Memorial Lecture by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck on the 70th anniversary of the execution of members of the resistance group "White Rose" on January 30, 2013, in Munich:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

2 February 2013 · Memorial Lecture on the 70th anniversary of the execution of members of the White Rose resistance group · Munich, Germany

Context
Gauck delivered a memorial lecture in Munich on January 30, 2013, commemorating the 70th anniversary of the execution of White Rose resistance members.
Main themes
White Rose resistance group, courage and moral conviction, Nazi dictatorship resistance, individual action against injustice, historical memory and legacy, civil courage, freedom and human dignity, German resistance movements, youth and resistance, role models for democracy
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,644
90th percentile
Sentences
256
93rd percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.6
17th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 63%61%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

256 sentences in 48 paragraphs

"Someone has to start eventually." So says Sophie Scholl to Roland Freisler on February 22, 1943 – the feared president of the so-called "People's Court," who sentenced her to death and had her executed on the same day. Like her brother Hans, like Christoph Probst, the young father of three, like later comrades Alexander Schmorell and Willi Graf, like her professor, Kurt Huber, and like Hans Leipelt two years later, in January 1945. Murdered because they looked, because they were outraged, because they acted, because they called criminals criminals and murders – murders, and cowardice – cowardice. They made the injustice public – with their so modest means. Because they also wanted to move others to look and no longer remain silent.

"Someone has to start eventually": In these words lies all the despair, loneliness, but also all the hope and courage of the young woman and her comrades. And in it lies so much that still speaks to us today, it will speak to us tomorrow and the day after, because it can spur us on, and because there will always be a kind of unease without which we become dull.

We live – fortunately – in completely different times. In a state where open words or criticism of political conditions do not lead to prison or even the guillotine. We live in a community where commitment to freedom, democracy, and the protection of human rights is not worthy of death, but on the contrary, is highly desired. And yet we know – in light of the challenges of our time – these declarations of powerlessness disguised as questions: "What can one person really achieve?" "What good does it do if I start, as long as others do not join in?"

To label these questions from the outset as an expression of disinterest or cowardice would be too simple. In fact, we encounter in them, if they are meant honestly and are not simply veiled escapism, a form of rationality that wants to dedicate its own actions and strengths only to a truly achievable goal – for who wants to strive for "nothing" or put themselves in danger for "nothing"?

The resistance fighters of July 20 – to name another group – were not deterred from their resistance by this question. Their resistance seemed meaningful to them even if they were to be defeated. They would at least have proven that not all Germans were dishonorable and devoid of conscience – and they would have left behind role models for the newly founded Germany after the coming end of the impending catastrophe – a lasting reminder of how important the stance of individuals would always and everywhere be, and hopefully a sustainable moral for the future. Their honor would not be based on a victory, but on the fact that they had not been forced to serve evil.

In this context, I once said in 1996: "Germans rarely go as far in such large numbers as the Poles, who have a different tradition of freedom. This nation considers it a virtue to fight even when success is highly uncertain. They try and regain their dignity in the struggle and victory or in dying and defeat. This is, of course, difficult to say when you are German. But how important it is for us to think of those Germans who valued freedom and dignity more than the clever securing of their survival."

We just heard what some fellow students have recorded. What do they associate with the White Rose? From the answers spoke admiration for the young people who had the courage to stand up for their own opinion – and even risk their own lives for it. But also the view that one cannot assume such a thing. Some answers simply revealed ignorance. Seventy years after the end of the White Rose, it is also not surprising if historical knowledge and insights are crumbling – even though there have been surprisingly many films about this time and also about the White Rose in recent years. Moving films, worthwhile books about the attitudes and actions of these people.

One student remark particularly caught my attention: "It's nice that there are such people." And do you know why? Because this answer is formulated in the present tense. "It's nice that there are such people." They existed and they exist, and we must keep both in our hearts.

We honor the resistance of the White Rose today also on behalf of the other active resisters and for all those who refused to comply with the unjust state in attitude and action at that time. They existed in all social classes, at all times of the Nazi dictatorship, for various convictions and different motives. If we look closely, we encounter people who remained human in inhuman times. Who helped others. Who acted differently than the partly approving, partly intimidated, silent majority.

We meet the conscientious objector Hermann Stöhr, who did not want to go to war, which he recognized as a crime. We meet the few soldiers, for example, who stepped forward when asked who could not shoot old people, women, and children. We meet the farmer woman who slips a piece of bread to a forced laborer. We meet the mother of three who, despite all dangers, hides a Jewish family. We meet many who said "no" out of their Christian conviction or political stance when a "yes" was so much easier.

To this day, there are no definitive answers to the question of who is capable of what kind of help. Despite all research and reflection on civil courage: There is still no formula for civil courage. But there are role models. Who is willing to sacrifice even their own life to save others – perhaps many – what should they be other than a role model?

Raul Hilberg once wrote: "There were two types of help. On the one hand, the occasional help that occurred in passing. The other helpers acted either out of opposition or pure sympathy or out of a sense of humanitarian duty. Much has been written about the humanitarian helpers. They were called altruists, righteous non-Jews, merciful Samaritans. But outwardly, they had little in common. They were men and women, older and younger, richer or poorer people. Like the perpetrators, whose opposite they were, they could not explain their motives. They called their actions normal or natural. And after the war, some felt embarrassed by the public praise."

Many of these regime opponents, often called "silent heroes," these non-conformists, refusers, dissidents were honored only late after the end of the Nazi dictatorship, having been much more frequently insulted and ostracized before, also thoughtlessly or willfully forgotten. What a shame. Of course: It is uncomfortable to be reminded of what could have been possible, partly with simple humanity, without great ideology, without a grand program.

Sometimes I think that the silence about what could have been possible has a reason. Our parents and grandparents did eventually talk a lot about the war. But at first, it was always about Hitler, Goebbels. They were the ones our parents and grandparents talked about, and when they compared themselves to them, they came off well. They had not been like that. Did they perhaps remain silent about the others to avoid having to compare themselves with those who were silent helpers? To avoid asking themselves: "What have I actually done?"

Kurt Tucholsky once said that in Germany, the one who points out the dirt is considered much more dangerous than the one who makes it. This was something a man experienced, a man to whom Germany, post-war Germany, owes a lot. I am speaking of Fritz Bauer, the former Attorney General of Hesse. He himself had fled from the National Socialists and then returned to his country. He was not only the driving force behind the so-called Auschwitz trials, which led to a broader public engagement with the Holocaust in West Germany starting in the mid-1960s.

It was Fritz Bauer who, in 1952, achieved that for the first time a West German court evaluated the military resistance of July 20, 1944, as serving "the good of Germany" – and not as "treason"! In Bauer's memoirs, we can read that this brave man, when he was in his own office building, felt – as he once wrote – as if he were in enemy territory. His professional colleagues there, his legally highly skilled and knowledgeable staff regarded him as an outsider.

The debate about a – every citizen's right – to resist against the unjust state ended in 1968 with the answer that is still valid in our country today. It is stated in Article 20, Paragraph 4 of our Basic Law: namely, against anyone who attempts to abolish the free democratic basic order, "all Germans have the right to resist."

In the meantime, our attitude towards the resistance fighters of that time has changed: Today we admire these people, for they allow us to believe that not all Germans were silent and cowardly followers back then. This afternoon, Inge Deutschkron reminded us in a moving memorial service in the German Bundestag of that time, of the dying, but also of the survival. She survived because she had helpers. She also reminded us of that. And time and again, we look at a time when it seemed so difficult for people to choose, seemingly impossible. But it was never impossible. This fact is also reminded to us by witnesses like Inge Deutschkron and like you, ladies and gentlemen, who are here today as friends or family of the conspirators of the White Rose. We must always preserve this knowledge, we must pass it on.

Our admiration for the brave and selfless individuals back then is always also fed by a perhaps unrecognized, but secret suspicion against ourselves: Would we have had the strength for such courage and selflessness? Or would we not have been able to act that way? I know what I am talking about – I am speaking of myself. I still remember well how, as a young man, at the age of the younger students here in the room, I sat in front of the radio and heard about the Polish priest Maximilian Kolbe, who went to his death in Auschwitz in place of a family father. Later, I learned the stories of the Scholl siblings. And I constantly asked myself in that youthful age: How would you have acted back then?

This is a frequently asked question in the German discourse on the past. Many of us, perhaps all of us, know this question. Loud or quiet, directed at ourselves. What do we answer to it? Would we believe ourselves if we said: I would have been willing to die so that someone else survives? Would we have been willing to risk our lives to start where others remain silent? Most of us would probably come to the conclusion, to the simple perception: No, I would not have been willing, I could not have done it, to give my life – because I would not have wanted to put my loved ones in danger, because I would have had so many wishes for my own life, or simply because I would have been afraid of death. All the more we admire the courage of the young women and men of the White Rose.

And now comes a very important point, a very important hinge. We can admire them in such a way that they have nothing to do with our lives anymore. Then we freeze in awe. Sophie Scholl's friend, Fritz Hartnagel, wrote in 1947 in a Munich student newspaper: "The certainly honest effort to preserve their memory carries the danger that they stand on a pedestal, far above our daily lives. Let us bring them into our lecture halls, let them sit among us."

I just used the word awe. But in the word "awe" is also the word "fear." How wrong it is to be afraid that we could never be strong and brave ourselves! We do not have to know at the beginning of our lives what we can do in the middle or at the end. Why should fear bind us? For fear makes us small and timid. Above all, we shy away from a much more uncomfortable insight: We cannot demand from each other to become heroes or even martyrs. What we can demand from each other is that we do what is possible. What we can do today, what I can do today, we could surely do. The decisive question is therefore not "What would I have done back then?", but: "What can I do today?"

And that is why it is so dangerous to distance those who are our role models, as if we could never reach them. We must also be able to believe that there is something within us that is indestructible. We must sense that it exists, even if we cannot yet define it precisely. When we believe in ourselves, we must have a path in mind that we do not yet see clearly, but that we trust ourselves to take. And fear would take away that trust. Therefore, admiration yes, love for those we look up to, yes, but not yet a reverence that would separate our life potentials from theirs.

The ability to resist authoritarian rule, by the way, was not a gift from heaven, not a one-time decision, and never merely a biographical coincidence. Moreover, many biographies of resisters show that resistance is not simply there, quasi-genetically present. We could remember: Resistance is not, resistance becomes. It begins with questioning what others do not want to know, or keeping a distance from those who organize or execute injustice. It grows from what we encounter and from how we respond to it.

The ability to engage for a free society and its order is similar. It is an attitude that each individual must work on. It is not automatically there. Under completely different conditions, of course, than those we just talked about in times of dictatorship, yes. But even here and now, I must first want to see, perceive what is happening around me. I must want to empathize with others, to be touched by the fate of others. I must want to think for myself. Make my own judgment. Develop an attitude. And above all, understand: I have a choice! I can complain in private about things I consider wrong or in need of improvement – or I can address them where change is possible. I can stand aside – but I can also act consistently. My choice is – compared to then – infinitely less risky. But it is not self-evident. We must make it clear to ourselves that we carry these potentials within us. So we must also be able to endure today, under certain circumstances, that we suddenly find ourselves in a minority with our opinion or attitude. And perhaps it also means that we must bear consequences that are uncomfortable for us.

Many see responsible action as a burden, as foolish. In fact, we need this attitude. And we wish to gain as much inner strength as possible. If we wish for that, we also become aware of how important what happens in the early days of our childhood is. Can we achieve inner strength without an early childhood feeling of being accepted? Probably only under extremely, extremely rare conditions. Can we develop an "I" without the acceptance from the encouragement and trust of those around us? The "I" must first learn to take itself seriously before it can even develop the courage for independence and otherness. Only when this has grown can the individual take steps toward resistance. Only then can we decide what we consider good and what we consider evil.

Thus, attitude can play a crucial role, the will, the ability, and the courage to become clear to myself as a human being about what justified purposes and goals for resistance are. That is possible. Without such clarification, action is difficult. It can at best be accidentally right or wrong.

Now let us look again at the members of the White Rose, and also at other resistance fighters: We notice that we can become strong and capable of action when we carry our values not only as rational thoughts in our heads but deeply within us, in our hearts. There, in our hearts, arise those deep and strong feelings that can break our anxiety, that can tear down our fears and doubts. "I am capable of doing good." There lies our ability to invest much, possibly even our own lives, for what we have recognized as good and right.

Dear students, today we live in relatively secure conditions and we know: It is our democracy. No one, really no one, hovers above it to protect it. We ourselves, you must do it. Of course, we have our institutions. But we are the citizens. And we must engage in the affairs of our democracy!

We could designate today, January 30, as the 80th "day of death" of a German democracy, the Weimar Republic. It was once called a "democracy without democrats." That is different today. Back then, democracy did not only die from the many enemies it had at the edges of society, but also because it had too few friends who stood up for it.

The facts and mental states of the last years, months, weeks, and days of Weimar have been told many times. Back then, 80 years ago, at the beginning, when resistance might still have had a chance of success, it existed here and there, but it was not supported enough. What could have been possible is shown by the small general strike in Mössingen or the protest marches with which Lübeck citizens had, in a sense, "demonstrated" Julius Leber out of prison. But many of the authorities at the time in the Reichswehr, in the churches, in the theaters, and also in the universities remained silent. The declared opponents were systematically terrorized, hunted down, and ultimately murdered. Political revenge was legalized.

However, judgment was not only extinguished by terror. "The majority of Germans" – as historian Fritz Stern said in his speech on July 20, 2010 – "The majority of Germans did not feel their own disempowerment, grateful for orderly prosperity." The injustice somehow affected others.

Hans Scholl with his cry of "Freedom," seconds before his death, Kurt Huber with his defense speech in court: "I demand the freedom for our German people back!" Both spoke for a people that had given up its freedom quite voluntarily.

There were also turning points at which things could have turned out differently. History is not a matter of course, but the result of countless individual actions – or indeed also of inaction. That is the disturbing – but at the same time also encouraging – message of a retrospective. And that is why I also want to appeal to those who stand aside today, or to the many indifferent people who see no reason to stand up for a pluralistic, tolerant, open society. I want to encourage them all: Do not be lukewarm! It is your country, shape it with the strengths that are within you!

Especially when conditions seem as orderly as they do with us, we easily fall prey to the temptation to let politics be served to us, so to speak. Richard von Weizsäcker expressed concern 20 years ago in his memorial lecture that citizens, I quote, "understand themselves less and less as bearers, but rather as consumers of politics." They assert their claims – and are disillusioned when they are not fulfilled. I could hold an entire lecture on this disillusionment of the Germans, but I have been told that I have already done so too often. So I will once again pursue the term "political disillusionment," to which this term immediately leads me. That was just crowned the "unword of the year" in 1992. The prominent political scientist and opponent of the Nazis, Ernst Fraenkel, author of the book "The Dual State," already spoke in 1966 about what he called "parliamentary disillusionment" in the Federal Republic of Germany.

Now we could be relieved. After all, it seems that complaints about political disillusionment have been voiced for so long without our democracy collapsing. On the contrary: It has repeatedly proven its strength – especially in difficult times. But the core message remains true and current – namely that the very word political disillusionment is revealing. It drives apart what belongs together: politicians and citizens, that is not two different things. Politicians are citizens. Citizens who have taken on a special responsibility and obligation from us, from us citizens, namely to serve our country for a time and on behalf of us all. It becomes dangerous when some only make politics, and others retreat into their disillusionment. That is not where we want to end up.

Of course, it is easier to complain about parties and holders of political office than to make oneself available for a political office or to stubbornly advance the issues that are important to oneself within a party. Political engagement requires more than just the choice between "I like it" and "I don't like it," no matter how helpful and new the internet may be for political opinion formation and participation. But those who only complain about "politics" virtually, but do not engage politically in real life, are essentially complaining about themselves. To speak with the White Rose – even if the urgency back then was truly completely different: "Do not forget that every people deserves the government it tolerates!"

"Democracy," we remind ourselves, and indeed with the words of Theodor Heuss, "Democracy is not a happiness insurance, but the result of political education and democratic disposition." Perhaps he should have added: "... and very hard work." Democracy is sometimes also a demanding form of coexistence. But it is the order that comes closest to our image of free and equal individuals, and I even say: the order that truly corresponds to this image of humanity!

Our particular vigilance today is directed at those who still do not accept this simple realization. Who do not want to accept that Germany is a diverse country in which people of different origins and different beliefs have their rightful home. Hatred and prejudice undermine and destroy the most important foundation of this community: the respectful coexistence of the many different. "The dignity of man is inviolable. To respect and protect it is the obligation of all state authority." These opening sentences of our Basic Law are a conscious counterpoint to the experiences of the horrors of Nazi rule. They are the – in both senses – most valuable promise of our state.

Just yesterday, I had a long conversation with members of the German Bundestag who belong to the NSU investigative committee of the Bundestag; soon I will meet the relatives of the victims. Even today, more than a year after the discovery of who is behind these brutal murders, there remains disbelief – and many questions. Questions not only for the authorities but also for the media, for the public, perhaps for ourselves: Why did it seem so plausible to many to search for the perpetrators in the milieu of organized crime? How can the lost trust be restored – also the trust in the institutions that are supposed to protect our constitution, our state? And finally, most importantly: How can we protect not only our constitution and our values but above all the people?

We need democratic parties like democratic citizens who collectively condemn those who condemn others. We tolerate no anti-Muslim, anti-Semitic, nor anti-German, no right-wing extremist, no fundamentalist expressions and activities. We resolutely confront those who bring fanaticism or violence into our country for ideological or religious reasons. We tolerate neither exclusion nor violence – from anyone against anyone, regardless of whether it comes from minorities among locals or newcomers. Regardless of who it comes from. The fight against prejudice, contempt, and hatred is sometimes an unpleasant, laborious, and in some places still a dangerous daily challenge.

Only where civil society is strong can inhumane attitudes not spread. I know – also from my previous work as chair of the association "Against Forgetting – for Democracy" – many who have been engaged for many years, often in schools, youth centers, church communities, associations, and memorials. I admire their consistency and perseverance and thank all those who have been and are active in foundations, citizens' initiatives for a short time or for decades to connect our democracy with the memory of what once was.

What I sincerely wish for is that we Germans, in conjunction with our European neighbors and friends, bring in our experiences – certainly the good ones, but also the terrible ones. I am pleased that Germany can do this again in the coming three years as a member of the UN Human Rights Council – and I look forward to my visit there in February.

Federal and European – this is how the Kreisau Circle once envisioned the future, just like the White Rose and many, many other opponents of the Nazis who so optimistically advocated for it, even though they knew that Hitler's Nazi Germany could brutally take away not only their lives but also their own future. "Freedom of speech, freedom of belief, protection of the individual citizen from the arbitrariness of criminal totalitarian states, these are the foundations of Europe" – this was stated in their first leaflet. How valuable it is that we have achieved this today! How important it is that we preserve it!

We cannot even begin to measure how much these men and women were missed in the reconstruction of our country and in the unification of Europe. We can only imagine how much their courage, political foresight, and humanitarian attitude would have benefited our country. And we can promise to keep alive in our hearts and minds what we learn from those who escaped back then.

One person for whom the death of friends and fellow students became a lifelong mission is among us: Hildegard Hamm-Brücher, two days younger than Sophie Scholl. She is here as a member of the association "Against Forgetting – for Democracy" and as a supporter of the initiative "Show Your Face," as a politician and as a citizen. When asked why she "shows her face," she said: "Because as a young person I experienced that looking away and the 'I can't change anything' mentality towards persecution, anti-Semitism, and dissenters became the guilt of almost all Germans."

Passing on her insight – that is our task, especially as the witnesses of this time become fewer. Today and in all future, it holds true: We will then be witnesses of the witnesses! However, we must also be witnesses of all those who today and everywhere in the world suffer from lawlessness and dictatorship. Those who fight for civil rights, women's rights, human rights.

Thus, our commemoration today is a bow to the courage and bravery of opposition members and resistance fighters. But at the same time, it is a call to us today to stand up with our strength for what they gave their lives for back then: for humanity and decency, for freedom and the rule of law. Their story shows us what is humanly possible – in the worst as well as in the best. Let us continually bring the young women and men of the White Rose into our lecture halls, into our schools, let us have them sit among us. And let us hear them say: "Someone has to start it eventually!"