Speech by the President of the Republic, Jair Bolsonaro, during the Meeting Brazil Overcoming Covid-19 - Palácio do Planalto

Brazil Jair Bolsonaro · Former President of Brazil

24 August 2020 · Meeting Brazil Overcoming Covid-19 · Palácio do Planalto

Context
Bolsonaro addressed health professionals at the Palácio do Planalto on August 24, 2020, during a meeting on Brazil's response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Main themes
COVID-19 pandemic response, hydroxychloroquine treatment, presidential decision-making, Brazil's healthcare policy, Minister of Health Mandetta, 2018 stabbing incident, military leadership philosophy, Revalida medical examination, public health protocols, personal political journey
Duration
~16 min
56th percentile
Words
1,970
56th percentile
Sentences
104
65th percentile
Readability
67
96th percentile
Grade
8.4
6th percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 61%58%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

104 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Dear doctors, health professionals, good morning.

Allow me to speak for five or six minutes. I decided to run for the presidency against the re-election of Mrs. Dilma Rousseff; I made a difficult decision. I knew that the chance of defeat was very high down the line. I could have easily been elected senator for Rio de Janeiro in 2018, but I chose to take a risk.

What was at stake in my understanding? The future of our Brazil; I know my limitations. There are many people here who are much better than I am, but I had, in a unique opportunity given what was happening to me up to that moment, a chance, however small it might be.

I also learned in the military that worse than a poorly made decision is indecision; if we military personnel remain indecisive, we will be hit, we will lose the war; if you do not decide, the patient loses their life.

And then came 2018; on the sixth day of September in Juiz de Fora, I was stabbed. I remember talking to the federal police officers and some military personnel beside me; I said, "It's nothing, I just took a soccer ball to the stomach," there was a cut and no blood. It even led some to believe it was a fake stabbing because it wasn't bleeding; in that region, it doesn't bleed. And thanks to the work of the federal police, especially at that moment, who had charted a route to the Santa Casa, which was the closest health center, I arrived there conscious and saw people in white; I was already losing consciousness, and I only remember someone saying, "We need to operate quickly, we need to cut."

That team that was there, obviously in a normal surgery, would not have performed that procedure, but it was an emergency, and each of those present, doctors, nurses, did what they had to do, according to him, without studying the patient, and it ended up that by a miracle, I was saved. I thank you, first God, then you for my life.

Well, we continued in 2018; after the elections, we chose here the first Minister of Health, Mr. Henrique Mandetta, who had been a federal deputy with me from Mato Grosso do Sul; I will not criticize him, I will just present the facts. He took office, did his job, and at first, things were going well; we had at the end of 2019, due to a mandate issue, an encounter with him that you need to be aware of; the AMB board was present with me. In December 2019, we had voted on a project in the Chamber regarding Revalida, and it was the broader Revalida, and one of the articles allowed private institutions to apply the Revalida. Mandetta was present, along with AMB personnel and some doctors, and the guidance from Mr. Henrique Mandetta was to sanction the project, that is, to allow the Revalida to be applied by private institutions as well.

With all due respect that I have, there are excellent private institutions in Brazil. But I felt that at that moment something was wrong with the doctors; until I pushed the issue, my way of being, I already had some freedom with one or two there, I said, "Come on, why are you all embarrassed? Is it to sanction as Mandetta indicated here, or is it to veto? Open up!" Creating a relaxed atmosphere, but I felt something was wrong; then one said, "Look, we would prefer that you veto it," sorry for contradicting Mandetta, and I vetoed.

When it came to the session to maintain or overturn the veto, that provision was maintained, revoked by only four votes; I believe that was a significant contribution I made at that moment with the AMB personnel for you. Because the Revalida is a serious matter; does it need to exist? Yes, it needs to exist; do many pass? No, few pass, but there was a mark of mine with the minister; I will not go into detail about what I thought at that moment.

We continued until we had the pandemic. I started to study, as the young Arthur Weintraub said, brother of Abraham, I began to study the matter; I saw in the United States, the American FDA had signaled to proceed with studies; I began to learn about what was happening in France as well; I contacted our ambassador, Mr. Serra, to bring me precise information about what was happening there. And there was a doctor, I do not remember his name, a long-haired guy (...) a figure, and he was the guy regarding hydroxychloroquine. I delved deeper, began to see with other ambassadors what was happening in some other countries around the world, like India, China itself, and now a piece of news has arrived, it seems to be true, that China has been treating with hydroxychloroquine since February, and then I got a grasp of the situation, called if I am not mistaken Márcio and Mandetta; I had studied the health protocol here for this COVID-19 issue that was made by Mandetta, and it was written there that treatment was only in severe cases.

I said, "Mandetta, you know I am not a doctor; the language is different; I had a lot of freedom with him, and he with me; I will not talk about the type of language here that is not the case; I am not a doctor, but why don't you change that thing and remove the word severe?" And he said, "Focus, science, lives," and always said that in ministerial meetings here, and I think he said the same thing to the Supreme Federal Court. That is why that decision from the Supreme to me (...) perhaps, to participate in the Federal Government in combating the virus and not just with resources and materials, and he did not want to change. And he even repeated what Raíssa said here; others said it too, the doctor's intention, if the doctor does not want to, too bad, another one will change, right? And just as one changes doctors, I changed ministers.

And then Teich came in; he stayed only 30 days. He claimed personal reasons for not wanting to continue, and to avoid a change, a third change, I left General Pazuello as interim. Because I understood that we needed a manager there. He participated in, he was the man who decided the Rio de Janeiro Olympics. It was complicated in 2016, and he took the lead in management. Likewise, he was the one who developed the entire operation acolhida in Roraima. As well as, he was the economic interventionist in the state of Roraima at the end of 2019, from 2018 to 2019. So, I understood that at that moment he was the right person, and we left Pazuello there.

The secretaries have not complained because you must know how health has always been in Brazil. When I invited some ministers, I said, "Ah, if I were you, I wouldn't accept." The same goes for the Minister of Health. To make things work there is not easy. It is an apparatus; it is an unbelievable thing. Just like in other ministries, the same thing happens. It is a difficult mission, and so Pazuello continued and decided to change; it was not a protocol; it was guidance. It was guidance. Pazuello decided to change the guidance and then put there, in any situation, to apply or rather, to prescribe hydroxychloroquine, so that the possibility of prescribing hydroxychloroquine, that the doctor could have their freedom.

And we have been seeing throughout this time what was happening in Brazil. I have friends from the Santa Casa de Juiz de Fora, in private hospitals, in military hospitals in almost all, and we also started to talk to these people. We slowly saw that there was indeed a signal that if this protocol was administered early, so to speak, right? Using hydroxychloroquine with azithromycin, people had a much higher chance of living.

Here in this building, over two hundred servers were affected by COVID, and from what I learned, the vast majority, if not all, I cannot prove, used hydroxychloroquine. None were hospitalized. I believe more than 10 ministers, there is one here, more than 10 ministers contracted COVID and were treated, logically with a doctor's prescription, with hydroxychloroquine. And none were hospitalized, none were admitted. So it is a sign; the observation is that it is working.

I always heard from Mandetta, there is no scientific proof. Come on, I know there isn't. As I have always cited in military history, the Korean War, the Pacific War, where soldiers arrived injured, and there was no one left to donate blood to them, and they ended up putting coconut water in their veins. And it worked. If we had to wait for scientific proof, what in the future could show that many lives could have been saved with coconut water. Here, chloroquine is the same thing.

And I saw the political pressure on doctors throughout Brazil. As I saw Raíssa here, the video she sent me, she didn't send it to me, she posted the video, and I watched it. Then I called her, I called on video, right? Because when I call just on the phone, people hang up thinking it's a prank. I called on video and talked to her, and I talked to Health here; that medication went there. And it has been working throughout Brazil.

I believe that the great truth, when I took it the next day, I was already fine. I believe that you can now say, there is still no scientific proof, but you are responsible for many lives. I even sent (...) to get this little medal here, which is called the Medal of the Peacemaker with Palm. This is because I saved someone's life one day. Unlike your activity. In '78, soldiers in a rope workshop fell into a lagoon that was about 2.5 meters deep. It's not much, but 2.5 meters is this. And I managed, I was a young aspirant of the Brazilian Army, I was 23 years old, I have always been an athlete of the Armed Forces. That athlete story, right? The press goes for mockery. When I get some lazy person among you, the chance of survival is much lower. They only know how to do evil, use a pen with malice for the most part. There are exceptions, like here with Alexandre Garcia; the chance of survival is much lower than mine. And who said "little flu" was Dráuzio Varella, just to make that clear, and then I went after it, right?

But the moment to save someone's life is priceless. And you, throughout your lives, have saved the lives of many people, and at a unique moment, you had to decide and did not sit on the fence. Because worse than a poorly made decision is indecision. So, you saved, in my understanding, many, thousands and thousands of lives throughout Brazil and without hydroxychloroquine. Had it not been politicized, many more lives could have been saved from those 115,000 that Brazil has reached at this moment.

So, now I want to thank you. I want to congratulate you for the decision made back then. And one thing is certain, from the weak, cowardly, and negligent, history will never remember. We will always remember all of you.

Thank you very much for this moment. God placed us here, and beside Him, nothing is impossible. Everything is possible. And you marked, in this difficult moment for the world, a position of courage and dignity. I am very proud and happy that you are here.

Thank you all very much, once again.