Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on February 20, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

20 February 2023 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court · Bellevue Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony at Bellevue Palace on February 20, 2023, marking the change of judges in the Federal Constitutional Court's First Senate.
Main themes
Judicial appointment ceremony, Federal Constitutional Court, gender parity in the judiciary, farewell to departing judge Susanne Baer, appointment of new judge Martin Eifert, diversity and institutional quality, history of women on the Constitutional Court, anti-discrimination law, academic career in public law and gender studies
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,275
63rd percentile
Sentences
117
70th percentile
Readability
41
38th percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%35%
  • Ceremonial 35%35%
  • Social 27%27%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

117 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Sometimes the two comes before the one: Just a few weeks ago, we made two changes in the Second Senate of the Federal Constitutional Court here in Bellevue. Today, we need to make a change in the First Senate. So I may today dismiss you, dear Ms. Baer, and appoint you, dear Mr. Eifert. It has not turned into a double change: You, dear Ms. Britz, must continue to be available to the Senate despite the end of your term. With you, I hope that you will not have to "sit out" for too long. But at least you will now enjoy the role of the longest-serving member of the First Senate.

With you, dear Ms. Baer, a wise, strong judge is leaving the Federal Constitutional Court today. You are the thirteenth judge of the Federal Constitutional Court overall and the eighth in the First Senate. Of the 114 former and current members of the Federal Constitutional Court, only twenty have been women.

When you and Ms. Britz took office, you both heralded the end of what was then referred to as the "Snow White Senate." That was five years in which the First Senate was composed of seven men and only one woman – at that time, Ms. Hohmann-Dennhardt. Before that – from 1951 to 1994, for forty years – there had been such a composition: Erna Scheffler, Wiltraut Rupp-von Brünneck, Gisela Niemeyer, and Helga Seibert were each the only woman in the First Senate. Today, that has become unimaginable!

The turning point towards a gender-parity composition began with your terms, dear Ms. Baer, dear Ms. Britz. And although today a man is replacing a woman, the court remains parity-composed overall. Nothing suggests that we should turn back the clock at this point. Because we all know: Diversity promotes quality. Our country, our institutions need variety to bring in as many societal perspectives as possible. And this is especially true for the Federal Constitutional Court.

Dear Ms. Baer, this topic is anything but foreign to you. In the early 2000s, about ten years before your election as a Federal Constitutional Court judge, you received the call to the professorship for Public Law and Gender Studies at the Humboldt University of Berlin, a position you have held ever since. This was your first appointment after your declined offer to the University of Bielefeld, and it followed almost seamlessly after your habilitation on the topic "The Citizen in Administrative Law between Authority and Activating State." You remained professionally rooted in Berlin, where you grew up as a native of Saarland. Previously, you had already attracted attention with your award-winning dissertation in anti-discrimination law from the city of Frankfurt am Main – the short title is "Dignity or Equality?" At your chair, the Gender Competence Center you led was located until 2010. Your professorship is also the birthplace of the Humboldt Law Clinic for Fundamental and Human Rights and the Law and Society Institute, of which you were the founding director in 2009.

However, your impressive academic career began abroad, with a master's degree from the University of Michigan Law School in Ann Arbor. There, you are now the L. Bates Global Law Professor. In general, you have a special relationship with the USA. After graduating from high school, a trip took you there, when two of your siblings were already living there. You met in Chicago the American law professor and feminist Catharine MacKinnon. She inspired you, and you have remained friends to this day, organizing joint seminars, as I have heard.

Your aversion to any form of discrimination and your determined commitment to its elimination have long characterized you: During your studies in law and political science in Berlin, you were involved in the women's movement and in initiatives against domestic violence. Today, you work academically on comparative constitutional law, anti-discrimination law, interdisciplinary legal research, and co-edit the feminist legal journal STREIT.

Your teaching activities have taken you to Budapest, Bielefeld, Erfurt, Linz, and Toronto. In the future, you will be a guest at the renowned London School of Economics. It is hardly surprising that you have already been awarded three honorary doctorates and are a Corresponding Fellow of the British Academy.

You have left the high academic level several times in favor of university administration. You were Vice President for Studies and International Affairs, later Dean of Studies of the Faculty of Law at the Humboldt University of Berlin, and also a member of the University Council of the University of Bielefeld. Perhaps while holding these offices, you felt transported back to your time in Berlin administration, when, after the Second State Examination, before you plunged into academia, you were responsible for soil protection and community gardens as a consultant in the Senate Department for Urban Development and the Environment.

You brought this vast and diverse wealth of experience to the First Senate. Your department essentially covered labor law, social law, freedom of association, and academic freedom. It could hardly have been more fitting for you!

Right in your first major Senate case, it was about nothing less than human dignity. The Senate found the level of benefits for asylum seekers to be evidently insufficient and therefore unconstitutional. A decisive sentence from the ruling still resonates today, many know it: "The human dignity guaranteed in Article 1, Paragraph 1 of the Basic Law cannot be relativized in migration policy." The Senate repeated this about ten years later when it found the unconstitutionality of the so-called "special needs level" for single asylum seekers in collective accommodations. In the area of social law, the Senate also made important decisions regarding state basic security, particularly concerning the limits of sanctions to enforce the participation obligations of unemployed persons.

In labor law, the Federal Constitutional Court, with you as the reporting judge, made decisions that shape the reality of life for many people. Thus, numerous resolutions on the right to strike were issued in the chamber, and the Senate ruled on the prohibition of unlimited fixed-term contracts without cause, on the shop opening law in Thuringia, and on the Collective Bargaining Unity Act. For this ruling, you, together with Judge Paulus, wrote a dissenting opinion because you did not share the majority's conclusion. This was different with your "Concurring" on the Inheritance Tax Act, when you, along with Judges Masing and Gaier, stated that while you agreed with the majority's conclusion, you missed the reference to the social state principle in the reasoning.

In the area of freedom of association, the leading decision on the proportionality of association bans was issued under your leadership. The chamber subsequently dealt several times with the observation of associations by the Office for the Protection of the Constitution. The Senate's decision on the constitutionality of mandatory membership in chambers of commerce and industry is of great relevance for the economic life in our country, both then and now.

You are well acquainted with academic freedom from practice, and your personal experiences were certainly helpful. Some chamber decisions concerned the organizational safeguarding of academic freedom, not least the capacity calculation – a very broad, complicated, and error-prone field. Your judicial department also produced the Senate's decision to ban prohibitive tuition fees. You were also involved with the constitutional requirements for the organization of universities.

Dear Ms. Baer, in twelve years you have dealt with diverse, important constitutional questions and shaped significant decisions. Overall, you have handled over 4,600 cases – an almost unimaginable number of cases. And this clearly shows: There was evidently much to do in your department, and you faced the tasks with unwavering perseverance.

You once said that only a humanly appreciative and supportive environment allows for intellectual development. You have apparently succeeded in creating such an environment around you. Because it is reported that you always motivated and inspired your employees to achieve their best, but particularly sharpened their view beyond the horizon. "The monologue is deadly," that is said to have come from you. Thus, intensive professional discussions were the order of the day in your department. You were said to have taken on the role of Advocata Diaboli – sometimes so convincingly that it was only noticed late. Occasionally, in discussions, a single keyword you picked up would lead your employees to enjoy a spontaneous, polished mini-lecture – that must have been impressive. At the same time, your ability to listen extremely attentively is praised. Your employees experienced much appreciation from you, even, as I hear, during late-night burger dinners after exhausting workdays or during joint hiking, mountain biking, and canoeing.

The Senate will certainly also remember your great gift for getting straight to the point. And alongside your undisputed constitutional expertise, it is sometimes said that helpful specialized knowledge, for example from the field of rap and hip-hop, flowed into the Senate, both in the "Metal on Metal" case, when your former colleague Paulus, as I mentioned during his farewell, provided the DJ. Your extraordinary rhetorical talent is known both in and beyond the court: "Ms. Baer could have read the phone book – no: of course presented it freely – and everyone would have hung on her lips," someone told me.

Dear Ms. Baer, you would not be you if you had not shaped the Federal Constitutional Court beyond your judicial activities. "She is passionate about constitutional jurisdiction," I have heard. Besides adjudication, it was important to you to make the court itself visible and tangible. Thus, you have engaged with heart and soul in several major events of the court over many years, such as the celebration of the return to the renovated courthouse, the birthday of the Basic Law, and the Days of German Unity.

Furthermore, you cared about the internationality of the court. You advocated for translations of decisions into English and initiated a newsletter that informs within the Federal Constitutional Court about decisions of European and foreign courts. Your commitment to gender-sensitive language has not only been reflected in decisions but is said to have even made its way into the rules of procedure of the Federal Constitutional Court. A certain tenacity and strategic skill are attributed to you. "Thick boards must be drilled slowly," you are said to have said, "best never alone, but with allies." Perhaps this latter experience also stems from your time as a successful rower. As European champion in 1983 and – already as a junior – multiple German champion and participant in two world championships, you rowed – of course! – in the boat class "double without coxswain."

That you have also been committed to legal education for years, for example through your engagement with the nationwide Forum Recht, is not only consistent from your legal sociological perspective: The law must be lived, and it helps to bring the rule of law closer to people. For this, dear Ms. Baer, you have invested much time and energy over the past twelve years. I believe it is worth it.

You are now returning to Berlin, to the Humboldt University. You no longer need to impose judicial restraint on yourself. Perhaps you now have a bit more time for friends and family, for sports activities, or for American series that you can apparently watch with pleasure and endurance. In any case, many people will again enjoy your lectures and seminars. You will certainly open many doors for yourself and for others. You will continue to inspire people to doubt and to think, leaving traces. And you are said to have planned joint appearances with Peter Huber, whom I just recently met again at his alma mater in Munich. We can look forward to that as well.

I may now ask you, dear Ms. Baer, to come forward for the presentation of the certificate of dismissal.

And not only that. You have rendered outstanding services to our country. As a visible recognition of this, I may now award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany. Congratulations!

Dear Mr. Eifert, the German Bundestag elected you as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court on December 15, 2022. I congratulate you warmly on that! The members of the German Bundestag apparently quickly reached a consensus on you as a successor.

With you, a professor follows a professor in the First Senate. You took up your first professorship in Public Law in 2005 at the University of Gießen, which is well known to Ms. Britz and me. In 2012, you moved to the Humboldt University of Berlin, where you have held the Chair of Public Law, particularly Administrative Law, for over ten years. The HU is now getting Ms. Baer back, but will largely have to do without you, dear Mr. Eifert, for the next twelve years.

For your tasks in the First Senate, I am sure you are well equipped. You are excellently qualified academically. Your career path is, on the one hand, that of a classic public law professor with a relevant doctorate and habilitation. But beyond that, you have always dared to look beyond the horizon and broadened your perspective. You completed your law studies in Hamburg with a stay abroad in Geneva, and after the First State Examination, you completed a master's program in Berkeley in the USA. After the Second State Examination, before embarking on an academic career, you worked for some time as a management consultant at one of the world's leading firms. I am confident that your expertise will greatly enrich the Federal Constitutional Court.

I would now like to invite you forward for your appointment and swearing-in. Congratulations!