep marks on their own biographies.

I also met today with people who have been intensively dealing with the history of the so-called "Red Army Faction" and the "German Autumn" for years, some for decades. Thank you very much, dear Ms. Frenz, for the intensive collaboration with the Hanns Martin Schleyer Foundation, which we will continue until the event on October 18 in Bellevue. Thank you also, dear Hanns-Eberhard Schleyer, and thanks to you, dear experts, for giving me your time: Professor Terhoeven, Dr. Ameri-Siemens, esteemed Mr. Peters. I greatly appreciate that you all came to Bonn.

Even though research has achieved a lot: Some questions about the events are still open. They are open because the perpetrators continue to remain silent. The myth of the terrorists lives on this silence, lives on the recurring, unanswered questions. I believe that Der Spiegel rightly referred to the RAF as the "undead" of the Bonn Republic.

All the more important it is that we counter such ambiguities in the processing with as many facts as possible. Thank you to everyone who contributes to this. Several media outlets have taken the 40th anniversary of the German Autumn as an opportunity for a retrospective. The editorial team of the Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger just handed me a current special edition during my visit to the Neven DuMont House.

The tour there also fit in another way with the theme of our evening. In addition to the traditional printing press, Neven DuMont has recently opened a brand new newsroom, so to speak, the digital age at your fingertips. An age in which, not least, political communication, as you all feel, obviously works differently than we learned it. What many of us associate with the Bonn years – perhaps the tranquility, perhaps the familiarity, perhaps also the certain closeness between politics and the reporting on politics – much of that changed. "Under 3" is still "under 3" today, at least politicians always hope so, but the interaction – even among journalists – has become different due to the profound changes in the media world: more hectic, harsher, and – who am I telling this to – at times also more unrestrained.

What does this mean for the future of our democracy? In the Bonn Republic, the mechanisms of opinion formation were as manageable as the federal capital itself. There were comparatively stable milieus and voter inclinations, and life in politics seemed, from today’s perspective, to be somewhat predictable. In the meantime, news from around the world reaches us in seconds, and even more surprising than the news itself are often the comments I read on social media. My wife and I were just traveling in the Baltics, including in Estonia. There, we not only gained some clarity about the digital enthusiasm that prevails in these new small countries within the EU, but we also heard that young people often stumble upon a shitstorm first and then try to trace back to the original story. Meanwhile, they post diligently. Anyone can be both sender and receiver today, nonstop. Sometimes it seems that way: without ethical boundaries. Or as Professor Strohschneider, whom we saw here yesterday, put it: The boundary between what can be said and what cannot is apparently being torn down.

I am sure that we – without cultural pessimism, please – will address this change and its consequences for democracy right away, given the composition of the panel, it cannot be otherwise.

Welcome, esteemed discussants! Günter Bannas will surely not miss the opportunity to comment on journalism in the Berlin Republic. Socialized in the Rhineland and having followed the political correspondents' entourage to Berlin after many years in Bonn, he knows both worlds as well as very few others. Perhaps he will also revisit some focal points of his party observation, for example, how the Greens emerged onto the political stage in the early 1980s and established themselves there despite the incredulous astonishment of the established parties. But perhaps he will also address changes within the people's parties themselves. How were political debates conducted 30, 40 years ago – similarly or differently than we are experiencing them now? I would like to hear what Rita Süssmuth has to say about this. She has accompanied the major societal issues for a long time, sometimes even driven them forward, when I think of our discussions about education or immigration.

Of course, I am just as excited about Franz Müntefering. His biographical connections to the topic of this evening are so numerous that one could fill an entire lecture with them. But perhaps that is precisely why he is predestined to step back from the many experiences and details and take a look at the big picture: Have political fundamental concepts changed from the Bonn to the Berlin Republic, dear Franz Müntefering, such as the definition of the social state, the capable state, or the defensive state?

Peter Schneider, as a man of language and an experienced rebel, I would like to invite you to brush against the grain a bit when the memories in our discussion round between politicians and those who have reported on them become somewhat too similar – certainly not carelessly. A few options come to mind right away, such as the question: What role did the events in the GDR play for the development and our perception of politics in West Germany? Or regarding the keyword protest culture: What did it mean back then to be leftist, and what does it mean today? How did the peace demonstration in Bonn's Hofgarten in 1981 differ from the protests at the G20 summit in Hamburg in 2017?

I believe that we will not run out of material, quite the opposite, dear Ms. Kolster. But the selection, condensing, and sharpening of historically-political debates is, as I see it, your great strength at Phoenix. And fortunately, you do not have the pressure to fit everything into 15 seconds or even 140 characters. We will certainly feel well taken care of with you this evening.

I would be pleased if in the last part of the discussion, you, dear guests, also take the opportunity to contribute with questions, comments, small anecdotes – as you wish. From depth to lightness, everything is allowed. The main thing is that the memory enriches our present. I believe the chances for that are not bad, because we do not often come together in such a circle as today. In this sense: Good luck!