Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the annual conference "Newspaper Congress 2013" of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers (BDZV) on September 17, 2013, in Dresden:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

17 September 2013 · Newspaper Congress 2013 of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers (BDZV) · Dresden, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the annual Newspaper Congress 2013 of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers in Dresden on September 17, 2013.
Main themes
Credibility of journalism, democracy and the press, digital transformation of newspapers, quality journalism, analog versus digital media, internet's impact on information, role of newspapers in society, freedom of the press, information overload, future of print media
Duration
~18 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,202
62nd percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.84
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 51%50%
  • Technological 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

125 sentences in 23 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, I thank each and every one of you who advocates for quality journalism in our country! Please consider this gratitude – alongside a few critical remarks that I may impose on you today – as my most important message. Thank you for everything that your newspapers contribute to our democracy in terms of insight, diversity of opinion, and richness of debate!

You can see that I cannot speak in favor of newspaper pessimism. However, I also do not want to fall into the opposite extreme, a naive, rose-tinted view of the situation. The question arises: Is the important function of newspapers for our democracy threatened by changes in the market?

I have the impression: The risks exist, are unmistakable, because the transformation in the newspaper market fundamentally affects the role of journalism for our democracy. And by this core, I mean exactly the part of quality that cannot be measured in quantities of paper or pixels, but must remain a constant amidst all change: the credibility of a newspaper. Credibility, for me, is exactly what makes a good newspaper. Credibility must continue to shape good journalism in the future, when we set aside all externalities – all questions of form and format.

Allow me to take a small detour at this point. The coexistence – or let’s say: the juxtaposition – of analog and digital newspapers is much more than a question of form, that is what I have learned. Many hours of this conference have been dedicated to this topic. Last night, I considered whether I should even engage in the debate about "pixels versus paper" as a layperson. Cultural pessimism is, of course, not part of my job description. Now, standing in a room full of experts, I would like to draw a few comparisons, as you have done in your conference program. Under the motto: The supposedly dead music industry? It still exists! The supposedly dead retail trade? It still exists! So what applies to the supposedly dead paper newspaper? – I admit, I like the thought that even in many years, large readerships will still pick up a newspaper and leaf through it, perhaps even cut out a clever commentary, as I often do, keep it, and quote from it when the opportunity arises.

However, it would be foolish to welcome the technology of tomorrow with the experience horizon of yesterday. The internet, a cultural revolution on par with the printing press or the steam engine, will continue to change our lives, perhaps much more profoundly than we can currently predict. And: With the triumph of the internet, traditional media have evidently lost their monopoly on information and interpretation. Already, the traditional division of roles between sender and receiver of a message, between producer and consumer, as we know it from the paper newspaper, has been dissolved online. Already, news of all kinds is disseminated at lightning speed, and globally. Already, millions of people feel almost overwhelmed by the flood of information that arises. Professional communicators – including politicians – invest a lot of effort to get their message across to the public. And already, there are moments when short tweets drive significant upheavals, just think of the Arab Spring.

Of course: How strongly the internet will influence the dissemination and significance of news cannot even be predicted by the smartest futurists, at least they can only vaguely sense it. The extent of the change is hardly foreseeable for anyone. We probably underestimate some things, but we also overestimate others. All the more worthwhile it is to continually explore the scope for quality journalism.

Upon closer inspection, some new forms of communication are not necessarily a competition for newspapers. It has become known that one cannot conduct a fundamental discussion with 140 characters, but one can refer well to places of debate – such as online newspapers. Moreover, the realization is gaining ground that anonymous collective intelligence may be engaging, but it can also drag some bloggers down, as sources remain unclear and facts and opinions blur. And the loss of clarity is generally also perceived as a loss of truth. Technically speaking, anyone can be a newsmaker today with little effort. But what does that mean for professional journalism? And what does it mean for our democracy beyond that?

At least in the medium term, unfiltered, often emotionally driven mass communication on the internet cannot replace the newspaper as a source. We will continue to rely on communication with rules of engagement, on news that is gathered and created with professional ethics and received with an awareness of their quality. A functioning democracy needs reliable reporting. It needs serious contextualization and knowledgeable interpretation of events.

Credibility, for me, is always a key term because it directs our gaze from the many changes to the essentials. Credibility, of course, is a quality that can be squandered in seconds but can only be earned through consistency. Newspapers, many newspapers, have earned it over decades, some even over centuries. I am pleased about every part of this cultivated culture that is still alive today. In August, I was able to congratulate the Hersfelder Zeitung on its 250th anniversary. Just imagine that. It reminded me once again how closely the history of published opinion is linked to the history of our democracy. Newspapers are mirrors of our community, in good times and bad. For me, such anniversaries are always a reason for joy because our federal country, not least thanks to its long-standing local editions, boasts the greatest diversity of newspapers in Europe. Some publications have succeeded in successfully placing their greatest asset – credibility – in the digital world as well. Others are still searching for new marketing avenues.

Of course, I cannot offer a finished model today, but I would like to name some minimum requirements for the civil society of the future: "We must maintain a free, independent, diverse, and quality press. We must be willing to afford it." That is how I formulated it a year ago at the presentation of the Theodor Wolff Prize. And I believe that we all agree on this goal here in this room. However, no one seems to have a blueprint for how exactly the willingness to afford it can turn into the ability to afford it, how one can lead to the other.

At this point, I would like to propose a thesis, dear publishers: Those who are credible will find supporters and allies on their path. The first ones that come to mind are those who were once called readers, who are now users, friends, and followers. The crucial point is: The majority of these recipients behave critically and demandingly. I rely on this in an enlightened, education-oriented civil society. Precise information and arguments will always find their audience.

However, I do not want to conceal that I already hear quite different voices today. When I ask people why they cannot get excited about reading newspapers, many respond that they simply do not find what they would like to read in them. More and more young people, for example, have the impression that the newspaper world describes a completely different reality than the one in which they live. How could newspapers win such groups over? I do not see a simple answer to that. Simplification would not be a solution for a pluralistic democracy, or it would be an extremely weak one. The more diverse lifestyles and thus expectations of journalism become, the more differentiated answers we need to the core question: When is it worthwhile for both sides – readership and owners – to maintain a newspaper?

The question of how exactly good, credible journalism pays off and what it can be worth to whom arises anew for you time and again. Your second major group of allies must therefore continue to be the editors.

Credible journalists are the greatest asset of a newspaper – with their intellect, their empathy, their curiosity, or their willingness to engage in discussion, sometimes simply with their name, which has developed into a brand over the years. Good journalists feel committed not only to the owner of their medium but also to the common good. They illuminate our present, uncover grievances, and risk their freedom or even their lives in some countries of the world. When they chase a scandal, they are not merely seeking excitement, but ultimately truthfulness. That is why they check the facts and listen to the other side. They do not understand success merely as a fleeting, spectacular moment. They rely on long-term success through presence and profile, through attitude and dedication. In this sense, they serve democracy. I say this not only as Federal President. I say it primarily as a reader who has longed for this kind of journalism to exist not only in Hamburg or Munich but also in Rostock or Dresden.

Therefore, for me, the debate about the future of quality journalism also includes a word about the employment situation of journalists. Everywhere, one can observe how permanent positions in newsrooms are increasingly disappearing, how freelancers toil for per-line fees, how trainees work as editors but earn apprentice wages. Precarious work, however, is not a stable basis for reliable content.

Even the permanent employees apparently have reason to nostalgically remember the good old days. Many of them would like to research more thoroughly, ask more often, and write more precisely. They resist producing quantity over quality. The time and cost pressure in newsrooms leaves less and less room for elaborate or investigative journalism. The elimination of foreign correspondent positions is an example of this.

At least, gradually, the realization is growing: Google can neither replace the spirit nor the intuition of a reporter on the ground. And I hope that with this insight, a countertrend can take hold. Because where savings are made too aggressively, it often turns out: Personnel depletion sooner or later affects quality. And readers notice that. It is therefore not mere idealism to state: In the long run, a solid staffing in newsrooms is both content-wise and economically sensible.

Quality journalism and profit orientation should not be opposites. Here in the hall, that sounds like a given, but outside, it sometimes needs to be explained. The best way to do this is probably through practical examples, examples that make it clear: Quality prevails. A convincing media product – whether a classic or digital newspaper – will also find an audience. I think of the many renowned publications that you publish. I think of the many awards and accolades for successful journalism that your companies can receive each year as a confirmation of their publishing work. Whether high culture or the struggles of the everyday: So much that is produced in Germany can be seen and read.

I also think of success stories that grow quietly. Regionally and locally, this happens thousands of times, as we know. I observe this journalistic work at the grassroots level with great interest because it is so similar to what democrats wish for from local politicians: to be close to the people, to listen without arrogance and without preconceived opinions, then to carry forward what moves the region and invite participation, and to clearly name grievances. However, the old journalistic wisdom still applies: In the community, it is sometimes easier to criticize the Pope than the local mayor.

It remains the high art to pose and answer the great questions of life from everyday life – to recognize the significant for society in the small. Let us only think of the often-cited rabbit breeding association, which is usually mentioned disparagingly as an example of the first reports of a trainee. However, it is such associations and initiatives where the lives of people take place and where, in part, grassroots democracy occurs. It is also there that it is contested who will win the election on Sunday and whether it would be helpful to visit not only one’s own garden but also the polling booth.

What new image could replace the cliché of the rabbit breeding association? Is it perhaps the multimedia, possibly internationally networked local newsroom? I admit, for some innovations, I still lack the imagination. Recently, I heard about so-called news games, games designed to introduce news-averse people to current events. Can that work? I do not know. Who knows, perhaps during my term, I will even have the opportunity to award a medal for such a novelty.

When it comes to the Internet, it is difficult to predict which innovations will challenge us in ten years. Will we talk more about the dangers and misuse, or about further distribution channels? The intelligent linking of word and image, of animation and moderation can lead us into a media future where even more people than before are reached with even better information. That would be good for media companies – and it would be good for democracy."

"Everything remains in motion." Between hope and hard work, this beautiful sentence today serves as analysis, forecast, and at the same time a call to action: If everything remains in motion, then I too, then we all are called to bravely embark on the journey!