Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the assumption of patronage of the "Initiative for a Capable State" on November 12, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

12 November 2024 · Launch of the "Initiative for a Capable State" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at Schloss Bellevue in Berlin on November 12, 2024, to launch the cross-party "Initiative for a Capable State" amid Germany's political crisis.
Main themes
Capable state initiative, state capacity and reform, trust in democratic institutions, bureaucracy and deregulation, federalism and administration, digitalization, infrastructure deficits, citizen satisfaction with government, liberal democracy, long-term structural reform
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,174
61st percentile
Sentences
105
65th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 77%75%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

105 sentences in 23 paragraphs

For several days now, we have indeed been in an extraordinary domestic political situation. Therefore, let me clarify right from the start: The "Initiative for a Capable State," which we are launching together with all of you today, is not a reaction to the developments since Wednesday evening of last week, as this project has been in preparation for months. And the date for today's launch has been set for a long time. More importantly: This initiative, which includes people with very different party-political and political views, should never have been and should not now be a comment on current politics or specific government constellations. On the contrary, I could even say: precisely because blockages and stagnations do not arise overnight, not even within a single legislative period, the initiative aims to think beyond the day.

It is deliberately broad and long-term in scope. It aims to develop proposals to make our federal legal and social state, its services, and its offerings in the interest of citizens faster, more effective, clearer, and more reliable—whether it concerns federalism or administration, the economy and location, education and social issues, resilience and security, digitalization, energy policy, or certain changes in our society.

Our country needs a capable government. I am currently discussing how this can happen quickly and reliably in terms of procedures at other tables with the stakeholders. The sooner there is a common roadmap, the better.

But beyond that, at the same time and independently, we also need a critical look at our state and its structures, because I am convinced: If liberal democracy is being challenged again today in our country, it is certainly also related to the fact that people are dissatisfied with the condition and performance of their state. The trust of many citizens in the problem-solving capacity, in the decision-making ability, and therefore in the usefulness of liberal democracy, its institutions, and representatives has evidently suffered, and in parts of society, it has even eroded.

We all experience in our daily lives that our federal legal and social state does not function in some areas as it could, as it should. And we experience that our state does not deliver and perform what we expect from it, that it too often fails to meet the demands we have of our country. When trains are delayed or do not run at all, when there is still no fast internet in some places, when bridges are broken, power grids are overloaded, and school buildings are dilapidated, then it is not just walls that are crumbling; trust in our state and its institutions is also crumbling. And that is precisely what takes away the momentum we so urgently need in this time.

Therefore, we must not lose any time. We need to find answers to the question of how we can make our state more capable of action. And that is exactly what you, dear guests, want to do in the coming months. I am pleased that the "Initiative for a Capable State" is starting its work today. And I am glad that all of you here in the hall are present at the kickoff. So, I warmly welcome you here at Schloss Bellevue!

The film we just saw conveys a bit of the mood that I encounter repeatedly—especially when I move my office for several days to smaller or medium-sized towns in the country. Yes, many people are concerned about the omnipresent crisis. That is true. And it is no surprise. But many who approach me during my "local times" are also full of courage and energy during this difficult time. Many want to get started, drive change, shape the future in their city. But they too often have to experience that state structures hinder and slow them down, for example, because there is a lack of room for pragmatic action or because the requirements of various authorities rub against each other and contradict one another.

When I say this, it has nothing to do with my fundamental doubts about the state and administration. Because state rules and control are not inherently questionable; rather, state rules and control primarily serve a political purpose decided by democratic majorities. Legal certainty, social justice, fair competition, labor protection, health protection, data security, and much more—this is, in my conviction, not achievable without the state and without rules. And perhaps we in Germany are a bit more concerned than others that there should be no favoritism or disadvantage against other beneficiaries or competitors.

Very different governing coalitions have therefore created new rules and regulations during their respective terms, often in the best political intentions. The call for deregulation is ubiquitous and undeniably justified—but, if you ask me, it is always a bit superficial. High and highest individual expectations of the state often lead to administrative processes, in other words: to bureaucracy. Therefore, for me, it is not just about deregulation. We must—central to this, I believe—also reassess our expectations of the state. That is why I speak less of deregulation and prefer to talk about state reform.

This also includes the relationship between the levels of government—between the federal government, states, and municipalities. For example: If I focus on the uniform implementation of legislative goals, then procedures and regulations that ensure exactly that are hardly avoidable. If I focus more on achieving objectives and less on uniform procedures and decision-making criteria, then this also has consequences in times of high mobility, when people change their place of residence and the federal state. The debates on education are old and well known to everyone.

We experience a similar tension regarding democratic legitimacy through broad participation of citizens and interest groups on one side and the effectiveness and efficiency of state action on the other side. In other words: The legitimacy of the democratic state suffers when citizens are not involved in the decision-making process. It also suffers when the level of participation leads to solutions being delayed for an increasingly long time after the emergence of problems. This is, of course, not a plea against participatory processes. But what I want to say is: The balance of input and output of democracy must be continually reestablished.

The pronounced willingness to litigate in Germany also occasionally leads to regulations becoming tighter and more detailed. Who am I telling this to? Hardly any development plan, hardly any development statute, hardly any result of a tendering process goes unchallenged. There is nothing wrong with that. Only: Every successful lawsuit usually leads to the administration sharpening and often expanding procedural criteria to reduce future litigation risks.

Last but not least, we experience that new regulations are established without questioning the old ones, that regulation upon regulation is piled up. Especially with subordinate regulations, there is neither an expiration date nor regular reviews. I remember that many years ago—30 years ago now—I was tasked in the Lower Saxony state government with a deregulation process, where I had to check how many reports actually come in annually in a state government, initiated by someone. And we came to the astonishing result—the number is not the issue—that there were 1,400 reports for which someone has to work, entire teams have to work to keep them updated every year.

One of the reports we came across was titled "Potatoes to Berlin." Now, you have to imagine: This project ran in 1994/1995. "Potatoes to Berlin" was a topic during the Berlin blockade, in which food, including potatoes, was delivered from Lower Saxony to Berlin. The blockade had been over for 45 years, and the report still existed. No one was bothered by this because for 45 years, this report had been answered every year with "No report." I only take this as an example to suggest that it is justified to assume that there are many such reports and reporting obligations that deserve review.

I will refrain from further examples. But what I want to say is: Over the years, a regulatory thicket has emerged that even experts sometimes find hard to see through. Often, it is no longer clear where decisions are made and who is responsible for their implementation. And during the course of the European integration process, the complexity has rather increased. In other words: Anyone who has ever tightened a screw knows that after tight comes loose. It is similar with regulation: If you overdo it, you sometimes achieve the opposite of what you want. Rules that are supposed to create clarity then multiply confusion and lead to frustration among citizens.

And during my "local times," I hear exactly that: There is the head of a construction company who is applying for a public contract, wants to take on the public contract, but then encounters highly demanding tendering regulations that he cannot process without additional staff for his company as a craftsman or small to medium-sized enterprise. There is the master craftsman who feels completely overwhelmed by her reporting obligations, the glass producer who needs to hire skilled workers from abroad but fails due to bureaucratic hurdles, the elderly retiree who finds it impossible to understand which state benefits he must apply for at which office with which form, the working mother who would like to handle her official matters digitally but has to show up with stacks of paper for a personal appointment at the authority. That is just one side. There is also the other side, the older woman who complained to me indignantly about "those up there." Why? Not because there is too little digitalization, but because she has experienced that no one in the authorities can be reached by phone or spoken to anymore. And she says: "We don't need more digitalization; we need more advisory offices where we can go!" That is the contradiction we have to deal with.

And there are, very importantly, mayors—some of whom are here in the hall—who have many good ideas for their cities and municipalities but often have to experience that the multitude and density of rules leave them little or no room for maneuver. I repeatedly invite groups of mayors, and they know this, and then I hear that some of them are so busy trying to understand, implement, and supervise the requirements they have that they sometimes simply lack the time to take care of what they had set out to do or for which they were elected.

A capable state is essential! Especially today, in this time of crises and changes, we need a state that best supports the many committed people in our country in realizing their potential, a state that does its part to better unleash the forces that lie within the economy and society. This year's Nobel Prize winners in Economic Sciences have shown and pointed out how important the rule of law institutions are for growth and prosperity.

For many reasons, we must therefore find ways to make our state, its authorities, and institutions more capable, meaning: more citizen-oriented, modern, clearer, reliable, and above all, more effective. It is about tidying up the toolbox of the state, sharpening individual tools so that it can solve problems quickly and well and provide services quickly and well. I do not claim that this is an easy task. But I am convinced that it is a worthwhile effort in the service of our democracy!

That is why I am very pleased that the founders of the "Initiative for a Capable State" approached me some time ago. We have met several times in recent months to discuss. And I was very happy to take on the patronage of this project. The initiator and the initiators will soon explain to us what they have planned. Personally, it was very important to me that this initiative is not a purely expert commission in the classical sense. Because it particularly relies on the knowledge and experience of practitioners, of mayors, entrepreneurs, craftsmen, school principals, and much more.

I would like to thank everyone who wants to contribute to the working groups in the coming months. I thank the participating foundations for their support, you here in the hall, and everyone else for dedicating your time to this demanding task. My heartfelt thanks to all of you!

I hope that you will develop creative and tangible proposals, that your recommendations will be widely discussed, and that you will be able to encourage politics and administration to initiate reforms. And I am very aware: This is all easier said than done. It will not succeed all at once. But even if we know that, it must not be an excuse not to try. I think it would be irresponsible not to embark on this path, because if we strengthen the capacity of our state, then we also strengthen, I am convinced, the trust in our democracy. And I believe that is worth every effort!

I am now looking forward to the words of Mr. Voßkuhle, Ms. Jäkel, and Mr. Rohe. And I am curious about the discussion that will follow. Thank you very much!