Speech by Federal President Dr. h. c. Joachim Gauck at the celebratory event "65 Years of the Federal Press Conference" on October 14, 2014, in Berlin:

Germany Joachim Gauck · Former Federal President of Germany

19 October 2014 · Celebratory event "65 Years of the Federal Press Conference" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Gauck addressed the 65th anniversary celebration of the Federal Press Conference in Berlin on October 14, 2014, reflecting on press freedom and media acceleration.
Main themes
Acceleration of information dissemination, press freedom, Federal Press Conference's role in democracy, media and journalism, elite versus citizen discourse, internet and technological change, capital press dynamics, fourth estate, democratic participation, media hype and news production pace, historical context of media criticism
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,599
69th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.98
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 60%60%
  • Technological 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

134 sentences in 27 paragraphs

For good reason, there is a thank you for the invitation in almost every speech. And I would like to express that here especially – not because I remembered a very strange day in 2010 when I was allowed to take a seat here as we came in together, but because I have very, very good reasons to agree with you, dear Dr. Mainz, after you just said: If we did not exist, we would have to be invented!

Evidently, you have made such a good impression that you have managed to bring two Federal Presidents here within five years to congratulate on the anniversary. My predecessor Horst Köhler was here and spoke quite pointedly to the assembled members on the occasion of the 60th anniversary. If one were to read that, one could find that several parts of Köhler's analysis could still be presented today. But you are all aware of that, I know. Furthermore, I know that media people do not like to hear the old, their business is the news. Therefore, I would like to talk today about a phenomenon that has been accompanying us for some time, will accompany us for even longer, and is gaining more and more significance for journalism, yes, for society as a whole: I would like to reflect on the acceleration of information dissemination and its consequences.

But first, a word about your work, about your work here at the Federal Press Conference, an institution – yes, it really is! – that remains unique in the world even 65 years after its founding. I was truly surprised when I brought that to mind in preparation. In other places, as we have already heard, government representatives usually only express themselves when they deem it appropriate – on the topics they formulate, at the locations they consider suitable, and in front of a participant group they determine. In Germany, everything happens differently: often not from the government side, but through a regular press conference organized by journalists, by a registered association, so to speak, civil society organized. Press law as a citizen's right.

The Federal Press Conference possesses something very essential: organizational power. Those who set dates and topics exert influence. The Federal Press Conference has carved out and maintained a key position in democratic discourse – it is one of the institutional foundations that allows the capital press to efficiently fulfill its role as part of the fourth estate. It is lived press freedom. It is also one of the guarantors that the population can participate in the process of information and opinion formation.

At the same time, however, the capital press – including the members of the Federal Press Conference – imposes quite a bit on the population. Sometimes I get the impression that a news item is published only because it is due, not because there is something in it. Because something must be happening, not because something is happening. Because one wants to be the first. The three square kilometers around your building at Schiffbauerdamm are by no means immune to what some call media hype. In the worst case, according to the motto: As long as the ticker is running! The pace at which topics are rushed through the arena, news is produced and denied, positions are spread and relativized is simply breathtaking. We have long known that what was once – perhaps euphemistically – called Bonn's tranquility is over. But I fear the tempo is now so high that larger parts of the population in Germany perceive the Berlin operation even more as something that has little to do with their own reality. When I talk to people during visits in the country, this discrepancy becomes particularly clear to me.

It is in the nature of things that capital journalists are usually a step ahead of the debates in the field. But it becomes concerning when both occur almost independently of each other, when different speeds not only create the danger but certainly increase the risk that the national discourse – and it is precisely this that the Federal Press Conference shapes – that this national discourse increasingly splits into an elite debate and a citizen debate.

As the root of all evil, the acceleration that is constantly increasing is often identified, the speed with which information is processed and communicated today. This acceleration is, of course, not a German specificity. It is not a specificity of the interaction between journalism and politics. It is a consequence of a global technological development, the core of which is currently the explosive development of the internet. I say "currently" because, as is well known, earlier epochs also experienced technological leaps and reacted to them with cultural criticism – regularly. This began very early. Even Plato rejected the culture of writing. He had reasons for that. He feared that writing would make people lazy thinkers, forgetful, and weak in judgment. The experience of acceleration has been a constant companion of industrial modernity, just as the complaints about its side effects have been. Just think of the invention of the electric typewriter and the personal computer. They generated the fear that good style and the entire thought process were in danger.

We smile today at some of the horror visions. But many do not smile at all when they hear the warnings about the so-called turbo journalism of the internet age. When the French theorist Paul Virilio described the "tyranny of real-time" almost 20 years ago, many skeptics found themselves in agreement with him and still do today. A large part of this criticism is still heard and articulated today: for example, about the impoverishment of content in the digital age, which knows only "yes" and "no," "thumbs up" or "thumbs down," at best the quick headline. And we continue to hear the concern about the end of quality reporting.

On the other side of the opinion spectrum, however, are those who see significantly more opportunities than risks in the internet, also for journalism and especially for capital reporting. They praise that everyone can be heard on the internet, that the threshold for publishing is lowered, that citizens can participate or can also control journalists. They see the World Wide Web as a motor of democratization, a new platform for an enlightened society, more interconnected and better informed than ever before.

Capital journalism now knows both sides of this debate. It suffers from the acceleration – and it also lives from it. Some see themselves existentially threatened, while others see a new business field opening up. In the online world, a much larger pool of sources is available at the push of a button than we were used to from classical libraries and archives. Journalists have never been able to inform themselves faster and more profoundly. However, they have also never had to process information faster. They have never had to check the credibility of their quickly accessible sources in a shorter time and then quickly form their own judgment.

When it comes to reporting and hard facts, short messages can be handled better, in my observation, than when it comes to analyses and evaluations, which must also have their place. Because those who want to interpret and comment need not only a solidly researched foundation but also the opportunity to reflect. Quality takes time. Otherwise, there is a great danger that only the nearest cliché is repeated and judgments are hastily passed on people as well as ideas. Thus, rumors arise, prejudgments, scandals that, upon closer inspection, may not even exist. Claims are put into the world that are difficult to retract, and judgments about people that stick, often also erroneous judgments. And we know from numerous self-critical statements in German journalism, especially in the past year, that we are not only talking about abstract dangers but about very concrete issues.

Within the aforementioned three square kilometers of Berlin, everything somehow seems urgent, even that which requires deceleration, intensive consideration, and double-checking. That is precisely the problem: it is the handling of acceleration, not even the acceleration itself.

Quality journalism, as we all must wish for, is journalism that recognizes temptations and resists them. It must not become the norm that topics that actually need a long breath quickly disappear from the agenda. Instead, those readers, listeners, and viewers who ask: What has actually become of the government initiative from the beginning of the year? What about the person who was recently at the center of the scandal? And what about the war or crisis area that was reported on so extensively last week? What fear was turned into a mass phenomenon by the accelerant hysteria – and what serious threat was trivialized or perhaps not even perceived?

It would be easy to place the responsibility for this phenomenon solely on you this evening. Schloss Bellevue is also located within the described three square kilometers, as is the Bundestag and most government buildings. It is not only journalists who chase the latest headline every day. Many politicians also strive for media presence. There may also be among us politicians who like the high speed of the media business because it seemingly allows complex projects to be presented so simplistically that the expected critical debate remains harmless or perhaps even completely fails.

Even if the media are not responsible for everything that displeases us about the acceleration of political operations, I do believe that you, dear members and partners of the Federal Press Conference, can do something. Initiatives can come from your circle to translate the established standards of journalism into the world of modern media.

Tissy Bruns, who unfortunately passed away far too early and therefore cannot celebrate this anniversary with us, already thought in this direction in 2007. At that time, she was the chairwoman of the Federal Press Conference. Her book bore the unflattering title: "Republic of the Self-Important. A Report from Berlin." There were as few ready-made solutions then as there are today. But Ms. Bruns set out on the path, and that counts. She inspired others, and that counts too. With great respect, I read today many wise reflections on media modernity that have been written by authors from your circle.

Undoubtedly, our society is in a process of adaptation – the media as pathfinders of the information society leading the way. We all must learn to deal with the constant increase in available information and its accelerated dissemination. We must learn to cope with the growing availability of information at any place and at any time. And we must learn anew, under changed conditions, to pay attention to the seriousness of our information and sources. This presents a particular obligation for online journalism and at the same time a great opportunity. If the source on the internet bears the name of an established newspaper or a renowned broadcaster, it can indeed be a quality seal. Moreover, the virtual world has its own mechanisms for verifying facts and thereby building trust.

Last but not least, we must learn to distinguish between fast information and quick judgment. What applies to information also applies even more to commentary. A thoughtful commentary can never be completed as quickly as a live broadcast because it is about more than the current events, more than the surface structure of events. Intellectual performance has limits to acceleration, and it cannot simply be delegated to machines.

That is actually a blessing because it is precisely these people – journalists! – who, despite all adaptation to modern circumstances, ensure that fundamental values do not erode. And that is why what has been declared dead for decades still exists: quality journalism. I find it every morning in various publications, I hear it on the radio, I see it on the screen. Therefore, I cannot and do not want to join the cultural pessimists who see only a downward spiral in the media business, who observe only hype, scandalization, or superficiality, who can discover only navel-gazing or deformation.

Let us look around: There continues to be, and to a significant extent, what my predecessor Horst Köhler called enlightenment and stance. There is the enlightening news, the detailed investigation, the great analysis, the profound explanatory piece, as well as the courageous interjection that stands against the mainstream. There is the extensive report, and there is the feature in which the niche topic gets its chance. And there is – as already mentioned – even the critical reflection of journalism on itself.

German journalism therefore has more reason to be self-confident than the debates about it sometimes suggest. Journalism has something to say, it has something to tell.

When I was a guest at the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers last autumn, at the large newspaper congress, there was much talk about the death of newspapers. But there was just as much talk about the hope for a new phase of the information age, in which it will be possible to disseminate information profitably in new ways. Profitably, because there will still be demand in the future. The need for facts and solid information, for explanations and contextualization of events in larger contexts, for trustworthy sources – all of this will remain. This need is shared by the vast majority of people who consume media. The younger generation has it too; they often just make use of new media. Those who are learning today are certainly not, on average, any less intelligent or demanding than the generation of the founders of the Federal Press Conference. But the way knowledge is acquired, the half-life of interests, the duration and amplitudes of debates – all of this has changed.

This does not mean the end for media – whether in Berlin or elsewhere. However, it does mean a strong and perhaps unwelcome invitation to change for some. For what is sometimes called media education in certain schools, it may also mean the guiding principle:

Be skeptical when a new accusation against a politician is reported at 11:07 a.m. and the first comment follows at 11:08 a.m.

Many of the questions that occupy us today are, in principle, familiar to us, by the way, for a long time. It is not as if we have not long known the conflict of goals between speed and seriousness. Reporting was already a hectic, error-prone business in 1949, when the Federal Press Conference was founded. To avoid mistakes, press codes were invented. We will certainly need them in the future – for the old, but especially for the new media. Care, transparency, and responsibility are and remain the core principles of serious journalism. And I like to repeat what I have said on other occasions: precarious work is not a stable basis for reliable content. Those who cut back on what only people, and not machines, can contribute to a journalistic process are cutting back in the wrong place.

I rely on the Federal Press Conference continuing to play its important role, that it will not succumb, either collectively or individually, to alarmism, but that it will confront the uncertainty about the future with its own strengths. It is, after all, demonstrably not the quietest, not the most hesitant minds that come together in this Federal Press Conference. Who would be better suited to defend and develop journalistic standards than you?

Therefore, allow me to combine my congratulations on the 65th anniversary with a thank you for your work. I follow your work with great appreciation. And I have one request: continue to make rich use of the opportunities this institution offers!