Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the opening of the annual meeting of the National Academy of Sciences Leopoldina on September 20, 2013, in Halle (Saale):

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

30 September 2013 · Annual meeting of the National Academy of Sciences Leopoldina · Halle (Saale), Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the opening of the Leopoldina National Academy of Sciences annual meeting on September 20, 2013, in Halle (Saale), marking the Academy's fifth anniversary as Germany's national academy.
Main themes
Science-society relationship, mind and genome interactions, Leopoldina National Academy of Sciences, scientific advice to politics, freedom of thought, German reunification and scientific cohesion, brain research, pre-implantation diagnostics, democracy and scientific expertise, identity and human development
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,487
67th percentile
Sentences
141
78th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.0
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 29%28%
  • Institutional 28%27%
  • Technological 15%14%
  • Economic 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 3%

141 sentences in 31 paragraphs

"Become who you are" – Some of us are familiar with this appeal that the philosophy of ancient Greece continues to make to us today.

However, how we become who we are is far from clear. Those who engage with the topic of this annual assembly, the complex interactions between mind and genome, between brain and society, will quickly realize this. We know: Our genes shape us and our life paths. But they certainly do not have the final word. Many conditions of our environment also determine in which cases and how our genes act. It fascinates me to learn how humanity is increasingly understanding the workings of the brain. Yet with each step of understanding, new questions arise – for the individual, for science, and ultimately for society as a whole.

Precisely because the new questions are relevant to our society, they are topics for the Leopoldina. Here, in its recent role as the National Academy of Sciences, it has found a task of the utmost importance. The Academy is now five years old in this role, a small anniversary and an occasion for celebration. I am glad to be able to attend your annual assembly this year, and in this magnificent building. I find it wonderful that Halle can adorn itself with this work of art and that you, as the Leopoldina, have found such a wonderful home here. Congratulations on that!

The Leopoldina was founded in Schweinfurt as the "Academia Naturae Curiosorum." Its long journey to this point has taken it through over 15 locations, arriving here in Halle. It has thus reached a place that offers it the best conditions.

During the decades of division – I would like to briefly refer to this as well – it remained a national institution for all of Germany. And we must not forget: What an achievement that was! The Leopoldina has shown that there is an intellectual cohesion that can overcome borders and connect people. The Leopoldina is a testament to the fact that true freedom of thought cannot be constrained by any corset – even though that is often attempted. With the construction of the Wall, not only were citizens of the GDR imprisoned in their own country, but scientists also experienced significant restrictions on their work. It was important that the Leopoldina offered scientists in the GDR a rare opportunity: They could exchange ideas with leading foreign researchers. The annual assemblies were also an important forum for this – developments in East and West were critically examined and discussed here. And so the Leopoldina helped to forge connections and thus also to hold our country together.

The Leopoldina has preserved the best of its long history: It stands for scientific seriousness and competence. The Leopoldina speaks with a clearly audible voice, knowledgeable and focused on facts, in the societal discourse in our country, which, without scientific expertise, sometimes tends to alarmism. It takes on this task of advising politics and society as a National Academy with a special legitimacy. The range of content in its formal statements is impressive. This is also evidence of the good cooperation of the Leopoldina, particularly with the acatech Academy of Engineering Sciences and the Berlin-Brandenburg Academy of Sciences. A beautiful example of this good cooperation is the Young Academy, which the Leopoldina and the Berlin-Brandenburg Academy jointly founded.

The Leopoldina's statement on pre-implantation diagnostics received much attention and significantly influenced the debate in the political arena and ultimately also the legislation. This shows the importance that your expertise is given by politics. You take a stand on central questions, not only within the Federal Republic but also internationally. The joint statements of the national academies at the G8 summits are an example of this.

Especially in times of complex societal challenges, credible information and well-founded knowledge are indispensable for making responsible decisions based on them. That is why politics needs advice, and that is why politics seeks the counsel of science. The results and advice of science provide a good basis for weighing different options. However, the final decision must always be made by democratically legitimized politics.

Politics and science not only have different tasks, but they also often operate under different logics. For the scientist, it is crucial whether their hypothesis is meaningful and verifiable – for the politician, it is about the possibility of implementing what is recognized as correct in a democratic process. In doing so, they often have to make compromises and also anticipate setbacks. And they must – and should – weigh the societal consequences of their actions.

If we recognize and accept these different tasks of politics and science, we can reflect on the fundamental aspects of science and science-based advice: What are their possibilities and opportunities? And where are their limits?

A deeper understanding of science – especially from the side of politics – is the appropriate starting point for being able to use good advice sensibly – not to underestimate it as too abstract or disconnected from life, but also not to overestimate it as apolitical. We should also be aware of how powerfully the spirit of the times shapes public debates. Because what scientific expertise brings to the debate with its knowledge at this moment is often unsettling to the spirit of the times. And that is why political advice from science is not so simple: Because other participants in the debate and thus other interests make themselves so audible in society that politics may be tempted to regard the advice of the expert as less important than the advice of those who currently dominate the debate. Yes, that must be said.

I would now like to address a few more points:

One does not have to have been a pastor like I was in earlier years to feel a bit of relief that there is no such thing as "final truths" in science. Science-based advice to politics and society inevitably reaches its limits where knowledge or even experience is simply lacking: For example, when chlorofluorocarbons were first used, no one could foresee what consequences that would have for the ozone layer. At that time, it was not even remotely foreseeable. Today we are wiser. Yet we are only just beginning to truly understand the complex interrelationships of climate change.

We should also be aware that there are occasionally communicative misunderstandings in conveying scientific findings. We all know the widely popular complaints about the alleged errors of meteorologists. However, the complicated probability calculations underlying weather forecasts are usually simply not apparent to us viewers and could be difficult to explain in the brevity of a weather report – an example of how we like to interfere in expert debates, even though we fundamentally understand nothing of it.

Of course, the process of "advising" politics through science is always more than just the repetition and transmission of knowledge. Interpreting and advising also means weighing and evaluating. That is why there is much debate about the extent to which norms should be the starting point for scientific recommendations to politics and society. You, dear Professor Hacker, have identified this question as a significant challenge for the Leopoldina: How can the "objective presentation of the scientific state of knowledge and the ethical justification of normative advice be connected"? – so your question. I am curious to see how this debate will develop further.

And that brings me to a wish I would like to express, as this forum seems particularly well-suited for it: I wish that science seeks dialogue with society even more strongly. Science should strive to continuously educate about individual topics as well as about the nature of science itself.

Eric Kandel, one of the important neuroscientists of our time – which fits very well with the theme of your annual meeting – has said about the relationship between science and the public: "We as scientists have the obligation to explain our work to everyone. Much of what we do is not so complex that it cannot be explained in two or three sentences at dinner. At least after three glasses of champagne." How you choose to follow that latter recommendation is, of course, up to you. But I would like to encourage you to convey your knowledge vividly wherever you can. You will certainly have to generalize in order to explain your research to laypeople in a few sentences. I say this with the clear awareness that not every great researcher can also be a great communicator. I am fully aware of that. But I do ask you: Do not shy away from making science "popular science" in the positive sense. It is my heartfelt request to you to commit to this obligation and to do something about it. Because we are currently experiencing in politics that not only the decisions made there are politically effective, but also the way in which politics is communicated. We could almost say that communication is part of political action. And this can be very well transferred to the matter I have just expressed my opinion on.

In a knowledge society, science not only has the task of informing and advising political actors. Knowledge-based political advice also means broad education. By this, I do not only mean individual facts, however important they may be. No, I also mean, as mentioned, educating about science itself – as the Leopoldina has already exemplified many times. A particularly encouraging sign of this is, for example, that one hundred students have also been invited to this annual assembly. I would like to extend a special welcome to them today. And I wish from science: Please dare to do more of this! Interest in science is not a question of age. And I say this not only as someone in whose age group many people pursue "studies in later life." It is worthwhile to address all age groups, to inform them about what is scientifically possible, and to inspire them for science and its possibilities.

I have spoken about the different spheres of politics and science and how science can approach society. I would like to briefly address two more topics that form crucial foundations for science-based advice to politics and society: the role of science in the context of ethical debates and the acceptance and promotion of excellence.

When we talk about the freedom of science in our country, it is not a cheap platitude. It is such a high good that it is enshrined in our Basic Law. This freedom applies. It reaches its limits where it conflicts with other fundamental rights. Technological progress enables humans to intervene with consequences of previously unimaginable magnitude and thus raises new questions.

We should reflect on what Hans Jonas formulated as an imperative: "Act in such a way that the effects of your actions are compatible with the permanence of genuine human life on Earth." We know that we can only meet the great challenges of our time with innovations. And yet we must shape this process responsibly. Because not only our own interests count, but also those of future generations.

Where scientific progress necessitates new boundaries, we must proceed very carefully: How do we deal, for example, with the potential of knowledge and application of genetic diagnostics? The connection "mind – brain – genome – society" becomes evident here in an almost existential way.

The freedom of science is a high good. Certainly, science should not always be subjected to an expected "added value" or quick "usability." However, publicly funded science is indeed accountable to the public – especially in times of tight budgets. The question of relevance is therefore not an attack on the freedom of science. Such debates must be allowed and accepted. We should distinguish between economic benefit and societal relevance. What matters is the significance of scientific knowledge for society.

But it is also true: Science has made an extraordinarily important contribution to our collective prosperity, and sometimes we have taken that for granted. Therefore, the scientific system plays a crucial role in the future viability of a high-tech country like ours. I am pleased that the Leopoldina is actively participating in this discussion on how we can further develop our scientific system.

Excellent research needs a foundation in breadth. Both require the necessary financial resources. In recent years, politics in Germany has done a lot. You know this better than I do. And politics has also achieved a lot: I think of the "Paket der Pakte." However, I also know the concerns of many scientists and scientific organizations about what will happen when the pacts expire. And that is just around the corner.

I also think about the fact that not only the state but also German companies are investing increasing amounts in research and development. I explicitly welcome that. And I think of the Federal Freedom of Science Act.

We should not beat around the bush: We need further efforts, we need new efforts. The European agreed three percent target for research and development has almost been reached in Germany. But it is up to us what target we want to set beyond that, what standards we want to apply to ourselves. It is clear: If we want to secure prosperity and quality of life in our country for the future, we must measure ourselves against competitors in the world.

When we look out into the world, it becomes clear to us that we are experiencing a transformation in science as well. Other regions of the world – such as Asia – are gaining further importance. This means: We must also continue to make efforts. If we want to strengthen our universities, we will also have to talk about better basic funding for our universities, as well as further improvements in teaching. We also need reliable and transparent career paths for our young scientists. And we must consistently seize the opportunities that arise from the internationalization of science. When numerous students and scientists come to German institutions, that is good and sensible. The same applies when young Germans go abroad to study. We must not only consider Germany. Even in matters of science, the European context – and cohesion – is of crucial importance.

Good education policy, as we hear time and again, regularly ranks at the top when people are asked about the most important political issues in surveys. I am sure that people expect a viable answer from the federal and state governments to the question of what future-oriented education, research, and development will look like in our country.

Given the necessary consolidation of public budgets, this is anything but an easy task. But here, what your society, the Leopoldina, has chosen as its motto should apply to our country, to politics, and to each individual: Nunquam otiosus – never idle!

I wish you all the best, not only for your annual meeting but also for all future work.