Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier "World Ethos Speech" on October 15, 2019, in Tübingen:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

21 October 2019 · World Ethos Speech · Tübingen, Germany

Context
Steinmeier delivered the annual World Ethos Lecture at the University of Tübingen on October 15, 2019, honoring Hans Küng and the Global Ethic Foundation.
Main themes
Global ethic, world peace and religious peace, faith and knowledge, foundations of coexistence, political ethos, Hans Küng's legacy, Jürgen Habermas's philosophy, nationalism and public discourse, ecumenical theology, humane values, interreligious dialogue
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,758
84th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.15
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.31
76th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 44%43%
  • Ceremonial 25%24%
  • Geopolitical 15%14%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

180 sentences in 66 paragraphs

"In these hallowed halls

One does not know revenge.

And if a person has fallen,

Love leads him to duty [...]

In these sacred walls

Where one human loves another,

No traitor can lurk,

Because one forgives the enemy.

Whoever is not pleased by such teachings

Does not deserve to be called a human being."

By "these hallowed halls," it is, of course, not the festive hall of the University of Tübingen that is meant, nor its lecture halls and seminar rooms. But it would not be entirely wrong either. It would not be wrong to establish a connection between the humane utopia that this song of Sarastro from The Magic Flute repeatedly touches upon for the listeners, a connection between the singer and what was first considered and reflected upon here in Tübingen, namely the idea of a global ethic.

Global ethic – is it even worth discussing anymore? Is it all at best just a dream of poetic and musical art? Is it still possible, or even promising, in this so torn world – or even just in our own German society – to come to an understanding about a common ethos, common value foundations of our coexistence? Is resignation not already spreading in many places?

Jürgen Habermas, the now ninety-year-old Nestor of German philosophy, will publish a new, almost 1,800-page book next month titled "Also a History of Philosophy." This massive opus deals, in short, with the more than thousand-year history of the relationship between faith and knowledge, religion and enlightened thinking, and not only that, but also with their mutual influence and confrontation. However, it is also driven by exactly this question: What "motivational resources" do we still have to draw strength for autonomous action, so that in "perceiving unavoidable problems we can trust and demand the spontaneity of reasonable freedom from ourselves and each other."

In doing so, Habermas identifies a sensitive, even destructive lack of public communication about the foundations of coexistence as a main problem. Or if you want to hear it in his words: "The dried-up national public spheres, into which many relevant topics no longer penetrate, are transforming into arenas of distraction and discontent and increasingly also of nationalist resentment."

It is striking that Jürgen Habermas, in this concern and this problem statement, also encounters questions that the idea of a global ethic initiated by Hans Küng raises. So there is agreement, at least in the problem statement, between the two currently most well-known living German-speaking scholars who have not become popes.

For the following modest thoughts on a political ethos and on coexistence in today's world, I would like to consciously draw inspiration from this place here, from Tübingen, and therefore repeatedly refer to Tübingen's history, events, and of course people.

You will allow me, therefore, to first warmly greet Hans Küng, without whom there would be neither the idea of a global ethic nor the foundation of the same name, nor this annual global ethic lecture.

I gladly accepted the invitation to give this lecture this year, especially out of respect for and admiration of Hans Küng, the great scholar who – although still a Swiss citizen to this day – has strengthened Germany's reputation as a place of theology and university scholarship worldwide for decades.

The University of Tübingen, but also the German humanities as a whole, have every reason to be grateful to Hans Küng. He has not only represented his field, Catholic and ecumenical theology, in a way that is understandable to broad circles, as evidenced by the high print runs and translations of his works into so many languages of the world, but he has also critically and constructively accompanied political and intellectual life in engaged contemporaneity.

In his Swiss incorruptibility and also in his Swiss obstinacy, he has not shied away from any dispute or confrontation. A lasting role model of a university teacher who is at the same time a vigilant political observer and engaged citizen. Such minds are role models; such attitudes embody an ethos by which one can measure oneself. From this place, then: Thank you for everything, esteemed dear Hans Küng. Even if your physical strength prevents you from being here today, you are nonetheless with us all the more through your idea and your spirit.

Hans Küng's commitment to peace and to understanding among religions was recently reflected for me like in a mirror when I had the honor of opening the World Assembly of Religions for Peace in Lindau in August. A piece of Tübingen in Lindau. The same spirit that speaks from the conception of the global ethic also inspired the participants of this assembly. "No world peace without religious peace" – this short formula, which also characterized many events there, has been repeatedly emphasized by Küng and the Global Ethic Foundation as a central element of their fundamental conviction.

This formula has been made effectively vivid and plausible through scientific and journalistic activities for an international audience. Let us all hope together that this seed continues to grow. How necessary this is became unmistakably clear in Lindau. How well this can succeed and how it is supported by the will of so many, I was also able to feel there. Cooperation among religions with a global ethical intention is something whose necessity has also been recognized by diplomacy and foreign policy, and for which I am myself engaged out of great conviction.

In the everyday life of many societies, religion is indeed a powerful factor. And for practical world politics, religions play an increasingly significant role, as is becoming ever clearer. Therefore, all those who want to come to an understanding about common ethical foundations and about the ethos of coexistence must engage with the actual contemporary form of religions in their culture-shaping effect. This cannot be emphasized enough, as Hans Küng has seen more than others.

How did Hans Küng come to his question and where did he formulate it? Just as there are places that have a paradigmatic significance for the idea of our democracy, places of the freedom revolution and of parliamentary new beginnings, there are also special places of thought that turn towards the world. Hans Küng's academic life cannot be imagined without Tübingen, that small, great city, of which Walter Jens once is said to have remarked: Cologne has a university, Hamburg can afford a university – Tübingen is a university.

It is probably not a coincidence that a conception like that of the global ethic was born precisely here. Goethe once said about Weimar: "From there, the gates and roads lead to all ends of the world." He wanted to convey to his assistant Eckermann that in the great world there is nothing of relevance that does not also arrive, be critically considered, and be intellectually and politically evaluated in small Weimar. I think: What applied to Weimar applies even more to Tübingen.

This justifies the idea of the universal validity claim of values, the awareness of a global ethic, for world responsibility: that everything reaches us, that everything concerns us, which reaches us through our analog or digital gates and roads from all ends of the world.

Those who today present the promises of new nationalism or fundamentalism with faces twisted in rage believe that the gates and paths can be closed, that global connections can be severed. But the opposite is the case. Global connections, dependencies, problems, and relationships of proximity continue to increase. They are of a technical-economic, ecological, but above all also of an ideal and cultural nature. What was once distant is coming closer to us. I am thinking not only of flight and migration but also of the digital communication space, which immediately brings every emotionally stirring event, every idea, every appeal, every ideology before our eyes and into our senses. Proximity then means friction, imposition, demand! To the extent that this has become and will continue to be the modern condition of humanity, we need all the more normative understanding.

We are dealing with each other. We are in the world – and the world is with us.

Normative understanding thus means both: a constant effort towards the peaceability of our mutual international relations and, at the same time, towards the inner peace of our own societies.

This is what we are reflecting on today here in Tübingen. The genius loci of Tübingen has often and repeatedly been shaped by the spirit of conversation, of learned disputation, of peaceful confrontation of great minds. The famous triad of the seminary students Hölderlin, Schelling, Hegel stands as a prime example.

One of them, Friedrich Hölderlin, wrote some of the most wonderful poems in the German language before he spent the second half of his life in so-called mental derangement here in Tübingen. In his poem "Peace Celebration," there is the line: "Since we are a conversation and hear from one another, [...]"

"Since we are a conversation": This seems to me an appropriate and also striking guiding thought for the possibility and reality of a global ethic.

"Since we are a conversation and hear from one another": Thus, a civil, peace-loving manner of confrontation is expressed in a very noble and restrained way, a conversation in "reasonable freedom," as Jürgen Habermas calls it. A conversation between people of the most diverse backgrounds, convictions, and attitudes.

If I only imagine who was found here at the same university in the 1960s of the last century – and indeed simultaneously: the Marxist Ernst Bloch, who had just written "Atheism in Christianity," and Joseph Ratzinger, the later pope, who published his bestseller "Introduction to Christianity," to name just these two paradigmatically.

Embodiments of foreign and indeed opposing worlds – but still in confrontation with each other and not each in his safe space, his filter bubble. Bloch's concise, magnificent sentence: "To think means to transcend," the sentence that stands on his gravestone here in Tübingen, always also means transcending one's own, always limited world, in order to let the other show a different piece of the world, a different perspective.

To elevate it to a politically-sociological level with Habermas: "Mutual perspective-taking symmetrically leads to the discovery of new traits in the other. It aims at something other than a one-sided inclusion of another into one's own horizon; rather, both parties must find out in which constructively to be designed horizon of shared behavioral expectations they want to live together." In other words: Real encounters change those who meet, and indeed both – and this change brings the possibility of real commonality, or better: in the differences that remain, the possibility of discovering what is common.

A common ethos that is to underlie our coexistence in our own society, but indeed also worldwide, urgently enables and needs exactly such conversation and hearing from one another.

"Since we are a conversation": It was not always peaceful at the German universities in those 1960s and 1970s. And the terrorism that claimed to radically realize the goals of the revolting youth reached its peak in October 1977, the so-called German Autumn. I take this time period because it was precisely during those days between the kidnapping of Hanns Martin Schleyer and that of the Landshut airplane that the celebrations for the 500th anniversary of Eberhard Karls University took place here in Tübingen.

Three

speeches that were held on this occasion are an impressive testimony to a simultaneously measured and determined reaction in heated times, in a situation that was extremely threatening to the community and its common ethical foundations.

The

first

– which I find significant because it is very self-critical – speech by Federal President Walter Scheel sounds almost like a single offer of conversation directed at the revolting students. He tried to address their genuine concerns. And this in light of the danger, as he said, that our country "falls apart into two hostile camps." He speaks of entire groups "that leave no good hair on this state," but rather "ridicule the government, parliament, trade unions, courts, authorities." They even despised the state institutions as "enemies of the people." Is that not disturbingly current? In many of our Western societies and indeed also here, we are currently confronted with structurally analogous phenomena. Scheel coined the then-famous term of critical sympathy, which was to shape the relationship of citizens to the state.

Such critical sympathy presupposes serious conversation. I believe that this is exactly what matters today: to possess the sovereignty to allow calmness and prudence to prevail, to engage in conversations where conversations are possible, to expose the infamous rhetoric of "enemies of the people" as wicked deceit, and to address the concerns of those who feel unheard or misunderstood with honest, credible openness.

The second speech also strikes a measured tone that comes from the ethos of conversation and understanding: the commemorative address by Hans Küng on the same day. It was, by the way, a small sensation to have Hans Küng, the Catholic, deliver the keynote address at a university that is traditionally very Protestant – a widely noted example. A widely noted example of the irenic spirit of the university leaders at that time. He spoke about the tense relationship between faith and rational science. Each, taken on its own, can lead to dangerous hubris: pure science without engagement with ethical or transcendent beliefs can develop disoriented fantasies of omnipotence. And religion that does not confront reason can become blind to reality and be seduced into unyielding dogmatism, with terrible consequences – one of perhaps the most catastrophic threats to a common ethos. We see this again today with all clarity, unfortunately, in many parts of the world.

Conversation always has to do with patience, at least when it is truly about understanding and communication. This applies, as I said, domestically; it applies even more so in the realm of foreign policy, in diplomacy; it applies in contract negotiations, in careful, respectful, unwaveringly solution-oriented dialogue. One of the most important experiences of my political life has made this unforgettable for me: the twelve-year negotiations over the nuclear agreement with Iran.

Twelve years of maintaining the conversation and repeatedly renewing the conversation, after interruptions and breaks, until the breakthrough was achieved. Whether the six foreign ministers who achieved the negotiation result were right or the one who brought the result crashing down just over a year later is another matter. Historians will evaluate that later.

But how often did I have to think during stagnant negotiations of that pious image, unique in art history, which can be found in Augsburg and which Thomas Sternberg drew my attention to: an image of the Queen of Heaven, Mary, as the Knot-Resolver. In her hand, she holds a tangled ball of thread, a knot, from which she, with infinite – one could say: heavenly patience – untangles the threads from the seemingly inextricable knot.

Does not the political ethos of responsible politicians consist in the modest, unwavering, patient untying of knots? I understand knot-tying as an ethical principle of political engagement, especially today.

But what if every offer of conversation falls on deaf ears? The third Tübingen anniversary speech clearly named this problem: a sermon by the Protestant theologian Eberhard Jüngel the next day. He explained how lies and half-truths destroy any reasonable conversation or prevent it from even taking place. And that a conversation also involves imposing uncomfortable truths on others, not sparing the partner or opponent. In this sense, he addressed the terrorists directly: "Repent, not before, but although it is already too late. […] Only the acknowledgment of the hard and relentless truth that you have not only become enemies of human society, but that you have no worse enemies than yourselves, can still help you. Only this truth can free you from yourselves."

Can one then, should one also speak reasonably with or at least to the unreasonable? The ethos of conversation includes the free and decisive word, especially when the chance of being heard at all is minimal. But talking reasonably with the unreasonable must not mean lowering oneself to the same level. To speak reasonably with the unreasonable, to tell them what they do not want to hear: that means precisely to remain true to one's own ethical conviction. It means to impose on the other, but also to trust them to discover or rediscover a common ethical foundation. It means to clearly and distinctly demonstrate that no one can be excluded from the common ethical foundation or be dispensed from the common ethical obligation.

The frictions currently evident within individual Western societies, as well as the frictions that arise within the world society, make what I have just said – admittedly very briefly – appear like the famous work of Sisyphus. A task that can sometimes be exhausting and that also occasionally knows hours of confusion or despair. But is there an alternative? An alternative to the friend-enemy thinking, to irreconcilable hatred? That can quickly lead to friend-enemy actions, thus violent confrontations, civil war, and war, which historically have mostly followed?

No, the idea of a world ethos has by no means become obsolete. On the contrary, it is of unprecedented historical urgency. But world ethos, ethos in general, is not primarily writing and paper. It contains a categorical imperative that obliges all people of good will. And indeed to persistent, even burdensome, targeted work on understanding and peace. In untying the most complicated knots. In listening to one another. In patient conversation.

But what if, you may object, time is running out? If there is seemingly no time left for patient conversation, for endless rounds of negotiation, for consideration and weighing, for arguments and counterarguments? What if a young generation cannot yet decide and execute what seems to them absolutely necessary politics, while they must still experience the consequences of inaction? And if an older generation postpones necessary action from one year to the next, the terrible consequences of which they will no longer experience?

Does not the "How dare you?" recently from New York – however one may have felt about the intense pathos of the young girl – resonate with a certain right in our ears and consciences? And does not the question of one generation's responsibility for the next and all those that follow raise entirely new questions about the formulation and practical implementation of a world ethos?

And in light of the disappearance of biodiversity – species are disappearing every year, every month, indeed every day – is there not also a completely new ethical dimension and challenge to consider, which has recently been tentatively referred to as the rights revolution of nature?

Day by day, we see the consequences of climate change. Its causes, at least for the most part man-made, can no reasonable person deny any longer. Does it not compel us to make decisions that have immediate consequences?

Peter Graf von Kielmannsegg recently raised in a thought-provoking essay the question of whether democracy in its current form and with its procedural methods and endless possibilities for objection is still capable of implementing the necessary decisions in practice, or whether only something like an eco-dictatorship could save us. Undoubtedly, the global questions of climate and biodiversity present us with new political and also political-theoretical questions. Questions that also address the theory and practice of a world ethos.

My conviction is decidedly this: especially now, especially in the face of pressing ecological questions, we should beware of downplaying the possibilities of democracy against the threatening, indeed almost apocalyptic magnitude of the challenge. We should beware of pitting one side against the other in democracy: for example, the passion and determination of young people on the streets against the supposed procedural obsession and exceedingly sober sluggishness of democratic institutions. Right now, we must know how to utilize what only democracy as a form of government offers us: the space for joint knot-tying. Passion and determination have their place in it just as much as readiness for dialogue and reason. Democrats must be both: radically willing to communicate and passionately reasonable, as Carsten Brosda writes. From both together, courage must arise to make decisions.

I quote once again from Walter Scheel's Tübingen speech: "It often takes a devilish courage, I speak from personal experience, for a politician to make a decision in such a complex, infinitely multifaceted, and no longer comprehensible society." That was in 1977! If, as I have occasionally said, democracy is the form of government for the courageous, then courage, especially the courage to decide, must belong to the ethos of the politician.

But decision-making courage does not mean – as is implied in the current revival of authoritarian worldviews – tackling the proverbial Gordian knot daily with leaderly pathos and a sharp sword. Much more than just the knot usually gets broken in the process. No: it is about holding on to knot-tying decisively, persistently, and consistently, also taking those at the shorter end of the thread along with us. Even where decisions must be made and implemented quickly.

Jürgen Habermas encourages us at the end of his new work to trust in the power of reasonable freedom. It is especially important that "the acting political class," as he says, "does not capitulate." That it does not allow itself to be intimidated "by the perception of allegedly systemic over-complexity."

No, we will not be intimidated. Not by the supposedly over-complex problems, but also not by the terrible simplifiers who want to divide the world into friend and foe and already know the solutions before they have understood the tasks.

We know that there is no paradise on earth. And whoever has ever tried to create it in the past – and the new human being along with it – has brought nothing but ruin. We know that the utopia from The Magic Flute is a poetic dream for which we have a deep longing, but which we as humans cannot realize ourselves.

This insight does not mean leaving the world as it is. We can make it better piece by piece. We can set ourselves the task of untying one knot after another. And let us be guided in this patient work by the claim that I would like to formulate once again with the famous words of a Tübingen resident, the teacher of hope, Ernst Bloch, that the world may become for us humans what "seems like childhood to all and in which no one has yet been: home."

Thank you very much!