Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier during his inaugural visit to Saxony-Anhalt at the Leopoldina – National Academy of Sciences on February 15, 2018, in Halle (Saale):

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

19 February 2018 · Inaugural visit to Saxony-Anhalt · Leopoldina – National Academy of Sciences, Halle (Saale), Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the Leopoldina National Academy of Sciences in Halle during his inaugural visit to Saxony-Anhalt on February 15, 2018, marking the Academy's tenth anniversary as national institution.
Main themes
Science and democracy, role of the Leopoldina National Academy, digitalization and technological innovation, scientific integrity and ethics, freedom and responsibility in research, science communication, democratic will formation, fight against anti-science sentiment, automotive emissions scandal, science policy in Germany
Duration
~13 min
45th percentile
Words
1,547
45th percentile
Sentences
70
46th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 47%43%
  • Technological 22%20%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Geopolitical 2%1%
  • Economic 2%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

70 sentences in 25 paragraphs

How wonderful it is to be with you in Halle! I have now been in office as the Federal President for almost a year and have traveled a lot – after eight years in the Foreign Office, now significantly more domestically and particularly often here in Saxony-Anhalt, between the Elbe and the Harz. On Martin Luther's round birthday, I was here several times in the birthplace of the Reformation; I was able to show the diplomatic corps the industrial focal points and cultural highlights of this country – I believe the Minister-President felt somewhat besieged last time.

But I am also still traveling abroad – in Africa, Asia, and the Middle East, even at Buckingham Palace, just last week with the Emperor in Japan. But what has been missing so far, and what has already generated some inquiries from journalists: I have not yet been to the "White House." Today, it is finally happening! I look forward to lively discussions about politics and society, science and innovation, as one can only have in the "White House" – here in the Leopoldina on the Jägerberg, and this in the tenth year of its existence as the National Academy of Sciences. I think this is a wonderful occasion for our meeting.

The Leopoldina itself is, of course, much older than ten years. It was founded in 1652 in Schweinfurt and found a permanent home in Halle 140 years ago after many years of wandering. The Leopoldina is today not only a stroke of luck for Saxony-Anhalt but for our entire country. By the way, this entire country embraced it even through the years of division. It is therefore good that it became the National Academy.

The founding of the National Academy expressed the insight that politics and society need wise counsel – and especially counsel based on scientific foundations.

First,

to find answers to the future questions that our society faces or will soon face – just think of the ever-accelerating succession of technological innovations and their impacts on our coexistence.

Second,

to understand how different answers to these questions can lead to completely different consequences and "path dependencies."

Or

thirdly,

sometimes also to first comprehend and articulate what questions we as a society must ask ourselves in order not to walk blindly into the future. Today's discussion on digitalization is meant to contribute to this.

Counsel from science is important, but decisions about our future questions must be made together in politics, business, and society – and indeed in and with the democratic institutions of will formation that we have in Germany and – I believe – should defend against all criticism and growing contempt.

Your work – the work of the Leopoldina with its analyses, position papers, recommendations, and events – contributes significantly to a culture of will formation, in which, in the end, the informed opinion, the better argument counts more than the coarse slogan or conspiratorial speculation. You, ladies and gentlemen, defend reason against the coarsening of our public debates – and to all those here in the hall who contribute to this, I extend my heartfelt thanks!

I want to make one thing clear at this point: Due to the recent cases of questionable studies related to the manipulation of emissions values in the automotive sector, the credibility and independence of scientific experts have become a topic of public discussion. Perhaps an isolated case – but with great significance, because it is being used by all those interested in delegitimizing science. We live in a time when the relevance of science is also being called into question in Western societies. The so-called "fight against the establishment" is indeed being waged not only against politics and the media but also in and against science. When the validity, even the necessity of empirical research is doubted, it does not bode well for the future of an enlightened society.

Isolated cases like the controversial emissions tests show that research must always be ethically accountable, that it must be able to publicly state why it is necessary and what goal it serves. Secrecy with a guilty conscience helps no one. Above all, science must never become a favor to powerful interests – whether economic or political. Each individual such case is water on the mills of science's enemies. On the contrary: We must offensively justify the necessity and objectives of empirical research. That is why it is good that the Leopoldina, together with other scientific organizations, launched a broad-based information initiative on animal testing back in 2016.

For me, the current discussion is a good reason to remind ourselves how closely freedom and responsibility are connected in science as well. Yes, we need ethics committees, we also need clear rules for the disentanglement of interests and transparency. But in the end, nothing replaces the individual’s sense of responsibility. Anyone who enjoys the freedom of science in our country must recognize and accept social responsibility beyond mere curiosity. Conversely, this means for politics: Those who demand responsibility from science must first and foremost protect its freedom.

You all here in the hall should know that you have a Federal President by your side who – wherever necessary – will champion the freedom of science, but who also relies on every researcher being aware of their great social responsibility. In recent weeks and months, I have had many discussions – with the Academy of Sciences, with representatives of major scientific organizations, just recently with the Science Council and the Donors' Association, and of course also at many universities and research institutions across Germany – and I have felt that the sense of responsibility in German science is deeply rooted. I count on that.

I now look forward to the panel discussion on a topic area in which we move daily and naturally, which has long permeated our everyday lives, but whose social impacts we have not yet sufficiently grasped. In digitalization, what I said at the beginning is particularly important: namely, to outline and formulate the right questions first in the seemingly overwhelming flood of change. We must not only focus on technological developments themselves but also ask: What do these developments do to us and to our coexistence?

For example, in the world of work: How do we preserve and renew the institutions of the social market economy, such as the social security systems, which are indispensable, even if job profiles and career paths will look very different?

How is the democratic discourse changing? How should we conduct societal debates when communication in social media is only happening within groups and milieus?

Or: What significance do our fundamental rights have in relation to monopolistic and internationally established digital business models, which – keyword "data as a raw material" – are only seemingly free? How relevant the issue of fundamental rights is can currently be seen in large-scale experiments in China, where societal control is attempted through big data. Each citizen is assigned an account, on which they can earn or lose points through their everyday actions. And this is not only an experiment at the individual level; we also see in China how behavior towards the government is either rewarded or punished, for example, with non-governmental organizations. Such things are certainly not threatening in Germany – but you can see how important it is that we discuss the societal impacts of technological developments intensively.

Or think of education: How do we educate the much-discussed generation of "digital natives" to become "native democrats"? How do we ensure that democracy still holds value for them when communication is so different, when there are no daily newspapers anymore, or when they only confirm each other among like-minded individuals? How do we equip them with the tools to distinguish between real news, misinformation, and manipulation?

I am grateful that the Leopoldina is specifically reaching out to students – because in the end, education for the digital world must of course be more than just the digitalization of teaching through tablets and apps. It is about nothing less than the reclamation of maturity in the digital world and about digital emancipation where ignorance, dependency, and external control have grown. I am pleased that two students who participated in the project "Digital Self – Digital Us" are also taking part in our discussion.

As complex as the questions are, the task is immense when we set out to find answers. That will be the task of the panelists shortly. I will only say this much in advance: Simplification will not help us. In bookstores, you will currently find a satirical future novel titled "Qualityland." In "Qualityland," the answer to literally all questions is "ok." There is no other way – because all-knowing algorithms have perfectly calculated every one of our decisions in work and family, in shopping and in democratic elections. They even know better than we do who the right partner for us is or when we should end a relationship, and they take care of that for us.

Fortunately, we do not live in "Qualityland," and fortunately, the answer to the big questions of digitalization is never just "ok" – or "like" and "dislike." On the contrary: The future is open, it is uncertain, and it is up to us to shape it.