Memorial lecture by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck on the 50th anniversary of the death of Theodor Heuss on December 12, 2013, in Stuttgart:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

17 December 2013 · Memorial lecture on the 50th anniversary of the death of Theodor Heuss · Stuttgart, Germany

Context
Gauck delivered a memorial lecture in Stuttgart on December 17, 2013, marking the 50th anniversary of Theodor Heuss's death.
Main themes
Representative democracy, civic spirit, culture of remembrance, Theodor Heuss's political legacy, direct democracy vs. parliamentary system, post-war German democracy, plebiscites and referendums, mentality change, federalism, demagogy and democratic safeguards
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,101
86th percentile
Sentences
212
90th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
68th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%44%
  • Social 36%36%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

212 sentences in 43 paragraphs

"On Representative Democracy, Civic Spirit, and the Necessity of Remembrance"

A memory lecture can be many things: remembrance and gratitude, a stage for the past, present, and future. As a citizen Gauck, I might have given a speech on freedom in honor of Theodor Heuss, the great liberal. But now I come to you as Federal President. I come with great joy and do not simply speak as citizen Gauck, but as the successor of that man who once said: "I do not give guidelines, I create atmosphere."

I am not entirely satisfied with this self-assessment. I categorize it under Swabian humor. Theodor Heuss was one of those great politicians – we all know that – who paved the way for West German democracy. And he did not only convey important things about democracy. He also advocated for a culture of remembrance, which later turned out to be something that became the intellectual property of a renewed Germany. Because he laid the foundation for this culture of remembrance, I cannot accept the statement about atmosphere at all. And when I read how he spoke about representative democracy, I do not want to talk only about atmosphere either. After all, I want to reflect on our civic society and what it has become.

By the time of the founding of the Federal Republic, Theodor Heuss had developed his fundamental beliefs: He stood by the West German state – unlike many other Germans at the time. To emphasize the provisional character would have meant undermining the action capability and authority of this new state. He also advocated for a strong competence of the federal government, as he feared the dominance of the states. He campaigned for and represented a representative democracy – and he considered the plebiscitary elements to be quite harmful in light of the historical situation and the size of Germany.

Some things have become irrelevant due to historical developments. Germany is reunified. The relationship between the federal government and the states is, despite some debates, well-ordered: It was tested in the West, in the East it was already desired in 1989 and then gladly adopted. However, Heuss's attitude towards direct democracy is likely to be more controversial today than it was then.

Heuss saw the parliamentary system as "the school of political responsibility." To the Social Democrat Walter Menzel, who was among the few who wanted to include popular initiatives and referendums in the Basic Law, Heuss replied in 1948: "Cave canem! I warn against burdening future democracy with this history." The popular referendum threatened to become a trophy of demagogues in the "large-scale democracy" and in the "time of massification and uprooting," Heuss said.

"It would have seemed nonsensical to me," he explained seven years later, "to restore legislation to the German people in its sociologically and psychologically amorphous state, which simply offers a temptation and a reward for every demagogue, for every demagogic demand." Heuss, who had emphatically demanded the direct election of the Reich President in 1932, urgently advised against the direct election of a Federal President in 1949. Yes, there we encounter a distrust that we may not share today, but that we can understand.

The surveys from the early post-war years are telling, according to which more than 55 percent of West Germans believed that National Socialism had been fundamentally a good idea, just poorly executed. Yes, that is how it is. I know a similar population behavior after the end of the GDR. Very similar numbers. I do not want to equate the systems, but one can certainly equate the slowness of the change in mentality. Change in mentality takes time – and I think Theodor Heuss did not scientifically work out this awareness; he felt it. Because he had also sensed the influences of the time that had now passed with his fellow countrymen. He was a contemporary; he did not have to work out the things that were intuitively clear to him.

Plebiscites were discredited after the war because their instrumentalization by the Nazi state was still too fresh in memory. Most of us do not know this today; those interested in history do: Adolf Hitler had the citizens vote simultaneously on leaving the League of Nations during the Reichstag election in 1933. And shortly thereafter, he also had the merger of the offices of Reich Chancellor and Reich President confirmed in a referendum.

In light of such circumstances in the recent past, the electorate of the early Federal Republic was only to be granted the right to decide, if necessary, on the reorganization of the federal territory. And so Theodor Heuss had no objection to a referendum taking place on whether the people of Baden and Württemberg should indeed have a new joint Southwest state in 1951.

Today, the concern about an uninformed public has diminished. Many citizens are politically interested. They are informed, they are democratically grounded – and they are not tempted to elect an authoritarian government. They do what is necessary in a democracy: they engage in public affairs, in the "res publica." They do not want to be merely affected; they want to be involved.

Plebiscitary elements are widespread in Germany. They exist in the federal states, they exist at the local level. Even in the parties, we have recently experienced a very attractive example, as most people find. Good experiences have been made with direct democracy. Issues can often be resolved very closely; they are experienced up close. It means special commitment to participate in a solution. This can activate the population. Often, local citizens know very well where the problems lie.

Now, however, the debate revolves around whether the federal government also needs more direct democracy. Advocates can be found in various parties; even in the recent coalition negotiations, this question played a role – it was discussed. Referendums are actually supposed to teach politics how to run. Grassroots democracy is seen as an innovative element, as a rejuvenating force of democracy: a plebiscite as a creative impulse that brings movement into rigid structures and thought patterns – especially in those four long years that must be waited before citizens can cast a ballot again.

I myself felt very intensely – and sometimes expressed – during this citizen-driven autumn of 1989, which has already been mentioned, that distrust towards our population was no longer warranted. And when, in recent years, the weariness with politics became a topic, the form of participation of the referendum appeared to me almost as a promise.

More inclusion, I hoped with the supporters of plebiscitary elements at the federal level, would also mean less alienation between the state and the citizen. And that is what we must always strive for. Studies have also shown for various countries that direct democracy actually makes citizens more satisfied – often even the losers of votes. It apparently seems easier to accept a defeat when one has been an active part of the controversy than to submit to a decision made by others. This statement was, of course, formulated in Berlin and not in Stuttgart. Let us take a look at our neighbors. In the referendum-friendly Switzerland, satisfaction with democracy increased in those cantons where referendums and initiatives were used more frequently than elsewhere. Thus, the desire to create more democracy and stronger consideration of the will of the people through referendums becomes understandable.

However, it is worth asking beforehand whether it is accurate to expect more democracy from more referendums. One of the great historical teachers of the present, the historian Heinrich August Winkler, once played out the following scenario in a critical essay on this question: If, for example, a quorum of 20 percent of eligible voters were sufficient for a referendum, then in the end, with a simple majority, only ten percent of the eligible citizens would make the decision. Thus, highly motivated and well-networked interest groups would gain disproportionate influence over politics. The majority would have to submit to a minority.

That is one danger of referendums.

But there is also the reverse danger: the disregard of the minority by the majority. The belief that referendums promote a tolerant, democratic politics occasionally proves to be an illusion. In 21st-century Europe, referendums are also pursued by populist and anti-liberal groups. Thus, minorities can easily be deprived of their rights.

Let us take an example, again from Europe: In Croatia, two-thirds of voters recently voted to enshrine only the traditional model of marriage in the constitution. Encouraged by this success, the rights of national minorities are now to be clarified by referendum, or we could say: possibly restricted. The protection of minority rights is one of the foremost goals of a representative democracy.

Once again, a look at Switzerland: It is often regarded as a model for a democracy with plebiscitary elements. In fact, direct democracy is considered an inviolable good there, almost an "identity feature" of the country as such. I myself am a declared friend of Switzerland, especially because of its tradition that dates back to 1848. Just in passing, I would like to modestly mention that in this exemplary country of democracy, women have only been eligible voters since 1971. This does not hinder my sympathy. I am pleased every time I encounter the citizen, the responsible citizen, particularly often in Switzerland.

The Swiss demonstrate admirable democratic maturity – because they generally understand how to make substantive decisions in referendums out of a sense of collective responsibility. For this reason, it is worthwhile to take a look at critical elements of the Swiss debate. The Zurich journalist Martin Senti notes: Originally, direct democracy in his country was a "corrective in the hands of minorities against overbearing political elites." However, for some time now, changes in the initiators and their strategies have been evident. Referendums are now also becoming instruments for representatives of parliament, even of the government. What they could not achieve through parliamentary means or in the government, they now attempt to achieve through the route of the plebiscite.

In general, it could be said for the larger Federal Republic: Referendums are not always advantageous. The work of parliament can even, perhaps unintentionally, be undermined; the representation of the people can be relativized in its central role and, in extreme cases, be defamed again in a very unpleasant tradition as a talking shop. Moreover, referendums sometimes threaten to deepen divides in society rather than bridge them. You could tell a lot more about this chapter here in the auditorium than I can. And another very weighty argument: Referendums only know a "yes" or a "no," no compromise.

The place of compromise, but also the place of differentiation, is parliament – and while there may be no guarantee for it, the representative usually has a view of the whole. Parliament can thus bundle different interests for the common good. And finally: It can also withstand and cushion populist currents.

There are indeed good reasons to carefully weigh the pros and cons of referendums at the federal level.

I want to avoid any misunderstanding: I wish for active citizens. I cannot imagine a country that can only rely on its institutions. It has grown dear to my heart, also because of the multitude of people who can be activated, who are active in associations and groups. And the German Southwest is a particularly beautiful example of this active citizenship. I am pleased every time I come here. Whether as a citizen or as president. Citizens who get involved, who fully utilize the opportunities for civic engagement, that is my concern. And I gladly connect here again with Theodor Heuss: Democracy, as an institution as well as a way of life, he said, "dies from the 'without me'; it lives from the 'with me.'"

There are many ways to influence our country and create a vibrant civic society. We start with the classic option, as provided in Article 21 of our Basic Law: The parties, it says there, participate in the political will formation of the people. It remains a very important form of participation to fight for ideas within a party. And certainly, parties do well to take up impulses from non-members. The founding of a party is also open to everyone, as we have experienced in various ways.

There are many other ways to change our country. Imagine if we were to take a tour of the political landscape in today's Germany with Theodor Heuss. Of course, much would be familiar to him: parties, trade unions, associations, chambers of crafts, clubs; he would also know about strikes and demonstrations. But then there would be a lot of new developments that he would not recognize. He would surely be surprised by the many citizen initiatives fighting against environmental pollution or xenophobia or for other causes. He would need an explanation of what an NGO is, a non-governmental organization. He would encounter "round tables" that try to develop solutions in cases of conflict and problems. He would meet "expert citizens" in the municipalities who support the elected officials in their work during council meetings. He would come across youth parliaments, he would encounter student representatives, and in universities, he would see opportunities for university co-determination and self-administration. In short, a wealth of participation that did not exist in his time would prove to him that there is an active, continuously activating civil society. He would probably be completely bewildered sitting in front of a laptop and seeing how individuals can make their voices heard and gain allies like never before with the help of the internet.

It is no longer just about preventing something when citizens come together. It is now about constructively shaping things, through the initiative of citizens and often in cooperation with public administrations – sometimes down to the details, often even through online dialogues: about budget planning and noise protection, about cultural monuments, about dog laws. The permeability between administration and citizens is growing. On the one hand, decision-makers are striving to communicate their plans better to the citizens, and on the other hand, they are incorporating the expertise of citizens into their decisions. If a consensus cannot be reached despite all efforts, one can still resort to a mediation process. Even major social and political issues are not only brought into the debate by parties and associations. We are currently witnessing how engaged citizens are creating platforms and founding movements that can become so significant in the pursuit of political or social goals that the representatives pay new and increased attention to the issue.

So, when I consider all of this, and when I imagine Theodor Heuss as my companion on this tour through civil society, I can only say: I am convinced that civil society can and has already gained a new and fresh face through growing citizen engagement, new forms of organization, and new technologies. From this power of citizens who have come together, representative democracy can and will draw strength. The time of representative democracy is not over. I consider it a core value of our free, open, and learning society. Therefore, daring more democracy does not mean underestimating, despising, or even abolishing representative democracy.

I am impressed and grateful for what Theodor Heuss said about the office of the Federal President and how he shaped it in this young state. He had no model to follow at that time. Initially, he saw himself as a president "in training." Then he found – in distinction and sometimes in friction with Chancellor Konrad Adenauer – his role beyond the operational day-to-day business. Theodor Eschenburg put it succinctly at the time: If the Chancellor has potestas, that is, power, then the President has auctoritas, that is, esteem and authority.

Theodor Heuss did this in a way that became exemplary for the Republic and for his successors. That is probably why he is being rediscovered, especially in recent times. For him, politics was never a "dirty business," but rather a stimulating challenge, which he, by the way, faced with humor. With zeal, but never without humor. He also remained close to the citizens, as he did not refrain from what he called "regulated tactlessness" even while in office. He remained true to his lifestyle. He convinced others through his civil, bourgeois style, his education, his immense diligence, and his inner calm, which protected him from political "nervousness" and panic-mongering. When we stood at his grave in the forest cemetery today, I thought: These waves of alarmism that repeatedly sweep through our country – that would certainly not have been his thing. His inner calm would have prevented him from getting involved in that. Theodor Heuss maintained contact with politicians and intellectuals of very different backgrounds – from conservative-national to left-intellectual circles – and thus also served as an example for a discursive democracy: Difference and diversity, as we can glean from this, he did not perceive as a problem, but as an inspiration.

There is something else that is very important to me in retrospect. When we search for the lines of tradition for our current culture of remembrance, we will encounter Theodor Heuss very, very early, at the earliest possible moment. After 1945, he acted as a teacher of democracy, as a principled but also disillusioned enlightener who confronted the crimes and guilt of the Germans. Heuss knew that "the German people made it easy for themselves, too easy in their mass, to fall into the shackles of National Socialism." He himself was not without fault and blame in his own judgment. Throughout his life, he was haunted by his approval of the Enabling Act on March 23, 1933, when he submitted to the majority vote of the liberal faction, although he had initially advocated abstention. Just before his death, he wrote to Toni Stolper, his closest confidante: "I knew even then that I could never erase this 'yes' from my life story."

Although he was aware of the entanglement of the Germans, he identified with the country into which he was born, with its history and its landscape. They were familiar to him, and he felt a special responsibility for this familiar land. Immediately after the war, he began to provide his fellow countrymen with a political and moral compass once again.

Let us take Adenauer: In his first government statement in 1949, he did remember the German victims of the war – the prisoners of war, the bombed-out, and the displaced. Yes, they deserved to be remembered. But he did not mention the expulsion and murder of Jewish Germans, the murder of Jews in other countries of Europe, and the millions of victims of the Nazi regime. Theodor Heuss had already recalled four years earlier in his moving speech "In Memoriam" in Stuttgart those who had become victims of terror, forced labor, and murder by the Nazi regime – victims among the Germans, but also hundreds of thousands, indeed millions of people who had become victims of the Germans. Some of them he had known, not a few had been his friends. He mentioned Eugen Bolz, arrested after the failed assassination attempt on Hitler, executed in Plötzensee. He mentioned Fritz Elsas, whose daughter was married to his son: shot in the Sachsenhausen concentration camp. He also mentioned Otto Hirsch, one of the most prominent representatives of German Jews, murdered in the Mauthausen concentration camp.

In 1949, he coined the poignant phrases in his speech before the "Society for Christian-Jewish Cooperation," which have retained their validity not only for his generation but also for those that followed: "The heinous injustice that has been perpetrated against the Jewish people must be brought to light in the sense: Are we, am I, are you guilty because we lived in Germany, are we complicit in the diabolical crime?" So he asked. And he answered: I do not see a collective guilt, "but something like a collective shame has grown and remained from this time."

Theodor Heuss initiated a restitution for the Jews with Adenauer in 1951, spoke in 1952 at the inauguration of the memorial at the former Bergen-Belsen concentration camp of the "pedantry of murder as a nearly automatic process," and he said what drove many of his fellow countrymen to vehement opposition: "We knew about these things."

While Heuss may have rejected collective guilt, he could and would not shy away from pursuing personal responsibility and guilt, even if he – like most Germans – quickly fell into contradiction with the bureaucratic method in which the Allies conducted denazification. However, he only formulated sharper criticism in private circles – he did not want applause from the wrong side. Openly, however, he advocated for the opposition and the resistance since the end of the war. It was not the case, he explained to the Allies, that there had been no resistance. The resisters would rather "with their dying serve Germany politically beyond death, so that the other Germany remains visible in its blood witnesses."

The "other Germany" was to become the new reference point for the Germans and for the world. Theodor Heuss therefore naturally stood by the tradition of the resistance fighters of July 20. While they continued to be regarded by the majority of his fellow countrymen as traitors to the country, traitors to the people, or even cowards, he spoke on the tenth anniversary of the assassination attempt on Hitler of the right to resistance, which could become a duty to resist in a tyranny.

This insight has remained with us as a legacy from Theodor Heuss: the understanding that state raison cannot be the highest value for a conscious and enlightened citizen. There can be no unconditional loyalty to a state if the state tramples on rights, if it even takes the freedom and life of those it is supposed to protect.

In the 1950s, it still had to be enforced against the majority what should be a command of humanity: not to repress guilt and shame, but to acknowledge them. Many were still resistant to looking back, to an inner purification. I often think about when the names of the resisters actually began to appear as street names? When schools were named after them or even barracks? If we investigate this in our immediate surroundings, we will often be shocked. Only the following generations faced the past. They did not invent the naming of guilt. The specialized discourses of victims, resisters, and scholars existed, but the following generation was able to process this knowledge from minorities and push it into society – we would say in the language of psychology, of psychotherapy, they began to initiate a process of working through guilt. The discourse of victims, of resisters, the discourse of minorities ultimately became an inner conviction of majorities. It was carried out to schools, to universities, into the public sphere. And then what Heuss saw as a prerequisite occurred, to – as he put it – "cleanse the name of our people."

Now let us once again take a tour with Theodor Heuss, a walk, an exploratory trip, this time in Berlin. In the area where I lived, at Bayerischer Platz, he sees small signs attached to lamp posts, not particularly large, that remind of the disenfranchisement of Jews during the Nazi era. We walk past doorways where stumbling stones made of bronze have been embedded, commemorating murdered residents. Perhaps we will encounter people kneeling there right now, cleaning these stones on the occasion of November 9. In the middle of Berlin, we come across a memorial, many memorials that testify to the guilt of the Germans towards the Jews, the Sinti and Roma, and homosexuals. And as we continue walking, we encounter a school class in the Reichstag that is currently debating Germany's freely elected parliaments. And at that moment, Theodor Heuss will recognize that, thanks in part to his political work, it has been possible to place the memory of the crimes alongside the memory of the freedom traditions of our country.

Thus, we remember today what Theodor Heuss has given to our democracy. They were not guidelines, but rather direction. And that is what we want to continue to follow.

We remain grateful for his actions, which understood how to bring citizens closer to their state, and we remain grateful for an attitude that was foreign to hatred. For Heuss, it was the courage to love. He asked: "Is that necessary? Yes! Hatred follows the inertia of the heart; it is cheap and convenient. Love is always a risk. But only in taking risks will we win."