Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the presentation of the study on dealing with the Nazi era on October 11, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

15 October 2023 · Presentation of the study on dealing with the Nazi era · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at Schloss Bellevue on October 11, 2023, at the presentation of Professor Norbert Frei's study on how Federal Presidents dealt with the Nazi era.
Main themes
Holocaust memory and German identity, dealing with the Nazi past, democratic self-understanding, right-wing populism and historical revisionism, historikerstreit legacy, constitutional values and patriotism, Federal Presidents and NS history, historical responsibility of state institutions, continuities before and after 1945, Norbert Frei's study presentation
Duration
~12 min
43rd percentile
Words
1,482
43rd percentile
Sentences
74
48th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 51%49%
  • Institutional 27%26%
  • Ceremonial 19%18%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

74 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Almost forty years ago, when the so-called Historikerstreit was conducted in the old Federal Republic, it was not only about how singular the Holocaust had been in world history. It was also about its significance for the self-understanding of the Germans in the post-war democracy. Should the Germans understand their history only as a source of national pride and self-confidence? Or should the civilizational break of the Holocaust be a central point of reference for a new, democratic self-understanding?

You all know the clear answer to these questions: The Holocaust is inextricably linked to us. Our democracy lives from the knowledge of its prehistory; indeed, it needs this knowledge. Because the past is never over, there is no final point between what was and what is today. The past shapes the present. And it forms the foundation on which our democratic society builds its future.

It was Jürgen Habermas who, during the Historikerstreit, called for a patriotism of values – those values that continue to shape our constitution, the Basic Law, to this day: the commitment to human dignity; the openness to European integration; the establishment of a liberal, yet resilient democracy. Those who remember the Historikerstreit today can appreciate how long the road has been and how great the resistance has been until the critical engagement with National Socialism and German guilt became a firm part of our national self-understanding.

Why am I telling you this today, almost four decades later? Because at this moment, political forces are once again gaining strength in our democracy that shorten and distort history, "straightening" it in their sense. Because once again, an end to the alleged "cult of guilt" is being demanded. Because the Holocaust is being relativized even in our country. Because hatred and incitement sometimes displace the public debate shaped by responsibility. And because the boundaries of what can be said are being deliberately shifted by some towards the unspeakable.

Democracy is not a state. It is never finished, always in the making, and never guaranteed for eternity. Our democracy does not live from the articles of the Basic Law, but because it is desired and lived by the citizens. This includes defending it against those who threaten or even despise democracy – and always being clear about the codes that contempt for democracy employs.

Or as it says in a wise essay from 2019: "Those who want to understand the recent successes of the right-wing populists would do well to recall the conditions under which right-wing patterns of thought took hold and found followers after 1945 [...] If you look more closely, the old slogans have hardly changed over the decades. What is new, however, is that and to what extent the tirelessly recycled demands for a 'final point' [...], for a healed history, a 'pure' nation [...] resonate." These lines were written by Professor Norbert Frei.

I am pleased to welcome you here today at Schloss Bellevue. The book that you, dear Professor Frei, are presenting to us today – "In the Name of the Germans. The Federal Presidents and the NS Past" – is the culmination and result of three years of research work. A work that deals with the past and is precisely why it is so significant for our present. You, dear Professor Frei, have delved into the archives with your team; you have sifted through files, correspondence, speech drafts, notes, and templates. I am very grateful to you for that.

Many ministries and authorities have had their handling of National Socialism in the young Federal Republic scientifically examined in recent years, and it was clear to me that the office of the head of state must not shy away from this task. How did the first Federal Presidents of our country view the time of National Socialism – and also their own biographical past? How did they express themselves about perpetrators and deeds, how did they speak about it in speeches, during state visits, or on memorial days? How did they remember the victims of German crimes? How did they deal with the NS past of award recipients during award ceremonies? What continuities existed before and after 1945? And how much were the heads of state drivers or driven by societal development? Your research, dear Professor Frei, provides a scientific answer to all these questions.

For the Federal President, it is a special obligation to confront the history of this office. A Federal President should provide orientation, also for the future of our society. And for that, engaging with the past – and, as I believe, also with the past of the Federal Presidential Office – is indispensable. Historical responsibility does not end at one's own door. That is why it was overdue to initiate this research project in 2019: an independent investigation that should go beyond a mere history of the agency and the exploration of possible personnel and ideological continuities or breaks with the NS era and ideally tell a history of the impact of National Socialism.

I am very pleased that the commission for this project was awarded to you after a two-stage selection process. Because as Jürgen Habermas once said about you: In your person, "the historian striving for objectivity and the politically engaged enlightener are united." How right he is!

I would also like to thank the members of the scientific advisory board who have supported and advised us on this project, starting with the selection decision. My thanks go to Professor Gabriele Metzler and Professor Sybille Steinbacher, Professor Anselm Doering-Manteuffel, Dr. Thomas Hertfelder, and Professor Michael Hollmann.

When Theodor Heuss was elected as the first Federal President on September 12, 1949, the National Socialist tyranny, the Second World War, and the civilizational break of the Holocaust were only four years in the past. Yet even in his inaugural speech, Heuss was dealing with an audience that was more or less vocally demanding a "great final point." In his speech, Heuss addressed this desire on the one hand by speaking of the "past that now lies behind us." On the other hand, he clearly lamented that "some people in Germany [...] want to forget too quickly."

Much of what was then called "coming to terms with the past" and what we now refer to as a culture of remembrance goes back to the speeches and actions of Theodor Heuss. He coined the term "collective shame." He used the National Day of Mourning in November 1952 to commemorate not only the German war dead in the Bundestag but explicitly the murdered Jews and victims of concentration camps. And when he said at the opening of the memorial site in Bergen-Belsen just a few weeks later: "We knew about these things," it was a provocation for many.

The "credible embodiment [...], wanting to learn from the past," is, as Professor Frei writes in the now available study, "the unending task of presidential action." All six Federal Presidents of the old Federal Republic – Theodor Heuss, Heinrich Lübke, Gustav Heinemann, Walter Scheel, Karl Carstens, and Richard von Weizsäcker – have faced and had to face this task, regardless of some differences in personal style. Who was a pace-setter, who was merely a routine player, or even a brake, will be elaborated on by Professor Frei shortly.

I cannot and do not want to preempt that, but since I had the privilege of having already taken a look at this book, I would like to share with you a significant impression: Some images become suddenly more diverse and also more contrasting upon closer inspection. Heinrich Lübke, for example, had been held in custody by the Nazis for more than a year and a half and made some decisions as Federal President that one would not have suspected given the spirit of the early 1960s.

" A story of guilt and shame, of forgetting and re-actualization," Professor Frei calls his now available book. An important part of this story also includes the staff of the Federal Presidential Office at that time. Their political origins, their attitudes, and their past could not and must not be disregarded in such a fundamental investigation. How did they experience the twelve years of National Socialist rule? How did their personal development shape their later work for the Federal Presidents? The answers to these questions also belong to a history of the impact of National Socialism.

Especially in this time, when our democracy is so challenged, we as a society must be aware of our history. Because what should not be repeated must not be forgotten either. The "Never again!" is much more than the moral foundation of our liberal democratic society. It is a mandate for all generations, for today as well as for all future ones.

And now I would like to ask Professor Frei to explain the results of his research work to us.

Thank you very much.