Speech by President Javier Milei at the Cato Institute and Liberty and Progress conference.

Argentina Javier Milei · President of Argentina

12 June 2024 · Cato Institute and Liberty and Progress conference

Context
Milei addressed the Cato Institute and Liberty and Progress conference in June 2024, reviewing his government's first six months of radical economic reforms in Argentina.
Main themes
Fiscal adjustment and surplus, hyperinflation prevention, economic crisis inheritance, monetary reform, public spending cuts, libertarian economic policy, seigniorage reduction, Central Bank debt, political opposition criticism, Argentina's economic turnaround
Duration
~48 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,713
93rd percentile
Sentences
240
92nd percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 73%72%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

240 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Having recently completed six months since the beginning of our mandate, I want to take a moment to emphasize the magnitude of the feat that Minister Caputo and his team are undertaking, because sometimes one hears some politicians or economic analysts and from what they say, it seems as if they live in another country: it would seem they live in Narnia. So let’s briefly put into perspective the work of our economic team. In December, we inherited twin deficits of 17 points of GDP; a currency gap of 3 to 1 between the parallel dollar and the official dollar; and a monetary surplus similar to that before the Rodrigazo; a state nearly on the brink of default; prices that were already rising at 1.5% daily, which combined with the debt of the Central Bank was leading us towards hyperinflation, with the aggravating factor of having poverty indicators much worse than in the lead-up to any other crisis in our history. In other words, in plain terms, we received a situation worse than that before the inheritance of the Rodrigazo, in terms of monetary imbalance, a situation in the Central Bank much worse than that which existed at the beginning of 1989, prior to the hyperinflation of Alfonsín, and with social indicators that were even worse than those we had in 2001. We were facing what was going to be the worst crisis in all of Argentine history.

And it is also worth mentioning that the outgoing government was aware of this. They speculated that our libertarian position would decide to open everything up instantly. And this is interesting because they had moved all the remunerated liabilities to one day, with phenomenal stock imbalances, the debt of the SIRA amounting to 50 billion dollars, debt for dividends, debt in pesos maturing equivalent to 90 billion dollars, 25 billion dollars of external debt maturing with multilateral organizations, with the agreement with the Fund fallen through. A government that, moreover, over the four years issued the equivalent of 28 points of GDP, but of those 28, 13 were issued during the last year. And I have to say it to their faces, they expected us to free everything, ignoring the dynamics of the stocks and that everything would explode such that they would throw people into the streets, do not dismiss their methodology of throwing corpses in the streets, going for looting. Something that some journalists promote from their platforms. They cry out for freedom of expression but are calling for the commission of crimes, which is also a crime. And in that context, that the whole crisis would do the work, the dirty adjustment, and they would return as redeemers at the beginning of 2024.

In just 6 months of management, we abruptly halted Treasury financing with monetary issuance, we made the largest public spending adjustment in the history of humanity, and we achieved the first quarter with a fiscal and financial surplus in the national public sector after 20 years. In that context, we also systematically lowered the Central Bank rates and are deactivating the bomb of debt in pesos. Even in a context of high inflation, despite what many said could not be done. I also want to mention here, because this is important: when we talked about the adjustment we were going to make, they said it was impossible. Some shameless individuals said that we could not adjust more than one point of GDP, when we made the Treasury adjustment, we expected to achieve financial balance throughout 2024 and we achieved it in the first month of management. Then they said we did it with accounting cosmetics, I say accounting cosmetics to adjust five points of GDP is quite difficult. But those same people who said we could not adjust more than one point later found that not only did we have a financial surplus in January, we had a financial surplus in February, we had a financial surplus in March, we had a financial surplus in April, in May, and we are going to finish the first semester with a surplus. And not only that, but in parallel, we had a quasi-fiscal deficit of 10 points of GDP and today we have reduced it by 9 points of GDP. We have adjusted up to this moment the equivalent of 15 points of GDP. And all of that we did in less than 6 months. Many times I find it amusing when they say “he said he was going to lower taxes and he raised them” and the question is, what do you think seigniorage is? Seigniorage is a scam. We are shrinking seigniorage by 15 points of GDP. We are returning to the people 15 points of GDP.

Therefore, while in December we were discussing hyperinflation, which many dishonest intellectuals also try to sidestep by only reporting what was happening with the CPI and not what was happening with the wholesale price index, which was 54%. And that annualized number gives 17,000. The wholesale inflation in April was 3.4%, which annualized gives 50%. I understand that 50% is an aberration, it is an aberration. But in the alternative scenario, we were traveling at 17,000%. It would be good if they were more intellectually honest. Another discussion that also seems very interesting to me, and that has great academic value from my point of view, is the discussion of the interest rate. To use it as an economic policy instrument to control inflation. My dislike for this manipulation of the interest rate is not new. My dislike for that Keynesian perspective that the interest rate is determined in the money market is not new. Because the interest rate exists because time exists, not because money exists. It exists because time exists. And it exists with individuals who are willing to pass consumption from the present to the future, to save; and there are individuals who are willing to pass production from the present to the future, that is, to invest. And therefore, the interest rate is a mechanism of intertemporal coordination, not the result of printing colored paper.

In that context, we consider that inflation is always, everywhere, a monetary phenomenon generated by an excess of money supply, either because the supply increased or because demand fell, or both things happened at the same time, which causes the purchasing power of money to fall and that implies that all prices expressed in monetary units rise. Therefore, our bet was to stop the issuance of money. We were convinced and were managing to close the issuance to finance the treasury, but we had another problem which was the endogenous issuance of money: if you look at it, most analysts at that time recommended us to set the interest rate at positive real levels. If we had listened to them, today the ratio between remunerated liabilities and the monetary base would be above 8, we would be discussing the carry trade problem, we would be discussing the bomb of the LELIQs and lowering inflation would be literally impossible.

However, we decided to arbitrate the interest rate in dollars. This implied a negative real interest rate in pesos and that allowed us to put the balance sheet of the Central Bank in order. Simultaneously, with the fiscal surplus, that also allowed us a substantial drop in country risk and allowed us to recreate a debt market for government debt, in a monumental task carried out by the Secretary of Finance Pablo Quirno and which in conjunction with the President of the Central Bank, began to mutate the debt that was in the Central Bank, to take it to where it should have originally been, in front of the financing of the fiscal imbalance, which was in the Treasury accounts. This means that today, the ratio of remunerated liabilities to the monetary base is at 1.2 times. That is to say, we reduced it to one third. But it is important to have an idea of the quantitative notions of that. Today we have a monetary base of 15 trillion pesos and we have remunerated liabilities of 18 trillion pesos. Now, the interesting thing is that of those 18 trillion pesos, 12 trillion are in the hands of public banks. Of those 12 trillion, seven are in the Banco Nación, where in addition the counterpart is that there are 3.5 trillion in Treasury deposits within the Banco Nación, therefore, there are seven that are not a problem. There are three that are in the hands of the Banco Provincia Buenos Aires. I say, although the little communist is an enemy of freedom and especially of this government, the fact that he has a fiscal deficit means that he uses the Banco Provincia as a financing mechanism and has such a tight liquidity position that he cannot move it from there. And, what remains, a large part is with the government of the City. Therefore, the real problem we face is 6 trillion pesos. And think that we have had, in some of the placements, offers for 18 trillion pesos. That is to say, that the problem of remunerated liabilities, that problem of endogenous issuance we have practically cornered.

However, I also want to express that once we finish with that, there is still a final stage to resolve the problem of the cepo, which is to resolve the problem of the puts. This is probably one of the greatest perversions committed by the previous government. Faced with the unwillingness of banks to finance the treasury, they indirectly used the Central Bank. And a way that also had the complicity of the International Monetary Fund, they financed it with instruments that are puts. So, what is the problem? Within the balance sheet of the Central Bank, what appears is the amount of the put and not the contingent liabilities that are open. To give you an order of magnitude, those contingent liabilities represent four points of GDP, when today the monetary base is 2.8. Imagine what it would be to throw all that amount of money into the street. Imagine that in addition and be aware of this that they are not even European puts, where you have defined the deadline when they expire; they are American puts and can be executed at any time. Therefore, once we finish with the remunerated, what we are doing is working on the solution to the problem of the puts to definitively open the cepo.

In that context, we are also confident because today between what we have in monetary base and remunerated liabilities that already reaches six points of GDP, when historically the demand for base in the 21st century has oscillated between 8 and 9 points of GDP. Therefore, once we finish resolving the problem of the puts, I commit to opening the cepo definitively. So, having made these references both in the fiscal and monetary realms, as a result of the fiscal anchor and the monetary anchor, inflation has been decreasing significantly for the past 5 months. Moreover, in a few days the inflation data corresponding to May will be known and all indications are that it will be below five points. Ultimately, our stabilization program is demonstrating its effectiveness. I also want to mention the intellectual dishonesty of many of our colleagues, because I can be President but I do not stop being an economist, nor will I stop being one. Furthermore, after this I have to continue earning a living as a speaker, which is why I resigned from my privileged pension to make it clear.

So, well, they took me out of the speech. I have been out of the speech for a while. But well, nothing, I will continue. What seems to me is the issue of the intellectual dishonesty of our colleagues, and one has to understand the characteristics of who makes the decisions. A stabilization program basically has three parts: it has a fiscal policy, an adjustment, it has a monetary policy and a exchange rate policy. Obviously, as a result of having had our brains washed for more than 100 years with socialist and dirigiste policies, they believe that there must be sectoral things, that prices must be controlled, that the dynamics of such price must be managed, that the other must be controlled. Guys, I am a libertarian liberal, I am not going to do that kind of garbage. I believe in freedom, I do not believe that politicians are gods.

Moreover, another thing that also seems profoundly intellectually dishonest to me, because it is not that it goes down… “oh, by magic the inflation goes down”, there is a program that is what makes inflation go down. And in that sense, I am surprised because if one has the evidence, one should at least be more sincere. But we are also doing it in a context where we are recomposing relative prices. Therefore, when one wants to look at inflation, ok, they do not like to look at wholesale prices because it proves that they were wrong and that things are working much better than they expected. Ok, I understand, but when they go to look at inflation, I say the most intellectually honest thing would be to look at the core. But no, it does not matter, let them continue denying the achievements, obviously they do not see it. So, I think we should be looking at the core. Still, you know what? No problem, because we are not only going to beat the core but we are also going to beat the general. We are going to crush inflation.

And, as if this were not enough, we have governed these first six months of the year uphill, managing the worst inheritance in history and without the Legislative Power or the instruments that all governments before ours have had. This is not a minor issue. It is not that politics has not accompanied us. Politics, even before we took office, has put sticks in our wheels. They put sticks in our wheels by finishing off the balance sheet of the Central Bank. And they put sticks in our wheels every single day that we try to govern. But, you know what? All of this is proving that the ideas of freedom are stronger, because despite the filthy political caste, we are achieving it. We are defeating inflation. But the country needs profound changes, fundamental economic reforms that exceed the immediate economic policy decisions that a president can make. And today, while the most ambitious economic, social, tax, and fiscal reform project since the return of Democracy is being discussed in the national Senate, there can be no doubt that Argentina is at a turning point. We can insist on the path that brought us here, insist on the model of the present state, which is really only present for some and sinks the rest into misery. We can insist on the model of runaway spending, of the productive interior drained and abused by politics from Buenos Aires, of suffocating tax pressure, of debt, of monetary issuance, of the discouragement of economic activity, and of the bureaucracy that hinders everything. Or alternatively, we can return to the path of freedom from which we should never have strayed: to reclaim the ideas and values that once made Argentina a world power, to resume the defense of life, liberty, and private property. And to aspire to be a country worthy of our identity and our history once again.

The bad thing is that we have lost a lot of time. We lost a century's worth of time. For 100 years, we have squandered the stock of resources, wealth, and advantages that our golden age bequeathed to us. We squandered it in the service of nothing, in the service of chimeras. We went from being a power to being a country of mediocre results. Despite the fact that our people are not mediocre, they are exceptional. The model of social justice and the present state has tied the hands of and plunged an exceptional people into misery, and unfortunately, we will never be able to recover this time. The good thing is that Argentine society, for the first time in years, has mobilized to demand a radical change in direction. It chose as president someone who, during the campaign, acknowledged and dared to speak truths that any other politician would have hidden with modesty. Society chose the path of freedom, knowing all the costly sacrifices that this entailed in the short term, and it chose it with the largest number of individual votes in the history of Argentine democracy. However, for some politicians, the popular mandate of nearly 15 million Argentines meant nothing. Because their priority is not the society that demands change out loud, not the country that needs to be redirected to prosper, but their personal and petty interests of the political caste that resists making reforms because they know that if they are made, it will work and will not return.

That is why, six months after taking office, they still do the impossible to prevent our program from prospering. Over the 100 years we have already lost, they make us continue to waste time because they know that our program threatens the unjust system from which they feed. This is not the first time I say this: the history of the last 100 years of our homeland allows a glimpse, a small window into what could happen with the rest of the free world if it lets its guard down and is seduced by socialism. Because it is the same ideas that are currently in vogue among the elites of the West that destroyed freedom in Argentina and condemned us to poverty. Ideas that possibly in some cases arise from a noble cause, which is to provide assistance to the weakest or those who have the least. But that has a vice at its root, which is state intervention as an instrument to impart social justice. They must understand that charity is good, but if it is done with one's own pocket, as Rothbard said: it is incredible how infinitely charitable people can be when the pocket that pays is someone else's.

In this context, the State is neither in its right nor capable of imparting justice through the distribution of wealth, because social justice is a morally, theoretically, and empirically flawed concept. On a moral level, because every act of distribution presupposes a prior act of coercion, which is to confiscate the goods of a private individual that are theirs by natural right. This means that the State is a criminal and violent organization, as it is financed by a coercive source of income called taxes. On a theoretical level, because by definition, the greater the state intervention, the less free the markets are and the worse they function, producing misery instead of wealth. As Hayek said, "every time the State intervenes, it generates a worse outcome than if it had not interfered." Why? Because state intervention introduces distortions in the price system, prevents correct economic calculation, and consequently nullifies what Hayek called "the correct functioning of the market as a discovery process." That is, in the constant search to compete in the market, the capitalist finds the right path. But this can only occur in a system of free prices that extract and transmit better information about the quantities of which goods or services are demanded and at what price. Collectivism, by inhibiting this discovery process and making it difficult to appropriate what has been discovered, ties the entrepreneur's hands and prevents them from producing better goods and offering better services at a better price.

And finally, as if all this were not enough, there is also empirical evidence of the inferiority of socialism. If we look at the indices of economic freedom, the freest countries have a per capita GDP 12 times larger than the repressed ones. And even the inhabitants of the lowest decile of the free system live better than 90% of the population of the repressed countries. In other words, free enterprise capitalism is superior to socialism even in the main task that socialism claims to do better, which is to help the marginalized. What underlies all this is that there is a proven direct relationship between repression and misery on one side; and conversely, there is a proven relationship between freedom and prosperity. And socialist ideas are fundamentally incompatible with prosperity, precisely because they are incompatible with freedom. The annulment of competition is incompatible with the defense of merit and effort; bureaucratic control is incompatible with creativity and innovation; directed distribution is incompatible with wealth generation; and at its core, a large state with broad powers that interferes in every private matter of people is incompatible with having a free, creative, and dynamic society that can generate wealth for itself and for future generations.

Today it seems that Argentina and a good part of the free world are turning in opposite directions. While some Western powers forget the basic norms that brought the prosperity they enjoyed in recent decades, Argentina is reconnecting with those ideas and values and is betting again on the model of Freedom. While developed countries become heavy with regulations and unjustified impositions, we are removing the regulations that have tied our people’s hands for decades and inviting the world's capital to cooperate with Argentina; because we understand free economic activity as the most natural act of cooperation that the human species has. That is, in Argentina we are reconnecting with the ideas that made modern Western civilization the greatest civilizational and economic development feat in human history. And we want to be a refuge for those who defend and live these ideas across the planet. There has always been a struggle between those who innovate and those who regulate; between those who generate and those who confiscate; between those who explore the territory and those who then draw the maps and set the limits. There has always been and will always be a struggle between the private and the state. Today in the technology sector, which is the most dynamic sector of the global economy, that struggle is palpable. The great visionaries of the sector flee from the regulations that the global political leadership infected with socialism seeks to impose on them. I tell you today what I have already told these actors in person: this Argentina is on the side of the private sector, not the State; it is on the side of those who work, of those who trade, of those who strive, it is on the side of those who take risks, invest, innovate.

As I said, it is on the side of those who take risks, invest, and innovate, who are by nature social benefactors, and it will defend the ideas of freedom with nails and teeth, because we know that in them lies the formula for prosperity. But it is not just about having the right ideas; we also need the material conditions to accompany us. Because after decades of stagnation, Argentina has everything in place to embark on a process of economic convergence that will place us on par with the great powers of the world in a few decades. At its core, the question is: What is the process of convergence? Here it is also worth making a methodological note about what we economists do, right? Because convergence is something that when you look at the history of humanity, those who embrace the ideas of freedom achieve it, but our growth models are simplified behind certain formats of the production function. And in reality, we do not even have the foundation for why convergence occurs. Ultimately, it arises in relation to the concavity of the production function and how far we are from the equilibrium of the per capita capital stock of the stationary state. Ultimately, what we are talking about is a mathematical relationship, and it is devoid of content. Convergence does not happen just like that, because if it did, then every country that was lagging behind could undoubtedly grow without doing anything, and that is false.

That is why I emphasize so much on two works: on Hayek's work and on Locke's work, which is synthesized by Israel Kirzner: this idea of the market as a discovery process and Locke's principle of appropriation, in a context where property rights are respected. If you do that, convergence will occur, because there are a lot of things that need to be discovered, and others have already discovered them. And that is why throughout the history of humanity, it takes fewer and fewer years to double per capita GDP: the first to achieve it was England, which took 58 years, but the last to do so was China, and it did it in 7 years. Moreover, in 14 years it quadrupled its per capita GDP, because it doubled it once and then doubled it again, and it did so from the impetus of the areas liberated to the market. So it is not that convergence is something that will happen tautologically, due to the shape of the production function, which also has no empirical counterpart. Because the empirical counterpart is increasing returns, not diminishing marginal returns.

And there, the key is precisely that what is at the core are the ideas of freedom. In some of the slides I saw during this conference, for example, I showed the relationship between per capita GDP among free countries and repressed ones. Moreover, not only that, free countries grow more than double than the repressed ones. So, the key lies there, in the institutional framework that allows for convergence. And if you add to that the improvements we are seeing in technological terms, especially with artificial intelligence, that convergence can be accelerated. So, Argentina today has the opportunity, if our reform prospers, to initiate this process of convergence to reach living standards similar to those of the most developed countries on Earth. More or less to give you an idea, the largest structural reform ever made in Argentina's history was Menem's in the 90s. The reform we are sending in the Bases Law is five times larger than that. And if you add the DNU, which is still in effect, we are making structural reforms eight times larger than what was the largest reform in Argentine history. And then the shameless come to say that there is no plan.

Moreover, if this first phase prospers, we would climb 90 places in economic freedom and we would start to resemble countries like Germany, France, and Italy. But that is not enough for me. One could think of Ireland, except for what it is doing at this moment. I mean, what it did was, with market-friendly reforms, go from being the most miserable country in Europe to having a per capita income 50% higher than that of the United States, and that could be a model. It also falls short of our ambitions. We still have 3,200 structural reforms pending. We will carry them out whether politics wants it or not. And we will make Argentina the freest country in the world. And then there are also the issues of the current situation.

Because we have been for decades a boiling pressure cooker with the lid on, all that needs to be done is to uncover it and resume the task of the market as a process of discovery. Where the low capitalization of the economy, the result of 20 years of populism bent on destroying capital, already generates enormous investment opportunities for those who bet on the country. Thus, by reducing the deficit, reducing the tax burden on economic activity, and staunchly defending property rights, we will achieve development that ceases to be a dream and becomes a reality. But not only will we make the right decisions regarding economic freedom and respect for property rights, we can converge in a relatively short time to levels of wealth enjoyed by the world's major powers today, but economic convergence for us is simplified, because we do not have to go through this laborious process of discovery that Hayek spoke of, since others have done it for us, which is what I was explaining about the foundations of convergence.

There is nothing to invent to reach the levels of wealth of the main countries in the world. We only need to generate the conditions of respect for private property so that private actors can take the knowledge of those who have already gone through the economic discovery process and reproduce it. This facilitates the process of wealth generation and economic growth. That is to say, they have already done the work for us. The arduous discovery process in which an actor finds a need and develops a product or service to satisfy it has already occurred and happens every day where property rights are respected. Because without appropriation, no discovery process is possible. That is why socialism has failed and will always fail. Because it inhibits the appropriation process of what has been discovered, destroying innovation and, consequently, the generation of wealth. For this reason, because the private sector learns from the discovery process of others, global economic growth has been accelerating for more than 100 years and is accelerating even more. If we add to this the technological tools we have today, such as artificial intelligence, that economic convergence process to reach the living standards of developed countries can be even much shorter than we think. All this implies that, in just one generation, Argentina could go from being a poor country to one of the most important countries in the world. All we need to do is to embrace the ideas of freedom again, defend life, and defend property.

So, I want to revisit something I expressed in recent weeks before the most powerful businesspeople in the world, in the technological sectors that are the frontiers of economic activity. Argentina was once a land of promises, capturing the imagination of adventurers and entrepreneurs because everything was yet to be done, because they knew they could invest their effort and capital and they would do well, because there was a state that protected property rights and protected the freedom of association among private individuals. Today we have everything to walk that path again and become the new Mecca of the West. We have the natural resources that the world needs, ready to be harnessed. We have the best human capital in the region, curious and trained to face the challenges of the present. And for the first time in 150 years, we are becoming a freer country every day. With these conditions, we have the opportunity to be at the forefront of technological and energy development, as we already are in the agricultural sector. For example, we can be a global hub for development in artificial intelligence, which is a market of high demand and high remuneration, which will facilitate a leap in productivity for an immense number of value chains in the economy and which will also allow us to reform the state so that it functions better and stops squandering taxpayers' resources. You already know that as the economy grows, I will keep spending in check. Why? To return the money to those who genuinely and originally generated it: to the private sector.

In this sense, we have the obligation to seize this opportunity. We owe it to the good Argentines to show them that their effort is for something, that work and sacrifice correspond to an improvement in their quality of life. I want to remind Argentines of what, after accumulating failure after failure, we forgot but what the rest of the world has known for the last 100 years: that economic freedom brings prosperity and brings prosperity for all, not just for some. For all these reasons, returning to my initial idea, today as a society, as a country, and as political leadership, we are at a crossroads: either we persist on the path of decay or we dare to walk the path of Freedom. That battle is even taking place in the streets. Fortunately, we have a great Minister of Security who is putting the streets in order, as we promised during the campaign.

Society has already chosen which of the two paths it wants to embark on. It has already taken the risk that comes with choosing freedom. And, from the presidency, we are embarking on that course with the tools we have. Now it is up to the rest of the political sphere to decide whether to support or turn their backs on the popular mandate to live in a freer country with a more dynamic economy, or whether to insist on persisting on the path of servitude, condemning us all to misery. They still have time to work together and show society that political leadership can rise to meet its demands. We have no other ambition than to generate the material and spiritual conditions for Argentina to become a prosperous country again. We are not interested in political power as an end in itself; we are not interested in gaining anything for personal gain.

We are here willing to give everything in service of our cause, even if it costs us our own personal well-being. If we manage to generate the necessary stability to reactivate economic activity, if we manage to pave the way for freedom, if we manage to withdraw the state as necessary for society to flourish, we will have succeeded. Because free economic activity will result in benefits for the common good of society. If we achieve this, it will not be our triumph, but that of society as a whole, which will have managed to leave behind 100 years of statism and decay. That is why, as we walk the path to that new Argentina, I thank all of you for being here. God bless the Argentines and may the strength of heaven be with us! Long live freedom, damn it! Long live freedom, damn it! Long live freedom, damn it!