Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the third forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on March 21, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

26 March 2018 · Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the third Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy in Berlin on March 21, 2018, discussing disinformation and facts in democratic societies.
Main themes
Fake news and disinformation, facts vs. opinions in democracy, digital media and misinformation, public discourse and truth, media freedom and press, political manipulation of facts, social media fragmentation, trust in democratic institutions, alternative facts, free speech and hate speech, Cambridge Analytica and data misuse, democracy and public reason
Duration
~15 min
53rd percentile
Words
1,842
53rd percentile
Sentences
99
62nd percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 56%56%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Technological 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

99 sentences in 33 paragraphs

"Fact or Fake? About a Significant Difference for Democracy"

I did not order today’s reporting on Cambridge Analytica, but it highlights the relevance of the questions at hand and underscores how necessary the debate is that we want to have today.

"It used to be, everyone was entitled to their own opinion, but not their own facts. But that's not the case anymore. Facts matter not at all. Perception is everything."

You think of the New York Times about Donald Trump. That may be, but it is wrong! This quote comes from Stephen Colbert, the American satirist, and he said it back in 2006, when the President of the United States was still George W. Bush. Even then, many years before the current dispute over "fake news" and "alternative facts," Colbert had the impression that in public debate, it was primarily about presenting the viewpoint that suits one best as clearly and definitively as possible—regardless of the facts.

Hannah Arendt made it clear more than 50 years ago in her famous essay on "Truth and Politics" that we are dealing with a "political problem of the first order" when "the factual reality itself" is at stake. "Freedom of opinion," she wrote at the time, "is a farce if the information about the facts is not guaranteed."

But what does it mean for liberal societies when public opinion disputes are no longer conducted on the basis of generally accepted facts, when the line between facts and opinions blurs, and it is claimed that facts are merely a matter of perspective?

We all know that facts alone do not lead to a political program. Truths of fact are not definitively established; they must be verified and, if necessary, revised by science and the media. Moreover, democracy is also the only form of government that allows for mistakes because the ability to correct is inherently built into the political system. But we must never give up the claim to distinguish between facts and evaluations. The possibility of making this distinction depends on nothing less than the future of our democracy.

For it is clear that only on the basis of solid, verifiable, and generally accepted facts can a reasonable public discourse succeed. A discourse that leads to informed decisions, enables the control of political leaders, and preserves, and possibly strengthens, trust in democratic institutions.

What should we orient our political actions towards in a world that is becoming increasingly complex if we can no longer start from what is and how it is? How are we to tackle the very real problems of our time, such as climate change, together if political forces simply refuse to acknowledge research findings or outright deny that there are insights that contradict their own viewpoints? And how are we to peacefully reconcile different interests and negotiate compromises if our society fractures into irreconcilable groups that only accept their respective "felt truths"?

Organized public lying, the manipulation of facts to gain a political advantage—all of this is, of course, not new phenomena, not even in the history of democracies. What is new today is the epidemic spread of disinformation on the internet, the immense power of digital media, but also the variety of attacks on the use of public reason.

And it is new that politicians undermine the evidential and binding power of facts by presenting obvious lies as "alternative facts" and interpreting the news of reputable media as "fake news." In isolated cases in Europe, there is state-sponsored hostility against journalists and interference in press and academic freedom. In Germany, too, the institutions of information and knowledge are under fire—especially when they are disparaged as "lying press," "mainstream media," or "state broadcasting."

The large platforms on the internet, with their hundreds of millions of users, make it possible for misinformation and conspiracy theories to be spread rapidly and shared en masse today. Often, events and scandals attract more interest than serious news. Professional journalists are no longer the sole gatekeepers of public communication, and they now have to compete for selection and attention against algorithms and opinion bots.

New media, which often are not "social" media at all, have lowered the barriers for any form of "hate speech." In the protection of anonymity, shamelessness grows, and the boundaries between what can be said and what cannot are increasingly blurred.

Crucially, however, digital media drive the fragmentation of the public sphere, which complicates societal dialogue. There is a danger that parallel worlds will emerge, in which self-confirmation through exchange with like-minded individuals prevails and everything that contradicts one's own viewpoint is ignored.

At the same time, in some parts of society, including among young people, trust in reputable media, research institutions, and democratic institutions is declining. Those who can handle complexity and provide orientation in an increasingly complex world are thus losing credibility. Yesterday, I was a guest at the Institute for Journalism at the University of Mainz. There, I discussed with researchers and students and learned the latest figures indicating that the downward trend has recently been halted and that, even if only slightly, trust in traditional media has increased again among the general population. That would be good.

For now more than ever, we need media that provide verified information, expose grievances, debunk lies, and make political processes comprehensible. We need media that create a common communication space for as many different people as possible—a public space where controversial opinions can be discussed.

I believe that democratic discourse in Germany still succeeds better than elsewhere, and we owe this to the many dedicated journalists who work every day in the press and on the internet, in radio and television, for truthfulness and quality. And just in passing, I personally hope that we will be spared a debate about the abolition of public broadcasting, as is being conducted elsewhere. I am convinced that we still need it. The mandate of public broadcasting is important for democracy. This also includes that we continually discuss how this mandate can be best fulfilled under changing conditions.

In the end, this democracy consists of informed citizens who want to form their own judgments in a complex world. Education and media literacy are indispensable prerequisites for this. But not every citizen can simultaneously be an investigative journalist; rather, every citizen needs orientation in the daily stream of information, needs islands of reliability. These islands must be media that we trust, on whose reporting we can base our judgments.

What can politics, media, and science do to combat disinformation? How can they regain credibility and trust? How can we continue to enable a reasonable public discourse based on facts? These are the questions we want to discuss this morning, here at the third Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy. I am very pleased to have three journalists and one scientist as guests today, who are all engaged with the topic of "Fact or Fake" in very different ways.

Jeff Mason, my first guest and well-known in Germany, works as a correspondent for the Reuters news agency directly in the White House and has the exciting task of reporting on the American president and his policies. We are, of course, also interested in what you have to report about the new approach of the White House to the media, and hopefully, you will be able to explain what we sometimes do not understand.

That one must also fight for the rights of journalists in established democracies is something he experiences in his daily work in a special way. As president of the White House Correspondents' Association, he reminded us last spring of what the task of journalists is. At that time, he said: "It is our job to report on facts and to hold leaders accountable. That is who we are. We are not fake news. We are not failing news organizations. And we are not the enemy of the American people."

I am curious to hear what he has to say today about the factual situation in the United States. Welcome, Jeff Mason!

My second guest also represents public broadcasting, which is derided by some as the epitome of "system media." Julia Stein is the head of the Politics and Research editorial team at the State Broadcasting House of Schleswig-Holstein, and as chair of the "Network Research" association, she advocates for journalists to verify facts, analyze data, and expose lies.

Roger Cohen of the New York Times once said: "Facts are the foundation of journalism; discovering them is its main goal—without fear or favor." I look forward to an investigative journalist who particularly embodies this statement—I think of the Panama Papers, Luxembourg Leaks, and more. Please welcome Julia Stein!

My third guest today represents traditional media and print media in our country. Ulf Poschardt is the editor-in-chief of the newspaper "Die Welt," and he has passionately advocated for the release of Deniz Yücel. Like many others, he continues to fight for the release of all journalists imprisoned in Turkey. I believe that deserves our support today as well.

In light of the debate about "fake news" and filter bubbles, he has called for calm. "For centuries," he says, "people have exchanged rumors in marketplaces and pubs. Now that happens on Facebook and Twitter. No problem. We [journalists] offer research and substance as a countermeasure."

I am not prone to alarmism, and I often advise us— you know that—to remain calm. But whether that should be our attitude in light of the changes in the media landscape and media usage and their consequences is what we want to discuss today.

"Disinformation," writes media scholar Stephan Ruß-Mohl in his new book, "is the plague of the digitized society. It spreads not only epidemically but also changes our perception of what we consider to be true. Combating this plague is increasingly becoming the central challenge for reputable media, yes, for democracy and for free societies."

I am pleased that we can soon discuss whether and how journalists can meet this high standard. Welcome, Ulf Poschardt!

Now I come to the scientist in our round. Michael Butter is a professor of American Studies at the University of Tübingen, and he has been dealing with conspiracy theories for several years—such as the theory of the "Great Replacement," which circulated online during the refugee crisis. Its proponents claim that a global "financial oligarchy" is in the process of erasing Germany from the map with the help of the "migration weapon."

His new book, which has just been published, bears the fitting title "Nothing is as it Seems." "The belief in conspiracy theories," it states, "is a symptom of a deeper crisis in democratic societies."

He will soon explain to us what this crisis consists of—please welcome Michael Butter!

The fight against disinformation is one of the great challenges of our time. Perhaps we can at least make a small contribution to enlightenment this morning. I am looking forward to our conversation, here on the podium and then throughout the hall. A warm welcome to all of you at Schloss Bellevue!