Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the presentation of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany to Heinrich August Winkler on March 16, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

19 March 2018 · Presentation of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany to Heinrich August Winkler · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony in Berlin on March 16, 2018, presenting the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany to historian Heinrich August Winkler.
Main themes
Western liberal order and its crises, historiography of Germany and the West, European Union challenges, transatlantic relations, Weimar Republic and democratic development, National Socialism and German history, normative model of the West, historical scholarship and methodology, political design and agency, Heinrich August Winkler's intellectual legacy
Duration
~15 min
53rd percentile
Words
1,832
53rd percentile
Sentences
85
55th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
12.4
49th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.34
81st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 54%44%
  • Ceremonial 25%20%
  • Geopolitical 16%13%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 19%

85 sentences in 25 paragraphs

An award ceremony is, alongside the special honor that is to be bestowed upon the recipient, always also an encouragement. Dear Heinrich August Winkler, I believe that encouraging your readers has always been a particular concern of yours.

However, in reading your most recent book, we must exercise patience until we are granted some encouragement. This book, as the first sentence of the preface warns, deals with a state of crisis. It speaks of the crisis of the European Union, the United States of America, and the transatlantic West as a whole. And thus begins an analysis of more than 400 pages. Only at its end does it hold out a – after all – encouraging sign.

When I read that, I thought to myself: This is what distinguishes the historian from the politician. Hardly any politician, especially one in government responsibility, would allow themselves to present their audience with a multiple crisis right at the beginning, only to keep them waiting for 400 pages.

Anyone who understands "crisis" as the peak and turning point of a dangerous development would likely feel dizzy while reading this. For this book, "Is the West Breaking Apart?" deals with nothing less than the possible failure of the order in which we live. It allows us to follow a development in which crises follow one another ever more closely. In fact, the word "crisis" seems to have shifted in recent years in the vocabulary of European and international politics and those who write about it, from denoting a state of emergency to becoming the norm.

Yet with Heinrich August Winkler, there is no dizziness. One does not get caught in a fateful undertow. Winkler's "History of the West," to which this latest book belongs, has exactly the opposite effect. The reading sobers in a good and – as I see it – necessary way. The book creates clarity, organizes, and evaluates. Not because the author lacks emphasis – Heinrich August Winkler has never left any doubt about his life’s theme, his stance – but because the matter requires it.

I believe this is an intellectual stance that is refreshing in times when gloomy apocalyptic scenarios and outrage-driven narratives compete for public attention. Even in so-called "crisis times," there remains, in my opinion, a sober but important realization that has perhaps become clearer to us than it was ten or twenty years ago: Neither the failure nor the success of our social order is fated. The future is open, and it is uncertain.

And that means: In the "normative model of the West," the life’s work of Heinrich August Winkler, there still lies, first and foremost, the possibility of a successful society. Thus, for me, Heinrich August Winkler's work has always also been an appeal for political design – and designability!

Nothing in history and hardly anything in personal life is predetermined. But Heinrich August Winkler did not arrive at his questions by chance either. Born in Königsberg during the time of National Socialism, carrying the not-so-light baggage of childhood memories of war and collapse, he began his intellectual journey together and intertwined with the Federal Republic. The location and self-assurance of this second democracy, which – that was the credo of his generation – should not suffer the fate of the first, underpins his scholarly work to this day in a life-worldly sense. Not entirely by chance, then, is the intensive study of the Weimar Republic, its parties, its middle classes, and its labor movement. Not by chance, starting from the Weimar question, is the larger question of why constitutionalism and the democratic revolution in Germany took so long to materialize.

The academic debates, the great controversies of the profession, beginning with the Fischer controversy over the guilt of the Wilhelmine Empire in the First World War, through the character of the 1918 revolution, the causes of the Nazi regime, to the historian's dispute of the 1980s and the question of the normality of the German nation-state – these controversies were always more than just cool science for Heinrich August Winkler. It was passionate. And for good reason. In these controversies, one might say, the soul of Germany was being fought over, or, simply put, the lessons from a catastrophic history of violence.

Dear Heinrich August Winkler, your voice has been clearly audible in many of these debates for decades. The strength of this voice lies not only in the fact that you are a truly gifted speaker and author. Above all, it expresses the authority of a methodically working historian who argues with profound knowledge of sources. Knowledge should precede values. It is particularly necessary to remind ourselves of this today. And you have always embodied this ethos.

Moreover, you have been one of the innovators in your field, continually inspiring numerous students. The liberation of historical science in Germany from the grip of an apologetic national history, the knowledge of Max Weber, the incorporation of modern social sciences with their focus on social contrasts, the European and international broadening of horizons – all of this you have advanced.

Even in this paradigm shift in historical science, what Jürgen Habermas summarized in a well-known sentence likely took place: "The unconditional opening of the Federal Republic to the political culture of the West is the great intellectual achievement of our post-war period." I would like to add: This intellectual opening of our country to freedom and democracy is, to a large extent, also the achievement of Heinrich August Winkler.

Ralf Dahrendorf once described the cardinal virtues of freedom as follows: To resist unfreedom, one needs, alongside mental clarity and steadfastness, "the discipline of the engaged observer, who does not allow themselves to be co-opted, and the passionate dedication to reason as an instrument of knowledge and action."

Readers of Heinrich August Winkler appreciate precisely this thematic, intellectual, and moral clarity. It makes his books a formative read, for the broader public as well as for historians and politicians.

For instance, Heinrich August Winkler teaches the foreign policy maker to precisely determine the coordinates of their position, for self-location is also important in a world that – as we experience – is constantly being remeasured. In such a situation, good scientific advice is invaluable, and I have gladly been your student in this regard.

Dear Heinrich August Winkler, it was therefore no coincidence that we encountered each other more frequently in recent years. Just a few months ago, we discussed a question at the Forum Bellevue on the future of democracy that is also your question: "What future does the West have?" One of those encounters, in February 2015, remains particularly vivid in my memory. At that time, you presented the fourth volume of your History of the West in the Nikolaikirche in Berlin. It was planned as the conclusion of your magnum opus. Yet on that February evening in the heart of Berlin, we all – the panel and the audience, and I believe you as well – had the feeling: This story, the story of the West, is far from complete, far from a conclusion. It is in flux, and this flux is not a calm stream.

And soon after our memorable evening there, a few more turbulences arose, about which we had already spoken, but whose outcome we did not yet know: the Brexit referendum, for example, the electoral successes of right-wing nationalist, anti-European parties in Europe, and especially the result of the presidential elections in the USA.

The West, as you said that evening, presents itself in the present as a deeply divided entity. And I find that to understand the reasons for this division, it is hardly sufficient to merely point fingers at others and constantly be outraged about what, for example, is currently emanating from the White House. Those in Germany who now speak with a certain cultural arrogance about the break with the USA, I ask whether we in Europe are not also facing quite similar societal challenges: The coarsening of political language, especially online, belongs to this in my view; as does the increasing polarization and a waning cohesion of the political center; the drifting apart of life worlds, for instance between urban agglomerations and rural regions.

I fear that the development, which has already created deep and widely visible rifts in America, can also be observed here. They are fissures, not chasms, but they are not harmless either. And precisely for this reason, I advise us to deepen our established transatlantic contacts and discussions rather than throw them overboard.

For, as you concluded that evening in February 2015: Despite all contradictions, you said, there is something that holds the West together at its core. Yes, the paradox is that the West is losing global, economic, and geopolitical significance, yet at the same time gaining in attractiveness.

What this gravitation can achieve against the centrifugal forces of Western societies is precisely your theme and remains so. Around this core, around the achievements of the American and French revolutions, around all of this your work revolves: around the inalienability of human rights, the rule of law, the sovereignty of the people, the separation of powers, and representative democracy.

We all know that this model of a free, democratic constitutional state, fought for by the founders of the USA and the Europeans, has opponents. It is not the external adversaries that should concern us the most, but rather the increasingly vocal detractors of free media, elected politicians, and parliaments within our societies. And their strongest weapon is distrust. The so-called "crisis of credibility" they declare is directed not only against the media, but also against societal elites and responsibility as a whole, against representatives of the state as well as against representatives of the economy, and, as you experience, also against representatives of science.

Also against historical science. Can one make a credible statement about the past? Is not every reflection on the past already an interpretation, thus subjective, and every statement about the past thereby more of a narrative? Heinrich August Winkler would probably, and perhaps he will say so shortly, even answer "Yes." The question is only, what follows from that affirmation? That every statement about the past is a narrative does not mean that it is entirely fabricated.

"All judgments on contemporary history are subject to the provisional and the subjective." Heinrich August Winkler explicitly stated this again on that February evening in the Nikolaikirche in Berlin. Avoiding the representation of the recent past is therefore not a way out of the dilemma. We would deprive ourselves of our judgment, he says, if we refrained from it. And we cannot and must not shy away from the future either. With a judgment sharpened by Heinrich August Winkler, we need not fear this future.

Dear Professor Winkler, that is why we ask you for your continued engagement, for your critical voice as an observer, as an analyst, and also time and again as an advisor. Thank you very much.