Speech by Federal President Horst Köhler at the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Bundeswehr Leadership Academy on September 14, 2007, in Hamburg:

Germany Horst Köhler · President of Germany

17 September 2007 · Celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Bundeswehr Leadership Academy · Bundeswehr Leadership Academy, Hamburg, Germany

Context
Köhler addressed the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Bundeswehr Leadership Academy on September 14, 2007, in Hamburg.
Main themes
Leadership selection and elite formation, Bundeswehr Leadership Academy anniversary, military education and broad general training, equal opportunity and talent promotion, democratic elites and responsibility, compulsory military service, Prussian military reform tradition, educational disadvantage and social mobility, German society and human potential
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,158
77th percentile
Sentences
146
80th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
53rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 42%39%
  • Geopolitical 29%27%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

146 sentences in 42 paragraphs

"Standards of Leadership Selection"

I.

It is a pleasure for my wife and me to be here with you today. I sincerely congratulate the Leadership Academy of the Bundeswehr on its impressive anniversary. The founding ideas of the Leadership Academy and its achievements are convincing. It has proven itself excellently. Its contribution remains indispensable.

I also find the motto of the Leadership Academy appealing: Mens agitat molem – The mind moves matter. Telekinetic strength – I wish for this for myself and for all those who bear responsibility in Germany. There is enough inertia that craves movement.

II.

The intellectual foundation of the Leadership Academy has been and is firstly the commitment to systematic selection of the best, which means: to the elite, and secondly the conviction: Military leadership requires more than solid military craftsmanship: It demands as broad an education and scientific training as possible.

Systematic selection of the best with equal opportunity – unfortunately, we are far from this in most other areas of life. In the public service, the only equivalents to the Leadership Academy that come to mind are the entrance exam and the attaché training of the Foreign Office, but these are at the beginning of a career. In other areas of the state, economy, and society, there is probably nothing that can be compared to the general staff officer selection of the Bundeswehr. On the contrary: Numerous studies show how some elite segments, whether intentionally or not, reproduce themselves, in other words: they close themselves off to high-performing talents from outside.

The Federal Republic has long struggled with the idea of systematically identifying and promoting talent, performance, and leadership readiness. In the first half of the 20th century, the German elites failed in a terrible way – thus, every attempt at a new selection of leaders quickly fell under political suspicion. However, after 1945, it would have been better to draw the opposite conclusion and to work much harder to shape a democratic elite of performance and responsibility with a common value canon. This, of course, presupposes equal opportunity already in school – while in our country to this day, a child of a skilled worker with equal performance has only a fraction of the chances of an academic child to attend high school, and the talents of children from educationally disadvantaged backgrounds and immigrant families are practically left untapped. This presupposes universities whose quality in teaching, research, and academic community fosters lifelong gratitude among graduates and the conviction that the community has given them something very valuable and now rightly expects an excellent contribution to the common good from the best – as for how the university conveys such feelings and attitudes today, you might want to ask your children. And this requires more support for gifted individuals than is currently the case, where the gifted support organizations reach only a fraction of the "high potentials" of each cohort. In all these areas, an incredible amount of work needs to be done to elevate the human potential of our country and to foster the necessary commonality among the democrats for those who will come after us and take on leadership positions. This remedial work has only just begun.

Against this background, the achievement of the Bundeswehr and its Leadership Academy shines all the brighter. It is exemplary close to the ideal of selecting the best. This, by the way, does not exclude military family traditions; on the contrary, it also thrives on them. The successful selection has repeatedly found its expression in the leadership positions that NATO has to offer. And take note: This formation of a military elite has been impressively achieved thanks to compulsory military service – one of many good arguments for this service.

III.

As the

second

founding idea of the Leadership Academy, I have identified the conviction: The military leader, and especially the staff officer, needs more than just military skill. He needs a broad general education, solid political knowledge, and a scientific mindset.

This conviction is at least 200 years old, and it has been contradicted for at least as long. There are always hard-boiled troopers who can only imagine educated and politically knowledgeable officers as "thought-heavy and action-light." The factual counter-evidence has already been provided by the Prussian army reformers themselves: At Groß Görschen in May 1813, for example, Scharnhorst, Gneisenau, and Clausewitz fought bravely "with the saber in hand." Scharnhorst received the wound there that would soon lead to his death.

Nowadays, at least, it should be clear to everyone: The officer educated in the sense of the Leadership Academy, who does not lose his military determination through his education, is in doubt the better soldier, because he can orient himself better in the world, because he is more open to new impressions and learns independently, because his judgment is freer, more proportionate, and more balanced, because he has historical awareness and thus respect for foreign cultures, because he is more articulate, because he shows more empathy without being paralyzed by it, and because he becomes less tolerant of injustice and meanness. All these qualities are more important today than ever.

This has primarily three reasons:

The

first

is as old as it is fresh: Citizens in uniform are to be led. This makes the leadership task particularly demanding and particularly rewarding. Internal leadership seeks the optimum of military performance with the highest degree of freedom and rights for the individual. This sounded revolutionary 50 years ago. Today, it corresponds to the self-confident attitude with which young people join the Bundeswehr. The young female and male soldiers want to serve, but they want to be taken seriously in doing so. The most perceptive among them – and there are many! – have an unerring eye for what is facade in a military leader and what is lived example and self-earned conviction. They are savvy media users and want to understand the purpose of their missions – which is something to be pleased about. The better leadership is conveyed to them, the more resilient and successful they will follow. And just as the troops, so too the corps of non-commissioned officers and officers. It is, after all, good German tradition to empower every rank to think along at the next higher level. Combine this with the critically constructive spirit that the men and women bring as citizens of our free democracy, and you have a leadership task of formidable dimensions. It has been successfully mastered, especially in the years of transformation since 1990, and this is a success that the Leadership Academy has also achieved.

But as the saying goes: Those who rest on their laurels wear them in the wrong place. The female and male soldiers expect clear communication from their military leaders "upward" and "outward": towards those responsible for foreign and defense policy, towards the public. For example, the parliament decides on the necessity of foreign deployments, but it should be made aware that the female and male soldiers also think about this, especially when they experience that in a deployment area, even after years, no progress has been made or that the time their deployment buys is not being used for vigorous civilian reconstruction. This is where staff training should also prove its worth: in the polite yet unambiguous reporting of what is amiss.

The

second

reason why the significance of the knowledge imparted here at the Leadership Academy is likely to increase even further: Leading is in a world that has become more complicated and complex and in a much broader spectrum of types of deployment, ranging from humanitarian aid to combat operations. The Bundeswehr was established to defeat the aggressor in an inter-state war. Fortunately, it has not yet had to face such a trial. However, the current deployments present it with extremely difficult challenges. The front lines in today's deployment areas are much less clear than they were between NATO and the Warsaw Pact. More often than not, it depends on the discretion of the deployed units whether a precarious peace can be maintained or violence breaks out. Many novel tasks of coordination, negotiation, and persuasion arise: from conversations with tribal leaders to discussions with officers of allied nations, from coordination with civilian reconstruction workers to motivating parents to send their sons and daughters to school. All of this demands a multitude of different skills from the staff officer, as taught here at the Leadership Academy: political judgment and diplomatic finesse, intercultural competence and language skills, proactive courage and the ability to operationally network with allies, combativeness and the most conscientious effort to protect and spare the innocent. It is precisely the synthesis of these qualities that promises to be successful. Certainly, at the center remains the ability to bring fire to the enemy and, if necessary, to dictate our will to him with violence. And Clausewitz was right in his warning against dulling one's own sword "gradually out of humanity until someone comes along with a sharp one that takes our arms off at the waist." But today we are experiencing conflicts in which the sword wants to be carried more than wielded and in which the deployment with the least collateral damage brings the greatest success.

The

third

reason for the value of comprehensive education, as imparted by the Leadership Academy to its graduates, arises from the consideration of the two previously mentioned: In the deployments of the Bundeswehr, it increasingly and decisively depends on each individual citizen in uniform. Once again Clausewitz: In the mountains and in combat in unclear terrain, each actor is more left to himself. This observation can be continued, and one can imagine an army dissolved into a large line of sharpshooters, "where each soldier fights his own battle." This imagined state often resembles the reality of deployment today: Small units operate largely on their own in an environment where the enemy is difficult to identify and the civilian population is used as cover. At the same time, the rules of a media age prevail, in which even a single wrong decision can trigger corresponding images and worldwide political upheaval. Under such conditions, patrol leaders must make decisions of great consequence under uncertainty and time pressure, and given the possible and necessary short reaction times, the officers bear immense responsibility for their own people and for the political overall context of the respective deployment. The Bundeswehr is well prepared for this: through its tradition of mission tactics; through female and male soldiers who, as citizens in uniform, did not have to learn to think along but were never unlearned from it and therefore develop a particularly good understanding of the political and cultural contexts at the deployment site; and through staff officers who know how to place the military in its contexts and can therefore lead their subordinates convincingly and successfully.

IV.

In this context, two interim remarks: The deployment experience naturally changes the Bundeswehr, and it hopefully changes public awareness.

The Bundeswehr is experiencing the transition from the cohorts that were shaped solely by service in the defense army in peacetime to the cohorts of the army in deployment. These, in turn, can be distinguished between those who have served or are serving in foreign deployments and those who serve only at home. The deployment experience has been a useful "reality check" for the Bundeswehr as a whole, as has long been proven, and it has shown itself fully capable of meeting this challenge. I sincerely hope that not even "two Bundeswehr cultures" will emerge – that of those who have been "out there" and that of the others. Preventing this is also an important leadership task.

At the same time, we must pay attention together to ensure that foreign deployments do not internally distance the troops from society as a whole. As far as the families of the soldiers are concerned, I do not see this danger. They provide a strong support for the Bundeswehr members. They are, by the way, more urgently asking than others whether the political leaders, above all the German Bundestag, always have convincing reasons for sending our troops into deployment. However, the overwhelming majority of society still displays that friendly indifference towards the Bundeswehr that I criticized two years ago at the Bundeswehr commanders' conference. It may be benign as I said back then, but it also appears a bit sleepy and immature. We Germans have a healthy self-interest in becoming more alert and competent in matters of foreign, security, and defense policy; the political leaders need corresponding pressure for oversight and inquiry; and the Bundeswehr deserves strong societal support, which can only grow from a clear understanding of the purpose of the deployments and the magnitude of the mission.

I therefore wish that the senior officers of the Bundeswehr would work even harder to initiate the necessary foreign and security policy debate. They have excellent prerequisites for this, as their training and experiences in these areas are unique. I can only encourage all of you to seek dialogue, especially with leaders from other fields, because they too should not be indifferent to the external challenges that Germany and the Western democracies face. A recent study states that the military elite is part of the communicative network of the German elites, but is rather on its periphery. I can only say: From there, take the leadership personnel in the state, economy, and society firmly in hand – always with the appropriate charm, of course! In doing so, you also render a great service to our country. And I have read that the Leadership Academy has already offered security policy seminars for representatives of churches, trade unions, political parties, and the media. The demand for such offerings seems enormous to me.

V.

The principle of selecting the best and an education and scientific training that extends beyond the military are the foundation of the Leadership Academy. The supporting pillars of its daily work are internationality and multinational and joint service cooperation.

A few days ago, the American feature film "Apollo 11" was shown on television. In it, there is a beautiful sentence that I can only quote here approximately, from memory: Humanity discovered with the moon landing less the moon than rather the common one world. "Good as poetry," one might say, but one could rightly respond: "The security of nations is founded on poetry." For those who deal with questions of so-called global governance soon recognize: There is no reasonable alternative to multilateral cooperation within and under the mandate of the United Nations when it comes to preserving or restoring peace and security.

From this realization, the Bundeswehr Leadership Academy has been drawing correct and important conclusions since 1962: It opened itself to officers from all over the world at that time and has since been visited by soldiers from more than 100 countries. Soon, there will be more than 2,100 foreign guests who have completed a course here; and many of them have subsequently taken on military and non-military leadership positions in their home countries. This shows, on the one hand, the excellent reputation that the "Fü-Ak" enjoys worldwide; and on the other hand, it shows how good foreign and defense policy can also be driven: by gaining the camaraderie and professional respect of foreign senior officers and allowing them to take a bit of our leadership philosophy out into the world. This is successful, sustainable communication, and global governance is just another word for it.

Of course, this communication should all the more succeed with our allies in Europe and NATO. We have been practicing this for a long time – are we far enough? Sometimes I hear that Germans and French cannot patrol together because the rules on the use of weapons are irreconcilably different. Sometimes I hear that a German division commander can reach his American counterpart on the phone, but not via radio, because different technology is used. Sometimes I hear that there is such a jumble of heads and representatives and national staffs and operational philosophies at some deployment locations that it would make the famous pig shudder.

After all, we are making progress in some procurement projects, in language skills, and in standardized planning processes, as are also practiced here at the Leadership Academy. But is all of this happening quickly enough? And if not: What can be contributed, especially in the context of national military academies, to improve the situation? And in any case: We Germans can make attractive contributions with the concept of Inner Leadership and with our excellent staff training.

More commonality – this is also demanded by the new tasks from the staff officers of the branches of service. They are discovering each other's capabilities in a joint deployment, so to speak, for the first time. That is why it is good that for almost three years now, the officers of the Army, Navy, and Air Force have been trained in a joint course. The reorganization of staff officer training has also formulated a flexible and good offer for lifelong learning – good, as this is increasingly important.

Joint operations – but this should not be remedial instruction in mutual cannibalization. Frederick the Great once wrote to a friend during the Seven Years' War that he felt like a violinist whose strings were being removed one by one. This feeling should never beset the Bundeswehr. Certainly, strategy is "a system of substitutes," and certainly, especially in foreign deployments, no one should be allowed to insist on authorized strengths when the available equipment is sufficient for mission fulfillment. However, such luxurious tendencies are, to my knowledge, very rare in the troops. What the soldiers in deployment may expect, what they have a right to, are, for example, sufficient national air transport capacities and sufficiently fast, sufficiently heavy equipment in case things do get tough when only light showers were forecast. Here too, leadership tasks arise in terms of clear communication, which is lacking. Clausewitz praises the "silent harmony of the whole action" as evidence of true generalship. I tell you: He did not have procurement issues in mind.

VI.

The Bundeswehr Leadership Academy stands in a great tradition – that of the General War School of 1810, the sister of Humboldt University. The Leadership Academy has helped the Bundeswehr create what other elites often lack: a group of leaders who are held together by personal achievement, a common ethos, and a strong sense of purpose. The path to this was by no means a carriage ride, but the conceptual effort and the commitment of those who taught and learned here have been worth it.

John F. Kennedy spoke in his inaugural address about the fight against the enemies of humanity, against tyranny, poverty, disease, and war. He called this struggle a long struggle in twilight, year in and year out. The struggle continues. It requires officers like those produced by the Bundeswehr Leadership Academy.