Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the occasion of the award of the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade to Amartya Sen on October 18, 2020, in Frankfurt am Main:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

19 October 2020 · Award of the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade to Amartya Sen · Paulskirche, Frankfurt am Main, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade ceremony at the Paulskirche in Frankfurt on October 18, 2020, honoring economist Amartya Sen virtually due to the pandemic.
Main themes
Global justice, freedom and human development, Amartya Sen's intellectual legacy, inequality and poverty, human capability approach, child labor, economic measurement beyond GDP, democracy and human rights, COVID-19 pandemic disruptions, Germany's global trade responsibility, moral philosophy and economics
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,385
65th percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.69
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.31
75th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Ceremonial 28%22%
  • Social 27%21%
  • Institutional 25%19%
  • Geopolitical 10%8%
  • Economic 10%8%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 22%

170 sentences in 49 paragraphs

The halls of the book fair deserted, the Paulskirche almost empty, the Peace Prize laureate on another continent – these are truly unusual times. Times that weigh heavily on the heart.

There is no normality in these times. And yet it is good that we hold on to this award ceremony. Today we honor a person who is uniquely connected to the idea of global justice. The search for justice and freedom must not pause, especially under the pressure of the Corona pandemic.

Who could be a better expedition leader for this search than today's laureate? With Amartya Sen, we honor a global citizen, a great public intellectual, a moral authority.

Dear Amartya Sen, it is unusually early for you, but nonetheless or precisely for that reason, a particularly warm good morning to Boston! How we would have loved to welcome you personally in Frankfurt. The Corona pandemic makes that impossible. And so you are far from us today, yet so close. Far, because we are separated by 6,000 kilometers and six time zones. And close, because your ideas and visions transcend every distance – between continents, cultures, and worldviews.

The digital world can never replace personal contact. But I have rarely been so grateful for the invention of video calling as I am today. We look forward to your acceptance speech!

Amartya Sen said of himself that he was "born on a university campus and seems to have lived on some campus all his life" – Cambridge, Delhi, Harvard, Stanford, Yale. He received his first professorship in Calcutta at the age of just 22. Outraged students at that time painted graffiti with a baby cradle on the faculty walls.

Amartya Sen is thoroughly an academic, but his work is not merely academic – at least not in the sense of being abstract, from the ivory tower for the ivory tower. He wanted to be understood. And as a scholar, he did not just want to comprehend the world. He wanted to change it. Amartya Sen has changed it.

His work spans six decades and ranges from economic theory to moral philosophy. His books are bestsellers. Amartya Sen holds more than a hundred honorary doctorates, and in 1998 he received the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences.

Now, then, the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade. Some observers asked: Does a Nobel laureate even need this award? I align myself with Carlo Schmid: The Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences may be the crown of expertise in economics, but the Peace Prize is the "citizen's crown of humanity."

We are presenting this citizen's crown today to a philosopher who does not wish to be a philosopher king. Instead, Sen wants to make the rulers into "real and thorough philosophers," enlightened politicians of freedom. Freedom from hunger, violence, oppression. Freedom to education, knowledge, personal development.

Amartya Sen writes against the inequalities and injustices of this world. His Human Development Index does not only consider gross domestic product; it looks at the well-being of people. For a society, Sen says, "can be economically highly efficient, but completely abhorrent."

Who, then, could deserve this award more than someone whose work, despite all its intellectual brilliance, is characterized above all by one thing: humanity. Thus, the Peace Prize honors the person Amartya Sen, and the person Amartya Sen honors the Peace Prize. And we here in the Paulskirche and in front of our televisions at home are happy to celebrate this moment together.

The right to a self-determined life for every person, regardless of their origin, skin color, without regard to their gender or sexual orientation, the right to education, to self-actualization, and not least the responsibility of the state and its institutions to enable exactly that: These are the convictions of Amartya Sen. They are core beliefs of a democrat that speak to my heart.

Amartya Sen has influenced generations of students, academic colleagues, indeed, his readers around the world. His writings have also broadened my view of economics. How do we measure the prosperity of a society? What constitutes good economic development? How do we achieve more global justice?

An appeal for more global justice falls on deaf ears if we do not critically examine our own actions. Germany benefits significantly from international division of labor. The value chains of our companies span the globe; our companies produce on all continents. Our prosperity depends on free global trade. We bear a great shared responsibility for fair global trade.

But our responsibility extends further. Global justice between North and South can only succeed if we become aware of the imbalances, the power asymmetries, as well as the interdependencies. And if we act accordingly. Or in Amartya Sen's words: Global justice can only succeed if we "share the world."

Still, more than seventy million children worldwide must work to avoid hunger. They are exploited in mines and quarries, laboring in cotton fields and banana plantations. They should be sitting at school desks!

The clothing in our stores also came from that textile factory in Dhaka, where thousands of people sat in cramped quarters at sewing machines. A fire broke out. We remember: The factory had no emergency exit. Far more than a hundred women died in the flames.

Dhaka is not an isolated case. Dhaka stands for the often inhumane working conditions in thousands of textile factories in South Asia and Africa. Dhaka is a symbol of the throwaway mentality and carelessness in the metropolises of the North, under which people in the metropolises of the South often suffer.

In a connected world, where we are closely linked as producers and consumers, as clients and suppliers, we need rules for globalization. These rules are not given by God; they are made by humans. If we recognize that these rules are unjust, must we not change the rules?

In some commentaries, it was said about this year's Peace Prize laureate: Global justice, freedom – that is all well and good. But in these tumultuous times, with the Black Lives Matter movement or the climate protests, are there not more pressing issues?

I consider that a misunderstanding. For Amartya Sen is precisely concerned with fundamental and particularly urgent matters. When Sen speaks of social and ecological justice, he is fundamentally always concerned with one thing: democracy. Democracy is for him the prerequisite for justice – and justice a fundamental prerequisite for democracy.

The fight against discrimination or against the life-threatening climate crisis – these are burning questions of justice to which our democracies must find answers. Yes, are these not elemental questions of justice to which democracy can provide an answer? What other form of government could continually realign justice under changing conditions and negotiate it for all?

Sen is aware of the weaknesses of democracy. "Democracy," he says, "is not an automatic remedy" against injustices. "Democracy is a way to empower people" to advocate for justice. In his words: "Democracy isn’t an automatic remedy of anything. It isn’t like quinine to kill malaria. Democracy is a way of enabling."

The hundred thousand young people at the climate protests, the enormous impact with which they have brought the ecological question to the center of politics, show how much democracy empowers people to stand up for their convictions and drive politics forward.

Criticism, opposition, protest are – beyond institutionalized procedures – an important part of democracy. They promote social change. They can turn initial minority opinions into the mainstream. But protest does not replace democratic majorities within the institutions responsible for decisions. The negotiation of conflicting interests there remains laborious and often lengthy. The results are often compromises and are not always satisfactory. Yes, democracy is not perfect. And it will never be. It is as imperfect as the people who live in it.

Here lies the challenge for our democracy: In the competition of political systems, it must continually prove whether it has the better answers to the great questions of our time. That it is better at ending discrimination. That it is better at achieving both: doing what is right for the planet and maintaining social justice in the ecological transformation.

Democracy does not protect us from wrong decisions. But it allows us to correct mistakes. No other form of government has a built-in mechanism for self-correction. And this ability to correct lies in free, fair, equal, and secret elections.

It is in our hands whether democracy can assert itself in the competition of systems. Let us face this responsibility!

The motto of Ferdinand I, Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, was "Fiat iustitia et pereat mundus." Justice at any cost, even if the world perishes?

Amartya Sen is a pragmatist of justice. He is not concerned with fighting for a perfectly just world, even if there were consensus on what that should look like.

Amartya Sen admires John Rawls' philosophy of justice for its theoretical brilliance. Designing a just world behind the "veil of ignorance," that is, regardless of one's own situation, seems tempting. However, Sen does not consider that either practicable or realistic. He wants to eliminate concrete and obvious injustices in the here and now.

Whether more state or more market is best suited for that, Sen considers quite soberly, without any ideology. He is concerned with the outcome; he wants to know: Where does the state empower people to lead a self-determined life? Where do justice and freedom flourish from personal responsibility? And where is solidarity required, even beyond the borders of one's own state?

These are questions that are never abstract and gain pressing concreteness in the great crises of this time. We know: Crises have never been the great equalizers they are often described as. Crises deepen divisions. The Corona pandemic affects all people and states, but it does not affect everyone equally. Where there is a lack of structures in healthcare, where the nutritional situation is poor, where great poverty prevails, there the virus strikes disproportionately hard.

The Corona pandemic is a litmus test for international solidarity and global cooperation in research and politics. Nowhere is this more clearly crystallized than in the question of a fair global distribution of a vaccine. A just global distribution is both: well-understood self-interest and categorical imperative. Let us do everything we can to ensure that humanity passes this test of its humanity!

For Sen, there is no real justice without political freedom, and no political freedom without democracy. One cannot be conceived without the other. Democracy is therefore also not a luxury item for rich countries and not merely a normative project of the West. It is a global yearning and a universal promise. The demonstrators on the streets of Caracas, Minsk, and Hong Kong remind us of this!

The universalism of democracy and fundamental human rights – these are the cornerstones of Sen's philosophy. This is the core of a fundamental insight that is once again under pressure today.

Sen weaves writings from Sanskrit with European intellectual history, connects John Stuart Mill with John Rawls, the Bhagavad Gita with Jürgen Habermas. He wants to show: In many parts of the world, there are related notions of justice, democracy, and freedom.

The universal claim of fundamental human rights is therefore not a Western or Eastern, not a European or Asian, not a German or Indian thought, but – as Amartya Sen emphasizes – a human one.

Seventy years ago, it was possible to give this hope a foundation with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: "All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights." This sentence is not only copyrighted by Europeans or North Americans. And it is not solely a Jewish-Christian heritage. This sentence was also co-written and adopted by Africans and Asians, by Buddhists, Muslims, and Hindus. Even if this promise has never been perfect, never equally present for all, it remains an epochal achievement in all its imperfection.

But what has been achieved is not guaranteed simply because it has been achieved. Worldwide, we see signs that the attained civilizational level is being called into question, that international legal obligations are being disregarded. Even in our neighborhood, fundamental democratic principles are being challenged. Freedom rights are being undermined, independent media and justice are brought under the control of governments.

Where democracy erodes, so do human rights. And where human rights erode, so does democracy. Democracy does not die in the dark. If it dies, it dies in the daylight, before all our eyes. We see how the international order is faltering, how authoritarian tendencies and nationalism are on the rise worldwide. Is there still hope?

Explicitly yes, and it is in our hands. Hasn't it been shown in these times of pandemic: Our democracy can respond to existential threats, and it can do so quickly, efficiently, and powerfully. And at the same time, it can preserve freedom. Whether it can continue to maintain the balance between security and freedom is not a given. It depends on all of us.

Trust, reason, diversity, solidarity – these are the strengths of our democracy. If we continue to rely on these strengths, then we have every reason to hope. Today, 75 years after the end of World War II and in the thirtieth year of German unity, we Germans can confidently say: It is not democracy that has historically failed. It is the enemies of democracy that have failed. Let us draw courage and hope from this.

At the opening of the book fair, David Grossman called hope a kind of anchor. He said: "When the anchor is thrown, it holds on to the future." To believe in the future and to have hope – that is also what the Peace Prize stands for. And for that, we honor Amartya Sen today.

Amartya Sen writes prose, but he loves poetry. He often quotes the Bengali poet Ram Mohan Roy: "Imagine how terrible the day of your death will be. / Others will continue to talk, but you will not be able to respond."

Amartya, which means the immortal. Yes, his visions are immortal – and they demand answers! Let us work on that!

Congratulations, dear Amartya Sen, on receiving the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade 2020!

(The speech of the Federal President was read in the Paulskirche by the actor Burghart Klaußner.)