Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the 100th anniversary of the death of Hugo Preuß on September 26, 2025, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

27 September 2025 · Speech on the 100th anniversary of the death of Hugo Preuß · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed guests at Schloss Bellevue on September 26, 2025, commemorating the 100th anniversary of the death of constitutional pioneer Hugo Preuß.
Main themes
Hugo Preuß legacy, Weimar Constitution and German democracy, democratic theory and pluralism, opposition to authoritarianism, equal voting rights and municipal self-governance, Jewish exclusion in Wilhelmine Prussia, performance administration, historical memory and democratic relevance
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,929
55th percentile
Sentences
91
58th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.33
80th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 76%76%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

91 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Whoever studied law in West Germany in the 1970s, like I did, learned administrative law primarily from the textbooks of Ernst Forsthoff, constitutional law from the works of Theodor Maunz, and constitutional history from those of Ernst Rudolf Huber – men who were entangled in the injustices of the Nazi dictatorship in different ways.

On the other hand, students generally learned nothing about Hugo Preuß. Yet this man was one of the great thinkers and pioneers of democracy in Germany. He was forgotten for far too long, and efforts were made to erase him from memory. Now, at a time when democracy is facing new challenges, when far too many people succumb to the temptation of authoritarianism, the thoughts of Hugo Preuß are more relevant than ever. That is why it is important for me to remember him today!

Dear guests, I warmly welcome you all here at Schloss Bellevue. I welcome and thank Professor Marcus Llanque, who will soon introduce us in more detail to the work of Hugo Preuß. A warm welcome!

And it is a special pleasure for me that many descendants of Hugo Preuß are here today. They have all come from Switzerland and France to Berlin, the city where Hugo Preuß worked for decades and from which his widow and children were once driven into exile by the Nazis. Dear Preuß family, a particularly warm welcome to you!

Hugo Preuß was born in 1860 as the only son of a wealthy entrepreneur here in Berlin. He lived on the other side of the Tiergarten, roughly where the Philharmonie stands today. His material independence allowed him to devote himself entirely to legal science and the common good, without having to take any considerations of the academic or political mainstream of his time.

Even his habilitation under Otto von Gierke turned the prevailing state concepts of the time upside down. "Community, State, Empire as Territorial Corporations," was the title of his work. And it truly broke with the Prussian glorification of the state and the fixation on sovereignty that prevailed among the state teachers of the time. Preuß wanted an organization of the state from the bottom up, an organization that was based on the equality of its members, that allowed for self-administration, and in which there was a decentralization of power to secure freedom. In doing so, Preuß was not only advancing the development of Gierke's idea of cooperation towards what we would today call a democratic pluralism theory. Thus, Preuß became not only a sharp critic of the system for which he coined the term "authoritarian state," but also, strangely enough, a visionary for its overcoming. The state is nothing other than "the people organized by the constitution," he said. He opposed the authoritarian state with the democratic people's state.

But Preuß did not limit himself to a legal theory. Just as unconventional as he acted in science, he also acted in politics. In 1895, he was first elected to the Berlin city council and immediately began to fight against the privileges that he owed to his own election. For under the Prussian three-class electoral system, the voting weight of each voter depended on the amount of taxes paid. Preuß fought for equal voting rights, he fought for municipal self-administration, and above all against the interference of the state and the ministries in the municipalities. He naturally opposed the state discrimination against Jews, which still existed in Prussia at that time despite formal equality.

And he advocated a new understanding of administration. This should not only act as an intervention administration with commands and prohibitions but also take care of the provision of citizens, for example, with public transport. Water and energy should not be completely left to the vicissitudes of the market. This was also a public task for Preuß, usually a public task of the municipalities – what we call performance administration.

In his milieu, in the bourgeoisie of the time, he did not receive applause for this policy. But Preuß made no compromises when it came to his convictions. He belonged to the small left-liberal faction of the Social Progressives and was elected as an honorary city councilor in the Berlin magistrate in 1910.

One could call Hugo Preuß a political professor if one did not know that he could never become a professor at the University of Berlin during the Empire, but remained a private lecturer. Jew and democrat, with this combination, he had no chance of entering the civil service in Wilhelmine Prussia. Only the private Berlin School of Commerce appointed Preuß as a professor.

Hugo Preuß was already 58 years old when his greatest political hour struck in November 1918. The revolutionary government, the Council of People's Representatives, made him their "Minister of the Constitution" and tasked him with drafting a new constitution for the then young republic. Preuß welcomed the revolution and lamented the "slackness and servility" of the German bourgeoisie, which would never have managed to overcome the authoritarian state on its own. That the new rulers around Friedrich Ebert appointed a bourgeois democrat like Preuß may be surprising, but it documents the constitutional consensus that existed at least for a time between the labor movement and the liberal bourgeoisie shortly after 1918. The future republic was to be a democratic one, not a rule of councils.

Within six weeks and after intensive consultations, Preuß formulated the first draft for the constitution that would go down in history as the Weimar Constitution. "All state power resides with the German people," he placed at the beginning of the draft. And because Preuß was not shackled by the dogma of sovereignty that understood the state as a closed power apparatus internally and externally, his cooperative thinking was also open beyond the state. Therefore, he formulated as another paragraph – and this sounds very modern today –: "The Empire recognizes international law as a binding part of its own law." Preuß envisioned a directly elected president and a parliamentary system of government; he advocated for a vertically structured self-administration that would replace the Bismarckian concept of the state; and he campaigned for the development from a formal to a social rule of law: "The democratic rule of law," said Preuß, "must not and cannot be satisfied with merely establishing formal legal equality, but must fill the formally democratic law with a social spirit."

Not all of his ideas were implemented at that time. For example, his proposal for a reorganization of the states failed. He wanted to dissolve the overpowering Prussia as well as the then large number of small states and instead create approximately equal-sized units. With this idea, Preuß was unsuccessful at the time. However, anyone who compares Preuß's plans with our current state structure recognizes the similarity and knows: Preuß was ahead of his time.

Even if Preuß can claim sole authorship of the constitution only for his first draft, no other constitution in German history, not the work of the Paulskirche and not the Basic Law, is as closely linked to a single person as the Weimar Constitution is to Hugo Preuß.

The constitution-making outlived Preuß by only six years. As Reich Minister of the Interior, he resigned in the summer of 1919 together with the entire cabinet in protest against the Treaty of Versailles. Although he was a co-founder of the German Democratic Party, a further significant political career was denied to him. Perhaps he was too independent, too progressive, too contentious for his own party friends. He remained a member of the Prussian Landtag until his death in 1925.

Hugo Preuß could no longer shape the great constitutional debates at the end of the Weimar Republic. He was also spared from witnessing how the Nazis destroyed his constitution once and for all starting in 1933, a constitution that they derided as the allegedly "un-German" work of a Jew. But Preuß could not intervene either when, after 1945, the construction flaws of the Weimar Constitution were often discussed, which was said to be largely responsible for the downfall of the first democracy. Many who had been involved in the destruction of Weimar democracy as politicians, jurists, but also as voters themselves evaded responsibility by pointing to the allegedly flawed constitution. Preuß had no scientific students who could have defended his legacy; he had no university professorship. And the mantra of the West German post-war period "Bonn is not Weimar" often meant at the same time: We have nothing to do with Preuß. For this reason, this significant man remained forgotten for far too long.

Today, no one needs the Weimar Constitution to distract from the decisive causes of the destruction of the first German democracy. In the meantime, Hugo Preuß and his work are being recognized more objectively and positively. And many are here in the hall today who have contributed to this with their work. The scholarly biography of Hugo Preuß and the collected writings are impressive results of a great jurist's biography. I thank you all for your work!

Of course, the Parliamentary Council in 1949 did many things differently than Hugo Preuß. The indirect election of the Federal President, the renunciation of an emergency decree power of the president, and the greater responsibility of the parliament instead of the head of state for the formation of government – all of these are examples of that. Nevertheless, the parallels between the Basic Law and the Weimar Constitution are much greater than one would have wanted to acknowledge in Bonn at the time. Today we know that it is not only the text of a constitution that matters, but also how it is interpreted and how it is applied. And by the way: Democracy does not live solely from the articles of its constitution, but from the fact that it is desired, lived, and above all defended by the vast majority. Today we know that Preuß's work – to quote Christoph Gusy – was "a good constitution in a bad time."

We certainly live in better times today, but even now, liberal democracy is once again being challenged – not only from the outside but also from within. For Hugo Preuß, the most important guarantee for the preservation and existence of a democracy was the citizens themselves. "If the people do not protect the constitution of the people's state, the constitution, but also the people, are defenseless," he wrote.

We must therefore repeatedly remind ourselves that democracy is not a given and that each and every one of us must do something to protect it. Indifference, lethargy, withdrawal are not an attitude. Such passivity, such "slackness," as Preuß would have said, does not fit a democracy.

It was a long, arduous path to establish democracy in Germany, full of detours and terrible setbacks. But at all times, there have been people who have fought for it with courage and passion, people like Hugo Preuß. His example shows what even an individual can achieve. And the suffering inflicted on his family, on so many German families starting in 1933, reminds us of what is always at stake.

The example of Hugo Preuß is therefore an incentive to show attitude today and to engage for democracy – not only in politics or science but also as citizens in our own communities. That is why, I believe, it is important that Hugo Preuß is not forgotten. Therefore, Hugo Preuß should be a firm part of our democratic traditions, our republican culture of remembrance – and if it were up to me, also of our legal education.