Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebration "100 Years of Goethe University" on October 18, 2014, in Frankfurt am Main:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

19 October 2014 · 100 Years of Goethe University celebration · Frankfurt am Main, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed guests at Goethe University Frankfurt's centenary celebration on October 18, 2014, marking 100 years of the civic-founded institution.
Main themes
Civic university founding, university education and society, German higher education history, academic freedom and debate, role of universities in democracy, Goethe University centenary, education as emancipation, student experience, Frankfurt civic identity, Leszek Kołakowski anecdote, Bildungsbürgertum, university-society relationship
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,786
72nd percentile
Sentences
151
81st percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.85
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 72%70%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

151 sentences in 37 paragraphs

How should one begin a speech at the university that bears the name of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, other than with the perhaps most famous sigh in the history of German literature:

“Alas! I have now studied philosophy,

law, and medicine and sadly also theology with great diligence.”

Admittedly, a rather unsurprising start to this speech. And I probably would have refrained from the “alas!” if it hadn’t been for a blog post I recently read, which featured a letter from a university graduate to her university, translating Faust’s monologue into our present day more than 200 years later.

I quote: “Dear University, I imagined you differently; I dreamed of you for years. Of discussions, of exchange, of the feeling of freedom…. I imagined how we would have wild debates at the university. Keynes! Marx! Weber! Dear University, I thought you would be a place for arguing […] This lack of passion was unbearable…”

Well, of course, there were many passionate responses to this vehement letter of complaint, which was really only missing Faust’s lament: “Here I stand, I poor fool! And am as wise as I was before.” Many agreed with the author, but many also disagreed and reported good experiences with their university, their studies, and their professors.

At this point, I felt, what is this writer longing for? – hopefully not for the wild times of 1970, when one of the strange chapters of this university was written. At the suggestion of Jürgen Habermas, the Adorno chair was to be newly filled, and they came up with one of the most significant Marxism scholars of the time, Leszek Kołakowski. But Kołakowski had just been reprimanded by his communist leadership in Poland. Now, the strange thing happened: At this beautiful Free University, there were leftist, far-left, and Marxist majorities that rejected him for lacking Marxist orthodoxy. The poor man then had to go to the academic desert of Oxford. So much for the spirit of the times.

The university and its condition do not leave people indifferent. And that is a good thing. Because when it comes to the education of future generations, the future of an entire society is always at stake. Therefore, universities should flourish and thrive, primarily in the interest of the students. Here in Frankfurt, there are 46,000 students who receive crucial opportunities for a successful life path through the best possible university education, but who are also expected to deliver performances as well-educated and well-trained graduates that are valuable for society as a whole. Conversely, the same applies: When it comes to the future of the university, the question is always also up for debate about what a society expects from its universities and what it is therefore willing to do for its universities. But we will come to that later. Only good things!

The Frankfurt University, which I wholeheartedly congratulate on its 100th birthday today, seems to me to be a good example to illuminate this interplay between a society and its universities a little more closely. This university is outstanding for various reasons: one of them is, as we all know or almost all of us here in the room, its founding history, which clearly differs from that of other universities. The founding of the older universities in Germany was usually driven by the will of a sovereign to enhance the glory of his principality and sometimes his own, and to strengthen the economic power of the territory – the latter being quite honorable motives.

However, the founding of the University of Frankfurt 100 years ago was driven not by princely but by civic will. The citizens of Frankfurt, at least sufficiently many of them, were convinced that higher education is the best thing that can happen to a person. When “Bildungsbürger” was an entirely positive term, and “citizen” in the fullest and truest sense was only the educated citizen, it was understood in Frankfurt that the founding of a university was something like a self-evident civic duty. For this reason, the Frankfurt University and the city of Frankfurt are rightly proud that this institution is a civic university.

A civic university thrives on engagement. This has been and is found in abundance here in Frankfurt because people know what a university, a very good and well-equipped university can give to a city and a society, both intellectually and materially. On the one hand, education helps to understand and interpret the world, and thus also to live together in a community of free citizens. On the other hand, it also offers tangible benefits.

Let’s not kid ourselves: Scientific education was already understood as an economic factor 100 years ago. That was also right, and we need not criticize it. Moreover, the idea was also alive that education through science is the key to the development of personality, to independent thinking, to the use of one’s own understanding, and thus to emancipation, to liberation from old authorities and from the constraints of nature.

Education and emancipation, or expressed differently, perhaps more comprehensively: education and freedom belong together. That is why I find it beautiful that we are celebrating this founding anniversary here at this site, here in the Paulskirche, one of the most distinguished places of the German democracy and freedom movement.

The history of universities, the history of the Frankfurt University as well, is part of the European history of freedom and part of the European history of truth.

Truth and freedom are siblings. Just as research and teaching need freedom to unfold and to seek and strive for truth unhindered, so political freedom depends on the truth being allowed, being fought for, and being made public without censorship. That the truth sets us free also applies to education, which – according to the famous words of Immanuel Kant – makes us free to use our own understanding without the guidance of another.

Thus, since their invention in the Middle Ages, universities have been urban places of emancipation. One of the first who can be addressed as a professor in almost the modern sense is the theologian and philosopher Peter Abelard. He developed a scientific method at the young University of Paris at the beginning of the 12th century that has lost none of its validity to this day.

“Sic et non” is the title of his most significant work. In it, the method of critical, scientific questioning of all authorities is systematically justified and carried out for the first time. Abelard lists contradictions in the texts of the Church Fathers in 158 sections, who had previously been simply unquestioned and unquestionable authorities. And he shows that only reasoned interpretation leads to truth. Quote: “By doubting, we come to inquiry, and through this, we grasp the truth.”

Freedom from prejudice, critical questioning of all authorities, precise analysis and interpretation of sources, reason as the highest authority: this is, so to speak, the first “critical theory” of the West, and it remains essential for any scientific work, everywhere to this day. That it was by no means easy to enforce is shown not only, but also by the history of Abelard, which is marked by struggles, condemnations, and banishments. It will always be so: Emancipation and liberation from authorities will never be distributed as a gift. They must always be fought for.

The continuity of academic thought, as it has shaped our universities, is primarily a continuity of critical consciousness. What begins in Paris with “Sic et non” leads through the great “Critiques” of the Königsberger to the Critical Theory of the Frankfurt School.

However, we also know, and we must not conceal this even on such a festive day, that the university has not always been the enlightened voice of reason. The spirit has not always played the most important role, nor the disinterested search for truth. The unspirit, yes, the conscious lie, racism, anti-Semitism have also found a home in universities in Germany. Intellectuality, we unfortunately know, is not an effective protection against barbarism. This is one of the bitter lessons from the experiences of the Third Reich. The Frankfurt University also very quickly and thoroughly separated itself from its Jewish teachers and students during those dark years. “Cleansing” was what they called it back then. Yet it owed its founding in good part to the Jewish bourgeoisie of this city. And a large part of its academic brilliance was derived from the contributions of the Jews who taught here.

By the way, pillars of society disappeared from all German cities along with the Jews: philanthropy, cultural brilliance, scientific excellence, and also an enlightened patriotism, losses without equal. Not to mention the hunted and all the murdered people. In the awareness of these losses and the delayed recognition and naming of the guilt that led to these losses, society had a great task after the war. Here in Frankfurt, the Frankfurt University tried to reconnect with its glorious times after the Third Reich and after the war. I imagine that to be extremely difficult in those times when external and internal destruction shaped the country. But it succeeded. Some scholars even returned from exile to help with the intellectual reconstruction of a better Germany from Frankfurt. Everyone still knows the names of Adorno and Horkheimer, who developed the Critical Theory of the Frankfurt School, which almost became a headline for an intellectual attitude, yes, for an important phase in the history of the young Federal Republic. All of this was closely connected with Frankfurt.

The history of the Frankfurt civic university is a success story. But one cannot rest on successes. Every era presents universities with new challenges, but also with new opportunities.

The enormous increase in student numbers since the 1960s, along with the rising number of lecturers and professors, has created a different type of university than was known until the middle of the last century.

This is an unprecedented educational policy leap: Where previously an academic career was only granted to a narrow elite of a cohort, today it is more than a third. The proportion of young people in a cohort who take up studies has risen from about five percent to about fifty percent since the early 1950s. I am aware of the associated problems, which occasionally need to be discussed. However, I do not want to address that here. This increase has fundamentally changed the character of universities, and it had to be shaped and financed, of course. The question of university financing is still being debated today. Many lecturers and professors complain that they are moving away from the core of their profession, from research and teaching, yes, sometimes they have to move away. Thus, it was and is necessary to find a new balance between research and teaching, between excellence and breadth.

One challenge that the founders of the Frankfurt University 100 years ago also did not have in this clarity before their eyes was the contribution that education can and should make to social cohesion and the social ascent of each individual. Now my gaze falls on our society as it presents itself today. We live today in a society of immigration. More than a third of the under-fives living in Germany have a migration background. The entire education system must – should I say: must – face this task. There are now many initiatives that have taken on this challenge. Right at the beginning of my term, I stood here at the same spot to welcome and congratulate the participants of the Start Scholarship Initiative. A large German foundation has recognized the fact that we need special support for this group of trainees, who – equipped with a migration background – do not have the same starting opportunities as children from the German educational bourgeoisie. We must understand that we need to address this reality of immigration, to see it as a practical task. And I am grateful for the initiatives and the individuals who are engaged in this field, providing help in language promotion or through cultural contributions. In sports, we have learned that every talent deserves support and that this support enriches everyone. I wish for the same insight in education and science: from kindergarten through school to university. At each of these stages, we can do much more to enable all young people in this country to lead successful lives.

In my understanding, the university can and must play an active role in shaping the immigration society, perhaps even a more active role than is currently customary. Foreign students and young people with a migration background need help. In some cases, financial support is necessary, for example through special scholarship programs. But most importantly, role models and encouragement are needed, and that long before enrollment. It must not be the case that a person's background—be it social or ethnically cultural—determines what future that person has! The key to overcoming such background barriers is education. The story of education as emancipation continues, and it must continue.

Is the old "citizen university" also up to these new challenges? Here in Frankfurt, you have found a clear answer to this question. You have rediscovered the principle of the citizen university for yourselves, you have consciously acknowledged your roots. Since 2008, Goethe University has once again been a foundation university. This model is intended to strengthen the connection between universities and civil society. It offers generous and far-sighted donors and supporters the opportunity to take responsibility for the university. The transformation into a foundation university strengthens the institution's self-responsibility. The foundation university can simultaneously develop a sense of community and an identity that connects educators and learners and establishes a strong connection to the social environment.

It becomes evident time and again: education and scientific excellence require such a supportive environment. In Frankfurt, there is this education-friendly environment. Cooperation and exchange are therefore essential success factors for this university, which has never seen itself as an ivory tower, but always as a civic forum. For this, one can truly congratulate today.

However, I want to make one thing clear at this point: the praise of donors and the call for further civic engagement for quality education must not lead to the state withdrawing from its responsibility in the education sector. Donors are not a fallback in times of tight budgets—they create added value.

Furthermore, it is right and important to think of new means and ways to pool resources. Thus, the federal government and the states have rightly been considering since the last legislative period how to further develop educational federalism to meet the increased demands. In the end, this will benefit everyone: the students, who will find attractive study conditions, the universities, which can further expand their strengths, and our country as a scientific nation.

The concentration of forces is also important because good universities today are in a global competition. In this competition, the Frankfurt University will benefit from its uniqueness as a citizen university, as well as from public support.

Europe, as the Indian author Pankaj Mishra recently wrote, has lost its luster. It used to generate trust in the universality of its experiences and solutions with its cultural and intellectual power. This trust has now been lost.

I do not share everything that this author states. However, one thing he says I consider so important that I want to present it here: Europe, he writes, must revive its own critical and cosmopolitan tradition; it needs openness, dissent, and no homogeneous worldview.

What this Indian author calls for is nothing more than the old and ever-young description of the task and essence of the European university, which in its good times was always open to the world and always ready to embrace foreign experiences. So let us get to work. Let us make our European university come alive again, so that it is intellectually both a challenge and a joy to teach and learn there.

Let us end as we began, with Goethe: When he began his studies at the age of 16, this Frankfurt University did not yet exist. So he went to Leipzig. From there, he wrote to his father on October 13, 1765:

"You cannot believe what a beautiful thing it is to have a professor. I was completely delighted when I saw some of these people in their glory!"

Those were the days: professors in their glory! That is somehow definitively a thing of the past. But could it not be possible to lead the university as a whole, as a community of educators and learners, of donors, supporters, and education policymakers, to a new glory? I cannot think of a better wish for this Goethe University in Frankfurt today.